Adaptive Protection Algorithm for Overcurrent Relay in Distribution System with DG

Transcription

1 J Electr Eng Technol Vol. 8, No. 5: , 2013 htt://dx.doi.org/ /jeet SSN(Print) SSN(Online) Adative Protection Algorithm for Overcurrent Relay in Distribution System with DG Byung Chul Sung*, Soo Hyoung Lee**, Jung-Wook Park and A. P. S. Meliooulos** Abstract This aer rooses the new adative rotection algorithm for inverse-time overcurrent relays (OCRs) to ensure their roer oerating time and rotective coordination. The alication of the roosed algorithm requires digital rotection relays with microcontroller and memory. The oerating arameters of digital OCRs are adjusted based on the available data whenever system conditions (system with distributed generation (DG)) vary. Moreover, it can reduce the calculation time required to determine the oerating arameters for achieving its urose. To verify its effectiveness, several case studies are erformed in time-domain simulation. The results show that the roosed adative rotection algorithm can kee the roer oerating time and rovide the rotective coordination time interval with fast resonse. Keywords: Adative rotection algorithm, Coordination time interval, Distributed generation, nverse-time overcurrent relay, Protective coordination 1. ntroduction The overcurrent relays (OCRs) have been most commonly used as an efficient device to rotect radial distribution systems. n such systems, the OCRs must oerate raidly to minimize fault duration and damage of equiment. Also, the aroriate time-lag between rimary and back-u rotections in OCRs must be ensured to avoid unnecessary oeration or false tri. n general, the OCR taking its rimary rotection zone must oerate firstly. Then, the OCR for back-u rotection should oerate only if rimary rotection fails to oerate correctly and after waiting for the aroriate delay duration, which is referred to as the coordination time interval. This means that all rotection functions must be coordinated roerly with their fast oeration for faults occurred in rimary zone. On the other hand, the interest to renewable energies and distributed generation (DG, PV, wind) results in increasing number of installations not only because of its eco-friendly asects but also its commercial advantages. Since the conventional relays including the OCR oerate with fixed arameters (settings), it is difficult to ensure the roer rotection oeration when oerating conditions of radial distribution system are changing as DGs connect and disconnect in the system. This roblem becomes more serious if multile DGs are connected to the system. n articular, the re-determined coordination between the Corresonding Author: School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea (jungark@yonsei. ac.kr) * School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea (guardchul@yonsei.ac.kr) ** School of Electrical and Comuter Engineering, Georgia nstitute of Technology, Atlanta, GA , USA (resonable21@gmail.com, sakis.m@gatech.edu) Received: January 22, 2013; Acceted: May 5, 2013 OCRs is affected by the increased fault current due to the connection of DGs and its reverse flow [1-4]. To solve this roblem, a new adative rotection algorithm is roosed utilizing the caabilities of the digital rotection relay such as intelligent electronic device (ED). Because the digital rotection relay is equied with microcontroller and memory, it is ossible to rogram it with the real-time oerating scheme and to store the required data. Moreover, it has communication links to exchange data and oerating signals between themselves as well as to reset the rotective function settings. t is also noted that they can communicate with the uer-level system such as suervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) system in modern substation. Therefore, it can adjust their oerating arameters and characteristics corresonding to the changes in the distribution system [5-9]. n this aer, the roosed adative rotection algorithm kees the roer oerations and coordination of OCRs with the system data from the digital rotection relay even when the oerating conditions change due to load variations and/or connection of DGs. Also, it can reduce the comutation time required to calculate the oerating arameters of OCRs such as ick-u current and time dial setting. The erformance of the roosed algorithm is evaluated with several case studies in a radial distribution system by using the ower systems comuter aided design/electromagnetic transients including DC (PSCAD / EMTDC ) software. 2. nverse-time Overcurrent Relay The inverse-time OCR, which is oerated by monitoring the magnitude of fault current, is the one of various 1002

2 Byung Chul Sung, Soo Hyoung Lee, Jung-Wook Park and A. P. S. Meliooulos rotection functions. The OCR transfers a tri signal when the fault current exceeds a re-determined ick-u current, ick-u. ts inverse-time current characteristic is exressed as (1) and (2), which resent the dynamics of induction disk OCR [10]. T0 1 dt = 1 (1) 0 t( ) A t( ) = TDS + B M 1 where T 0 is the oerating time, is the fault current seen by the OCR, TDS is the time dial setting, and M is the ratio of / ick-u. Also, A, B, and are coefficients which so selected as to reresent inverse, very inverse, and extremely inverse tyes of OCR. t is observed from (1) and (2) that the tri time, t() is the function of the fault current,, which may vary during the fault. Therefore, the value of t() may be also changed according to the time. This recirocal number of varying t() is integrated from zero unless the fault current is reduced below the ick-u current. f the integration value becomes 1, then, the OCR issues a tri command to the OCR. n other words, the fault current is integrated from zero to the oerating time, T 0. n most cases, the OCRs are alied to a radial distribution system as shown in Fig. 1. Since the current is flowing from the substation to downward only in one direction, the OCR is connected to the radial line right behind the related bus. Only one OCR is used er a rotection zone while two other OCRs are necessary for each direction if the bi-directional flows of fault current are considered. This one-way fault current flowing to downward is assed through a current transformer (CT) between distribution line and OCR. Then, the fault current measured by the CT is used as the inut of OCR to determine its oerating time. Also, the magnitude of fundamental comonent of fault current sensed by the CT is samled as the inut for the digital OCR. (2) The rimary and back-u rotection zones for OCR-1 and OCR-2 are shown in Fig. 1. n general, several rotective devices installed in series should have the secified oeration sequence as in Fig. 1. This relationshi among rotective devices are said to be coordinated or selective. n order to isolate the minimum ossible faulted area with, the relays of rimary rotection zone should be firstly oerated deending on the location of the fault, and their associated back-u relays should tri only when the rimary relays are not oerated correctly. For examle, if a fault occurs at the oint between the bus 2 and the bus 3 in Fig. 1, the OCR-2 oerates as the rimary rotection to minimize the outage area, which must be isolated by the oeration of the breaker. Also, the OCR-1 should serve as the back-u rotection to cut off the fault current if the OCR-2 cannot oerate normally. Moreover, it is essential to maintain the roer time interval between the rimary and back-u rotection. This is called the coordination time interval (CT) [11-12], which is usually 0.2 s to 0.5 s. This CT is required to aly all rotection devices such as even reclosers and fuses as well as relays in a distribution system. ts associated equation is given as in (3). t t CT (3) back u rimary where t rimary and t back-u are the oeration times of rimary and back-u rotections, resectively. The oerating time of the back-u rotection is generally larger than that of the rimary rotection. Therefore, the difference between them should exceed the CT as (3), which has 0.2 sec as the minimum value as mentioned before. When the DG is connected to a radial distribution system, it can increase the fault current and ossibly reverse the direction of ower flow. The latter case is illustrated in Fig. 2 that the flow of fault current is changed by connecting the DG at bus 2. n other words, the fault current from the DG flows reversely to the fault location, F1 in Fig. 1. Then, it is added to the fault current flowing from the substation. This results in increasing the fault Fig. 1. Alication of OCRs to a radial distribution system Fig. 2. Fault current increased by connecting the DG and its reverse ower flow 1003

3 Adative Protection Algorithm for Overcurrent Relay in Distribution System with DG time required to determine their oerating arameters will also increase [6, 7, 9]. For this reason, the adative rotection algorithm to drastically reduce the comutational effort is roosed in this section. 3.1 Determination of ick-u current Fig. 3. Protective coordination between the rimary and back-u relays considering CT when the DG is connected current when comared to the case without the DG. Moreover, when the fault occurs at the fault location, F2, it is also increased due to the DG even though there is no reverse flow of the fault current. f the fault occurs at the fault location, F3 on the adjacent feeder, its magnitude sensed by OCR-n also becomes larger since the fault current from DG flows reversely to the F3. Therefore, the OCR-n might function incorrectly unless its oerating arameters are changed roerly [2, 4, 12]. n summary, the increased fault current can have the undesirable effect on the oeration of OCRs in the distribution system. Because the OCRs have the inversetime current characteristics as given in (1) and (2), their oerating times are decreased corresondingly to the amount of increase in fault current. n other words, the larger the magnitude of fault current becomes, the faster the OCR will oerate. However, note that a too-fast oeration of relay may lead to unnecessary removal of a larger ortion of the system. As shown in Fig. 3, the rimary OCR might have difficulty in coordinating with the back-u OCR when the fault current is increased. That is, the required coordination time is reduced as the available fault current increases. This results in mis-coordination. f this fault current is further increased over the rated value of rimary relay, it is unable to coordinate with the back-u relay, resulting in ossible misoeration. Therefore, the oerating arameters of OCRs must be correctly adjusted for the revailing fault conditions with the direction-sensitive caability of whether the current flows in either direction [4]. 3. Proosed Adative Protection Algorithm Otimization of the oerating sequence of all rotective devices while maintaining their rotective coordination in the resence of multile DGs is very comlex. n articular, as the number of OCRs and DGs increases, the calculation Assume that the ick-u current, ick-u of OCR is calculated eriodically from the monitored current. t will have different value whenever the system configuration is changed. For each time interval, the load current calculated after a fixed time from its starting oint is used to determine the value of ick-u. The rovision of a time delay to stabilize the distribution system is necessary to select a stable load current corresonding to the connection of DG. Then, the value of ick-u is determined as shown in (4). = 1.5 (4) ick u L N where L N is the load current calculated after the fixed time from its starting oint of N-th time interval. As (4), the new ick-u is set to be 1.5 times the selected load current because a safety margin must be given to it. This safety margin is necessary so that the OCR oerate by the normal load current of the steady-state, which is used to determine ick-u. n other words, the OCR will tri the intact art of the ower system if the value of L N is set as the ick-u current. Moreover, the multilier, 1.5, can be adjusted to rovide the required safety margin. Therefore, the ick-u current can be obtained with the load current, which reflects the condition of the system. Note that the length of time interval must be roerly set not to calculate the ick-u current too frequently. After another time delay, the value of ick-u is alied to determine the oerating arameters of OCR. This time delay is required so that the OCR oerates with its redetermined arameters in case of the fault occurred at the oint, where the L N is obtained. n other words, if this fault current is used as the ick-u current of OCR directly, it might be too large to searate the fault area from the distribution system correctly. Moreover, this waiting eriod rovides the sufficient time to calculate the new value of time dial setting (TDS), which is described in the following section. 3.2 Determination of time dial setting As mentioned reviously, the OCR has two imortant oerating arameters, the ick-u current and TDS. The ick-u current is firstly calculated with the load current by (4). Then, the new TDS, TDS new is comuted by (5) to maintain its original oerating time and CT without regard to the change of system condition. n other words, the TDS new is determined to make the OCR oerate similarly to the re-determined oeration time according to the OCR characteristic in (2). 1004

4 Byung Chul Sung, Soo Hyoung Lee, Jung-Wook Park and A. P. S. Meliooulos TDS =TDS ( A+ B( M 1))( M ' 1) new ( A+ B ( M ' 1))( M 1) where the A, B, and are the associated coefficients of OCR, and M is the ratio of / ick-u for the current time interval. The M becomes different from the M determined form the revious time interval if the ick-u and fault current is varied deending on the system condition. Their relationshi is defined as (6) M ' (5) = km (6) n (5), the values of A, B,, and TDS are ket to be constant even after the system condition is changed. Note that the M can be known by the fault current data stored in the OCR memory. Moreover, analysis of off-line fault current in a distribution system is conducted if it is required to udate with the changed data. Therefore, the M can be easily calculated by transmitting it to the OCR through the communication links. Consequently, it is ossible to obtain the TDS new raidly because all values in (5) are already known. As well, the TDS can also be obtained more easily for the case that loads and OCR characteristics are changed. n summary, when the load is changed, the udate of fault current data is not necessary because it may remain constant in ractice. n contrast, the ick-u current is relaced by the new one according to variations of load current. Therefore, only M is changed into M, and the TDS new is obtained by using (5). Also, if only characteristics of the OCR are changed, the new TDS is comuted with new coefficients, as given by (7). n this case, the M for revious time interval is the same as the M for current time interval because there is no change in both ick-u current and fault current. A + B M M ( 1 ' 2 1 1( 1))( 1) TDS new =TDS ( A ' B2 ( M 1))( M 1) (7) ick u. re TDS re = 1.5 ick u L N ick u N= N+ 1 TDS new ick u TDS new TDS new Fig. 4. Procedure to imlement the roosed adative rotection algorithm 1005

5 Adative Protection Algorithm for Overcurrent Relay in Distribution System with DG where (A 1, B 1, 1 ) and (A 2, B 2, 2 ) are the coefficients for reviously and newly chosen characteristics, resectively. By the roosed method, the TDS new in (7) can be simly determined in the case that multile transitions occur. n other words, after the ick-u current and TDS are calculated newly, these oerating arameters are then alied to the OCR at the same time. 3.3 Procedure to imlement the roosed algorithm The overall rocedure to imlement the roosed adative rotection algorithm is shown in Fig. 4. Firstly, the values of re-determined oerating arameters, which are ick-u.re and TDS re, are obtained. Also, the fault current data is stored. Thereafter, the value of ick-u seen by the OCR is calculated with the information of load current, and held during the time delay before the roosed algorithm is alied to the OCR. Without any changes in a distribution system, it is ossible that the value of ick-u becomes different from that in the revious time interval. n most cases, it occurs in the first time interval. n this case, the fault current data stored in the OCR is used to find the values of M and M in (6) until the fault current data is changed according to the system condition. Then, the two TDS new corresonding to close-in faults for both rimary and back-u rotection zones are comuted by (5) for each OCR during the short time delay. Note that the last OCR in line uses the TDS for only rimary rotection zone because it avoids roviding the back-u rotection. After determining the values of icku and two TDS new, they are used to relace the redetermined oerating arameters. n a steady-state condition, the next interval is udated with the above new oerating arameters. Then, the value of ick-u is calculated again. f there are still no changes in the system, there is no need to calculate the two TDS new because the value of ick-u is identical to that for the revious time interval. n other words, the TDSs are ket to be constant with the same ick-u without changes in system condition. n the case that there is a change in system by load variation, or connection of DGs, the value of ick-u becomes different from that of ick-u.re or ick-u determined in the revious time interval. This does not aly to the case that the characteristic of OCR is changed. Then, the two TDS new for the rimary and back-u rotection are determined as reviously. n articular, the udated fault current data is unnecessary for the cases of change in load and OCR s characteristic, as mentioned in sub-section 3.2. Therefore, the two TDSs for these two cases are comuted by using (5) and (7), resectively. n contrast, the connection of DG requires udating the fault current data. After transmitting this udated information to the OCR, the M and M are calculated by (6). Thereafter, the TDS new is obtained by (5). f the condition of system is not changed any more, the alied oerating arameters are fixed. When a fault occurs in the distribution line, the OCR will resond according to the oerating arameters, ick-u and TDS new, which are calculated in above. Then, each OCR determines the oerating mode between rimary and back-u rotections by checking the fault location, which can be found by comaring the monitored fault current to the stored data. Finally, the oerating modes of OCR are selected with the roer TDS according to whether it corresonds to the rimary or back-u rotection. 4. Test Distribution System and OCR Setting A test system has been used to evaluate the erformance of roosed rotection algorithm. The test distribution system is shown in Fig. 5. This distribution system consists of a 154-kV substation, a 154/22.9-kV transformer of 10 MVA, four loads on the 22.9-kV line, and three OCRs. The load and line imedance data are given in Tables 1 and 2, resectively. t is assumed that a three-hase short-circuit fault with its fault imedance, R f of 0.01 Ω is alied at bus 4. Then, the system is rotected by three coordinated OCRs, which are named OCR-1, OCR-2, and OCR-3. The CT ratios of each OCR are set to be 200:5, 150:5, and 100:5, resectively. The oerating characteristics of three OCRs in Table 3 are selected based on the EEE standard C [10]. Note that a three-hase short-circuit fault might occur at each line. Then, according to the fault location, the close-in Table 1. Load data Fig. 5. Radial distribution test system Load S [MVA] P [MW] Q [Mvar] Load Load Load Load Table 2. Line imedances Line medance [Ω] From bus To Series resistance bus (R) Series reactance (X) Z TR R f Total

6 Byung Chul Sung, Soo Hyoung Lee, Jung-Wook Park and A. P. S. Meliooulos Table 3. Constants and exonent for various OCR characteristics from EEE Standard C Characteristic A B Moderately inverse (M) Very inverse (V) Extremely inverse (E) Fig. 6. Equivalent circuit of distribution system by the imedance method and far-bus faults have their maximum and minimum values, resectively. n general, the equivalent circuit of distribution system shown in Fig. 6 is used to calculate the short-circuit current by using the imedance method. Each art of ower system such as external grid, transformer, and line is converted to its imedance [13-14]. Then, the oerating arameters of OCRs are determined after calculating the short-circuit current with the load and imedance data in Tables 1 and 2. For examle, when a three-hase short-circuit occurs at bus 4 (therefore, it is the far-bus fault of OCR-3), it is calculated by both the value of total series imedance from source to fault location, which is the sum of the imedance for the equivalent circuit in Fig. 6, and the voltage level of the ower system as (8). U S sc3 = = [A] 3 Z + Z + Z + R S TR L f (8) Table 4. Pre-determined oerating arameters of OCRs sc3 [A] T o [sec] Currnet (A) Current (A) OCR-1 OCR-2 OCR-3 Line12 C FB Line23 C FB Line34 C FB CT ratio 200:5 150:5 100:5 Characteristic V V M ick-u [A] TDS Line12 C FB Cal Line23 C FB Line34 C FB Line12 C FB Sim Line23 C FB Line34 C FB Time (sec) (a) Time (sec) (b) Symmetrical AC comonent of SC3 (RMS) DC comonent of SC3 Fig. 7. Waveforms of sc3 when a three-hase short-circuit occurs at bus 4 (a) resonse of a-hase sc3 (b) symmetrical AC and the DC comonent of sc3 where sc3 is the magnitude of the three-hase short-circuit current, and U S is the hase-to-hase voltage. Because the source imedance is so small that it can be neglected, the total series imedance from source to fault location is 0.06+j24[Ω], and its magnitude is aroximately 24 Ω. The waveform of short-circuit current flowing from bus 3 to bus 4 is shown in Fig. 7(a). The short-circuit current consists of the DC comonent, which is decreased exonentially based on the ratio of resistance to reactance, and the symmetrical AC comonent. The resonses of these two comonents are shown in Fig. 7(b). As mentioned reviously, the magnitude of the symmetrical AC comonent is used as the inut of OCRs. t is known from Fig. 7(b) that the root-mean-square (RMS) value of symmetrical AC comonent is obtained as aroximately 550 A. Note that this value is almost same as that of shortcircuit current calculated by (8). n Table 4, the short-circuit currents as close-in (C) and far-bus (FB) faults are obtained in each line of test distribution system by simulation. Also, their values are comared with those of short-circuit currents calculated by the imedance method as given in (8). t is clearly observed from Table 4 that as the fault location is closer to the substation, the magnitude of short-circuit current becomes increasing. After calculating the short-circuit current in each line, the oerating arameters of all OCRs are determined so that the distribution system can be 1007

7 Adative Protection Algorithm for Overcurrent Relay in Distribution System with DG rotected within a roer time. t is assumed that the C fault current flowing toward downward in line is equal to the FB fault current flowing toward uward in line [11]. Thereafter, all arameters and selected characteristics of three OCRs are given in Table 4. The oerating times obtained from simulation are the times when the integration becomes one as given in (1) and its oerating signal is released. When they are comared with the calculated oerating times by (2), the results show that they are almost same. For both cases, the CT of 0.2 s is roerly determined for all lines. Also, the time interval required to calculate the new ick-u current and TDSs is assumed to be 1 s. Then, the time delays for measuring the load current and calculating new TDSs of OCRs are 0.3 s and 0.1 s, resectively. 5. Performance Evaluation To evaluate the erformance of the roosed algorithm, the condition of distribution system is changed by connecting the DG of 4 MVA at bus 2 as shown in Fig. 8. The outut voltage of DG is 10 kv, and it is connected to the system through a 10/22.9 kv transformer. First, the ick-u current is calculated based on the load current after 0.3 s from the starting oint of time interval, which is 0.5 s. t is known from the result in Fig. 9 that the load current seen by OCR-1 is decreased to 1.61 A after connecting the DG. n contrast, the load currents seen by OCR-2 and OCR-3 are slightly changed. When a three-hase short-circuit with the fault imedance of R f is alied to bus 4, the equivalent circuit considering the connection of DG is formed as shown in Fig. 10 by alying the imedance method. n this case, there are two sources of fault current, and it is described that the two sources are connected in arallel. Moreover, the magnitude of short-circuit current deends on the location, where the DG is connected. Therefore, it is necessary to consider the ratio l, which is defined as the distance from substation to DG over the distance from source to fault location. Since the line distance can be equivalent with its corresonding imedance, the distance between any two buses is reresented by the imedance data in Tables 2 and 5. Then, the total summation of all imedances in the equivalent circuit in Fig. 10 is calculated by (9). ( ZS + ZTR + l ZL ) ( ZTR _ DG + Z DG ) Ztot = + (1 l) Z Z + Z + l Z + Z + Z S TR L TR _ DG DG where Z TR_DG and Z DG are the imedance of transformer connected to the DG and the DG itself, resectively. n the equivalent circuit, the imedances are referred to the secondary side of the transformer, as given in Table 5. Also, the value of l is 0.4 in this case. sc3 U S = = = [ A] 3 Z tot L (9) (10) sc3,dg Z TR_DG Z DG Fig. 8. Distribution system with the DG connected to bus 2 through the transformer sc3,substation Z S Z TR l Z L (1-l) Z L 4 R f 3.5 U S Current (A) A 1.61 A 3.73 A Fig. 10. Equivalent circuit when the DG is connected Table 5. medance data of DG transformer and DG itself 2 Load current seen by OCR-1 Load current seen by OCR-2 Load current seen by OCR Time (sec) Fig. 9. Load current seen by each OCR at the secondary side of CT before and after the connection of DG medance medance [Ω] Series resistance (R) Series reactance (X) Z DG Z TR_DG Total medance by reflecting referred to secondary side

8 Byung Chul Sung, Soo Hyoung Lee, Jung-Wook Park and A. P. S. Meliooulos = sc3, substation sc3 Z + Z TR _ DG DG Z + Z + l Z + Z + Z S TR L TR _ DG DG (11) Finally, the total short-circuit current, sc3, which is the sum of sc3, DG and sc3, substation in the arallel circuit of Fig. 10, is comuted by (10) similar to (8). Moreover, since OCR-1 can monitor only sc3, substation from Fig. 8 and the value of sc3 is divided into sc3, DG and sc3, substation, the value of the inut for it can be calculated by (11) according to the equivalent circuit. On the other hand, the shortcircuit current for the C fault at line34 can be also calculated by the same manner as (10). n this case, the value of l is 0.6 because the DG is still connected at bus 2, however the fault occurs close to bus 3 [15]. After connecting the DG, the short-circuit currents, sc3 seen by the OCRs for the C and FB faults at line34 are given in Table 6. However, the oerating times, T o of OCR- 2 and OCR-3 changed by the connection of DG under the revious setting in Table 4 are s and s, resectively. Because they oerate quickly, the difference of T o between them is about 0.11 s, which is smaller than the required minimum CT of 0.2 s. This might cause a rotective coordination roblem. When the roosed method in Fig. 4 is alied, the new ick-u currents for OCR-1, OCR-2 and OCR-3 are calculated by (4), they are 2.42 A, 5.57 A, and 5.60 A, resectively. Then, two TDS new fitting to these new ick-u currents are obtained so that the T o of OCRs is ket to be the reviously established values required as given in Table 4. The values of TDS new and T o are given in Table 6. t is observed that T o for OCR-2 and OCR-3 are now changed to s and s, resectively. The difference is s, which is greater than the required minimum CT of 0.2 s. Therefore, they satisfy the rotective coordination requirements. Since the short-circuit occurs at line34, OCR-2 and OCR-3 oerate as back-u and rimary rotection, resectively. Then, the C fault current at bus 3 is considered to evaluate the rotection coordination between the OCR-2 and the OCR-3. Therefore, the OCR-3 setting TDS new is for the rimary rotection. n contrast, the TDS new for OCR-2 is determined for the back-u rotection by the C fault at line34. Because the OCR-3 is the last rotective device in the radial line, the setting TDS new is for the rimary rotection only. Therefore, the roer rotection can be still rovided by the OCR-3 even though the T o for the rimary rotection is slightly increased to s from s in Table 4. Differently from the above case, the OCR-2 oerates as the rimary rotection if the short-circuit occurs at line23 in Fig. 8. Moreover, the OCR-1 oerates as the back-u rotection. n this case, the new ick-u currents for OCR- 1, OCR-2 and OCR-3 are equal to the above case. However, the T o of OCR-1 and OCR-2 are changed by connecting the DG. As given in Table 7, those values are s and s, resectively. t is observed that the T o of OCR-2 is reduced greatly from s (see Table 4) to s. This is because only OCR-2 is affected by the short-circuit current from the connected DG. Therefore, the difference of s in T o, which is still valid for the rotective coordination because it is larger than the re-determined CT of 0.2 s. Also, the values of TDS new and T o with new setting for the OCR-1 and OCR-2 are given in Table 7. The TDS new of OCR-2 is whereas that for the back-u rotection is as given in Table 6. This means that the OCR-2 can select the oerating mode with different TDS new deending on the fault location. When the OCR-2 oerates as the rimary rotection based on the related TDS new, , the T o for C fault at line23 is s, which is very similar to the reviously established T o of s (in Table 4). Moreover, the CT between the OCR-1 and OCR-2 decreases from s to s, which is the same to the re-determined CT and still satisfies the required minimum CT of 0.2 s. For the FB fault at line23, it is verified that line23 can be rotected by the rimary rotection of OCR-2 because the To of s is similar to its re-established value of s in Table 4. Table 6. New oerating arameters of OCRs by connecting DG to Bus2 when fault occurs at Line34 OCR-1 OCR-2 OCR-3 sc3 [A] C FB C Cal T o with old FB setting [sec] C Sim FB Load current at 0.8 sec [A] New ick-u current [A] k for C New TDS C Cal T o with new FB setting [sec] C Sim FB Table 7. New oerating arameters for connection of DG at Bus2 with fault at Line23 OCR-1 OCR-2 OCR-3 sc3 [A] C FB C Cal T o with old FB setting [sec] C Sim FB Load current at 0.8 sec [A] New ick-u current [A] k for C New TDS C Cal T o with new FB setting [sec] C Sim FB

9 Adative Protection Algorithm for Overcurrent Relay in Distribution System with DG 6. Conclusions This aer roosed a new adative rotection algorithm for digital overcurrent relays (OCRs) in radial distribution systems that adats to changes in a distribution system due to connecting/ disconnecting DGs. The roosed method can be alied to the intelligent electronic devices (ED) such as digital (numerical) rotection relays because these devices can rovide the functions required for data rocessing, data storage, and communication links. The rotection erformance of the roosed method was evaluated with simulations on an examle system and several case studies. The results showed that the oerating time and coordination time interval (CT) are almost same as their re-determined values while the oerating arameters of OCRs are automatically udated by the roosed simle rocedure. Therefore, it could reduce the required calculation time. n future studies, the adative rotection algorithm for bi-directional flows of fault currents in both radial and loo distribution systems is will be investigated. Acknowledgements This work was suorted by the National Research Foundation (NRF) of Korea under Grant , funded by the Korea government (MEST). References [1] S. Santoso, and T. A. Short, dentification of Fuse and Recloser Oerations in Radial Distribution System, EEE Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 22, no. 4, , Oct [2] W. J. Park, B. C. Sung, K. B. Song, and J. W. Park, Parameter Otimization of SFCL With Wind- Turbine Generation System Based on ts Protective Coordination, EEE Trans. Alied Suerconductivity, vol. 21, no. 3, , Jun [3] S. Chaitusaney, and A. Yokoyama, Prevention of Reliability Degradation from Recloser-Fuse Miscoordination Due to Distributed Generation, EEE Trans. Power systems, vol. 23, no. 4, , Oct [4] H. J. Lee, G. T. Son, and J. W. Park, Study on Wind- Turbine Generator System Sizing Considering Voltage Regulation and Overcurrent Relay Coordination, EEE Trans. Power Systems, vol. 26, no. 3, , Aug [5] A. P. S. Meiooulos, G. Cokkinides, R. Huang, E. Farantatos, S. Choi, Y. Lee, and X. Yu, Smart Grid Technologies for Autonomous Oeration and Control, EEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol.2, no.1,.1-10, Mar [6] M. M. Mansour, S. F. Mekhamer, and N. El-Sherif El-Kharbawe, A Modified Particle Swarm Otimizer for the Coordination of Directional Overcurrent Relay, EEE Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 22, no. 3, , Jul [7] A. C. Enrizquez, E. V. Martinez, and H. J. Altuve, Time Overcurrent Adative Relay, Elsevier, Electrical Power and Energy system, vol.25, , Ar [8] V. Calderaro, V. Galdi, A. Piccolo, and P. Siano, Adative Relays for Overhead Line Protection, Elsevier, Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 77, , Dec [9] A. Conde, and E. Vázquez, Oeration Logic Proosed for Time Overcurrent Relays, EEE Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 22, no. 4, , Oct [10] EEE Standard nverse-time Characteristic Equations for Overcurrent Relays, EEE standard C [11] J. L. Blackburn, Protective Relaying: Princiles and Alications, 2 nd ed., Marcel Dekker, nc., [12] EEE Guide for Protective Relay Alications to Distribution Lines, EEE standard C [13] A. Berizzi, S. Massucco, A. Silvestri, and D. Zaninelli, Short-circuit current calculation: A comarison between methods of EC and ANS standards using dynamic simulation as reference, EEE Trans. ndustry Alications, vol. 30, no. 4, , Aug [14] Schneider Electric, Calculation of Short-circuit Current, 2005, [15] D. N. Gaonkar, Distributed Generation, ntech, Byung Chul Sung received the B.S. and M.S. degree from the School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea, in 2006 and 2009, resectively. He is currently ursuing his Ph.D. degree in Yonsei University. His research interests are in ower system oeration and control, fault-current-limiter (FCL) control connected ower grid, develoment of bi-directional rotection coordination technique for distributed generation. Soo Hyoung Lee received the B.S. and Ph.D. degrees from the School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea, in 2008 and 2012, resectively. He is currently a Post-doctoral Research Associate in the School of Electrical and Comuter Engineering, Georgia nstitute of Technology, Atlanta, GA, USA. His research interests are in load flow of ower system, otimization of grid connected distributed generation systems, anti- 1010

10 Byung Chul Sung, Soo Hyoung Lee, Jung-Wook Park and A. P. S. Meliooulos islanding algorithms and inverter control for distributed generation systems, and measurement based load modeling. He was the reciient of the Gold Prize Paer Award from the TMS nstitute of Technology and Second Prize Paer Award from the Yonsei Electric Power Research Center. Jung-Wook Park was born in Seoul, Korea. He received the B.S. degree (summa cum laude) from the Deartment of Electrical Engineering, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea, in 1999, and the M.S.E.C.E. and Ph.D. degrees from the School of Electrical and Comuter Engineering, Georgia nstitute of Technology, Atlanta, USA in 2000 and 2003, resectively. He was a Post-doctoral Research Associate in the Deartment of Electrical and Comuter Engineering, University of Wisconsin, Madison, USA during 2003~2004, and a Senior Research Engineer with LG Electronics nc., Korea during He is currently an Associate Professor in the School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea. He is now leading the National Leading Research Laboratory (NLRL) designated by Korea government to the subject of integrated otimal oeration for smart grid. He is also a chair of Yonsei Power and Renewable Energy FuturE technology Research Center (Yonsei-PREFER) in School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea. His current research interests are in ower system dynamics, renewable energies based distributed generations, ower control of electric vehicle, and otimization control algorithms. Prof. Park was the reciient of Second Prize Paer Award in 2003 from ndustry Automation Control Committee and Prize Paer Award in 2008 from Energy Systems Committee of the EEE ndustry Alications Society (AS). He is currently a vice chair of ntelligent Systems Technical Alications Committee of EEE Comutational ntelligence Society (CS) A. P. S. Meliooulos was born in Katerini, Greece, in He received the M. E. and E. E. diloma from the National Technical University of Athens, Greece, in 1972; the M.S.E.E. and Ph.D. degrees from the Georgia nstitute of Technology in 1974 and 1976, resectively. n 1971, he worked for Western Electric in Atlanta, Georgia. n 1976, he joined the Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Georgia nstitute of Technology, where he is resently a Georgia Power Distinguished Professor. He is active in teaching and research in the general areas of modeling, analysis, and control of ower systems. He has made significant contributions to ower system grounding, harmonics, and reliability assessment of ower systems. He is the author of the books, Power Systems Grounding and Transients, Marcel Dekker, June 1988, Lightning and Overvoltage Protection, Section 27, Standard Handbook for Electrical Engineers, McGraw Hill, He holds three atents and he has ublished over 220 technical aers. n 2005 he received the EEE Richard Kaufman Award and in 2010 the George Montefiori Award. Dr. Meliooulos is the Chairman of the Georgia Tech Protective Relaying Conference, a Fellow of the EEE and a member of Sigma Xi. 1011