Hydrodynamics: Setting the Scene*

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Hydrodynamics: Setting the Scene*"

Transcription

1 Hydrodynamics: Setting the Scene* *a selective view Prof. Rodney Eatock Taylor and Prof. Paul Taylor University of Oxford The Lloyd s Register Educational Trust (LRET) Marine & Offshore Research Workshop February, 2010 at Engineering Auditorium, NUS

2 Hydrodynamics: Setting the Scene* *a selective view Rodney Eatock Taylor and Paul Taylor University of Oxford LRET Marine and Offshore Research Workshop National University of Singapore, February 2010

3 Hydrodynamics and Modelling One of our aims must be to model the interaction of the most extreme waves with structures in the sea. And we must also consider hydrodynamic models motivated by design for operational conditions in waves Also Resistance, Manoeuvring, Sloshing, VIV/VIM, Hydroelasticity,.., which are not considered here Typhoon TLP from

4 Modelling using CFD From: Summary of CESOS Workshop 2007, by Marilena Greco

5 Issues raised Wave analysis Wave structure interaction Near-trapping by multiple structures in waves Wave-in-deck issues (waves + interaction): jackets and GBS Wave-induced sloshing in gaps Floatover A few comments on CFD

6 Wave analysis Time series plot of some large waves

7 NewWave Average of largest 50% linear profiles * compared with NewWave profile + * linearised using (average crest -average trough profile)/2 + average shape of extreme in linear random Gaussian process (Boccotti, Lindgren)

8 NewWave embedded in random record

9 Freak waves? Consider behaviour near an extreme crest: set-down will decrease crest elevation, while set-up will increase it. The famous New Year Wave measured at the Draupner platform in the North Sea. For convenience the time is set to zero under the extreme crest.

10 Setdown under extreme crest? T.A.A. Adcock & P. H. Taylor, 11th International Workshop on Wave Hindcasting and Forecasting, 2009.

11 Setup under Draupner crest The second order difference waves under the Draupner giant wave.comparison of filtered data and predicted second order difference waves based on a model of crossing seas. (Evidence of crossing seas from meteorology, measured forces, and absence of breaking in wave record from laser) T.A.A. Adcock & P. H. Taylor, 11th International Workshop on Wave Hindcasting and Forecasting, 2009.

12 Other evidence of set-up in crossing seas A. Toffoli et al. / European Journal of Mechanics B/Fluids 25 (2006)

13 Wave climate variability T.A.A. Adcock & P. H. Taylor, 11th International Workshop on Wave Hindcasting and Forecasting, 2009.

14 Wave-structure interaction 6 ka = ka = ka = 3 ray theory approx 6 ka = Diffracted wave field near single vertical cylinder

15 Diffraction by arrays, near-trapping and wave-in-deck 6 ka = , β = 0 o 6 ka = , β = 15 o ka = , β = 30 o ka = , β = 45 o

16 Near-trapping in square array Runup at cylinder 3, β = 45

17 Influence of local geometry Dimensionless wave amplitude near arrays of circular and non-circular cylinders ka= 1.831, β= 45 (simple models of a specific semisubmersible).

18 Application to a GBS

19 2 nd order behaviour simulated using Oxford program DIFFRACT near trapping frequency doubling : input waves at frequency f strong local surface response at 2f Body and free-surface grid for quadrant of the structure (using two planes of symmetry)

20 Incident wave End-on waves at near-trapping. β=0 o, f=0.126 Hz

21 Where does the high response occur? Linear amplitude response profile along the center-line of the structure at f=0.126hz. 2 nd order sum amplitude profile along the center-line of the structure at 2f =0.126Hz. Linear diffraction calculations provide useful guidance to 2 nd order behaviour

22 11m Predicted surface elevation between the rear legs with 11m incident focused wave group T p = 14.3 s η (1) η (2+) η (1+2) =TOTAL Practical implications for concrete GBS with closely spaced columns - water projection to high level - hitting the deck - air down to just above the caisson (slam loading on the top?) Walker et al., Ocean Engineering 2008

23 Waves in gap between closely spaced vessels SAFE OFFLOAD programme (EU) Noble Denton Experiments at DHI and Imperial College have confirmed importance of large free surface motions in the gap As has second order boundary element analysis at Oxford

24 Linear motions and elevations, beam sea 1 Floating Fixed

25 Relationship between first-order and second-order results for elevation(beam sea 1) point (-2,0) 7 point (-2,0) LINEAR nd order quadratic η (1) /A η (2) q ω (rad/s) point (-2,0) TOTAL 2 nd order ω (rad/s) point (-2,0) 2 nd order potential 0.76 η (2) η (2) p ω (rad/s) ω (rad/s) First-order Second-order

26

27 Behaviour in transient waves Response in gap between 2 boxes with NewWavefocused group, beam seas, broad band spectrum

28 Experiments on GBS and Tanker (fixed) IC model scale unit: m water depth=0.82m

29 First-order wave elevation at centre line 5 4 T=0.780s(beam sea 2) Numerical (Oxford) Experimental (IC) T=0.889s(beam sea 2) Numerical (Oxford) Experimental (IC) 3 4 η (1) /A 2 η (1) /A y T=1.067s(beam sea 2) Numerical (Oxford) Experimental (IC) y T=1.455s(beam sea 2) Numerical (Oxford) Experimental (IC) η (1) /A η (1) /A y y

30 T p =1.2s incident y=0 Wave group excitation Beam sea, tanker exposed ζ t(s) First-order elevations at point (-0.03,0) in Beam Sea (T=1.01s) (T=1.03s) Numerical(Oxford) Experimental(IC) RAO for elevation at midpoint of gap η (1) /A (T=0.88s) (T=0.77s) Overall good agreement -freq of peak ~2% out - magnitude over-estimated f(hz)

31 Floatover operations Behaviour of flexibly connected bodies Chevron Olokola Floatover Installation Study Ocean Dynamics LLC

32 Relative heave motions of barges based on extension of diffraction analysis for flexibly connected vessels

33 Link to hydroelastic analysis of flexibly connected structures From: Wang, C. M. & Tay, Z. Y. HydroelasticAnalysis and Response of Pontoon-Type Very Large Floating Structures

34 Areas needing further understanding As discussed here Extreme wave statistics Directional nonlinear wave kinematics (with and without breaking) Wave structure interaction effects various, including wave-in-deck Other topics Coupled tank sloshing and vessel motions (parametric resonance, ) Impact pressures (compressibility effects, ) Hydroelasticity

35 Areas for further CFD development Unstructured adaptive grids for VOF modelling Overlapping grids Grid size (Re) 9/4 (for representation of disparate length scales in turbulent flow) Turbulence modelling for unsteady free surface flows LES SPH Hybrid approaches: simple modelling to identify critical parameters (wave frequency, direction, load case, geometry), followed by very detailed CFD e.g. strip theory + RANSE Coupled and multi-scale formulations Benchmark results for validation Integration of codes into optimisation tools (as has been done for nonlinear wave resistance)

36 Opportunities for marine CFD From:

37 Opportunities for marine CFD Courtesy:

38 Opportunities for marine CFD Courtesy:

39 Thank you Questions?

VIOLENT WAVE TRAPPING - SOME RESULTS ON WATER PROJECTION AROUND SEMI-SUBs AND TLPs

VIOLENT WAVE TRAPPING - SOME RESULTS ON WATER PROJECTION AROUND SEMI-SUBs AND TLPs VIOLENT WAVE TRAPPING - SOME RESULTS ON WATER PROJECTION AROUND SEMI-SUBs AND TLPs Paul H. Taylor James Grice Rodney Eatock Taylor Department of Engineering Science University of Oxford Contents Introduction

More information

THE NATURE OF THE DRAUPNER GIANT WAVE OF 1 ST JAN 1995 AND THE ASSOCIATED SEA-STATE AND

THE NATURE OF THE DRAUPNER GIANT WAVE OF 1 ST JAN 1995 AND THE ASSOCIATED SEA-STATE AND THE NATURE OF THE DRAUPNER GIANT WAVE OF 1 ST JAN 1995 AND THE ASSOCIATED SEA-STATE AND HOW TO ESTIMATE DIRECTIONAL SPREADING FROM AN EULERIAN SURFACE ELEVATION TIME HISTORY PAUL TAYLOR, TOM ADCOCK, ALISTAIR

More information

Wave Driven Free Surface Motion in the Gap between a Tanker and an FLNG Barge

Wave Driven Free Surface Motion in the Gap between a Tanker and an FLNG Barge Wave Driven Free Surface Motion in the Gap between a Tanker and an FLNG Barge L. Sun a, R. Eatock Taylor a,b and P. H. Taylor b a Centre for Offshore Research & Engineering and Department of Civil & Environmental

More information

OTG-13. Prediction of air gap for column stabilised units. Won Ho Lee 01 February Ungraded. 01 February 2017 SAFER, SMARTER, GREENER

OTG-13. Prediction of air gap for column stabilised units. Won Ho Lee 01 February Ungraded. 01 February 2017 SAFER, SMARTER, GREENER OTG-13 Prediction of air gap for column stabilised units Won Ho Lee 1 SAFER, SMARTER, GREENER Contents Air gap design requirements Purpose of OTG-13 OTG-13 vs. OTG-14 Contributions to air gap Linear analysis

More information

Methodology for sloshing induced slamming loads and response. Olav Rognebakke Det Norske Veritas AS

Methodology for sloshing induced slamming loads and response. Olav Rognebakke Det Norske Veritas AS Methodology for sloshing induced slamming loads and response Olav Rognebakke Det Norske Veritas AS Post doc. CeSOS 2005-2006 1 Presentation overview Physics of sloshing and motivation Sloshing in rectangular

More information

Seakeeping Models in the Frequency Domain

Seakeeping Models in the Frequency Domain Seakeeping Models in the Frequency Domain (Module 6) Dr Tristan Perez Centre for Complex Dynamic Systems and Control (CDSC) Prof. Thor I Fossen Department of Engineering Cybernetics 18/09/2007 One-day

More information

Notes for the Students by Marilena Greco:

Notes for the Students by Marilena Greco: Notes for the Students by Marilena Greco: In the following you find topics proposed by MARINTEK, by DNV GL and by SINTEF Fisheries and Aquaculture, for possible Project and Master Theses on hydrodynamic

More information

OMAE HIGH FREQUENCY LOADING AND RESPONSE OF OFFSHORE STRUCTURES IN STEEP WAVES

OMAE HIGH FREQUENCY LOADING AND RESPONSE OF OFFSHORE STRUCTURES IN STEEP WAVES Proceedings of the ASME 11 3th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering OMAE11 June 19-24, 11, Rotterdam, The Netherlands OMAE11-51 HIGH FREQUENCY LOADING AND RESPONSE OF OFFSHORE

More information

WAMIT-MOSES Hydrodynamic Analysis Comparison Study. JRME, July 2000

WAMIT-MOSES Hydrodynamic Analysis Comparison Study. JRME, July 2000 - Hydrodynamic Analysis Comparison Study - Hydrodynamic Analysis Comparison Study JRME, Prepared by Hull Engineering Department J. Ray McDermott Engineering, LLC 1 - Hydrodynamic Analysis Comparison Study

More information

Comparison of Present Wave Induced Load Criteria with Loads Induced by an Abnormal Wave

Comparison of Present Wave Induced Load Criteria with Loads Induced by an Abnormal Wave Rogue Waves 2004 1 Comparison of Present Wave Induced Load Criteria with Loads Induced by an Abnormal Wave C. Guedes Soares, N. Fonseca, R. Pascoal Unit of Marine Engineering and Technology, Technical

More information

SIMPLIFICATION BY MATHEMATIC MODEL TO SOLVE THE EXPERIMENTAL OF SLOSHING EFFECT ON THE FPSO VESSEL

SIMPLIFICATION BY MATHEMATIC MODEL TO SOLVE THE EXPERIMENTAL OF SLOSHING EFFECT ON THE FPSO VESSEL European International Journal of Science and Technology Vol. 3 No. 5 June, 2014 SIMPLIFICATION BY MATHEMATIC MODEL TO SOLVE THE EXPERIMENTAL OF SLOSHING EFFECT ON THE FPSO VESSEL LuhutTumpalParulianSinaga

More information

Hull-tether-riser dynamics of deep water tension leg platforms

Hull-tether-riser dynamics of deep water tension leg platforms Fluid Structure Interaction V 15 Hull-tether-riser dynamics of deep water tension leg platforms R. Jayalekshmi 1, R. Sundaravadivelu & V. G. Idichandy 1 Department of Civil Engineering, NSS College of

More information

MODELLING THE INTERACTION BETWEEN WATER WAVES AND THE OSCILLATING WATER COLUMN WAVE ENERGY DEVICE. Utku Şentürk, Aydoğan Özdamar

MODELLING THE INTERACTION BETWEEN WATER WAVES AND THE OSCILLATING WATER COLUMN WAVE ENERGY DEVICE. Utku Şentürk, Aydoğan Özdamar Mathematical and Computational Applications, Vol. 16, No. 3, pp. 630-640, 2011. Association for Scientific Research MODELLING THE INTERACTION BETWEEN WATER WAVES AND THE OSCILLATING WATER COLUMN WAVE ENERGY

More information

Report of the Ocean Engineering Committee

Report of the Ocean Engineering Committee Report of the Ocean Engineering Committee Presented by Wei Qiu, Committee Chair Memorial University, Canada September 4, 2014 Copenhagen, Denmark Committee Members Prof. Wei Qiu (Chairman), Ocean Engineering

More information

A Preliminary Analysis on the Statistics of about One-Year Air Gap Measurement for a Semi-submersible in South China Sea

A Preliminary Analysis on the Statistics of about One-Year Air Gap Measurement for a Semi-submersible in South China Sea Proceedings of the Twenty-sixth (2016) International Ocean and Polar Engineering Conference Rhodes, Greece, June 26-July 1, 2016 Copyright 2016 by the International Society of Offshore and Polar Engineers

More information

EXTREME VERTICAL IMPACT ON THE DECK OF A GRAVITY-BASED STRUCTURE

EXTREME VERTICAL IMPACT ON THE DECK OF A GRAVITY-BASED STRUCTURE Rogue Waves 2004 Brest October 20 th 22 nd 2004 EXTREME VERTICAL IMPACT ON THE DECK OF A GRAVITY-BASED STRUCTURE Rolf Baarholm, Carl Trygve Stansberg, 1 Contents Background and objective for study Simplified

More information

Overview of BV R&D activities in Marine Hydrodynamics

Overview of BV R&D activities in Marine Hydrodynamics Overview of BV R&D activities in Marine Hydrodynamics Special attention to hydro-structure interactions Šime Malenica Bureau Veritas Marine & Offshore Division Research Department Harbin, 29th of June

More information

Simple Estimation of Wave Added Resistance from Experiments in Transient and Irregular Water Waves

Simple Estimation of Wave Added Resistance from Experiments in Transient and Irregular Water Waves Simple Estimation of Wave Added Resistance from Experiments in Transient and Irregular Water Waves by Tsugukiyo Hirayama*, Member Xuefeng Wang*, Member Summary Experiments in transient water waves are

More information

Second-order diffraction by two concentric truncated cylinders

Second-order diffraction by two concentric truncated cylinders Second-order diffraction by two concentric truncated cylinders by Spyros A. Mavrakos and Ioannis K. Chatjigeorgiou National Technical University of Athens Laboratory for Floating Bodies and Mooring Systems,

More information

Proceedings of OMAE'02 21 st International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering June 23-27, 2002, Oslo, Norway

Proceedings of OMAE'02 21 st International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering June 23-27, 2002, Oslo, Norway Proceedings of OMAE'02 21 st International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering June 23-27, 2002, Oslo, Norway OMAE 2002-28435 ESTIMATION OF EXTREME RESPONSE AND FATIGUE DAMAGE FOR COLLIDING

More information

The role of resonant wave interactions in the evolution of extreme wave events

The role of resonant wave interactions in the evolution of extreme wave events The role of resonant wave interactions in the evolution of extreme wave events Richard Gibson & Chris Swan Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Imperial College London SW7 2AZ United Kingdom

More information

DYNAMIC CHARACTERISTICS OF OFFSHORE TENSION LEG PLATFORMS UNDER HYDRODYNAMIC FORCES

DYNAMIC CHARACTERISTICS OF OFFSHORE TENSION LEG PLATFORMS UNDER HYDRODYNAMIC FORCES International Journal of Civil Engineering (IJCE) ISSN(P): 2278-9987; ISSN(E): 2278-9995 Vol. 3, Issue 1, Jan 214, 7-16 IASET DYNAMIC CHARACTERISTICS OF OFFSHORE TENSION LEG PLATFORMS UNDER HYDRODYNAMIC

More information

STEP-WEC: STEP CHANGE FOR WAVE ENERGY CONVERSION THROUGH FLOATING MULTI-BODY MULTI-MODE SYSTEMS.

STEP-WEC: STEP CHANGE FOR WAVE ENERGY CONVERSION THROUGH FLOATING MULTI-BODY MULTI-MODE SYSTEMS. UKCMER SuperGen Marine Energy Grand Challenge Assembly 216 STEP-WEC: STEP CHANGE FOR WAVE ENERGY CONVERSION THROUGH FLOATING MULTI-BODY MULTI-MODE SYSTEMS. People Manchester Bath Oxford Peter Stansby Jun

More information

Optimal Design of FPSO Vessels

Optimal Design of FPSO Vessels November 2, 201 Optimal Design of FPSO Vessels Ezebuchi Akandu PhD, MTech, BTech, COREN, RINA, MNSE Department of Marine Engineering, Rivers State University, Port Harcourt, Nigeria akandu.ezebuchi@ust.edu.ng

More information

The dynamics of the floodwater and the damaged ship in waves

The dynamics of the floodwater and the damaged ship in waves The dynamics of the floodwater and the damaged ship in waves Zhiliang Gao ( 高志亮 ) 1*, Dracos Vassalos 2 1 Research Center of Coastal and Estuarine Engineering, Tianjin Research Institute for Water Transport

More information

Time domain assessment of nonlinear coupled ship motions and sloshing in free surface tanks

Time domain assessment of nonlinear coupled ship motions and sloshing in free surface tanks Time domain assessment of nonlinear coupled ship motions and sloshing in free surface tanks 1 outline 1.Motivation & state-of-the-art 2.Simulation approach 1.SHIXDOF: nonlinear ship motion TD 6DOF 2.AQUAgpusph:

More information

Analytical Predictions of the Air Gap Response of Floating Structures

Analytical Predictions of the Air Gap Response of Floating Structures Lance Manuel Department of Civil Engineering, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712 e-mail: lmanuel@mail.utexas.edu Bert Sweetman Steven R. Winterstein Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering,

More information

Safetrans Safe design and operation of marine transports

Safetrans Safe design and operation of marine transports Safetrans Safe design and operation of marine transports CONTENTS General Voyage Motion Climate Monte Carlo Simulations Calculation of Ship Motions Weather Databases User Group References 2 SAFETRANS Safetrans

More information

Yanlin Shao 1 Odd M. Faltinsen 2

Yanlin Shao 1 Odd M. Faltinsen 2 Yanlin Shao 1 Odd M. Faltinsen 1 Ship Hydrodynamics & Stability, Det Norsk Veritas, Norway Centre for Ships and Ocean Structures (CeSOS), NTNU, Norway 1 The state-of-the-art potential flow analysis: Boundary

More information

Modelling and Identification of Radiation-force Models for Ships and Marine Structures

Modelling and Identification of Radiation-force Models for Ships and Marine Structures Modelling and Identification of Radiation-force Models for Ships and Marine Structures A/Prof Tristan Perez Leader Autonomous Systems & Robotics School of Engineering, the University of Newcastle AUSTRALIA

More information

Hull loads and response, hydroelasticity

Hull loads and response, hydroelasticity Transactions on the Built Environment vol 1, 1993 WIT Press, www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3509 Hull loads and response, hydroelasticity effects on fast monohulls E. Jullumstr0 & J.V. Aarsnes Division of

More information

Effect of Tethers Tension Force in the Behavior of a Tension Leg Platform Subjected to Hydrodynamic Force Amr R. El-Gamal, Ashraf Essa, Ayman Ismail

Effect of Tethers Tension Force in the Behavior of a Tension Leg Platform Subjected to Hydrodynamic Force Amr R. El-Gamal, Ashraf Essa, Ayman Ismail Vol:7, No:1, 13 Effect of Tethers Tension Force in the Behavior of a Tension Leg Platform Subjected to Hydrodynamic Force Amr R. El-Gamal, Ashraf Essa, Ayman Ismail International Science Index, Bioengineering

More information

Design, Construction & Operation of LNG/LPG Ships, November, Glasgow, UK

Design, Construction & Operation of LNG/LPG Ships, November, Glasgow, UK Design, Construction & Operation of LNG/LPG Ships, 29-3 November, Glasgow, UK SLOSHING AND SWIRLING IN MEMBRANE LNG TANKS AND THEIR COUPLING EFFECTS WITH SHIP MOTION M Arai and G M Karuka, Yokohama National

More information

Analysis of experimental data: The average shape of extreme wave forces on monopile foundations and the NewForce model

Analysis of experimental data: The average shape of extreme wave forces on monopile foundations and the NewForce model Downloaded from orbit.dtu.dk on: Jan 6 29 Analysis of experimental data: The average shape of extreme wave forces on monopile foundations and the NewForce model Schløer Signe; Bredmose Henrik; Ghadirian

More information

INFLUENCE OF TETHER LENGTH IN THE RESPONSE BEHAVIOR OF SQUARE TENSION LEG PLATFORM IN REGULAR WAVES

INFLUENCE OF TETHER LENGTH IN THE RESPONSE BEHAVIOR OF SQUARE TENSION LEG PLATFORM IN REGULAR WAVES INFLUENCE OF TETHER LENGTH IN THE RESPONSE BEHAVIOR OF SQUARE TENSION LEG PLATFOR IN REGULAR WAVES 1 Amr R. El-gamal, 2 Ashraf Essa, 1 Faculty of Engineering, Benha Univ., Egypt, 2 Associated prof., National

More information

WP-1 Hydrodynamics: Background and Strategy

WP-1 Hydrodynamics: Background and Strategy WP-1 Hydrodynamics: Background and Strategy Harry B. Bingham Robert Read (Post-doc) Torben Christiansen (PhD) Mech. Engineering Tech. Univ. of Denmark Lygnby, Denmark Eric D. Christensen Hans Hansen DHI

More information

OpenFOAM simulations of irregular waves and free surface effects around a monopile offshore wind turbine

OpenFOAM simulations of irregular waves and free surface effects around a monopile offshore wind turbine OpenFOAM simulations of irregular waves and free surface effects around a monopile offshore wind turbine Ariel J. Edesess 1 4 th Year PhD Candidate Supervisors: Dr. Denis Kelliher 1, Dr. Gareth Thomas

More information

Rogue Waves. Thama Duba, Colin Please, Graeme Hocking, Kendall Born, Meghan Kennealy. 18 January /25

Rogue Waves. Thama Duba, Colin Please, Graeme Hocking, Kendall Born, Meghan Kennealy. 18 January /25 1/25 Rogue Waves Thama Duba, Colin Please, Graeme Hocking, Kendall Born, Meghan Kennealy 18 January 2019 2/25 What is a rogue wave Mechanisms causing rogue waves Where rogue waves have been reported Modelling

More information

Q/A Sheet. Title of Abstract: Active sound control using a floating flexible plate Author(s): Avital, E. et al. Question(s)

Q/A Sheet. Title of Abstract: Active sound control using a floating flexible plate Author(s): Avital, E. et al. Question(s) Title of Abstract: Active sound control using a floating flexible plate Author(s): Avital, E. et al. Name: R.W.Yeung : I was not too sure how you plan to do your control of the pressure applied on the

More information

Analytically-oriented approaches to nonlinear sloshing in moving smooth tanks

Analytically-oriented approaches to nonlinear sloshing in moving smooth tanks Analytically-oriented approaches to nonlinear sloshing in moving smooth tanks by Alexander Timokha (Jena-Kiev-Leipzig-Trondheim) & Ivan Gavrilyuk (Eisenach-Leipzig) Overview Motivation: coupling with rigid

More information

LIQUID SLOSHING DYNAMICS IN A BARGE CARRYING CONTAINER SUBJECTED TO RANDOM WAVE EXCITATION T. Nasar 1, S.A.Sannasiraj 2 and V.

LIQUID SLOSHING DYNAMICS IN A BARGE CARRYING CONTAINER SUBJECTED TO RANDOM WAVE EXCITATION T. Nasar 1, S.A.Sannasiraj 2 and V. Journal of Naval Architecture and Marine Engineering June, 22 DOI:.3329/jname.v9i.76 http://www.banglajol.info LIQUID SLOSHING DYNAMICS IN A BARGE CARRYING CONTAINER SUBJECTED TO RANDOM WAVE EXCITATION

More information

Hydrodynamic Interaction of Three Floating Structures

Hydrodynamic Interaction of Three Floating Structures Hydrodynamic Interaction of Three Floating Structures Muhammad Farid Abdul Halim, a, and Jaswar Koto, a,b,* a) Department of Aeronautical, Automotive and Ocean Engineering, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering,

More information

Exploitation of Ocean Predictions by the Oil and Gas Industry. GODAE OceanView Symposium 2013

Exploitation of Ocean Predictions by the Oil and Gas Industry. GODAE OceanView Symposium 2013 Exploitation of Ocean Predictions by the Oil and Gas Industry GODAE OceanView Symposium 2013 Introduction Information needs Challenges Acknowledgements IMarEST/SUT Metocean Awareness Course Colleagues

More information

THE EXCEEDENCE PROBABILITY OF WAVE CRESTS CALCULATED BY THE SPECTRAL RESPONSE SURFACE METHOD. R.Gibson, P.Tromans and C.Swan

THE EXCEEDENCE PROBABILITY OF WAVE CRESTS CALCULATED BY THE SPECTRAL RESPONSE SURFACE METHOD. R.Gibson, P.Tromans and C.Swan THE EXCEEDENCE PROBABILITY OF WAVE CRESTS CALCULATED BY THE SPECTRAL RESPONSE SURFACE METHOD R.Gibson, P.Tromans and C.Swan Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Imperial College London. SW7

More information

Influence of sea structures on wind measurements: CFD analysis

Influence of sea structures on wind measurements: CFD analysis Influence of sea structures on wind measurements: CFD analysis Leonid Vasilyev, Konstantinos Christakos, Brian Hannafious Polytec R&D Institute EERA DeepWind 2015 12 th Deep Sea Offshore Wind R&D Conference,

More information

ROLL MOTION OF A RORO-SHIP IN IRREGULAR FOLLOWING WAVES

ROLL MOTION OF A RORO-SHIP IN IRREGULAR FOLLOWING WAVES 38 Journal of Marine Science and Technology, Vol. 9, o. 1, pp. 38-44 (2001) ROLL MOTIO OF A RORO-SHIP I IRREGULAR FOLLOWIG WAVES Jianbo Hua* and Wei-Hui Wang** Keywords: roll motion, parametric excitation,

More information

A Discussion About Seakeeping and Manoeuvring Models For Surface Vessels

A Discussion About Seakeeping and Manoeuvring Models For Surface Vessels A Discussion About Seakeeping and Manoeuvring Models For Surface Vessels Tristan Perez, Thor I. Fossen and Asgeir Sørensen Technical Report (MSS-TR-001) Marine System Simulator (MSS) Group (http://www.cesos.ntnu.no/mss/)

More information

Space-Time Wave Extremes in WAVEWATCH III: Implementation and Validation for the Adriatic Sea Case Study

Space-Time Wave Extremes in WAVEWATCH III: Implementation and Validation for the Adriatic Sea Case Study Space-Time Wave Extremes in WAVEWATCH III: Implementation and Validation for the Adriatic Sea Case Study Francesco Barbariol 1, Jose-Henrique G.M. Alves 2,3, Alvise Benetazzo 1, Filippo Bergamasco 1, Luciana

More information

CFD DESIGN OF A GENERIC CONTROLLER FOR VORTEX-INDUCED RESONANCE

CFD DESIGN OF A GENERIC CONTROLLER FOR VORTEX-INDUCED RESONANCE Seventh International Conference on CFD in the Minerals and Process Industries CSIRO, Melbourne, Australia 9-11 December 2009 CFD DESIGN OF A GENERIC CONTROLLER FOR VORTEX-INDUCED RESONANCE Andrew A. ANTIOHOS,

More information

Hydrodynamic analysis and modelling of ships

Hydrodynamic analysis and modelling of ships Hydrodynamic analysis and modelling of ships Wave loading Harry B. Bingham Section for Coastal, Maritime & Structural Eng. Department of Mechanical Engineering Technical University of Denmark DANSIS møde

More information

Classification of offshore structures

Classification of offshore structures Classification: Internal Status: Draft Classification of offshore structures A classification in degree of non-linearities and importance of dynamics. Sverre Haver, StatoilHydro, January 8 A first classification

More information

Trajectory Tracking of a Near-Surface Torpedo using Numerical Methods

Trajectory Tracking of a Near-Surface Torpedo using Numerical Methods ISSN (Print) : 2347-671 An ISO 3297: 27 Certified Organization Vol.4, Special Issue 12, September 215 Trajectory Tracking of a Near-Surface Torpedo using Numerical Methods Anties K. Martin, Anubhav C.A.,

More information

Experimental and numerical investigation of 2D sloshing: scenarios near the critical filling depth

Experimental and numerical investigation of 2D sloshing: scenarios near the critical filling depth Experimental and numerical investigation of 2D sloshing: scenarios near the critical filling depth A. Colagrossi F. Palladino M. Greco a.colagrossi@insean.it f.palladino@insean.it m.greco@insean.it C.

More information

HEAVE DAMPING EFFECTS DUE TO CIRCULAR PLATES ATTACHED AT KEEL TO SPAR HULL

HEAVE DAMPING EFFECTS DUE TO CIRCULAR PLATES ATTACHED AT KEEL TO SPAR HULL HEAVE DAMPING EFFECTS DUE TO CIRCULAR PLATES ATTACHED AT KEEL TO SPAR HULL P.Uma 1 1 M.TECH Civil Engineering Dadi Institute of Engineering and Technology College Abstract Single point Anchor Reservoir

More information

Published in: Proceedings of the Twentieth (2010) International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference

Published in: Proceedings of the Twentieth (2010) International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference Aalborg Universitet Performance Evaluation of an Axysimmetric Floating OWC Alves, M. A.; Costa, I. R.; Sarmento, A. J.; Chozas, Julia Fernandez Published in: Proceedings of the Twentieth (010) International

More information

The use of a floating quay for container terminals. 1. Introduction

The use of a floating quay for container terminals. 1. Introduction The use of a floating quay for container terminals. M. van der Wel M.vanderWel@student.tudelft.nl Ir. J.G. de Gijt J.G.deGijt@tudelft.nl Public Works Rotterdam/TU Delft Ir. D. Dudok van Heel D.DudokvanHeel@gw.rotterdam.nl

More information

EVALUATION OF THE EFFECT OF CONTACT BETWEEN RISERS AND GUIDE FRAMES ON OFFSHORE SPAR PLATFORM MOTIONS. A Dissertation BON-JUN KOO

EVALUATION OF THE EFFECT OF CONTACT BETWEEN RISERS AND GUIDE FRAMES ON OFFSHORE SPAR PLATFORM MOTIONS. A Dissertation BON-JUN KOO EVALUATION OF THE EFFECT OF CONTACT BETWEEN RISERS AND GUIDE FRAMES ON OFFSHORE SPAR PLATFORM MOTIONS A Dissertation by BON-JUN KOO Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University in

More information

International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 9, Issue 2, February ISSN

International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 9, Issue 2, February ISSN International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 9, Issue, February-8 48 Structural Response of a Standalone FPSO by Swell Wave in Offshore Nigeria Abam Tamunopekere Joshua*, Akaawase

More information

Evaluation of Hydrodynamic Performance of a Damaged Ship in Waves

Evaluation of Hydrodynamic Performance of a Damaged Ship in Waves Evaluation of Hydrodynamic Performance of a Damaged Ship in Waves Sa Young Hong, Seok-Kyu Cho, Byoung Wan Kim, Gyeong Jung Lee, Ki-Sup Kim Maritime and Ocean Engineering Research Institute/KORDI, Daejeon,

More information

Multiple Wave Spectra. Richard May Team Lead, Aqwa development

Multiple Wave Spectra. Richard May Team Lead, Aqwa development Multiple Wave Spectra Richard May Team Lead, Aqwa development . Introduction Ocean waves with different frequencies and directions are very difficult to model mathematically Various simplified theories

More information

TIME-DOMAIN SIMULATION OF THE WAVE-

TIME-DOMAIN SIMULATION OF THE WAVE- Chinese-German Joint ymposium on Hydraulic and Ocean Engineering, August 4-3, 8, Darmstadt TIME-DOMAIN IMULATION OF THE WAVE- CURRENT DIFFRACTION FROM 3D BOD Abstract: Zhen Liu, ing Gou and Bin Teng tate

More information

Nonlinear Sloshing Simulation under Dynamic Excitations

Nonlinear Sloshing Simulation under Dynamic Excitations Nonlinear Sloshing Simulation under Dynamic Excitations Neptune Yu, Alex To and Goman Ho (Ove Arup & Partners Hong Kong Ltd., Hong Kong) Abstract: This paper simulated non-linear sloshing effects under

More information

The effect of top tension on VIV model analysis of a vertical flexible riser

The effect of top tension on VIV model analysis of a vertical flexible riser The Second Conference of Global Chinese Scholars on Hydrodynamics The effect of top tension on VIV model analysis of a vertical flexible riser Muyu Duan 1,2, Bowen Fu 1, Decheng Wan 1* 1 State Key Laboratory

More information

Modelling trends in the ocean wave climate for dimensioning of ships

Modelling trends in the ocean wave climate for dimensioning of ships Modelling trends in the ocean wave climate for dimensioning of ships STK1100 lecture, University of Oslo Erik Vanem Motivation and background 2 Ocean waves and maritime safety Ships and other marine structures

More information

Analysis of a Wave Energy Converter with a Particular Focus on the Effects of Power Take-Off Forces on the Structural Responses

Analysis of a Wave Energy Converter with a Particular Focus on the Effects of Power Take-Off Forces on the Structural Responses Analysis of a Wave Energy Converter with a Particular Focus on the Effects of Power Take-Off Forces on the Structural Responses Andrew Zurkinden, Lars Damkilde Wave Energy Research Group Civil Engineering

More information

MODELLING RECURRENCE MOTION OF A LARGE VOLUME SEMI- SUBMERSIBLE

MODELLING RECURRENCE MOTION OF A LARGE VOLUME SEMI- SUBMERSIBLE Jurnal Mekanikal December 2012, No 35, 13-27 MODELLING RECURRENCE MOTION OF A LARGE VOLUME SEMI- SUBMERSIBLE Agoes Priyanto *, Adi Maimun and Dwi Putra Rishandi Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Universiti

More information

Experimental and numerical investigation of 2D sloshing with slamming

Experimental and numerical investigation of 2D sloshing with slamming Experimental numerical investigation of 2D sloshing with slamming A. Colagrossi C. Lugni M. Greco O. M. Faltinsen a.colagrossi@insean.it c.lugni@insean.it m.greco@insean.it oddfal@marin.ntnu.no INSEAN,

More information

Theoretical Study on Effect of Turret Location on Dynamic Response of Moored Twin Hulls FPSO System

Theoretical Study on Effect of Turret Location on Dynamic Response of Moored Twin Hulls FPSO System Theoretical Study on Effect of Turret Location on Dynamic Response of Moored Twin Hulls FPSO System Nik Mohd Khairuddin B. Nik Ismail, a, and Jaswar. Koto, a,b,* a) Department of Aeronautics, Automotive

More information

AEROELASTICITY IN AXIAL FLOW TURBOMACHINES

AEROELASTICITY IN AXIAL FLOW TURBOMACHINES von Karman Institute for Fluid Dynamics Lecture Series Programme 1998-99 AEROELASTICITY IN AXIAL FLOW TURBOMACHINES May 3-7, 1999 Rhode-Saint- Genèse Belgium STRUCTURAL DYNAMICS: BASICS OF DISK AND BLADE

More information

B P. Stansby 1 Introduction. L. Sun 1 J. Zang 1 P. Stansby 2 E. Carpintero Moreno 2 P. H. Taylor 3 R.

B P. Stansby 1 Introduction. L. Sun 1 J. Zang 1 P. Stansby 2 E. Carpintero Moreno 2 P. H. Taylor 3 R. J. Ocean Eng. Mar. Energy (2017) 3:51 68 DOI 10.1007/s40722-016-0071-5 RESEARCH ARTICLE Linear diffraction analysis of the three-float multi-mode wave energy converter M4 for power capture and structural

More information

Control strategies in OWC plants

Control strategies in OWC plants Control strategies in OWC plants 27/03/2017 TECNALIA By François-Xavier Faÿ Contents Generalities in OWC systems Numerical modelling of the overall system Adaptive control for OWC Rotational speed control

More information

A Fully Coupled Model of Non-linear Wave in a Harbor

A Fully Coupled Model of Non-linear Wave in a Harbor Copyright 2013 Tech Science Press CMES, vol.91, no.4, pp.289-312, 2013 A Fully Coupled Model of Non-linear Wave in a Harbor Daguo Wang 1 Abstract: A 2-D time-domain numerical coupled model for non-linear

More information

ASSESSMENT OF STRESS CONCENTRATIONS IN LARGE CONTAINER SHIPS USING BEAM HYDROELASTIC MODEL

ASSESSMENT OF STRESS CONCENTRATIONS IN LARGE CONTAINER SHIPS USING BEAM HYDROELASTIC MODEL ASSESSMENT OF STRESS CONCENTRATIONS IN LARGE CONTAINER SHIPS USING BEAM HYDROELASTIC MODEL Ivo Senjanović, Nikola Vladimir Faculty of Mechanical Engineering and Naval Architecture, University of Zagreb,

More information

Recent hydrodynamic investigations Floating solar islands and Ringing of offshore wind turbines

Recent hydrodynamic investigations Floating solar islands and Ringing of offshore wind turbines Recent hydrodynamic investigations Floating solar islands and Ringing of offshore wind turbines AMOS days 2017 Trondheim, Norway, 09.11.2017 Trygve Kristiansen 1 1 Dept. of Marine Technology and NTNU AMOS,

More information

13. ANALYSIS OF THE NORTH SEA DATA

13. ANALYSIS OF THE NORTH SEA DATA . ANALYSIS OF THE NORTH SEA DATA.. Introduction The aim of the analysis of this additional data from the North Sea (the WADIC project) is not the mere repetition of the analysis of Chapter for another

More information

TOPIC: CONSOLIDATION EXERCISES ON SOUND, DOPPLER EFFECT AND LIGHT. QUESTION 1: 10 minutes (Taken from DoE Additional Exemplar P1 2008)

TOPIC: CONSOLIDATION EXERCISES ON SOUND, DOPPLER EFFECT AND LIGHT. QUESTION 1: 10 minutes (Taken from DoE Additional Exemplar P1 2008) TOPIC: CONSOLIDATION EXERCISES ON SOUND, DOPPLER EFFECT AND LIGHT SECTION A: TYPICAL EXAM QUESTIONS QUESTION 1: 10 minutes (Taken from DoE Additional Exemplar P1 2008) The sketch below shows a stationary

More information

Limit cycle oscillations at resonances

Limit cycle oscillations at resonances IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering PAPER OPEN ACCESS Limit cycle oscillations at resonances To cite this article: K Hellevik and O T Gudmestad 2017 IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng.

More information

CFD Simulations of Floating Point Absorber Wave Energy Converter Arrays Subjected to Regular Waves

CFD Simulations of Floating Point Absorber Wave Energy Converter Arrays Subjected to Regular Waves energies Article CFD Simulations of Floating Point Absorber Wave Energy Converter Arrays Subjected to Regular Waves Brecht Devolder 1,2, ID, Vasiliki Stratigaki 1 ID, Peter Troch 1 ID and Pieter Rauwoens

More information

Numerical Study on the Liquid Sloshing in a Battery Cell Equipped with New Baffle Design

Numerical Study on the Liquid Sloshing in a Battery Cell Equipped with New Baffle Design International Journal of Mechanics and Applications 2016, 6(2): 31-38 DOI: 10.5923/j.mechanics.20160602.03 Numerical Study on the Liquid Sloshing in a Battery Cell Equipped with New Baffle Design Abdallah

More information

Applying the Wavelet Transform to Derive Sea Surface Elevation from Acceleration Signals

Applying the Wavelet Transform to Derive Sea Surface Elevation from Acceleration Signals Applying the Wavelet Transform to Derive Sea Surface Elevation from Acceleration Signals *Laurence Zsu-Hsin Chuang **Li-Chung Wu **Ching-Ruei Lin **Chia Chuen Kao *Institute of Ocean Technology and Marine

More information

Experimental study of the wind effect on the focusing of transient wave groups

Experimental study of the wind effect on the focusing of transient wave groups Experimental study of the wind effect on the focusing of transient wave groups J.P. Giovanangeli 1), C. Kharif 1) and E. Pelinovsky 1,) 1) Institut de Recherche sur les Phénomènes Hors Equilibre, Laboratoire

More information

Chenyu Luan - CeSOS 1. Chenyu Luan a,b,c, Valentin Chabaud a,d, Erin E. Bachynski b,c,d, Zhen Gao b,c,d and Torgeir Moan a,b,c,d

Chenyu Luan - CeSOS 1. Chenyu Luan a,b,c, Valentin Chabaud a,d, Erin E. Bachynski b,c,d, Zhen Gao b,c,d and Torgeir Moan a,b,c,d Validation of a time-domain numerical approach for determining forces and moments in floaters by using measured data of a semi-submersible wind turbine model test Chenyu Luan a,b,c, Valentin Chabaud a,d,

More information

16855 North Chase Drive, Houston Texas (682) Ping Lu

16855 North Chase Drive, Houston Texas (682) Ping Lu 16855 North Chase Drive, Houston Texas 77060 (682) 234-8150 pilu@eagle.org Researcher & Engineer II, Corporate Offshore Technology, American Bureau of Shipping Research Interests & Expertise Numerical

More information

On the evaluation quadratic forces on stationary bodies

On the evaluation quadratic forces on stationary bodies On the evaluation quadratic forces on stationary bodies Chang-Ho Lee AMIT Inc., Chestnut Hill MA, USA June 9, 006 Abstract. Conservation of momentum is applied to finite fluid volume surrounding a body

More information

Effect of Tethers Tension Force on the Behavior of Triangular Tension Leg Platform

Effect of Tethers Tension Force on the Behavior of Triangular Tension Leg Platform American Journal of Civil Engineering and Architecture,, Vol., No. 3, 7- Available online at http://pubs.sciepub.com/ajcea//3/3 Science and Education Publishing DOI:.9/ajcea--3-3 Effect of Tethers Tension

More information

Influence of yaw-roll coupling on the behavior of a FPSO: an experimental and numerical investigation

Influence of yaw-roll coupling on the behavior of a FPSO: an experimental and numerical investigation Influence of yaw-roll coupling on the behavior of a FPSO: an experimental and numerical investigation Claudio Lugni a,b, Marilena Greco a,b, Odd Magnus Faltinsen b a CNR-INSEAN, The Italian Ship Model

More information

Effect of Gravity on the Vertical Force of an Oscillating Wedge at Free Surface

Effect of Gravity on the Vertical Force of an Oscillating Wedge at Free Surface Effect of Gravity on the Vertical Force of an Oscillating Wedge at Free Surface Master of Science Thesis For the degree of Master of Science in Offshore and Dredging Engineering at Delft University of

More information

Den Danske Maritime Fond projekt: , DTU Mek; Post Doc, udvikling af software The Final Report. Report. Mostafa Amini Afshar Harry Bingham

Den Danske Maritime Fond projekt: , DTU Mek; Post Doc, udvikling af software The Final Report. Report. Mostafa Amini Afshar Harry Bingham Den Danske Maritime Fond projekt: 4-88, DTU Mek; Post Doc, udvikling af software The Final Report Report Mostafa Amini Afshar Harry Bingham Contents Project summary.......................................

More information

COPPER FOR BUSBARS CHAPTER 4: SHORT-CIRCUIT EFFECTS

COPPER FOR BUSBARS CHAPTER 4: SHORT-CIRCUIT EFFECTS European Copper Institute COPPER FOR BUSBARS CHAPTER 4: SHORT-CIRCUIT EFFECTS David Chapman August 2011 ECI Available from www.leonardo-energy.org Document Issue Control Sheet Document Title: Publication

More information

Dynamics of Offshore Structures

Dynamics of Offshore Structures - 7?// 3 Dynamics of Offshore Structures, Editor John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Contents Preface Contributors Acknowledgments xi xiii xv 1 Structures in the Offshore Environment 1 1.1 Historical Perspective,

More information

Efficient Prediction of Dynamic Response for Flexible and Multi- Body Marine Structures

Efficient Prediction of Dynamic Response for Flexible and Multi- Body Marine Structures Reza Taghipour Efficient Prediction of Dynamic Response for Flexible and Multi- Body Marine Structures Thesis for the degree of philosophiae doctor Trondheim, October 28 Norwegian University of Science

More information

The Floating Production, Storage and Offloading Vessel Design for Oil Field Development in Harsh Marine Environment

The Floating Production, Storage and Offloading Vessel Design for Oil Field Development in Harsh Marine Environment The Floating Production, Storage and Offloading Vessel Design for Oil Field Development in Harsh Marine Environment Ezebuchi Akandu, a,* AtillaIncecik, a and Nigel Barltrop, a a) Department of Naval Architecture,

More information

Rogue Waves. Alex Andrade Mentor: Dr. Ildar Gabitov. Physical Mechanisms of the Rogue Wave Phenomenon Christian Kharif, Efim Pelinovsky

Rogue Waves. Alex Andrade Mentor: Dr. Ildar Gabitov. Physical Mechanisms of the Rogue Wave Phenomenon Christian Kharif, Efim Pelinovsky Rogue Waves Alex Andrade Mentor: Dr. Ildar Gabitov Physical Mechanisms of the Rogue Wave Phenomenon Christian Kharif, Efim Pelinovsky Rogue Waves in History Rogue Waves have been part of marine folklore

More information

Mathematical modelling and analysis in marine renewable energy

Mathematical modelling and analysis in marine renewable energy Mathematical modelling and analysis in marine renewable energy Pierpaolo Ricci 23 rd April 2012 INDEX About Tecnalia Introduction: The state of Marine Renewables Marine Energy technologies: a systemic

More information

Research Activity of LRETC: Structures

Research Activity of LRETC: Structures Research Activity of LRETC: Structures Y. Kim, W.I. Lee, M.H. Cho (MAE) and In-Sik Nho (CNU) Seoul National University The Lloyd s Register Educational Trust (LRET) y g ( ) Marine & Offshore Research Workshop

More information

Statistical properties of mechanically generated surface gravity waves: a laboratory experiment in a 3D wave basin

Statistical properties of mechanically generated surface gravity waves: a laboratory experiment in a 3D wave basin Statistical properties of mechanically generated surface gravity waves: a laboratory experiment in a 3D wave basin M. Onorato 1, L. Cavaleri 2, O.Gramstad 3, P.A.E.M. Janssen 4, J. Monbaliu 5, A. R. Osborne

More information

Small Scale Field Experiment on Breaking Wave Pressure on Vertical Breakwaters

Small Scale Field Experiment on Breaking Wave Pressure on Vertical Breakwaters Open Journal of Marine Science, 2015, 5, 412-421 Published Online October 2015 in SciRes. http://www.scirp.org/journal/ojms http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/ojms.2015.54033 Small Scale Field Experiment on Breaking

More information

Sloshing-Ship Motion Coupling Effect for the Sloshing Impact Load on the LNG Containment System

Sloshing-Ship Motion Coupling Effect for the Sloshing Impact Load on the LNG Containment System ABS TECHNICAL PAPERS 5 Sloshing-Ship Motion Coupling Effect for the Sloshing Impact Load on the LNG Containment System Jang W. Kim, Kunho Kim, Peter S. Kim and Yung S. Shin American Bureau of Shipping

More information

Aalto University School of Engineering

Aalto University School of Engineering Aalto University School of Engineering Kul-24.4140 Ship Dynamics (P) Lecture 9 Loads Where is this lecture on the course? Design Framework Lecture 5: Equations of Motion Environment Lecture 6: Strip Theory

More information

International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 5, Issue 7, July-2014 ISSN

International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 5, Issue 7, July-2014 ISSN ISSN 2229-5518 692 In literature, finite element formulation uses beam element or plate element for structural modelling which has a limitation on transverse displacement. Atkinson and Manrique [1] studied

More information