E(6T. w5 (U.q ` / gs 3, 3 J9 ' [+!; ) M :B :N/ \ 8 f 4 :!=.1 4 :) :./ 3^K P/.

Transcription

1 *+,- /1392 #$% "! / ( #$ ->0) 5 "&0"0,=!I- 2 1 : C Nv) ( 49 :0= 1392/11/24 : 1392/8/6: E(6T!.4 gf 8!4 8 3E ) 3 J9! 3N0+ = - : d- -] e w5 (U.q ` / gs 3, 3 J9 ' [+!; :@@A ) M - 3N0+ M 2> = ) 3N) ) 3. `+!1 2>! gf ` / : \q ) : TL) 0!K :> [K)D? 2.3 -]!4 8 ) ) U! :\) ] : 8 T :N9 ` /! * [M5 (E ;5!P* : n? \) ; 8 E gs!k` / ]! * 8 :. / `., ) 4 : 8 ] (8 :K' ] ) 2 `<9. 5: Q : ) `., ) : ) 5 K * 3K7 ) * 5 Q OK ` / (3 J9!4 8 ' [+ 8 b0 ) 3. ) 3N)!1 - T 4K: [K)D? -)MN 3 8 :/E ) : *! ) CJ ) `S T!42>.4K: 2 - vc< ) : / J* C 3 4 E. (3/) (!4 8 (: hk * ( :\) :#( DU&" mojtabi@gmail.com eslami.r@ac.au.ir :B :N/ \ 8 f 4 :!=.1 4 :) :./ 3^K P/.2

2 )G.1 4>.3 K!4>!K) * ) * U.q )!4 :q P9 K (4 a+, - :C+!K 8! A 5 (: C tc+ K [ 3w5 4 - L9!K. E).<* : C!E!K 8 4 (4 ' :K7 t.1 m+ 4! :K4 ) 4: :* U.q!K< / 4:? :);!K M W m+ 4! Z9 2/.3 ); 8 : ) `., (: 4< [K)D? T ) K); 2.OK I%"Z. #%I. " '&(%&.2 4) U Z0 (3. ) 3N)!1 zg'!e ) L9 [K)D??!K[? 4 :> [K)D? 2.3 TL) 0 :@@A zg' 3. ) 3N)!1 48 * TL) 0! :K`9 A 4) -1 : 4: 3-4 C `S - E ` / -2 3A K8 E 1? > -3 I%"Z. & #" " # <$.3 6Q I* " < j< n% ) +/ (K) /= (hk *. TE : hk * 4 3. ) 3N)!1.3-1 : hk *.4K: `J [ 58' ) 58' < 3 :>E )! *!K:K58 hk * 4 3. ) 3N)!1 W! N+ 2 ) 4: OQ : [ :> taa ) : -] 30 K8! 53E ) - :+.» : hk *. O* : ) : / * 3 : -] ZG, : hk *.«[3] 8!K (G K3' ) KL+ `40 48 * 8 aq!>n1 ) :Gq t= M.(105 z (1388 (-Q) 4K: K3 ) K!D O (!w53 ) 48 * (O _1 : hk * [JK ) 4N8 ` 5 8 0K ) -] 3/) T ) 0 (: v 1 O _1 :/L 2 O.4: _1.3 ) 8!!4 4) 3/B ) :./ (:!K! 53E 3 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 1. Hidden Factors 108

3 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ 109 ) d>* y9 : 3 3; ) (:!K) 5 ) tm9) :!K (4 * _1 2 3!w53 _1 (: hk * _1 2.3 v 1 8 C>; 2.: v 1 : hk * :q / K! 5OG -!K3N) 2 O.(158 :1380 (!8 ) 4! ) 3 (3N4/ (!8 4: K3N)!P/!K!K! 53E ) : hk * (' ] ) ) 4N8 B ( 4A '!K[K)D? `<9 K8.(162 :1380 ( ).4 :* > > E :4 : : hk * T :. cgq K8 : ) :4 b E hk * T 2 :: (cq : hk * -1 3N) )4!K3' : hk * T 2.: 3* (3 :? _1 58 «:. : -]» : : I' )./ O+ B * (4: 2J hk * 2.(203 :1375 (:Q) 4: 3. e!p/ / ' ) 3.4 E) M : 3 ) 3 W4 3 J9 - >Q ) ].3 :. _1 : -] m0 :@K * 2A ::N>; :>0 : hk * -2 U>L ) - 9 H `N - { ( E) :. ) : :K58 :N>; : hk * 3;5 52 :.4: 3/B C>; ) A ) A: 3 J9!K' T 2. 5: < 2? d ) 3 * Be 39 K) 5 ) > E m0!d ) :1. (e@n (d4? T :!K-] z' (: hk *.(159.z (1380 (!8 ).3 M Z>* [+ 4) (3 *? b E!D) hk * T 2 :: : hk * -3 4 :K58 : -]!K) ) K) *.4 > E > : : ) :!K-] m hk * T 2.4>.1 ' Ux) ) 0/ ) o0 : -] K8 3' ) 4!4) :+. ' * e J (1974 () ) 4N8 159 :1380 (!8 ) 3 cn' ) t < bq) ON/ (: hk *!4O+ 2 3 E 4 53E T ) ) 4N8 wn.: 4 K8 :0 K J. (4 E) hk * :>0 cq : hk * :4 : - 3 ' :.0Q!4O+!4`J.(8 z (1391 (:,<) : cq : hk * : :>0 : :,L OK ) : hk *! 4: -d *,L E!> E :!> E w5.9 P `J ) (w5.9!4ˆ? ) 3>L) e!> E. 2 3>0 OK : hk *. Q 4 ) {4= 2/ (> 2 4: : hk * F 24. :.(205 z (1375 (:Q).4 : R ( : 2/ ) 4 : ) :>0 hk * R ( 4 109

4 : -] 4)!1 E) :K> ) KWC > E K : hk * -4Q T K 3 0/ : 3» (b E :; > (: (3*S).4: O] O9 tq!w5 gs! :>1+ ( : ) * (a* a* (0.B) O/ : J9 U.q v1 : 0K [M5 : /! (: /!K3 U > 2 (247 z (1380 (!?) «. 5 :Q R :Q!K\) (:. ) :.,! p49 3 (3-4/ 5 :>) UB 4: - : 3 (: 3 : : hk * ) ) 0N8!4O+ E.3 5 ) 3 J9 - [+!> 1 3 J9 Z{>* 2 3 J9 :/L (: : hk * ) 4K - ) (- ) [+ ) 3 J9 3/) - 39 ) 4Q Z/ ( > 3K - [+ 3K - [+ (: ) :>0 : hk *!5) [+ ) P9 2.4: 3 J9 Z>* :K@E! ) [+ :4: 4? 3K ) 3/ 3 J9 30 ( z z (1380 (K).3 J9!4 8 6Q =" I* b0 A J ) WC A H 3 2 3/) 4E) : -] 2A» od) J > : -] e 0/. E (1381 (3)) «.4 3/B [ + ) 2Q - bq [o )] ) 3 : J9 a9 = O9 >0 A 3 2 «3/)» 2) _L 2! :55!K54. {E ) 3/B -)MN ) 4 V G /E 48 - ) 4@ OK 3/) ) - : O+ :. : 3 4 )4 54 e :- ) 3/) :@@.8 :g) :K?!K3 J9.4K ) ) 8 ) 4 d 3/) 4 ) 3{/) E) :K54 (Z) :- a.1 :q 3/) («:».4: [+! K - 8 `0Q O=? Q 28 vc1< 2!?.!E [q 2 : «!d- BC* H0N ˆK 2 3! ) J9 :> : 8 5: C 0 K3 J9!K Kx 8 ) -;.t» 2 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 1. Active 2. Subjective 3. Legitimacy 110

5 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ U> ). 40 *! Kx M : (4: ; * 8 ) h@ - 3 p - :K) 5 4: : J9 :) 8!.3 4 :!4>.(114 z (1380 (:Q,) 4 Z/ ' : Z 4:!N+ ) 24E (I) :K54 :- 8 3N0+ 4' 8 3/).r 4: - 8 3N0+ (- I :q R! 3/) (3N0+ ) 3/) * 5 s :!d- :0 : C -].4-] e! Q 2 ) «N FG» 3 J9 3/) b0 (> 44 ) +* :> ( < (-G> 30R +* :N) ) 2 G> S ( 0?) : C O9 (4)4' :> 4: 3N0+ ].3 4' * ) 3/B. ) FG C!> E 0K Z/ ' ) 4K ` 3 J9! :K) 5 * «: \ w?» ;5 ( 5 `J - 3' H : J9 = ) 4 ) 5 * 8 V B 39! ) : K3 J9 ) 9 0/.3 3N0+! 3 J9 8 : : O+ :. K8!1. Z/ ) R ) L!) > E e * ) - :K3 J9.1 4K: 4: 3/B 8 ) 0E!) > E e * ) - :K3 J9 ) 9.2.(53 z (1378 (!) 111? 6Q #(? E@,A " I* K ) ) L.3 8!4 8 (3/) G/ 3 J9!K? 2 : [?! : 3/) G/ (8 2' ) :E: < /)»!4 8 3E 2K. 5: `40 ' 4L 3/) 4 ) : 4 d- 3 J9 : («:@K 3/)» «:./ (134 z (1378 (?:.Q) «. M d- < 4 J. (4 d- Z< z (1379 )!4K) 3 V «V4K t +» ) «:q g» 4 :.!4 8 «3 s -= ) KV4K a+, 3+* M»!4 8 (3 4 9C1< hk *.(111 -].(55 z (1370 (:> ) 3 4 U > (3 V4K 4!E!4K ) 4K -= 4K bq 8-2 :;x) 4 (:!> )! (: (:/E (! * :54 0EK :0? (: -] e :.<!;x) z (1383 (!4SQ) 3 TE 8 e e 3 ) [8!4? D) (4)!K 8 «!4 8» x e :! [M* I0!Ky, :J ( /.(299 ) ) K3* x 4 ) :.'!9 4! o^1.3 3 J9 111

6 :. 3 F L ( OK * [' 39 3, - *! :.1!K3< *.(72-71 z z (1379 (! G) 3 '! : 5: `J Z<!?!4 8 3;5 : wn!.3, ) ON (!Q 3 4 E) 3 J9!4 8!K :J :3 4 ' ' 5!K:5D) K).Q!).Q K ) 3 -d 55!K) 3 4 (3 O KV4K 2 ˆ8.4J Z0 :*4K ) V4K 4: : J9 K :V4K.2 K:5D) 2 5 K : +9!4)8 ) (V4K t (V4K V;! KV4K V;.3 3 J9! ? 4 V4K ) V4K - 3 )!) L (Z>* 3K - D)) -! 8 [ J. (9 `/ ) K - < ) 4: MK 8! ) 4: 8 2? 3++9 ).4: - :? ) \M@ 2 )M* V4K t.3 2A M V4K t! OK ) 3 J9! OK ) K )8: E) K8 M :R)!K] (4: :5 ) ( J9! KF8 52 4? ( :? :K!5 > E ) 4*: -.4K: [K 3 J9 : OO 3 ) OA :>0B B (4 ) : 9: : +9 :KV4K -=.4: u' ) 5 - O:!4.!J 2 (V4K 4 :5D) E = -272 z z (1380 (K) 4 : E )! [+ : J9!KV4K 2? 3++9 :4!> E!K)! 49 3N) :!K)» 3;5 :4!> E (3 :4!> E!w5 gs :? 4 K 3N) )... :@ (5 z (1377 (W)4A) «. w?: gs M 58' 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- : C!E 0K (! ' œ 38! : )!d- 4`SQ 8.4: F? I* " <, #g.3-2 '!KZ :B 2q ) 2 :'! ) ) :0» (3* : C!E -] 20 ) U<!! ) 8 : C? ]! :N9 4 -]! KE 49) 3++9 e J. (3!d- ) 2 F!> :!d-.3 2J - \ w? )4 ( 5 `J 2!0 : ] 4 5 :> 3 : C (1382 (! ' :9) «.3 w?j 2 )4 OK :>Q)!d- a+, J8 2L 112

7 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ :> : C O? J. (3!44E 4 2 bq) (K Q n?.3 (T) FNB:2:./ 8 n? ) ((z) -C 0? 3 J9 (:!d- :K+* > 3 2N) 2 ():' œ38! 0K : C tc+ TQ) (20! ] ) :./ B ' J; ) (-4Q 3 J9 `J o 4 -G> - tr ) - 98 :> (!E :J :3? ) [2 ] : C!E».4 E ) ).4: 2> 3 4 ) :N) CJ )! 4K K8 3>E! 2A...3 : C 3> ) -C J;!? :> :9 ` (: C.0 ) «.3K OK : C n? (3 : OG (4: tq - (:!d- : J9 :> (: C -] [2A ]» (46 z (! ' ) 3' 2 4 ' ' 0q.)! 3 ) 4 5: m < ) : vc* ) vc<!e ) M5 K [) 3] :N 34K! - 5! (1380/3/15 (! ' :9 `+ 15 z (1382 (!49) «.: u' O+ <, #g 6Q =" I* " E@,A )4' :> 3d) ) :N 3 J9 (3/)!A ) b0 (4 / [ H».4: 3/) :N 7 t ME :d) 5 K o ( 5: A 4: t=!+/ 2A.3K ) :K ' F9< ) t 4)4' (!49 +/ V G -M. (2Q O] ) 3 J9 =8 ) 5 < 4)4' 7 Q.q V G ) V B 4 ' ) a9 2! 3) :! 2 3K 0? - 3d) ) 3 J9 a s 4)4' :Q) 4 tg ) )7s > E :N -J9 a9 ) 3 w5) -G> 2E ) (T) -G> ((z) v0g ) «3) K:' ) +9 ) :K!K 3 4 FG :!9 A (4?! ) 3' ' : -] 3/) (3 p ] :0.(40 z (1378 (!M!K-] `+ 4A K (4 T) 3 J9 8 4q : J ! d ) 3 - VC' 4A K ( 5: T) 3 J9 8 4 : J9 ' - 5 ) 4 - _NG.( z z (1377 (!M v0g ) 4J 3/ :QC'!K\ ) :? >.3 ); : R D) )!!K3 J9 > -C >» (:> :K+* O?!)? : R : )!!K3 J9 > ) 3 a9!)? : C 3 J9 ) ) 3 0> 3 p `9 ) :P> : C -] 0N.3 3 p -+ ) 4: 30p ) 20 :N :9) a9 :>.a9 30p 3 a9 cq -+ K ]F9< ) 4 a9 cq! :K5 ) p! a9! E _NG 113

8 : -] 3 p : );.3 > 3 p! (4 -4+ ) 3 p [? Q ) a9 (: C 3 J9 3 2 : C -] 3 p : R [? 3 p : R ) : -] :N).8 4N 3 a9 U 3 p ) (3 8 * 4 5 : 3.(91-90 z z (1378 (:. 8!E) «3 8!4)8 E) ) Q ) a9 <, #g 6Q )$* I* " E@,A : 3 (:!> O </ :J 2ˆK.3 : : -+ 2! 5-4/ (: -] 3N>* U.q v1 ) K3N>* gf 3 ([' 0K tq! 4) \C!> -; (25 z (1383 (!* (:qq8).3 3N) 3 2w5 gs ) : ) :/E : : -! ) [+ ) :. B :!d- 3 J9 4)4'! tg :N) 4Q Z+ 3E! ) : 3 J9 = 3.1 (3N0+ (106 z (1382 (2 ) : 3 J9 :? ) 39 ) ;9 (!4 8 3E 3 4' 2 (: C O9 3d) \ w? o ) ) 2 \ w? od) - 8 0K 5 :9 4 4!4E P9 ) 40,< - 5».4: 2 =).2 (:> a+, > E 3 J9 2. 4Kq a* : C -] (4 (T)2 fn P9 W0 E) 49 (83 z (1378 (:. 8!E) «.: a+, -! : * 2 (z) 0?» :4 *:! ) 3' )4 5 K : C (44 5 : C 3 J9 4 (z) -C 0? n? ) 4 4Q 3 C 5 n?.3!4/ :N) 5 4/ :? 4 ;!'!4 ' 3) 2.(180 z (1385 (H))B 2 4) «2 K ' Z9 8 (4 ) 3d) `< tg 3d) (z).3 m) : 0?! (T) f \ w? ) 3N0+ ( P9 8 3d) Z/ o ).3 - od) 4K:! 3{=9 ) E) ) 0 543> P9 5» :4 * :0/ 2ˆK» :4 * M.(31 (1379 (:L4) «Ow :Q) :> : C -] 2.(70 (1379 (:L4) «4 : ( )? [ *!) 3 J9 / 3.>* y/ - ] ) (: tg 3d) 4)4'! : -] (:!d-.!4 :0 3 J9 2q (4 ;5 [? BK!E w5.4!w5? () :' œ38! 0K 3 : C!E 30 4A K (40 3 J9 `J ) TE J +*! 5» :4 *: 2 M : C 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 114

9 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ J9 J.: IQ 8 3d) FG :N) 4)w> : C 3 J9 ns -4/ (466 z (1369 (:'! ) «4 3d) 2. H; J. ) 2. (44 -] `J =8.3 :?!8 t o/ (: ]9C BK :4: F.E [+ 2 :J. 2N^ E wn 4: - 39 m : 3E :! 4 ) 3N) (40 3. Q8 4 E» - 3L 4J [ 4 K (4K ' :K8 ) K Q8 ) K ( z z (1378 (b :'! ).«...!K 4 F.E 3 J9 ' - N 3 J9 30p ) [4? 4 ;5 ˆ8 K = -) E). -30R +* 3 J9 ' ) (T) -G> ) (z) œz (3 3 J9 «!4 8» E) x :> : C -] 8 [+ ) - : 3 Ux).E - 3 -C od<» 3* : : C b Gq : ( œ ;.' ( T 3!4> 8 Q 8.:. - / ) :0' :9 K )! w?3n^ ) ' ( 4)4' 3 : 4+ ) 3 2> ' 4 ' `d 2K.3 :N +9 2q =8 zg' : b (76 z (1383 (: :N) «.4 3 ' (T) :./ P9.3 * 2 2q (M ) - `+ `+g M (2 [q -J,!K» :45: 2A -! RC0N 53!01' (: ) :N n : (2./ 5J? 4K= O]/!K) ) : C /E 2 2 :? ) «: 4* B ) K ) [ K -! / 2-2 :+9» :4:!)8 K8 K8 Ux) (- ) 4 2 ' ' 2 30R ) P9 ) 4 *) (3>? 3 M ) (85 z (1379 (:L4) «4 * (OK * : ) 45? 2 / Oq :K vc<! E ) (4J h O' * A ) (4 2 3/B 48 FE) )» _ < x» M ) (540 z (1379 (:L4) «.4)) * K! u a9 ) (4 (755 z (1379 (:L4) «.4J!' (Z4/ (a9 2q 4: 3 J9!4 8 Z0Q - ) 3 J9 Ux)! ((T) :./ P9 - a9 ) (- O9 a9 (3 * 4)4' :Q+9 2 O» :4 *: =8 M/ ) 3;N -] 8 ) ( 30 e K! 4)4' a9 2.3 O9 ME 4 ) [? vc< (4 vc< ME -! A.3 Q a9 (4 2A M O9 ) 4 O9 a w vc< (-!4? ) : ) (4 5 ) '!= K3 ( * Z4/ 3 ( 5 -Q 2 4/Q (4 M/ 2JN. 5 *!4 Z ) (4 :)M* 3N)!+ K4 ) ( vc< 5) = 115

10 4<+ ) V4K (4? O )! 54 O9 (4 Œ5 O9 : * -! 5.4 K 2!K3.w5 :K0!) 2. * O!K. 54A :+9 :5M JA 5) * KZ!.4 5 `1>!4)4' -J9 ) 4 : * KHK ) 4*!' J ) 8.4. :N * 5 u) :.B 1' ) (* `1> (1379 (:L4) «. 54 :N!K3' ) (4 E ) M/ JK0 (755 z :K58» (b FJ!)? ( : C!E w5 (() :' œ38 2ˆK ;9 3L 2 ŠM» «' Fq 3 J9 K8 : 5OK ) ] ) 3 ) - : d- 3 J9 vc<!) (248 z (1385 (:'! ).4: «> E 3 (155 z (1378 (a :'! ).4: 2J «-!K ` 3» ME M () :' œ38 (: : 3 J9-98!K :Q+9 w@k 2» :4: 3 J9 4 8! :;NJ! M - ((T) :./ P9 A 3N) (4J K!K 3N) 4 ] 40 2 I+* ) 4 e 3N) -' (539 z (1378 (c :'! ) «4 :0? 4 K (4K4 -= K!K 4: = 3E : [+ - (:!d- 4 (:. B 2 OK : `Q ] ) [+ 2.4 :> : C 3 J9!4 8 ) 2-4 K :< (K8! 3N^ ) U.J OK ) 3 8! :+9.': 1N :> : C -]!4 8 ( E `.' &,& < n% " )" #L& #".3-3 +/.3-2 J0 *[? - :;.* ) (!K3) [ )= ) ) * 4 8!' ) 3 F0 - '. Z/ Z 8 3 -d 4 4;5 e :9 - (U) J! wn 4 J. (3 «:@ -0»!'!0 I+* (54 2 (40 0x : 5 4Š 5.5 e ) 4 OK 8: ) cq 3N^ K J8: ( a.1 4Q - ] -» («:/-1.» 1 2.(1390 hk * ) A K» (27 z (1387 (a! :LQ) «.4 -!4 (a! :LQ) «.: 44...[M] - 2 JK0 1;N (4:! Z) 34 ) 3 J9 :@) - o+ : hk * =K 2.(30 z (1387 8! Z : y/ (1387 (b! :LQ) M 4Q 4 ) 4 9 ] :4A 3K - ] 3 :4.)8!N> 2.> E 4Q - K ) 5 0' :0 (3 : ]! ) ) 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 116

11 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ 117 g8 :9 J; ] ) [+ :> (3 J9!4 8 ) 3N0+ (3/)! q;n / ' t «:+1+B 2» Zp /.3 M ) 8 44 [/ < 2.4:! 5.E 3/ 8 ) z 9 (J ž4 ) ž?» :4: ) ) ž? )...3 * 5 ; e ; e :N) ( :K) 5 3 :!NM 3 :!NM 3++9 )...w5: ' Z9 ' 3/ (U>L : d, (H 2K (1360 (:+1+B 2) «.3 * 5 :K) 5 :N) ( «!40 3 J9 -u ) u K -!40 3 J9»!' A < <>!) [? (:Q: 39 (- :4E `./ o4/ (!M 3 J9 K 4 8 :>.3 ) : m1, ) 3/ N)! 5u) :?... ) * (- R (4Q! ' Z/ I u ) u K 2 (4Q Ÿ' = ) * \ 5 > E u ) u K (3 J9 Z) (a! :LQ) :4 M 3 J9 + I+* :!> E 3N) 3. :' ) :/E [0E R8 (- : *8[+ 39.(30 z (1387 \».4: 8 n? 9 ) H) )!KhE gf ) J8 B ) 2q!K Q 4+/ ) 3J n? M zgq! * 4Q././! 0K - 2E -4+ ) :!,< - P9!!R8!1+ (V)40 5 `Q 3 ) :w :. 3P (3B) [E (0 [0E. :+. :1.!' ) 3N) _NG ) b* 3. 4K * (: C tc+ -= ) ' OKM? -Q (3; :. E) 2 :);!K`>NnJ/ M 3N) ) 39 ) 3 8! gs (129 z (1379 (39) «.4 ' ) L» ;< ) 44E J; x F0 H [0E?:.Q (2 «. t= : / [q 3 4 Z/! ) 3 J9 ) 3N) 3P FNQ EQ 3 J9 ') D) ) 4>!KZ 4!R8!1+ (!) O/ 2* 2 Z)! =. 2!4E < :K'B) 4) 2.4 4Kq a* 3 FKw * 2 ( dj -] a ) 2 ) :!K3P! 5u) (:! =K OKA Q :!KZ ) 4! : `J 3N) ) 2 2 m0 (:!K I :!K3P! 0K ) Z>* P9 `9 M tc+ n? ).(1387 (?:.Q) 3 : d- -]! = K 4 Q.4 4K' '? G' 8 o4> 3. ) 3N) ` > :@@A :>B+ ) hk *: ) 40 ) * 3 J9 :db!) :q!? 2 g!) - (4> I. zg' ) (3 `,!K[0E».4 = 5MK? ) ad O9 e! hk * )!8!P* n; : C!) 4!K E ) 44 44? J? 2 :q 117

12 3*C' 3/) E ) -; 4 2)4!4 J? )!!4 -)4 M 4 VG zg' ) :q! = 2 (117 z (1383(:0B0B) «.3 Q 8 [ :1 40 ) :QN: ) * u)!.? ) EQ 3 J9 = 2 ') ( 4? `0Q 30 :E `Q [M* :E _1 - : / W w5 2K7 3 J9 30 :q :4 :/ - (:> E ] FE 2 wn 40 3 J9 FE Z)!E CJ ) K: - ` / ) 4 ' +9 =8 ) 44 3 J9 ' - (EQ n? zg' ) K M ]1+.4 : H9 3 J9 M :N^ wn 44: 4 )8 ' ) 5 ( (9) (2.> 2 + ) 2N^! (tc+ `)» EK 3. ) 3N) 2 :!K4? E) H9 F 24 ) 4)8 -!K Kh (UNq ) a* J T J ) 3 9 )!8 H9 Z9 2/... bb /!.9.: u EK M : ) : `J K [4? (K) 5!K K] ) 3N) ) 4 :C+ 4Q :K4 ) M! :< * ([44!K OR (1359 '8 z (1379 (39)«eM OK -4< OE ˆK :5M W, `+ 3. ).(444 44? 3N) ) 3 J9! d, (8!' Z e ) :., he TQ) 4> Q 9C< a1 3* 5 )!E 44E! 0K ) 3* : C!E w5 4 8 la!kve O ) 3* [M*!E3 ' ) 35 Vw9! )3q 3? :! ' E (3Q) En (:=* :K.4 EE : J9 F< 3 ).: «:54» / ) 2 V1>!GQ!> ) he!k: ' KR4R ) 4 :EO - : ) :4 0N1 ) 2 44+/ 2 K:P> 2!GQ J./ 30.(1385 (39)4 5 V1>!GQ `S ) K 2 ) A K.3 P ) U.q K)PQ ) (4 v 1!!Ky49 ) V 9 ) OQ < 50 I+*!E 3! :K!Q8!M!) ` 4< 60 )49 M ) 3!E 3 q ) 3 M 2 B2 : 3* 2. 3* `0Q!K) 30 M 2 F 7's!8 4 ) - ' M )!GQ J./ 30 J8 2L (-!K E 2 : wn 4 : H9 :K:5' M : ) : 0N1 30 op> (4 ( * 2! )49 he ) tc+ (3. ) 3N) :q `5 v 1 L *! K> ) 0' T [M* ) K3 T [K 2. 4Z>* Z9 o4= : :;< ) :/E (!!Kt8 `p :K[ TQ) ) (d^ G+ ) GQ. :+. 3. ) 3N) F1Q )!1! w?f8! :Kc' 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 118

13 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ 4< 80!> :. : 3 ) ' -) q : 2A ) :? :);!K`., 3 4< : [E. K)4<!?! a9 4E) P9 E bl) :4 / :/ q 2 2A :E' o / ) :;!K3.3 ) :B.-] 3/) [M* :> ( ) 2!4/ `+.3 -] ) ) =K (4 4' 9C< ) :4!> E!) / :'!Q8!E3 ) K! 5 op> ) K: q ) Kh (/01 ) I ) 4 <!, Z TL) 2 (;Nq.4 ' z'!k: +* ) ;Nq 4 Kx > E 4 +* ) 4: - > ) \> 3.;R ) K\ ); ) u ) u K ) Z 3K n?».4: pj ) T )!4) +9 (K!8 I (:!> ) `>;N!K`5 ) Z>* ) H9 3. ) 3N)!1 e :NA 9C< ) =K M 3. ) 3N) ) ` s ) E ' ) ]9C :K44 ) K3< * : [NA 2.3' K8 +N w? 8 :KVJ V G -]! :M A 44 TL) 2. 48! :K4! 3 `K :< * =K 2. 3> V4K ) K 8 cgq ) MK ) ) Z ] 4 : K3.Q ) KF8 (U>L ) Q m+! 4 a+,!k:l /OK ) K` > Z92/. 3 _,< : 4Q ) `/! K8!. 4N!!K! ) )8 3 9 :/E!Kd ) K Q! - 2 Z9 K (4 : ) 4: `+ 48!K!! 4+ A 5.(444 z (1379 (39)«3. e 4 :> : ) :/E!K! 4Z>*! =8.4 8!) ) 3N4/ > OK ) O 3N) (9C< 3N) 4> H `N :* B ) (4 *! 5:* ) he n?!kz :N) 2N^ ne!» ' O/ 1384 Z - (4 O - ' m0 () 1 8 [K ' ) 4: 3. ) 3N) 2!.<* 4K 4! «- :GQ K) 2 ea ) - 2 -)4 ) P9 M O E n.4k FE e: OQ 3N) ) - m0!44e T (:!K ; FNR m+ 9C<!) 4 =!K!8 (2;Nq!K/ VC'.4 ) 8!1 :JM!4K ' 3N) UNq /01 O=9 ) 3N) + O=9 3* M ) 2 ) 3N)!1 4 em! ) Z :0p, 4) 2.3/4 2 OK!E 3 q!4< 86!d 3 M : M 3. y/ o+ J )C/ (q!k44 :J! F.+!/ J. =E 119.4: ; D!49, :* >! 1384 q :.0 0/.1 119

14 ) P* 4 : FE O+ R B (4 3 J9 ' `< 9 a/ VJ ) (:!K zg' ) 39! «:@ -0» ` > K!) 25 P9 ) 1392 q TQ) A :E `Q [q! 3 J9 4 :4 3 :;B!4 :9) 29!)? 3 ) q -!4< 72/8 4? )! 49 VJ 2 ( q F.+ :/4 K8 :'.3 w5 * 2A : 3. ) 3N) `+ ) ` >!' A Q ) F Q 2w5 3?» 3 ] : ] : 44 = 30!E (O]/ F1Q ) 2 ( N) :> «4 5 Q 3) :K@E 3. ) 3N) 8 ) 4 ' Ux) ) UNJ (' +9 :8 2L M - ) 4 `/ ' Ux) (:4 ) :4 [E ] : < 2.4 K8 -= 3E d^ G/ (/01 ) tm9 `p :1)!K ) 3. (3N) E 4».3 em!.<* -4Q )! I :..N2 )!+1 I, :0E!K* ) 4K ` > 4:E :d 49 4: :/E!K`5 4J8 ) I Z9 ) 3 4ˆ? (4w5: I)!K ) 3N)! -4Q : 2. 5 Q 4 4 :E ) :> E (! V ) b) 3R : G! 4.[K]«4 5 a+, :0 B N) : C t.1!> E c* +".4 ; a+, 3K ) T F :'\) </ :K)D? K -= 3 -d.3 4 '? </ 2 :NE :K@.4 1' 2 `<9!^ O? [K)D? e m0 ]F9< :' :(KO?) [K)D? :;.* :0 Z0 [K)D? 2 =8.4: /!+ )! ; (: 50g :;.*!M= 8!K [= A ) 5: Q! ;!KO?! (3 * 3K7 :.4 50g :? 4 : (: -= :!K>!K4 * ' ) :. 4 * F 3/ (a+, \) : `< :[K)D? -=!.2 : (:; : [K)D? -=!, (48 z (1382 ( *9).3 [K)D?.9 K K3K7 4 4K' ; :0 \) [K)D? 2.!4O+ ) K :0.1.4 U 8!K@N ) : )!q (:4! :J ] K[K)D? ::J y9 [K)D? T.3. Q!q ) :4!K[K)D?! [K)D? 2.44 O+ :K@ 8 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 120

15 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ ( [? (09G ˆK :;.q!k ) KM [K)D? 2 :K!)8 5!K.4...) K ) (K3 (:!K3 ) K-? (K\M5 ` tj!k (W4 ). [K!)8 5! 8 2JN (4K : 4) [K)D? 2! 8!> E :! 8! ) > E.5 1 * :55 (4 ]4 O> A ) 4 ; K3K7 U! :\).3 O K8 :*G ) O=9 :)3 4 ; :. / `., K `.,! [K)D? 2 :K `., M.6 (1388 (JK ) * : 1387 (JK ) *? & 5Q& " <0+".4-1 `., 8!? 3 *!K54 ) (K\ W!!M :\) K@N 2!? ) J8 K ] W ) K@N ) 4 U * 3K7 3! 8 S K8 4 U 3K7!!' ) : 4K W *!! * \) :/E -./ a+,!k\) \) :.< );.4 : ) :; [K)D?!K\) 4? \) 2.(1996 () )4: `., * (K!E.(73 z (1390 (:9 ) := ) :9)4:!48 *!E [K)D?. w?: < U.q!K`J!>N1 [K)D? K8 -= ) 4 U > `9 48 *!4 2 ( 3 4 ; v!.9 : 5: Q : :55!K54 ) +/!/= : T)! : 0/ /= 4N (UN /= 2.!)8 5 E) >N1 >E!> E [K)D? TL 2 (:.0Q ++,, `., (09G 4 55 b ) 4 4 «5 L9! ;5!P*» TL zg' :+ >1Q ) O.* (nj/ :9 ) 55!K 0' K )!KM5 ;5!P*!= 3.(1386 ( : `Q (4 E) [K)D? KM5 4> 3>1Q :C K.(2008 ). 2)3 :55 [? [K)D? TL!K0E - 4! ((2001 ( ))4 E) 4 cq! 5! ( \) H.(2000 (2 )4K 4-=!K[K)D? :543!/= tq (t ) ea (! 8)!K 2.44 :9 B - 3>E ) * 3K7 ) J*!.3 K8 4> O * :55 wn ) (1386 ( 4K' tq 4 2ˆ Q-methodology 2. Concourse 3. Q-sample 121

16 1 4>!4> ) e!.4 E) :Gq WC K M 543 4> ; JK ). 2 (1999 ()) )4K:?!K.(2008 (he ) M) ). 2)4: :*!4 [K)D? \) 0/ /= : 4 F!K!)8 5 (u 2 ) 2 JK ) e 4A K.(1390 (:9 ) := ) :9)4: F!0E b! : 4K' M od> e 4 3 4> ) qn b `J ) M 8 ((1994 ) e )4.(2000 (M 8)4: [K)D? K!K I!KM5!4 )!F n? ::. / `., ) :@0K `., ( \? :. / `., \) ; 4!) /CB (543.4:!4 U.q!K) 5 * (:. /!K E n.4 5: Q! 8 I :KM5 Z) \).3 4? ] 2! \) ) :K` / ; ( ; 8 H ) 4 E (4* 5 2? d!k ` / e 3, : ` / 2 3, * 3K7 4: ) : '? ` / 3K7 e!!!km*- ) : 0, \) :9) 0, K` / e K! K0/ :. / : \) 2.3 K` /.(1390 (:9 ) := ) %E& 5 " 2N.5 %E& 2N :>.3 ; L9 [K)D? :543 U< F.R 4 tq!5 * «4*4K tq» («H!K» b)! e (55 CG, _1 ) :/E +0B )! J* 5 ) CG, (* 9 (:54 `, (2 (ne,n 43 ; 15 :54?.4 E) (1) Z)4E : [ 5 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 1. Brouwer 2. Mrtek 3. Addams 122

17 1$0 " #,-&./ *%/ / D) E (T " 5Z< F.BvC< )? -4 K / D) O+i<) ) O. O. ) : : : 4 d ) / D) N(; :N) 8 = `G, ) / D) T0033* h>-).1-', J< "T! 4 / D) A / D) 10 5 B0, $/ '+, -. '()" 1392 ) y90 :J [K)D? TL E :?.) "1-1 ' -3 O 4% %-& 8 U.q!K0E : 55 a B!!K ]x (3K ) -! / 2 < (z'!9 4: -4 K (TL 3 / E K ]x 2.3* (tj ] )C/ 4 \C [K)D? v 1 -/ ) :.!P* `<9! ]. ; > E `' - U.q Q ) 5 0' tq (4! 3> E!M5 39 ) 4 Vw9! J ] :' ( ;5 44 u 54E!K!) ) 4!w !KM5.(2 Z)4E) E) (!!KM5 4> T.2-',.4 4K' vc< 3>L) ((dj):gq ) : R!K3> - [ 5 TL) (> E -/!!4 Q! 3 9 ) : / hk *!+ TL) 4 (vc<! Z>* 3 ) `S.4: 0 55!K 30-0 );: <.3* 4K' 0 ) :N>! ( +* :N) 3E 3 9 ) +* 3d) -!)?.3* 4K' 3*? ` : -C):/E ) :Gq : 53> 30 : / 35.* 4K' ; 3*? ( J : ) V) >.: vc< bl) (4 3/ :QC' ) 4 T) ' n 4 (4K + ad 54 tq 3E ' 3' ) :K58 - :<.4: 3 9 3*?! K 5 123

18 .2-',. /.4 4K' 3*? ) > h (8 0E :> ) V / ) K0 Z0Q.* 4K' ; 3*? ) 4 (: 5n?) ) : 0G> 2w5 ; 3*? ) 4 (8 `/ ) (: 4 8) ) 2 FG> 0R ).* 4K' (4 a+9 8 ) ;x) ) C' 4 t,< :<.4 4K' >!) > E.3* 4K' 3 >!K 3*? ) [ 8 > E (d 3Q [K.: `9 CJ (- [K )!GQ 3>L) 0 bl) ) 4 vc< GQ 3>L) (:? ) :N GQ O e =.4: 0 OK ; :N> ) * 0!GQ 3>L) (Z 0N )!GQ O e =!.).4*: 0K 4s ) 39!GQ M I 4-=!K!M _,<! E E (3; :@) [K ((!:<G')44 `<!K3! E `p (tc+.4 4K' vc< bl)...) :. 4N. vc< E *, : :0J ) :C+!E ns tq 3 9 :N>! +* :N) 3E 3 9 ) +* 3d) 2N^!)?. OK' `9 CJ F.R : C Z< 8!40? ) C' M5 ) 4 :@8.4 4K' (..) Ke : `p ): C 3>! Q ) 3 J9! -C :>Q)! E.O: em.l*!4 * * (: J9!KM.) 39 a B - hk * ) :K58!+.4 OK' Z4 *?!> E ) ) (44 (tm9 ) zq ))- b* (4 `+ K :<.35 4K' :Q!> E.3* 4K' 0 TL) 4 :./ 3 4 Z/ )!M E C!K3 4 4 :db M ) (Q 4> 2 ) 49) ) A J K' vc< bl).3* 4K' 0 3>L) (E 40 )!J 0 ) Q = 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 124

19 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./.2-',. / ) * [K KWJ1< (Z< :' 4 8 ) `.N2!> E 3' 2.3* 4K':Q ) > E!*? 2/ (w5 gs!k 4K! w ) Z>* :. e =.: `9 CJ ) * [K K[ (Z< CJ (! 5OG K8 3 ) ]F9< ) 5 0' : / ' *.4: b;.4: 3*? : J9 O 3 C Vw9 ) dj -] e! Q a B.: ) ) TL) Q ) O]! Q 3E :9!/= 3>BQ bl) * * R ) :/E )!GQ 4; ) 3 J9 44 '.3* 4K' 0 : Q ) -] H )4 ( L9 Z9 -+ ) 4Q F9< *.: `9 CP> 3*? ) :) [ 8 ( :4!K!8 = ) : Q a B.35 4K' 4: (4 4Q ) ) g!k) 5 39 `+ ) - ' (tm9 :Q).4 3*? ) 3+* ` / > E (4)8 ) (7;!7 zq ) K) 5 )) -!K 2 s ) CJ `9 tm9 5. 4K' 3*? Vw9 :. (4 4Q ) ) g!k E ) ) b* *9 K (tm K' : 8 * * (4.3 4> ) ] ) K 8 4. Rd) 3* 4K' 0 E 3>L) (3 ON/ := x ) tm9!k3* x ) 4! :9E * :K@ 2N^ ; ' UNq J* [K)D? 0/ 39! e (!4! :-3. Z)(.5/ /.'?/(T 3;Nq (1) 3+* Z o0 b e 0/ /= O]!5!!KM5 4: ' 543 : Z9.(1 `J) 4!40 (9) * 4 ( KM5 4> =8.4 b 3;Nq ) 3+* M H

20 n ) 4 O+ (UNq ( ]: (a* ):.! 0/ 4 '.4-4Q * KM5 F 30 3* 5: Q K8 ' (-3 /-) -3.5?.0F/ p!-).1-j / ( 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- #$ -> 0) %E& 5 ",H.5-2 [K)D? :' A!K` / n (4,L E :543!4) 5 a+, TL 543 3K7 ); () 5)` / ((1 3?) L9 8 5: Q :K) 5 ; K ) : ` / 4 * :. /.3.4 5:!E A ) 5 A6 ) A3 543 Zp /.! 5M :. / %9,.6 () 5)` / K 3,!KM5 e K :. / 3 OK * J 2 M*-!KM5 ( (` /)) 5 K :. /!K!F. 5 0, cq FE 3++9 ) (4* 5 Q! 3;Nq 3+* ) 5 K :.(3 Z)4E) 5: : (3 * 3K7 M # "&A 6<$ 6C% 4 B# (-)=H_.5 T A(*F J % =H_ ' ln -.50T A() (+)ln -.5 T A(*F J % 2 J % 3 J % 4 J %.3-', 126

21 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ 127 :.<!KM5 `., ) M= :K7!K@N U ) K3K7 : :?!.9 UNq!KM5 ) 30p 3 C/ 3+*!KM5 ) 543 3;Nq ) 3+* `<9 ] E.3 (4: B!M5! :; 3 C/ A :K@ K) 5 : : ; K) 5 ] (Ns 2 4K /. :. ) : `S F.R K8 tq!km5 3;Nq ) 3+* :.<!KM5 K ) tm9 4 I)!K V1>!K`9.(34(35(36(22!KM5)44 :E 8 : 4K K` / :. 54 A : :. B 543 ` %40 ) 5 2 :( : 4L) e ) 5 (UN Z 37 : 2@ (4K:!E ' Z ! * ) zg' ' (: [ 5,N.4: O. ; 2 ) (: ; 3 (! W4! ; *.44!E :!4) 5 K ' * :Q ) 5Z< ' : wn ) (24- ) 29- ) 4+)4 3 J9!GQ ) : ' L :K@ () 5 ) 21+)4K 39 a B ( TL) 4 ) ) ] ((38- ) 37-) 4 Ns 2 (4.SQ 8! :,,< ) 39 -!)? < 44+> ) (17+.(4+)3* 4K' a+, 543 ` %26/7 ) 5 2 :(: 8 ) 5Z<) ) ) 5 (t :.3 Z 42 : 2@ ( 5: Z 65 (Z 22! * ) 3 E ' ) 4 : W4! :Q ) (: ) : W4! ) ' ; 1 ) ( 5Z< ' ; 3 (4 / : [ 5,N.4K d 2! *.3 4 : [ 5!KtAA -4 K F ) : C! 0< zg' ) 4+* : 3 J9 : E) A 5 (4 5:!E ) 5!KZ84 8 ) 0 :L 39 E 3>L) ((29- ) 9-)4 4s 39 : (38+)4: 2J M ' : 8 bl) 4 Z9 2/ ) ((20+)4: a01 ' wn 4: 2J : 8 ) qn 3 J9 e! Q =8 (K) VC' wn I 0 M -! * J./ (4 4s 0 39 [+ 4 K (14- ) 12-)4) 3;Nq CJ :. B * 2.(6+)4: gf.(19+ ) 6+)4 2N^ OK ) - OK! :QC' 3>L) 0 3N) ) ' 543 ` %20 ) 5 2 :(Z : L) ) 5 (u ) (4 : W4! ; (Z 62 24! * : 2@ zg' ) F.BvC< ; 2 ( * 2! 4/ : [ 5.3 : W4! M ; :K@ (4* 5!E ) 5! *.3 )? ; 1 127

22 3;Nq ) (3+)- 4 8,<!) (37-)4)4 Z9 2/ (4: 39!4/ FE : : 5:B * 44+> ) (20- ) 18- ) 4-)4 3 J9 zg' ) ' E CJ!4/ =8 (e ) 5 4 wn (20- ) 10+)3 CJ ) 3 J9 : 54Q UNq ) 5 2. = t.1 : J9 -] (4- ) 18-)9 vc< O `9 e /!GQ `S 2ˆK 8.(39+)44?: MA.(13+)4 4s : Q ) ` %13/33 : L)A ) 5 ( ; 1 (O. W4! ; Z ) Z 36 8 : 2@.4* 5 * 4: ].4K F.BvC< :@K 4 / : [ 5,N ) 4 : 39 ' J; ) ' O ((20- ) 18-)4K `SQ 3J.! - [+ [+!; (3q ) 5 ) VC' ) (17- ) 32-)4): 3;Nq : ) :. B A ) 5 2.(5-)4K :/E!K< / 2 P9 4 h ' (0 :L > E 2 2 FE!4/ 44+> ) (25+)4: 40 * 5 (!+ ) 4 :K@ 4/ B 4: ] ) 5 2.(31+)4 = ) 4 E 4 ' 4 (4K 40 )!GQ!K`9 A 5 (4 3 E I ˆ8 K 30 L > :K@ :.!K3+* ) K3;Nq E pj (4:? TL) 0! :/E ) : ) 44 ] 0! :<'!) )? 8 4K: 8.4?: :B * 3;Nq #D9.7 0 :@@A» TL 8 * 3K7!@N 4 :> [K)D? 2 3K7 :! :\) ] 2!. 5 Q : «TL).4 ; 4) K8 : o : 3K7 T 4 ([K)D? E.3 gf 8 ] M 8 : [ 5 T ) 0! )4 :K@ K [+ ) - ) 39!N+ T,N 3K7 T A 2 :.! ] :4 5: O+ :.! ) ' ( 0-4 < (4 MA 3 J9!4 8 ' [+ - :< Z) 3N9 (UN -!.) 4 44+> ) 3 J9 _,< 3 9-4/ `J (3>L) 3L -4/ : 4 : hk * K (2. vc< TL) Q _N< 3 J9 54!K: 3./ - ) H4+!E) (39)» 8 H 3 wn (220 z (1387 (b! :LQ)«.4: 3 J9 )! 4!= 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 128

23 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./!4/ vc< ) _N< 3 J9 e! Q )4, - [+ 2 09< ` / OK (39 3L < T ) 5.( ) 5)4: 3 J9 (4: 3 J9!4/ 3>L) vc< ) 9 39C< ) 3 J9 ' +*.(e ) 5)4: U > 9!)? - [+ ( 2 a+,! ); 2 ) J ( 2! * m0 [K)D? : 2ˆK 4 `40 (4K, K :. Z0 :L ) 4 4? ` ZJ.(A ) 5)4K: S : n; ME ( =! :<' `9-4/ 3L < (40 h? 3 J9!4 8 ' [+ - :< (t 4s ) 4 gf +* K3J B 3 J9 ) - [+ (3 J9 3L ] 2! :./ ) H. :K`9 ( vc<! 9 ) - OK [+ 4 T 2 * ) 5 2 4K: a+, `<9.() ) 5)4 2K7.4 :K! 5:B * - 24 ) 4M 8 ' : 5 8!4 8 ) 3/) ' [+ - :+. B 4K:!4 2 ) `S T!42> ` / (K8 FNR : hk * bq) ) 3 J9 2ˆK.3 U.q K8 [) ) [! = ) 8 `9 ) CJ t.1 hk * a01 ( <>!) -!4/ : hk * /7 : : C!E -] 4+ OK ) +* OK Ns 2 ) (3 :!d-.3 ) : OG (> E 4 4 :? ;5[? `S E! 3 9 J [K ( vc< - 3 [M* 3E (7;! : / J* 4 (> E ONJ = MK? ) 39 9! 40 - : ] 24.4)8!) 3. ) 3N)!1!N+ - : hk * vc< a B Ns 2 O!J ) 4 8 M ' Ux) (4: 8 ' +9 J )C/. 5 -= OK B ) &W..8 : 3 =!K :! :K[K)D? 3 -d ([K)D? 2 )?! p49 3 = 3E (3!K, `9 :!KJK ) * 5 <. 5 S ) : (> E

24 - g8 ) O] f g8 ) O] f g8 ) O] f - g8 ) O] f.82/10/14 (/CB ) (:./../ :OQ.2 u.b0n.(1369) : (4 u.-!;,<.(1385) : (5 u.-!;,<.(1378) : (18 u.-!;,<.(1378) : (6 u.-!;,<.(1378).?a :.: -./ hk *.(1383) (! ' :9 [œ 38] œ v) (:'! [œ 38] œ v) (:'! [œ 38].():' œ v) (a :'! [œ 38].():' - œ v) (b :'! [œ 38].():' - œ v) (c :'! [œ 38].():' (!* ) :./ (:qq8 49)."" +#.5H'/ '. $ /? /.(_Nu)".(1360) :./24, (:+1+B2.69 (.0!.=.""0/.^/(. -5 :." (.28 ( )'!.G*.""$.:@K * ) :./ 3 :.:@.5.5"TQ' ' -> ".(1380) 294 (:Q, / ".D-) p - ".(1380) 29 ( 0 -= ".(1379) :./4, (! G :.!) E' L CR."".D-) / 5"H -) ' 5 (<F".(1380) 2N (!?.! 0K >N1.ƒ :OQ."H % ' 5lN ^' }ln ^'".(1378)! 4JK)D? œ40/ (:. 8!E / "#5]'#3 }#H'/ ' ".D,".(1377) 49) (:5M ) )4 * (:B* ( (W)4A #F 4 / (N.M :."".(w.3 :."" -$% / cl<) ]' (F. l ".(1382) L4, 05~ "0".(1390)! /=# #F ("# -I M ( *9, (:9 ) e (: := (t+> (:9 44 J>.5) ( /.!">-i Z.:5 3 4!K\) G*."-3 "0]'.54 ) 53.!." ( " "0D,".(1385) :." (# ' k (% 0, / "$ 0 ' O:4) ".(1379) Q4, (39 Q4, (39.hE ++, ) >N1 3 J9!.G*.".(#45 #wd l F / "0/.^/( ".(1382) 49 (!49.29.: C 6C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 130

25 1392 $/ '+, -. '()" *%/ 1$0 " #,-&./ 131!E! ) 4< ++, M :( :( :."-3 "0]'".(1386) L./ ( : C / "3 E5'Q2 "0]'".(1387) Z/ (78 )!4 4 (:N (29 ( * : / "=3 E5'Q2 "0]'".(1388) ) (-) Z ( ] ) 4+!.G*.".;< :."p,./(' Z/ (78 )!4 4 (:N (29 ( * :.;< :."p,./(' " 05(N.5=HK ".(1375) t (:Q -./ b E Z? 4 :." ( " 05(N / I "4 ".(:) O9 (3*S.M? :H8 :."(# p #, 05(N".(1379) 2,N (:+* )!4 4 (:N ) Nn (!4K.:0B0B :."(.(#45 #wd #l.5/-05 %-& ) ^' ;".(1378) : C.0.: C.0 : "# #05(N (#F #"#, '.8 O (M) (Lj)".(1380) œ`.' (!8 * :.! 0.10 œ4!e."c-n (:. >N1!.G*." ( &<H h*3".(1385) H))B 2 4.: C hk *. 0 :OQ (: :;1G!E."x+4H r".(1379) :L4.82.) 4)! ;K." ".(1390) 49 (U.V> :OQ.""0/ -;".(1382) L49 (2 ' () 1* / -&* / " 05(N /.N '.(w S".(1391) :./ (:,<.2 (9 ). Journal of Social Sciences."? (F (LK J -%. :." ( / ".* '!".(1383) E (:0B0B. ' :." ( / / 4 ".(1387) 29 (a!.":'(#* (#i% / "#.!-! /(2(w 8 $ ".(1387) 29 (b!.31\ ( 0K!.=."" w.?3 ' %'(* ".(1383). ' : L4, :LQ :LQ (!4SQ :K)D? 3)>."H'/ Z0.-1H ' -8 " (;".(1387) œ39 (?:.Q.: C 131

26 - :K)D? ) : 8 f.n Q :."".D-).5EH".(1388) :.>N40/ (-Q. :.".^/( ' "F_ H'/".(1383) :OQ."?(I / ' k-l;".(1377) 0:./ (::N :+4, (!M v0g.1 u (:' - :K)D? ) : 8 f :OQ."+ ".(w".(1378) :+4, (!M v0g.!) ) :."! ' ( O;+d> ' 5 ' 05(N".(1370) - :K)D? ) : 8 f :OQ."lN ^' F tt "51".(1387).2 u.:'! < (:>!4 4, (:Q!.():'.: :.(1381) 29 (."H'/.5(w".)4 (3) (9!.=.""I ( cl< (w! -; / /( (9!.=.""I ( cl< (w! -; / /( 1,".(1380) 294 (K c< (108 ) 107 1,".(1380) 294 (K.108 ) 107 Addams, H., Q methodology. In H. Addams, & J. Proops (Eds.), "Social Discourse and Environmental Policy: An Application of Q Methodology", 2000, pp Almond, G.A. and SIDNEY VERBA (1974). "The Civic Culture". Princeton: Princeton university press. Amin, Z. (2000). "Q Methodology A Journey into the Subjectivity of Human Mind". Singapore Medical Journal, 41 (8): Brown, S.R., 1996, "Q Methodology and Qualitative Research", Qualitative Health Research, 6(4), pp Brouwer, M. (1999). "Q is Accounting for Tastes". Journal of Advertising Research, 39 (2): Donner, J. (2001), "Using Q-Sort in Participatory Processes: An Introduction to the Methodology". In R. A. Krueger, M. A. Casey, J. Donner, S. Kirsch, & J. N. Maack, Social Development Papers (Vol. June). Washington, D.C: Social Development Department of the World Bank. pp Mrtek, R. G., Tafesse, E., & Wigger, U. (1994), "Q-Methodology and Subjective Research". Journal of Social and Administrative Pharmacy, 13, pp Ten Klooster, P. M., Visser, M., & de Jong, M. D. (2008). "Comparing Two Image Research Instruments: The Q-Sort Method Versus the Likert Attitude Questionnaire". Food Quality and Preference.19, pp C% 4 B# # "&A 6<$ / ( #$ -> 0) 5 "& 0 "0,=! I- 132

27 1$0 " #,-&./ SPSS N ( ƒ-) AD).5J % ', $/ '+, -. '()" *%/

28 Exploring Attitudes toward Relationship between Government and Nation in Iran: A Q-Methodology Study Mojtaba Ahmadian, Rohollah Eslami Received: 28 October 2013 Accepted: 13 February 2014 In an Islamic democracy system, people have an effective role in creating acceptability for government, in order to make it efficient. But according to some different factors, people s attitude towards their role and its extent in the government changes during the time; that is an effective factor in determining the interaction between nation and government, and thus determining the acceptability and effectiveness of the government. This study aims to examine Iranian s attitudes about the ways to improve situation and life standards in Iran and to identify the influence of probable factors in their attitudes. For this purpose, Q methodology is used to explore the attitudes and factors in it. This methodology after identifying the existing discourses, chooses attitudes of different people who were polled and then checks them out, and detects and analyzes the mentality of individuals in each group. The result of this study indicates that, the type of people s attitude towards relationship between the nation and the government and consequent their role in making government efficient is a determining factor in their approach towards the national issues and problems and the style of their social and political behaviors as well, thus it clearly shows that how senior managers should pay attention to manage public opinion and modifying public attitudes in this case. Key Words: Q-Methodology, Political Culture, Islamic Democracy, Legitimacy, Effectiveness. 7