Applied Integer Programming: Modeling and Solution

Transcription

1 Applied Integer Programming: Modeling and Solution Chen, Batson, Dang Section Blekinge Institute of Technology April 5, 05

2 Modeling Combinatorical Optimization Problems II Traveling Salesman Problem Importance of the TSP 3 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching

3 Importance of the TSP Traveling Salesman Problem A traveling salesman is to visit a number of cities and the distance connecting two cities are known; the problem is to find a shortest route that starts from a home city, visits other cities exactly once, and returns to the home city.

4 Importance of the TSP Traveling Salesman Problem A traveling salesman is to visit a number of cities and the distance connecting two cities are known; the problem is to find a shortest route that starts from a home city, visits other cities exactly once, and returns to the home city. Became popular in (954) (Dantzig, Fulkerson and Johnson) Perhaps the most well-studied COP Thousands of publications. Over 000 distinct papers cited Representative of N P-hard COPs Primary driving force in novel optimization and solution algorithms Many AI algorithms, GA, SA, Tabu search, heuristics developed to (at least partly) solve the TSP

5 Importance of the TSP Milestones of TSP instances solved to optimality Year No. of Cities Data Set Research Team dantzig4 Dantzig, Fulkerson, Johnson random points Held and Karp random points Camerini, Fratta, Maffioli grl0 Grötschel lin38 Crowder and Padberg att53 Padberg and Rinaldi gr666 Grötschel and Holland pr39 Padberg and Rinaldi pla7397 Applegate, Bixby, Chvátal, Cook 998 3, 509 usa3509 Applegate, Bixby, Chvátal, Cook 00 5, dl5 Applegate, Bixby, Chvátal, Cook 004 4, 978 sw4978 Applegate, Bixby, Chvátal, Cook , 80 pla3380 Applegate, Bixby, Chvátal, Cook , 900 pla85900 Applegate, Bixby, Chvátal, Cook

6 Importance of the TSP Slow progress (950 to mid-970s ) Lack of applications. Could only solve small instances of the problem

7 Importance of the TSP Slow progress (950 to mid-970s ) Lack of applications. Could only solve small instances of the problem Rapid progression (mid-970s - mid-000s) Increased computational capability and introduction of branch-and-cut technique TSP can be used as a benchmark for IP algorithms

8 Importance of the TSP Some definitions Definition Let G = (V, E) be a graph where V is the set of vertices (nodes) and E is the set of edges (arcs). If the TSP is defined over a directed graph, then we have a asymmetric TSP. If the the TSP is defined over a undirected graph, then we have a symmetric TSP.

9 Importance of the TSP Some definitions Definition Let G = (V, E) be a graph where V is the set of vertices (nodes) and E is the set of edges (arcs). If the TSP is defined over a directed graph, then we have a asymmetric TSP. If the the TSP is defined over a undirected graph, then we have a symmetric TSP. Definition A route is sequence of distinct nodes (v, v,..., v n, v n ) such that (v i, v i+ ) E, i =,... n. If the route contains all nodes of the graph, it is called a Hamiltonian route

10 Importance of the TSP Definition A cycle is sequence of distinct nodes (v, v,..., v n, v n, v ) such that (v i, v i+ ), (v n, v ) E, i =..., n. If the cycle contains all nodes of the graph, it is called a Hamiltonian cycle

11 Importance of the TSP Definition A cycle is sequence of distinct nodes (v, v,..., v n, v n, v ) such that (v i, v i+ ), (v n, v ) E, i =..., n. If the cycle contains all nodes of the graph, it is called a Hamiltonian cycle Finding the shortest Hamiltonian cycle gives is a solution to the TSP.

12 Importance of the TSP Example of Hamiltonian cycle

13 Importance of the TSP Example of Hamiltonian cycle

14 Shortest Hamiltonian Paths Finding the shortest Hamiltonian path in graph G = (V, E) can be transformed into a TSP in the following way:

15 Shortest Hamiltonian Paths Finding the shortest Hamiltonian path in graph G = (V, E) can be transformed into a TSP in the following way: Construct a new graph G by: adding a virtual node to G connect the new node with all the others with distance zero

16 Shortest Hamiltonian Paths Finding the shortest Hamiltonian path in graph G = (V, E) can be transformed into a TSP in the following way: Construct a new graph G by: adding a virtual node to G connect the new node with all the others with distance zero Solve the TSP in the new graph G

17

18

19

20

21 If a starting position for the salesman is given, say node. Then we do the following transformation:

22 If a starting position for the salesman is given, say node. Then we do the following transformation: Add the arcs (v i, v ), i =,... n with distance zero to the graph Solve the TSP

23 If a starting position for the salesman is given, say node. Then we do the following transformation: Add the arcs (v i, v ), i =,... n with distance zero to the graph Solve the TSP

24 Suppose we require that the salesman has to visit each city at least once, instead of exactly once. Consider the following transformation:

25 Suppose we require that the salesman has to visit each city at least once, instead of exactly once. Consider the following transformation: Whenever there exists a route from v n to v k in G. Construct a new graph with arcs (v n, v k ) where the distance equals the total cost of the shortest path between them.

26

27

28 In the multiple TSP, m salesmen has to visit n customer cities. Let f p, p =,,... n be the fixed cost if salesman p is activated. The problem is determine how many of the salesmen should be utilized such that their total traveling distance is minimized and each city is visited once by one and only one salesman and then return to the home city (node 0). If the network is directed we can transform the multiple TSP to to a standard asymmetric TSP by the following steps:

29 Arrange the fixed cost in ascending order f 0 f... f m Add dummy nodes labeled,,..., (m ) as a home city for salesman, 3,... m, respectively. 3 Add the arcs ( i, j), i =,,..., m and each (0, j) A with distance c i,j = c 0,j + f i 4 Add the arcs (j, i) whenever (j, 0) A with distance c j, i = c j,0 + f i 5 Add the arcs ( i, (i )) for every pair of i =,,..., m with distance c i, (i ) = f i f i.

30

31

32 + f f 0 + f + f 3 + f f 4 + f 0 + f 4 + f 3 + f 3 + f f 4

33 + f 0 0 (f 0 f ) + f + f + f f f 4 + f 0 (f f ) + f + f 4 + f f f 4

34 Suppose we obtain the solution (0, ), (, 4), (4, ), (, )(, ), (, 3), (3, 0) Salesman 0 visites cities and 4; salesman visits none and salesman visits cities and 3.

35 Let G = (N, A) be a digraph where the nodes have been partioned into k disjoint subsets N i, i =,,... k. The problem of the clustered TSP is to find the minimum cost Hamiltonian cycle with the constraint that nodes within the same cluster must be visited consecutively. The problem can be transformed to the standard TSP by adding an (large) additional cost to the arcs between nodes that do not belong to the same cluster.

36 Let G = (N, A) be a graph with a positive or negative arc value c ij, (i, j) A. The problem is to find a Hamiltonian cycle (v, v,... v n, v ) such that c, c n,n + c n, is maximal. The problem can be transformed into a standard (minimum) TSP by setting c ij = c ij or c ij = c ij + M (M large constant) if c ij becomes negative.

37 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Job scheduling Suppose that n jobs with a given processing time has to be processed on a single machine. The jobs can be processed in any order but some machine job setup times are dependent, e.g. job i must precede job j. Objective is to find a sequence of jobs so all jobs are processed such that the total process time is minimized.

38 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Job scheduling Suppose that n jobs with a given processing time has to be processed on a single machine. The jobs can be processed in any order but some machine job setup times are dependent, e.g. job i must precede job j. Objective is to find a sequence of jobs so all jobs are processed such that the total process time is minimized. Assembly line In assembly line systems, jobs can be grouped together as clusters. The job within the same cluster must be completed before proceding to the next cluster. This type of sequencing can be considered as a clustered TSP.

39 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Cellular manufacturing In cellular manufacturing the aim of to group together similair parts to be processed in a machine cell together. Aneja and Kamoun (999) showed that the problem of sequencing jobs by a robot in a machine cell can be formulated as a TSP.

40 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Cellular manufacturing In cellular manufacturing the aim of to group together similair parts to be processed in a machine cell together. Aneja and Kamoun (999) showed that the problem of sequencing jobs by a robot in a machine cell can be formulated as a TSP. Flow shop sequencing Suppose we have n jobs with given process time that are to be processed on m machines in the same order. Each machine can work on one job at the time and must be completed without interruption. No waiting time is assumed, that is when job j is completed the j + job in the queue is starting immediatly. The objective is to finish the last job as soon as possible. This problem can be considered as a n-city shortest Hamiltonian path problem which in turn can be tranformed into an n + node TSP by adding a virtual node.

41 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Drilling holes on IC boards A number of holes are needed on integrated circuit (IC) boards for mounting chips and other hardware. The holes are typically produced by a programmed drilling machine. The TSP is to minimize the the total traveling time of the drill.

42 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching School bus routing The problem to schedule school buses to pick up and transport children to and from schools can be viewed as a multiple TSP if it possible to neglect the time windows and bus capacities constraints. Otherwise the problem is a vehicle routing problem

43 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching School bus routing The problem to schedule school buses to pick up and transport children to and from schools can be viewed as a multiple TSP if it possible to neglect the time windows and bus capacities constraints. Otherwise the problem is a vehicle routing problem Parcel/postal delivery/dispatching This problem is a modified problem of the TSP where a vehicle is has to visit a set of streets (arcs) instad of nodes. A path traversing all arcs exactly once is called an Eulerian path.

44 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching School bus routing The problem to schedule school buses to pick up and transport children to and from schools can be viewed as a multiple TSP if it possible to neglect the time windows and bus capacities constraints. Otherwise the problem is a vehicle routing problem Parcel/postal delivery/dispatching This problem is a modified problem of the TSP where a vehicle is has to visit a set of streets (arcs) instad of nodes. A path traversing all arcs exactly once is called an Eulerian path.

45 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Meals/Clinic on wheels This version of the TSP is about dispatching a fleet of vehicles in urban or rural environments to satisfy the demand for some commodity or service, e.g. deliver food to elderly on regular basis or medical services in communities.

46 Machine Sequencing Problems in Various Manufacturing Systems Sequencing Problems in Electronic Industry Vehicle Routing for Delivery and Dispatching Thank you for listening!