METAL ABUNDANCES IN THE OUTSKIRTS OF

Transcription

1 METAL ABUNDANCES IN THE OUTSKIRTS OF GALAXY CLUSTERS AURORA SIMIONESCU ISAS/JAXA with: Ondrej Urban, N. Werner, S. Allen, Y. Ichinohe and the Perseus/Virgo Suzaku Key Project collaborations

2 5 YEARS OF CLUSTER OUTSKIRTS SCIENCE SnowCLUSTER2010 SnowCLUSTER2015

3 THROWBACK WEDNESDAY: SNOWCLUSTER2010 Perseus RASS image and initial Suzaku pointings Temperature profiles as of SnowCluster2010. Some data points did not pass further systematic checks, (or Maxim s scrutiny)

4 Perseus A2199 relaxed massive/hot PROGRESS SINCE SNOWCLUSTER2010 less massive/cooler dynamically active Coma Virgo

5 PROGRESS SINCE SNOWCLUSTER2010 Walker et al. 2013

6 K K 500 = 1.47 ( r r 500 ) 1.1 (Voit et al. 2005, Pratt et al. 2010) kt expected (r) = P(r) 2/5 K(r) 3/5 n expected e (r) = P(r) 3/5 K(r) 3/5. P(r) P 500 = P 0 (c 500 x) γ [ 1 + (c 500 x) α] (β γ)/α (Nagai et al. 2007, Planck Collaboration 2013) Note 1: be careful about normalisation of entropy power law model! Note 2: be careful about inferring r500 from scaling relations! (e.g. YX-r500 relation has less scatter than kt-r500) Ideally, use exact same method as Planck Collaboration 2013 if using their model.

7 DENSITY BIAS DUE TO GAS INHOMOGENEITIES NO temperature biases within r200; some interesting effects start to be seen beyond (does electron-ion non equilibrium set in as well??) Some clusters show no density bias, e.g. A2142 or the group RXJ1159 Walker et al. 2013

8 AZIMUTHALLY RESOLVED GAS CLUMPING IN PERSEUS In Perseus, within r200 along all arms, correcting ne is SUFFICIENT to bring BOTH entropy and pressure in agreement with expected profiles. Both macroscopic clumping (due to E-W large-scale sloshing asymmetries) and microscopic clumping (along relaxed N-S axis) must be present. Urban et al. 2014

9 Beyond thermodynamics: Chemical enrichment history of the ICM

10 PREVIOUS EVIDENCE SUGGESTING METAL ENRICHMENT IN CLUSTER OUTSKIRTS Leccardi et al average metallicity profile of a sample of clusters with XMM Fujita et al abundance in the compressed region between two merging clusters with Suzaku

11 METALLICITY PROFILES WITH SUZAKU Perseus Cluster (Werner et al. 2013) Coma Cluster (Simionescu et al. 2013) Flat metallicity profile with Z~0.3 Solar out to r200 exquisitely measured in the Perseus Cluster. The metallicity profile in Coma also shows the same trend (albeit with much larger error bars).

12 IRON SPREAD SMOOTHLY THROUGHOUT THE PERSEUS CLUSTER 78 Fe abundance measurements across the cluster at different radii and azimuths show strikingly uniform distribution Werner et al. 2013, Nature

13 Ram-pressure stripping of member galaxies should produce a central peak and a patchy metallicity distribution. The uniform iron distribution suggests that galactic winds at z~2 were mainly responsible for getting the metals out of the galaxies and into the IGM/ICM. Metals escaped from the galaxies and got mixed into the intergalactic gas before the entropy profile became very steep, preventing efficient mixing. Domainko et al. 2006

14 IMPLICATIONS OF EARLY METAL ENRICHMENT all massive clusters should show a similar, uniform level of enrichment at 1/3 of the Solar metallicity. There should be no significant evolution with redshift! galactic winds during the period of peak star formation and AGN activity probably played an important role in getting the metals out of the galaxies early on (z~2) many type Ia supernovae (SNIa), which are the main sources of Fe, must have exploded shortly after the epoch of peak star-formation. This is consistent with recent findings based on SNIa delay time distributions (Maoz et al. 2012). this scenario predicts that the warm-hot intergalactic medium in large-scale structure filaments connecting to massive clusters is also metal-rich, and can be detected in line-emission with future high-grasp, high-spectral resolution missions. if the material currently falling into massive clusters is iron-rich, iron nuclei are likely to be accelerated as they pass through the accretion shocks, providing an important source of the highest energy cosmic rays. OR CAN WE ACHIEVE SUCH A UNIFORM MIXING OF THE METALS EVEN AT LATER TIMES??

15 Perseus A2199 relaxed massive/hot WHAT ABOUT METALS IN COOLER (MORE LINE RICH!) SYSTEMS? less massive/cooler dynamically active Coma Virgo

16 TO THE VIRIAL RADIUS OF VIRGO - WITH XMM-NEWTON! Urban et al. 2011

17 TEMPERATURE AND METALLICITY PROFILES IN VIRGO MEASURED WITH XMM-NEWTON Urban et al In this regime (signal is concentrated in Fe-L line), clumping may affect the temperature and metallicity measurements too!

18 THE VIRGO CLUSTER KEY PROJECT 60 Suzaku pointings 4 different directions over 1Ms total exposure AO 7-8

19 METALLICITY IN THE OUTSKIRTS OF VIRGO Profiles along northern arm from XMM (black) vs. Suzaku (red) Metallicity profiles along the 4 Suzaku arms Simionescu et al., in prep

20 LOWER METALLICITY IN THE OUTSKIRTS OF LOWER MASS CLUSTERS? Centaurus Cluster, Walker et al Metallicity lower than 1/3 Solar in the outskirts of lower-mass clusters. Real effect or onset of Fe- L bias?? Iron abundance (solar) A2199 NE NW SW SE A2199 Key Project, Sato et al., in prep Projected radius (arcmin)

21 VIRGO CLUSTER MULTIPHASE TEST arm 1T model, free Z 2T model, Z=0.3 2T model, Z free (additional d.o.f.) N (10) W (5) S (8) E (7) all (30) Significant improvement in C-statistic for NO additional d.o.f. when using 2T model with kt_low=0.7 kev and metallicity fixed at 0.3 as opposed to 1T model with free metallicity. Only mild improvement (DeltaC=44.7 / 30 d.o.f.) when metallicity is left free in 2T model. Simionescu et al., in prep

22 EFFECT OF MULTIPHASE ON VIRGO CLUSTER THERMODYNAMIC PROFILES Free Z (black) vs. Z=0.3 (0.7 kev component treated as bkg)

23 THE MANY GRAINS OF SALT #1: Do we even know what the (X-ray defined pseudo-)entropy of a two-phase gas is? [ ] fne,c ln S c + (1 f )n e,h ln S h S = exp fn e,c + (1 f )n e,h What if it is more than two phase? Xue et al. 2004

24 THE MANY GRAINS OF SALT #2: A recent issue has been discovered concerning the removal of flickering pixels in Suzaku XIS; this mostly affects the energy band below 0.7 kev, but may have some influence on the multi-phase structure inferred from spectral fitting. Stay tuned & ask me for a patch if you are working on XIS data.

25 TAKE HOME MESSAGES Lots of progress in the understanding of cluster outskirts since SnowCluster2010! The gas density in cluster outskirts becomes nonuniform between r500 and r200. Not all clusters show the same clumping level; some may show none. Perseus Key Project results show that the metallicity is constant at 0.3 solar both as a function of radius and azimuth out to the edge of the cluster. Early enrichment or more efficient mixing than previously thought? Lower-mass clusters tend to have lower metallicity in the outskirts - but this is probably a multi-phase bias. How do we understand the entropy of ICM having this complex thermal structure?