Complex Systems Workshop Lecture III: Behavioral Asset Pricing Model with Heterogeneous Beliefs

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Complex Systems Workshop Lecture III: Behavioral Asset Pricing Model with Heterogeneous Beliefs"

Transcription

1 Complex Systems Workshop Lecture III: Behavioral Asset Pricing Model with Heterogeneous Beliefs Cars Hommes CeNDEF, UvA CEF 2013, July 9, Vancouver Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 1 / 52

2 Outline 1 Introduction 2 The model 2-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend followers 3-type model: fundamentalists vs. optimists and pessimists 4-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend and bias 3 Empirical Validation Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 2 / 52

3 Introduction Literature Hommes, C.H., (2013), Behavioral Rationality and Heterogeneous Expectations in Complex Economic Systems, Cambridge. (Chapters 6 and 7) W.A. Brock and C.H. Hommes, A rational route to randomness, Econometrica 65, (1997), W.A. Brock and C.H. Hommes, Heterogeneous beliefs and routes to chaos in a simple asset pricing model, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 22, (1998), Hommes, C.H. (2006), Heterogeneous Agent Models In Economics and Finance, In: Handbook of Computational Economics, Volume 2: Agent-Based Computational Economics, Edited by L. Tesfatsion and K.L. Judd, Elsevier Science B.V., 2006, Hommes, C.H. and in t Veld, D. (2013), Behavioral heterogeneity and the financial crisis, CeNDEF working paper, July Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 3 / 52

4 Introduction Traditional Rational View representative agent, who is perfectly rational expectations are model consistent Friedman hypothesis: irrational agents will lose money and will be driven out the market by rational agents simple (linear), stable model, driven by exogenous random news about fundamentals prices reflect economic fundamentals (market efficiency) Lucas: macroeconomic policy should be based on rational expectations Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 4 / 52

5 Introduction Heterogeneous, interacting agents approach heterogeneous agents, heterogeneous beliefs market psychology, herding behavior (Keynes (1936)) bounded rationality (Simon (1957)) markets as complex adaptive, nonlinear evolutionary systems interactions of agents create aggregate structure explaining stylized facts Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 5 / 52

6 Introduction Some Problems Interacting Agents Approach wilderness of bounded rationality many degrees of freedom for heterogeneity what exactly causes the outcome in a (large) computational HAM Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 6 / 52

7 Introduction How to Discipline Bounded Rationality? stylized agent-based models behavioral rationality behavioral consistency: simple heuristics that work reasonably well evolutionary selection ( survival of the fittest ) and reinforcement learning laboratory experiments to test individual decision rules and aggregate macro behavior Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 7 / 52

8 The model Asset Pricing Model with Homogeneous Beliefs Agents choose between risk free and risky asset: R = 1 + r > 1: gross return on risk free asset p t : price (ex div.) per share of risky asset y t : IID dividend process for risky asset z t : number of shares purchased at date t End of period wealth: W t+1 = R(W t p t z t ) + (p t+1 + y t+1 )z t = RW t + (p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t )z t Myopic mean variance maximization: demand z t solves Max{E t W t+1 a 2 V tw t+1 }, so z t = E t[p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t ] av t [p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t ] = E t[p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t ] aσ 2 (where σ 2 is common beliefs on variance V ht ), Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 8 / 52

9 Equilibrium Price The model Market equilibrium between supply and demand: equilibrium pricing equation: E t (p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t ) aσ 2 = z s Rp t = E ht (p t+1 + y t+1 ) aσ 2 z s special case: constant zero supply of outside shares z s = 0: Rp t = E ht (p t+1 + y t+1 ) Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 9 / 52

10 REE fundamental solution The model Equilibrium pricing equation: (common beliefs on future dividends E t [y t+1 ]) Rp t = E t [p t+1 + y t+1 ] no bubble" condition implies unique bounded fundamental solution p t : (discounted sum expected future cash flow) p t = E t[y t+1 ] R + E t[y t+2 ] R 2 + For special case of IID dividends, with E t [y t+1 ] = ȳ: p = ȳ R 1 = ȳ r Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 10 / 52

11 The model Model in deviations from fundamental deviation from fundamental Pricing equation in deviations: x t = p t p Rx t = E t x t+1 Notice: rational bubble solutions: x t = x 0 R t with self-fulfilling belief xt+1 e = gx t 1, with g = R 2. Equilibrium pricing equation with heterogeneous beliefs: (in deviations from RE-fundamental) H Rx t = n ht E ht x t+1 h=1 Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 11 / 52

12 The model Asset pricing model with heterogeneous beliefs agents choose to invest in risk free or risky asset R = 1 + r > 1: gross return on risk free asset p t : y t : n ht price (ex div.) per share of risky asset IID dividend process for risky asset : fraction of agents of type h Myopic mean variance maximization of expected wealth demand for risky asset by type h: z ht = E ht[p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t ] av ht [p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t ] = E ht[p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t ] aσ 2 (common beliefs on variance V ht = σ 2 and a risk aversion parameter) Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 12 / 52

13 Market equilibrium The model Equilibrium of supply and demand: H h=1 n ht E ht [p t+1 + y t+1 Rp t ] aσ 2 = z s equilibrium pricing equation: H Rp t = n ht E ht (p t+1 + y t+1 ) aσ 2 z s h=1 special case: constant zero supply of outside shares z s = 0: H Rp t = n ht E ht (p t+1 + y t+1 ) + ɛ t h=1 (where noise term ɛ t (e.g. random supply of shares) has been added) Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 13 / 52

14 Heterogeneous Beliefs The model Assumptions about beliefs of trader type h: B1 same constant beliefs on variances for all types h: V ht [p t+1 +y t+1 Rp t ] = V t [p t+1 +y t+1 Rp t ] = σ 2 B2 common and correct beliefs on future dividends: E ht [y t+1 ] = E t [y t+1 ], for all types h special case of IID dividends: E ht [y t+1 ] = E t [y t+1 ] = ȳ. B3 heterogeneous beliefs on future prices of the form: E ht [p t+1 ] = E t [p t+1 ] + E ht[x t+1 ] = pt+1 + f h(x t 1, x t L ) special case of IID dividends: E ht [p t+1 ] = p + f h (x t 1, x t L ) Under assumptions B1-B3 equilibrium pricing equation in deviations x t = p t p from the fundamental: H H Rx t = n ht E ht [x t+1 ] = n ht f ht h=1 Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 14 / 52 h=1

15 The model Forecasting rules belief of type h on future prices: or in deviations: E ht [p t+1 ] = p + f h (x t 1,..., x t L ) E ht [x t+1 ] = f h (x t 1,..., x t L ) Important special cases: rational expectations: "f (x t 1,..., x t L )" = x t+1 (also perfect foresight on other belief-fractions n ht ) fundamentalists: f 0 (no knowledge about other beliefs and fractions n ht ) pure trend chasers: f (x t 1,..., x t L ) = gx t 1 pure bias: f (x t 1,..., x t L ) = b. simple example: linear forecast with one lag f ht = g h x t 1 + b h trend extrapolator: f ht = x t 1 + g h (x t 1 x t 2 ) Question: Do rational agents and/or fundamentalists drive out trend chasers and biased Cars Hommes beliefs? (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 15 / 52

16 The model Evolutionary selection of strategies evolutionary selection or reinforcement learning: more successful strategies attract more followers fractions of belief types are updated in each period, according to (discrete choice model, BH 1997, 1998) n ht = eβu h,t 1 Z t 1 where Z t 1 is normalization factor and β is intensity of choice. β = 0: all types equal weight β = : neoclassical limit, i.e. all agents use best predictor Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 16 / 52

17 The model Evolutionary selection of strategies realized profits in period t π ht = R t z h,t 1 = (p t + y t Rp t 1 ) E h,t 1[p t + y t Rp t 1 ] aσ 2 (with y t = ȳ + δ t ) (x t Rx t 1 + δ t ) E h,t 1[x t Rx t 1 ] aσ 2 Fitness function or performance measure (weighted sum of) realized profits U ht = π ht + wu h,t 1 C h where C h 0 are costs for predictor h, and w is memory strength (w = 1: infinite memory; fitness accumulated wealth w = 0: memory one lag; fitness most recently realized net profit) Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 17 / 52

18 The model Asset Pricing Model with Heterogeneous Beliefs (in deviations from the RE fundamental) Rx t = H n ht f h (x t 1,..., x t L ) = h=1 n ht = e βu h,t 1 Hh=1 e βu h,t 1 H n ht f ht h=1 U h,t 1 = (x t 1 Rx t 2 ) f h,t 2 Rx t 2 aσ 2 C h Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 18 / 52

19 The model Examples with Heterogeneous Linear Beliefs (in deviations from the RE fundamental) example with linear predictors f ht = g h x t 1 + b h : Rx t = H n ht (g h x t 1 + b h ) h=1 n ht = e βu h,t 1 Hh=1 e βu h,t 1 U h,t 1 = (x t 1 Rx t 2 ) (g hx t 3 + b h Rx t 2 ) aσ 2 C h Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 19 / 52

20 The model 2-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend followers Two-type Example: Fundamentalists versus trend Two trader types, with forecasting rules f 1t = 0, fundamentalists at costs C f 2t = gx t 1, g > 0, trend followers Define difference in fractions: m t = n 1t n 2t Rx t = 1 mt 2 gx t 1 m t+1 = tanh( β 2 [ gx t 2 aσ 2 (x t Rx t 1 ) C]) Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 20 / 52

21 The model 2-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend followers Two-type Example: Fundamentalists versus trend Theorem. (existence and stability steady states) Let x be positive solution of m eq = tanh( βc/2) m = 1 2R/g tanh( β 2 [ g aσ 2 (R 1)(x ) 2 C]) = m 1 0 < g < R: E 1 = (0, m eq ) globally stable steady state 2 very strong trend chaser, i.e g > 2R: three steady states E 1 = (0, m eq ), E 2 = (x, m ) and E 3 = ( x, m ) 3 R < g < 2R: if costs C > 0, then we have a pitchfork bifurcation for β = β, that is, a unique steady state for β < β and three steady states for β > β. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 21 / 52

22 The model 2-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend followers Two-type Example: Fundamentalists versus trend Moreover, Hopf bifurcation of non-fundamental steady states E 2 and E 3 : stable for β < β < β unstable for β > β Corollary: costly fundamentalists and cannot drive out trend chasers driven by short run profits. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 22 / 52

23 The model 2-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend followers Bifurcation diagram and Lyapunov exonent plot Figure: Bifurcation diagram (left) and largest Lyapunov exponent plot (right) for 2-type model with costly fundamentalist versus trend followers. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 23 / 52

24 The model 2-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend followers Time series of prices and fractions and attractors (a) (b) (c) 1 (d) (e) 1 (f) Figure: Time series of prices and fractions and attractors in the phase space for 2-type model with costly fundamentalist versus trend followers. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 24 / 52

25 The model 2-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend followers Homoclinic Orbit for β = + Two possibilities for the unstable manifold W u (E) (Brock and Hommes, 1998, Lemma 4, p.1251): 1 if g > (1 + r) 2, then unstable manifold W u (E) equals the (unbounded) unstable eigenvector; typical solutions are exploding, diverging to infinity with trend followers dominating the market; 2 if 1 + r < g < (1 + r) 2, then unstable manifold W u (E) is bounded; all time paths converge to the (locally) unstable saddle-point fundamental steady state; homoclinic orbits Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 25 / 52

26 The model 3-type model: fundamentalists vs. optimists and pessimists Three Type Example Three types (zero costs) f 1t = 0 fundamentalists f 2t = b b > 0, positive bias (optimists) f 3t = b b < 0, negative bias (pessimists). Rx t = n 2,t b 2 + n 3,t b 3 n j,t+1 = exp( β aσ 2 (b j Rx t 1 )(x t Rx t 1 ))/Z t, j = 1, 2, 3 Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 26 / 52

27 Three Type Example The model 3-type model: fundamentalists vs. optimists and pessimists Theorem. (existence and stability steady state) Assume opposite bias, i.e. b 2 > 0 > b 3, then (1) has unique steady state E, which equals the fundamental steady state when b 2 = b 3. E exhibits a Hopf bifurcation for β = β : E stable for 0 < β < β and E unstable for β > β. Corollary: Biased beliefs lead to a different route to complexity Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 27 / 52

28 Three Type Example The model 3-type model: fundamentalists vs. optimists and pessimists Theorem (neoclassical limit, i.e. β = ) When biased beliefs are exactly opposite, i.e. b 2 = b 3 = b > 0, then (1) has globally stable 4-cycle. For all three types, average profit along this 4-cycle is b 2. Corrolary Fundemantalists with zero costs and infinite memory can not beat opposite biased beliefs! Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 28 / 52

29 The model 3-type model: fundamentalists vs. optimists and pessimists Bifurcation diagram and largest Lyapunov exponent plot (a) (b) Figure: Bifurcation diagram (top panel) and largest Lyapunov exponent plot (bottom panel) for 3-type model with fundamentalists versus optimists and pessimists. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 29 / 52

30 Phase plot The model 3-type model: fundamentalists vs. optimists and pessimists x t x t 1 Figure: Phase plot for 3-type model with fundamentalists versus optimists and pessimists, as in Brock and Hommes, 1998, Figures 7 and 8. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 30 / 52

31 x Time series The model 3-type model: fundamentalists vs. optimists and pessimists n n n Figure: Time series for 3-type model with fundamentalists versus optimists and pessimists, as in Brock and Hommes, 1998, Figures 7 and 8. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 31 / 52

32 Four Belief Types The model 4-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend and bias (zero costs; memory one lag) example. g 1 = 0 b 1 = 0 fundamentalists g 2 = 0.9 b 2 = 0.2 trend + upward bias g 3 = 0.9 b 3 = 0.2 trend + downward bias g 4 = R = 1.01 b 4 = 0 trend chaser (1) Rx t = 4 n h,t (g h x t 1 + b j ) h=1 n h,t+1 = exp( β aσ 2 (g hx t 2 + b h Rx t 1 )(x t Rx t 1 ))/Z t, h = 1, 2, 3, 4 Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 32 / 52

33 The model 4-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend and bias Four Belief Types Rational Route to Randomness: β < β : fundamental steady state globally stable β = β : Hopf bifurcation of steady state β < β < β : periodic and quasi-periodic price fluctuations on attracting invariant circle high values of β: strange attractors β = : convergence to (locally unstable) fundamental steady state Theoretical Question: Is the system close to homoclinic orbits and chaos, when the intensity of choice β is high? Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 33 / 52

34 Figure: Bifurcation diagram (top panel) and largest Lyapunov exponent plot (bottom Cars Hommes panel) (CeNDEF, foruva) 4-type model. Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 34 / 52 The model 4-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend and bias Bifurcation diagram and largest Lyapunov exponent plot

35 The model 4-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend and bias Chaotic and noisy chaotic time series, and strange attractor (a) (b) (c) (d) Figure: Chaotic (top left) and noisy chaotic (top right) time series of asset prices in adaptive belief system with four trader types. Strange attractor (bottom left) and enlargement of strange attractor (bottom right). Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 35 / 52

36 Figure: Forecasting errors for nearest neighbor method applied to chaotic returns series (lowest graph) as well as noisy chaotic returns series, for time horizons 1 20 and for different noise levels, in ABS with four trader types. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 36 / 52 Forecasting errors The model 4-type model: fundamentalists vs. trend and bias Prediction Error chaos 5% noise 10% 30% 40% Prediction Horizon

37 Empirical Validation Empirical Validation: PE and PD ratios S&P500, PY Ratio Fund. Ratio PY Ratio Fund. Ratio Price-to-Earnings Price-to-Dividends Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 37 / 52

38 Empirical Validation S&P 500, benchmark fundamental p t = 1+g 1+r y t (g constant growth rate dividends) Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 38 / 52

39 Empirical Validation BH-Model and risk premium market clearing (with zero net supply) H h=1 n h,t E h,t [p t+1 + y t+1 ] (1 + r)p t av t [R t+1 ] = 0 equilibrium pricing equation p t = r H n h,t E h,t (p t+1 +y t+1 ), or r = h=1 H h=1 n h,t E h,t [p t+1 + y t+1 p t ] p t, estimation: required rate of return r = risk free interest rate + risk premium Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 39 / 52

40 Empirical Validation Stochastic cash flow with constant growth rate log y t Gaussian random walk with drift: log y t+1 = µ + log y t + υ t+1, υ t+1 i.i.d. N(0, σ 2 υ), This implies y t+1 y t = e µ+υ t+1 = e µ+ 1 2 σ2 υe υ t σ2 υ = (1 + g)ε t+1, where g = e µ+ 1 2 σ2 υ 1 and ε t+1 = e υ t σ2 υ, which implies E t (ε t+1 ) = 1. all types correct beliefs about cash flows E h,t [y t+1 ] = E t [y t+1 ] = (1 + g)y t E t [ε t+1 ] = (1 + g)y t. Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 40 / 52

41 Empirical Validation RE fundamental benchmark for constant growth cash flow p t = r E t(p t+1 + y t+1 ) "no bubble" condition implies unique bounded RE fundamental price p t : (discounted sum of expected future dividends) pt = E t(y t+1 ) + E t(y t+2 ) 1 + r (1 + r) = 1 + g 1 + r y (1 + g)2 t + (1 + r) 2 y t +... = 1 + r r g y t. fundamental price to cash flow ratio δ t = p t y t = 1 + r r g = m Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 41 / 52

42 Empirical Validation Reformulation BH-model in terms of price to cash flows equilibrium pricing equation p t = r H n h,t E h,t (p t+1 + y t+1 ) h=1 in terms of price-to-cash flows δ t = p t /y t δ t = 1 H R {1 + n h,t E h,t [δ t+1 ]}, h=1 R = 1 + r 1 + g Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 42 / 52

43 Empirical Validation Heterogeneous Beliefs in terms of price-to-cash flows deviation price-to-cash flow from fundamental x t = δ t m = δ t 1 + g r g belief of type h about price-to-cash flow: E ht [δ t+1 ] = E t [δ t ] + f h (x t 1,..., x t L ) = m + f h (x t 1,..., x t L ) pricing equation in deviations from fundamental H R x t = n ht f h (x t 1,..., x t L ), h=1 R = 1 + r 1 + g Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 43 / 52

44 Empirical Validation Evolutionary Fitness Measure realized net profits in period t U ht = π ht = R t z h,t 1 = (p t + y t Rp t 1 ) E h,t 1[p t + y t Rp t 1 ] av t 1 [p t + y t Rp t 1 ] Assume (in analogy with BH) V t 1 [p t + y t Rp t 1 ] = V t 1 [p t + y t Rp t 1] = y 2 t 1η 2 fitness in deviations from fundamental U ht = π ht = (1 + g)2 aη 2 (x t R x t 1 )(E h,t 1 [x t R x t 1 ]) Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 44 / 52

45 Empirical Validation Two-types: Fundamentalists versus trend Two trader types, with forecasting rules f 1t = φ 1 x t 1, 0 φ 1 < 1 fundamentalists f 2t = φ 2 x t 1, φ 2 > 1, trend extrapolators Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 45 / 52

46 Empirical Validation Fractions of the Two Types fractions of belief types are updated in each period according to discrete choice model (BH 1997,1998) n h,t = exp[βπ h,t 1 ] Hk=1 exp[βπ k,t 1 ] = k h exp[ β πh,k t 1 ], where β > 0 is intensity of choice and π h,k t 1 = π h,t 1 π k,t 1 difference in realized profits types h and k In 2-type case, fraction of type 1: n t = exp { β [(φ 1 φ 2 )x t 3 (x t 1 R x t 2 )]} Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 46 / 52

47 Empirical Validation Estimation of two type model in deviations from fundamental; synchronous updating; Boswijk et al., JEDC 2007 R x t = n t φ 1 x t 1 + (1 n t )φ 2 x t 1 + ɛ t R = 1 + r 1 + g φ 1 = 0.762: fundamentalists, mean reversion φ 2 = trend extrapolators β 10 φ t = n tφ 1 + (1 n t )φ 2 R market sentiment φ t < 1: mean reversion; φ t > 1: explosive, trend following Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 47 / 52

48 Empirical Validation Fraction Fundamentalists & Market Sentiment Explanation: dot com bubble triggered by economic fundamentals and strongly amplified by trend following behavior Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 48 / 52

49 Empirical Validation Average Response to Fundamental shock (2000 runs) short term overreaction and long term mean reversion Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 49 / 52

50 Empirical Validation Financial Crisis Extreme Event in Linear RE Model Quantiles of 2000 simulated predictions of the PE-ratio in deviations from fundamental Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 50 / 52

51 Empirical Validation Financial Crisis not Extreme in Nonlinear Switching Model Quantiles of 2000 simulated predictions of the PE-ratio in deviations from fundamental Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 51 / 52

52 Empirical Validation Conclusions Asset Pricing Model with Heterogeneous Beliefs rational route to randomness as β increases, with temporary bubbles and crashes weak correlation of beliefs: stable price behavior; strong coordination of beliefs: unstable price dynamics counter-examples to Friedman hypothesis: fundamentalists do not drive out irrational technical analysts, driven by short run profits empirical validation: explanation of bubbles and crashes consistent with learning-to-forecast laboratory experiments Cars Hommes (CeNDEF, UvA) Complex Systems CEF 2013, Vancouver 52 / 52

Topics in Nonlinear Economic Dynamics: Bounded Rationality, Heterogeneous Expectations and Complex Adaptive Systems

Topics in Nonlinear Economic Dynamics: Bounded Rationality, Heterogeneous Expectations and Complex Adaptive Systems Topics in Nonlinear Economic Dynamics: Bounded Rationality, Heterogeneous Expectations and Complex Adaptive Systems CeNDEF, Amsterdam School of Economics University of Amsterdam PhD - Workshop Series in

More information

Behavioural & Experimental Macroeconomics: Some Recent Findings

Behavioural & Experimental Macroeconomics: Some Recent Findings Behavioural & Experimental Macroeconomics: Some Recent Findings Cars Hommes CeNDEF, University of Amsterdam MACFINROBODS Conference Goethe University, Frankfurt, Germany 3-4 April 27 Cars Hommes (CeNDEF,

More information

Simple Forecasting Heuristics that Make us Smart: Evidence from Different Market Experiments

Simple Forecasting Heuristics that Make us Smart: Evidence from Different Market Experiments Simple Forecasting Heuristics that Make us Smart: Evidence from Different Market Experiments Mikhail Anufriev Cars Hommes Tomasz Makarewicz Rebuilding Macroeconomics Conference HM Treasury, London, UK,

More information

Learning to Forecast with Genetic Algorithms

Learning to Forecast with Genetic Algorithms Learning to Forecast with Genetic Algorithms Mikhail Anufriev 1 Cars Hommes 2,3 Tomasz Makarewicz 2,3 1 EDG, University of Technology, Sydney 2 CeNDEF, University of Amsterdam 3 Tinbergen Institute Computation

More information

The Heterogeneous Expectations Hypothesis: Some Evidence from the Lab

The Heterogeneous Expectations Hypothesis: Some Evidence from the Lab The : Some Evidence from the Lab Cars Hommes CeNDEF, Amsterdam School of Economics University of Amsterdam Evolution and Market Beavior in Economics and Finance Scuola Superiore Sant Anna, Pisa, Italia,

More information

Local Interactions in a Market with Heterogeneous Expectations

Local Interactions in a Market with Heterogeneous Expectations 1 / 17 Local Interactions in a Market with Heterogeneous Expectations Mikhail Anufriev 1 Andrea Giovannetti 2 Valentyn Panchenko 3 1,2 University of Technology Sydney 3 UNSW Sydney, Australia Computing

More information

Bifurcation Routes to Volatility Clustering under Evolutionary Learning

Bifurcation Routes to Volatility Clustering under Evolutionary Learning Bifurcation Routes to Volatility Clustering under Evolutionary Learning Andrea Gaunersdorfer Department of Business Studies University of Vienna Cars H. Hommes FlorianO.O.Wagener Center for Nonlinear Dynamics

More information

Bifurcation Routes to Volatility Clustering under Evolutionary Learning

Bifurcation Routes to Volatility Clustering under Evolutionary Learning Bifurcation Routes to Volatility Clustering under Evolutionary Learning Andrea Gaunersdorfer University of Vienna, Department of Finance Brünner Straße 72, 1210 Wien, Austria Cars H. Hommes Florian O.

More information

FADING MEMORY LEARNING IN THE COBWEB MODEL WITH RISK AVERSE HETEROGENEOUS PRODUCERS

FADING MEMORY LEARNING IN THE COBWEB MODEL WITH RISK AVERSE HETEROGENEOUS PRODUCERS FADING MEMORY LEARNING IN THE COBWEB MODEL WITH RISK AVERSE HETEROGENEOUS PRODUCERS CARL CHIARELLA, XUE-ZHONG HE AND PEIYUAN ZHU School of Finance and Economics University of Technology, Sydney PO Box

More information

Does eductive stability imply evolutionary stability?

Does eductive stability imply evolutionary stability? Does eductive stability imply evolutionary stability? Cars Hommes and Florian Wagener September 8, 009 Abstract This note presents a simple example of a model in which the unique rational expectations

More information

A dynamic stochastic model of asset pricing with heterogeneous beliefs

A dynamic stochastic model of asset pricing with heterogeneous beliefs Università degli Studi di Macerata Dipartimento di Istituzioni Economiche e Finanziarie A dynamic stochastic model of asset pricing with heterogeneous beliefs Serena Brianzoni, Roy Cerqueti, Elisabetta

More information

Recurent Hyperinflations and Learning

Recurent Hyperinflations and Learning 1 / 17 Recurent Hyperinflations and Learning Albert Marcet and Juan P. Nicolini (AER,2003) Manuel M. Mosquera T. UC3M November 24, 2015 2 / 17 Motivation of Literature Expectations play a key role in macroeconomics

More information

Replicator dynamics in a Cobweb model with rationally heterogeneous expectations

Replicator dynamics in a Cobweb model with rationally heterogeneous expectations Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization Vol. xxx (2006) xxx xxx Replicator dynamics in a Cobweb model with rationally heterogeneous expectations William A. Branch a,, Bruce McGough b a Department of

More information

under Heterogeneous Expectations

under Heterogeneous Expectations Interest Rate Rules and Macroeconomic Stability under Heterogeneous Expectations Mikhail Anufriev a Cars Hommes a Tiziana Assenza b,a Domenico Massaro a a CeNDEF, School of Economics, University of Amsterdam,

More information

Speculation and the Bond Market: An Empirical No-arbitrage Framework

Speculation and the Bond Market: An Empirical No-arbitrage Framework Online Appendix to the paper Speculation and the Bond Market: An Empirical No-arbitrage Framework October 5, 2015 Part I: Maturity specific shocks in affine and equilibrium models This Appendix present

More information

Financial Factors in Economic Fluctuations. Lawrence Christiano Roberto Motto Massimo Rostagno

Financial Factors in Economic Fluctuations. Lawrence Christiano Roberto Motto Massimo Rostagno Financial Factors in Economic Fluctuations Lawrence Christiano Roberto Motto Massimo Rostagno Background Much progress made on constructing and estimating models that fit quarterly data well (Smets-Wouters,

More information

A model of financial market dynamics with heterogeneous beliefs and state-dependent confidence

A model of financial market dynamics with heterogeneous beliefs and state-dependent confidence A model of financial market dynamics with heterogeneous beliefs and state-dependent confidence Carl Chiarella (carl.chiarella@uts.edu.au) School of Finance and Economics, University of Technology Sydney,

More information

A Metzlerian business cycle model with nonlinear heterogeneous expectations

A Metzlerian business cycle model with nonlinear heterogeneous expectations A Metzlerian business cycle model with nonlinear heterogeneous expectations Michael Wegener Frank Westerhoff Georg Zaklan April 11, 2008 University of Bamberg, Feldkirchenstr. 21, 96045 Bamberg, Germany

More information

HETEROGENEOUS BELIEFS, RISK, AND LEARNING IN A SIMPLE ASSET-PRICING MODEL WITH A MARKET MAKER

HETEROGENEOUS BELIEFS, RISK, AND LEARNING IN A SIMPLE ASSET-PRICING MODEL WITH A MARKET MAKER Macroeconomic Dynamics, 7, 2003, 503-536. Printed in the United States of America. DOl: 10.1017.S 1365100502020114 HETEROGENEOUS BELIEFS, RISK, AND LEARNING IN A SIMPLE ASSET-PRICING MODEL WITH A MARKET

More information

Bounded Rationality and Heterogeneous Expectations in macroeconomics Cars Hommes

Bounded Rationality and Heterogeneous Expectations in macroeconomics Cars Hommes MACFINROBODS: WP Behaviour under uncertainty, heterogeneous agents and herding Bounded Rationality and Heterogeneous Expectations in macroeconomics Cars Hommes Universiteit van Amsterdam MACFINROBODS First

More information

Sentiments and Aggregate Fluctuations

Sentiments and Aggregate Fluctuations Sentiments and Aggregate Fluctuations Jess Benhabib Pengfei Wang Yi Wen October 15, 2013 Jess Benhabib Pengfei Wang Yi Wen () Sentiments and Aggregate Fluctuations October 15, 2013 1 / 43 Introduction

More information

Ergodicity and Non-Ergodicity in Economics

Ergodicity and Non-Ergodicity in Economics Abstract An stochastic system is called ergodic if it tends in probability to a limiting form that is independent of the initial conditions. Breakdown of ergodicity gives rise to path dependence. We illustrate

More information

Price and Wealth Dynamics in a Speculative Market with an Arbitrary Number of Generic Technical Traders

Price and Wealth Dynamics in a Speculative Market with an Arbitrary Number of Generic Technical Traders Price and Wealth Dynamics in a Speculative Market with an Arbitrary Number of Generic Technical Traders Mikhail Anufriev Giulio Bottazzi S.Anna School for Advanced Studies, Pisa, Italy February 20, 2005

More information

Area I: Contract Theory Question (Econ 206)

Area I: Contract Theory Question (Econ 206) Theory Field Exam Summer 2011 Instructions You must complete two of the four areas (the areas being (I) contract theory, (II) game theory A, (III) game theory B, and (IV) psychology & economics). Be sure

More information

Nonlinear dynamics in the Cournot duopoly game with heterogeneous players

Nonlinear dynamics in the Cournot duopoly game with heterogeneous players arxiv:nlin/0210035v1 [nlin.cd] 16 Oct 2002 Nonlinear dynamics in the Cournot duopoly game with heterogeneous players H. N. Agiza and A. A. Elsadany Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science Mansoura

More information

The Ramsey Model. (Lecture Note, Advanced Macroeconomics, Thomas Steger, SS 2013)

The Ramsey Model. (Lecture Note, Advanced Macroeconomics, Thomas Steger, SS 2013) The Ramsey Model (Lecture Note, Advanced Macroeconomics, Thomas Steger, SS 213) 1 Introduction The Ramsey model (or neoclassical growth model) is one of the prototype models in dynamic macroeconomics.

More information

Lecture 9: The monetary theory of the exchange rate

Lecture 9: The monetary theory of the exchange rate Lecture 9: The monetary theory of the exchange rate Open Economy Macroeconomics, Fall 2006 Ida Wolden Bache October 24, 2006 Macroeconomic models of exchange rate determination Useful reference: Chapter

More information

Expectations, Learning and Macroeconomic Policy

Expectations, Learning and Macroeconomic Policy Expectations, Learning and Macroeconomic Policy George W. Evans (Univ. of Oregon and Univ. of St. Andrews) Lecture 4 Liquidity traps, learning and stagnation Evans, Guse & Honkapohja (EER, 2008), Evans

More information

FINM6900 Finance Theory Noisy Rational Expectations Equilibrium for Multiple Risky Assets

FINM6900 Finance Theory Noisy Rational Expectations Equilibrium for Multiple Risky Assets FINM69 Finance Theory Noisy Rational Expectations Equilibrium for Multiple Risky Assets February 3, 212 Reference Anat R. Admati, A Noisy Rational Expectations Equilibrium for Multi-Asset Securities Markets,

More information

Wealth Selection in a Financial Market with Heterogeneous Agents

Wealth Selection in a Financial Market with Heterogeneous Agents Wealth Selection in a Financial Market with Heterogeneous Agents Mikhail Anufriev a,b, Pietro Dindo b,a, a CeNDEF, Department of Quantitative Economics, University of Amsterdam, Roetersstraat, NL-08 WB

More information

Psychology and Economics (Lecture 3)

Psychology and Economics (Lecture 3) Psychology and Economics (Lecture 3) Xavier Gabaix February 10, 2003 1 Discussion of traditional objections In the real world people would get it right Answer: there are many non-repeated interactions,

More information

Macroeconomics II. Dynamic AD-AS model

Macroeconomics II. Dynamic AD-AS model Macroeconomics II Dynamic AD-AS model Vahagn Jerbashian Ch. 14 from Mankiw (2010) Spring 2018 Where we are heading to We will incorporate dynamics into the standard AD-AS model This will offer another

More information

Dynamic AD-AS model vs. AD-AS model Notes. Dynamic AD-AS model in a few words Notes. Notation to incorporate time-dimension Notes

Dynamic AD-AS model vs. AD-AS model Notes. Dynamic AD-AS model in a few words Notes. Notation to incorporate time-dimension Notes Macroeconomics II Dynamic AD-AS model Vahagn Jerbashian Ch. 14 from Mankiw (2010) Spring 2018 Where we are heading to We will incorporate dynamics into the standard AD-AS model This will offer another

More information

1 The Basic RBC Model

1 The Basic RBC Model IHS 2016, Macroeconomics III Michael Reiter Ch. 1: Notes on RBC Model 1 1 The Basic RBC Model 1.1 Description of Model Variables y z k L c I w r output level of technology (exogenous) capital at end of

More information

Ramsey Cass Koopmans Model (1): Setup of the Model and Competitive Equilibrium Path

Ramsey Cass Koopmans Model (1): Setup of the Model and Competitive Equilibrium Path Ramsey Cass Koopmans Model (1): Setup of the Model and Competitive Equilibrium Path Ryoji Ohdoi Dept. of Industrial Engineering and Economics, Tokyo Tech This lecture note is mainly based on Ch. 8 of Acemoglu

More information

Information Percolation, Momentum, and Reversal

Information Percolation, Momentum, and Reversal Reversal Daniel Andrei Julien Cujean a b c Banque de France, Mars 2014 Reversal 0 / 14 Time-Series Momentum and Reversal: Evidence T-Statistic T-Statistic by Month, All Asset Classes 6 5 4 3 2 1 0-1 -2-3

More information

1. Money in the utility function (start)

1. Money in the utility function (start) Monetary Economics: Macro Aspects, 1/3 2012 Henrik Jensen Department of Economics University of Copenhagen 1. Money in the utility function (start) a. The basic money-in-the-utility function model b. Optimal

More information

ECOM 009 Macroeconomics B. Lecture 2

ECOM 009 Macroeconomics B. Lecture 2 ECOM 009 Macroeconomics B Lecture 2 Giulio Fella c Giulio Fella, 2014 ECOM 009 Macroeconomics B - Lecture 2 40/197 Aim of consumption theory Consumption theory aims at explaining consumption/saving decisions

More information

Endogenous Information Choice

Endogenous Information Choice Endogenous Information Choice Lecture 7 February 11, 2015 An optimizing trader will process those prices of most importance to his decision problem most frequently and carefully, those of less importance

More information

Asset Pricing. Chapter IX. The Consumption Capital Asset Pricing Model. June 20, 2006

Asset Pricing. Chapter IX. The Consumption Capital Asset Pricing Model. June 20, 2006 Chapter IX. The Consumption Capital Model June 20, 2006 The Representative Agent Hypothesis and its Notion of Equilibrium 9.2.1 An infinitely lived Representative Agent Avoid terminal period problem Equivalence

More information

"0". Doing the stuff on SVARs from the February 28 slides

0. Doing the stuff on SVARs from the February 28 slides Monetary Policy, 7/3 2018 Henrik Jensen Department of Economics University of Copenhagen "0". Doing the stuff on SVARs from the February 28 slides 1. Money in the utility function (start) a. The basic

More information

Information Choice in Macroeconomics and Finance.

Information Choice in Macroeconomics and Finance. Information Choice in Macroeconomics and Finance. Laura Veldkamp New York University, Stern School of Business, CEPR and NBER Spring 2009 1 Veldkamp What information consumes is rather obvious: It consumes

More information

Relationships between phases of business cycles in two large open economies

Relationships between phases of business cycles in two large open economies Journal of Regional Development Studies2010 131 Relationships between phases of business cycles in two large open economies Ken-ichi ISHIYAMA 1. Introduction We have observed large increases in trade and

More information

Econ 5110 Solutions to the Practice Questions for the Midterm Exam

Econ 5110 Solutions to the Practice Questions for the Midterm Exam Econ 50 Solutions to the Practice Questions for the Midterm Exam Spring 202 Real Business Cycle Theory. Consider a simple neoclassical growth model (notation similar to class) where all agents are identical

More information

Exploring Financial Instability Through Agent-based Modeling Part 1: Background and Early Models

Exploring Financial Instability Through Agent-based Modeling Part 1: Background and Early Models Blake LeBaron International Business School Brandeis University www.brandeis.edu/ blebaron Mini course CIGI-INET: False Dichotomies Exploring Financial Instability Through Agent-based Modeling Part 1:

More information

Adaptive Learning and Applications in Monetary Policy. Noah Williams

Adaptive Learning and Applications in Monetary Policy. Noah Williams Adaptive Learning and Applications in Monetary Policy Noah University of Wisconsin - Madison Econ 899 Motivations J. C. Trichet: Understanding expectations formation as a process underscores the strategic

More information

Learning and Monetary Policy. Lecture 4 Recent Applications of Learning to Monetary Policy

Learning and Monetary Policy. Lecture 4 Recent Applications of Learning to Monetary Policy Learning and Monetary Policy Lecture 4 Recent Applications of Learning to Monetary Policy George W. Evans (University of Oregon) University of Paris X -Nanterre (September 2007) Lecture 4 Outline This

More information

A suggested solution to the problem set at the re-exam in Advanced Macroeconomics. February 15, 2016

A suggested solution to the problem set at the re-exam in Advanced Macroeconomics. February 15, 2016 Christian Groth A suggested solution to the problem set at the re-exam in Advanced Macroeconomics February 15, 216 (3-hours closed book exam) 1 As formulated in the course description, a score of 12 is

More information

Ambiguity and Information Processing in a Model of Intermediary Asset Pricing

Ambiguity and Information Processing in a Model of Intermediary Asset Pricing Ambiguity and Information Processing in a Model of Intermediary Asset Pricing Leyla Jianyu Han 1 Kenneth Kasa 2 Yulei Luo 1 1 The University of Hong Kong 2 Simon Fraser University December 15, 218 1 /

More information

Knowing What Others Know: Coordination Motives in Information Acquisition

Knowing What Others Know: Coordination Motives in Information Acquisition Knowing What Others Know: Coordination Motives in Information Acquisition Christian Hellwig and Laura Veldkamp UCLA and NYU Stern May 2006 1 Hellwig and Veldkamp Two types of information acquisition Passive

More information

General Examination in Macroeconomic Theory SPRING 2013

General Examination in Macroeconomic Theory SPRING 2013 HARVARD UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS General Examination in Macroeconomic Theory SPRING 203 You have FOUR hours. Answer all questions Part A (Prof. Laibson): 48 minutes Part B (Prof. Aghion): 48

More information

Lecture 6. Lorenz equations and Malkus' waterwheel Some properties of the Lorenz Eq.'s Lorenz Map Towards definitions of:

Lecture 6. Lorenz equations and Malkus' waterwheel Some properties of the Lorenz Eq.'s Lorenz Map Towards definitions of: Lecture 6 Chaos Lorenz equations and Malkus' waterwheel Some properties of the Lorenz Eq.'s Lorenz Map Towards definitions of: Chaos, Attractors and strange attractors Transient chaos Lorenz Equations

More information

Learning, Expectations, and Endogenous Business Cycles

Learning, Expectations, and Endogenous Business Cycles Learning, Expectations, and Endogenous Business Cycles I.S.E.O. Summer School June 19, 2013 Introduction A simple model Simulations Stability Monetary Policy What s next Who we are Two students writing

More information

Citation for published version (APA): Ochea, M. I. (2010). Essays on nonlinear evolutionary game dynamics Amsterdam: Thela Thesis

Citation for published version (APA): Ochea, M. I. (2010). Essays on nonlinear evolutionary game dynamics Amsterdam: Thela Thesis UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository) Essays on nonlinear evolutionary game dynamics Ochea, M.I. Link to publication Citation for published version (APA): Ochea, M. I. (200). Essays on nonlinear evolutionary

More information

Dynamic Regimes of a Multi-agent Stock Market Model

Dynamic Regimes of a Multi-agent Stock Market Model MPRA Munich Personal RePEc Archive Dynamic Regimes of a Multi-agent Stock Market Model Tongkui Yu and Honggang Li Department of Systems Science, Beijing Normal University November 2008 Online at http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/14347/

More information

Foundations of Modern Macroeconomics B. J. Heijdra & F. van der Ploeg Chapter 2: Dynamics in Aggregate Demand and Supply

Foundations of Modern Macroeconomics B. J. Heijdra & F. van der Ploeg Chapter 2: Dynamics in Aggregate Demand and Supply Foundations of Modern Macroeconomics: Chapter 2 1 Foundations of Modern Macroeconomics B. J. Heijdra & F. van der Ploeg Chapter 2: Dynamics in Aggregate Demand and Supply Foundations of Modern Macroeconomics:

More information

Speculative Investor Behavior and Learning

Speculative Investor Behavior and Learning Speculative Investor Behavior and Learning QJE 1996 Stephen Morris presentation by Jonathan R. L. Halket Speculative Investor Behavior and Learning by Stephen Morris p. 1/13 Introduction and Motivation

More information

University of California Berkeley

University of California Berkeley Working Paper #2018-02 Infinite Horizon CCAPM with Stochastic Taxation and Monetary Policy Revised from the Center for Risk Management Research Working Paper 2018-01 Konstantin Magin, University of California,

More information

MA Advanced Macroeconomics: Solving Models with Rational Expectations

MA Advanced Macroeconomics: Solving Models with Rational Expectations MA Advanced Macroeconomics: Solving Models with Rational Expectations Karl Whelan School of Economics, UCD February 6, 2009 Karl Whelan (UCD) Models with Rational Expectations February 6, 2009 1 / 32 Moving

More information

problem. max Both k (0) and h (0) are given at time 0. (a) Write down the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) Equation in the dynamic programming

problem. max Both k (0) and h (0) are given at time 0. (a) Write down the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) Equation in the dynamic programming 1. Endogenous Growth with Human Capital Consider the following endogenous growth model with both physical capital (k (t)) and human capital (h (t)) in continuous time. The representative household solves

More information

Topic 8: Optimal Investment

Topic 8: Optimal Investment Topic 8: Optimal Investment Yulei Luo SEF of HKU November 22, 2013 Luo, Y. SEF of HKU) Macro Theory November 22, 2013 1 / 22 Demand for Investment The importance of investment. First, the combination of

More information

DEM Working Paper Series. Macroeconomic Stability and Heterogeneous Expectations

DEM Working Paper Series. Macroeconomic Stability and Heterogeneous Expectations ISSN: 2281-1346 Department of Economics and Management DEM Working Paper Series Macroeconomic Stability and Heterogeneous Expectations Nicolò Pecora (Università Cattolica di Piacenza) Alessandro Spelta

More information

Managing Unanchored, Heterogeneous Expectations and Liquidity Traps

Managing Unanchored, Heterogeneous Expectations and Liquidity Traps This research was carried out in the Bamberg Doctoral Research Group on Behavioral Macroeconomics (BaGBeM) supported by the Hans-Böckler Foundation (PK 045) Managing Unanchored, Heterogeneous Expectations

More information

Heterogeneous speculators, endogenous fluctuations and

Heterogeneous speculators, endogenous fluctuations and Heterogeneous speculators, endogenous fluctuations and interacting markets: a model of stock prices and exchange rates Roberto Dieci (rdieci@rimini.unibo.it) Department of Mathematics for Economic and

More information

INTRICATE ASSET PRICE

INTRICATE ASSET PRICE Chapter 1 INTRICATE ASSET PRICE DYNAMICS AND ONE-DIMENSIONAL DISCONTINUOUS MAPS F. Tramontana, L. Gardini and F. Westerhoff * Department of Economics and Quantitative Methods, University of Urbino, Via

More information

Dynamic IS-LM model with Philips Curve and International Trade

Dynamic IS-LM model with Philips Curve and International Trade Journal of Mathematics and System Science 6 (2016) 147-158 doi: 10.17265/2159-5291/2016.04.003 D DAVID PUBLISHING Dynamic IS-LM model with Philips Curve and International Trade Michiya Nozaki Gifu Keizai

More information

Volume 30, Issue 3. A note on Kalman filter approach to solution of rational expectations models

Volume 30, Issue 3. A note on Kalman filter approach to solution of rational expectations models Volume 30, Issue 3 A note on Kalman filter approach to solution of rational expectations models Marco Maria Sorge BGSE, University of Bonn Abstract In this note, a class of nonlinear dynamic models under

More information

Data Abundance and Asset Price Informativeness. On-Line Appendix

Data Abundance and Asset Price Informativeness. On-Line Appendix Data Abundance and Asset Price Informativeness On-Line Appendix Jérôme Dugast Thierry Foucault August 30, 07 This note is the on-line appendix for Data Abundance and Asset Price Informativeness. It contains

More information

B5.6 Nonlinear Systems

B5.6 Nonlinear Systems B5.6 Nonlinear Systems 5. Global Bifurcations, Homoclinic chaos, Melnikov s method Alain Goriely 2018 Mathematical Institute, University of Oxford Table of contents 1. Motivation 1.1 The problem 1.2 A

More information

Dynamic stochastic game and macroeconomic equilibrium

Dynamic stochastic game and macroeconomic equilibrium Dynamic stochastic game and macroeconomic equilibrium Tianxiao Zheng SAIF 1. Introduction We have studied single agent problems. However, macro-economy consists of a large number of agents including individuals/households,

More information

Animal Spirits, Fundamental Factors and Business Cycle Fluctuations

Animal Spirits, Fundamental Factors and Business Cycle Fluctuations Animal Spirits, Fundamental Factors and Business Cycle Fluctuations Stephane Dées Srečko Zimic Banque de France European Central Bank January 6, 218 Disclaimer Any views expressed represent those of the

More information

Macroeconomics Theory II

Macroeconomics Theory II Macroeconomics Theory II Francesco Franco FEUNL February 2016 Francesco Franco Macroeconomics Theory II 1/23 Housekeeping. Class organization. Website with notes and papers as no "Mas-Collel" in macro

More information

Foundations of Modern Macroeconomics Second Edition

Foundations of Modern Macroeconomics Second Edition Foundations of Modern Macroeconomics Second Edition Chapter 4: Anticipation effects and economic policy BJ Heijdra Department of Economics, Econometrics & Finance University of Groningen 1 September 2009

More information

Citation for published version (APA): Kopányi, D. (2015). Bounded rationality and learning in market competition Amsterdam: Tinbergen Institute

Citation for published version (APA): Kopányi, D. (2015). Bounded rationality and learning in market competition Amsterdam: Tinbergen Institute UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository) Bounded rationality and learning in market competition Kopányi, D. Link to publication Citation for published version (APA): Kopányi, D. (2015). Bounded rationality

More information

Critical Slowing Down as Early Warning Signals for Financial Crises?

Critical Slowing Down as Early Warning Signals for Financial Crises? Critical Slowing Down as Early Warning Signals for Financial Crises? Cees Diks, Cars Hommes and Juanxi Wang Centre for Nonlinear Dynamics in Economics and Finance (CeNDEF) University of Amsterdam Tinbergen

More information

http://www.ibiblio.org/e-notes/mset/logistic.htm On to Fractals Now let s consider Scale It s all about scales and its invariance (not just space though can also time And self-organized similarity

More information

On the Stability of the Cournot Equilibrium: An Evolutionary Approach

On the Stability of the Cournot Equilibrium: An Evolutionary Approach On the Stability of the Cournot Equilibrium: An Evolutionary Approach Cars H. Hommes Marius I. Ochea Jan Tuinstra 15th December 2011 Abstract We construct an evolutionary version of Theocharis (1960 s

More information

Motivation Non-linear Rational Expectations The Permanent Income Hypothesis The Log of Gravity Non-linear IV Estimation Summary.

Motivation Non-linear Rational Expectations The Permanent Income Hypothesis The Log of Gravity Non-linear IV Estimation Summary. Econometrics I Department of Economics Universidad Carlos III de Madrid Master in Industrial Economics and Markets Outline Motivation 1 Motivation 2 3 4 5 Motivation Hansen's contributions GMM was developed

More information

Heterogeneous Expectations, Exchange Rate Dynamics and Predictability

Heterogeneous Expectations, Exchange Rate Dynamics and Predictability Heterogeneous Expectations, Exchange Rate Dynamics and Predictability Sebastiano Manzan and Frank H. Westerhoff Department of Economics, University of Leicester University Road, Leicester LE1 7RH, United

More information

Lecture 15. Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Model. Randall Romero Aguilar, PhD I Semestre 2017 Last updated: July 3, 2017

Lecture 15. Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Model. Randall Romero Aguilar, PhD I Semestre 2017 Last updated: July 3, 2017 Lecture 15 Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Model Randall Romero Aguilar, PhD I Semestre 2017 Last updated: July 3, 2017 Universidad de Costa Rica EC3201 - Teoría Macroeconómica 2 Table of contents

More information

Estimating Macroeconomic Models: A Likelihood Approach

Estimating Macroeconomic Models: A Likelihood Approach Estimating Macroeconomic Models: A Likelihood Approach Jesús Fernández-Villaverde University of Pennsylvania, NBER, and CEPR Juan Rubio-Ramírez Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Estimating Dynamic Macroeconomic

More information

Is the Macroeconomy Locally Unstable and Why should we care?

Is the Macroeconomy Locally Unstable and Why should we care? Is the Macroeconomy Locally Unstable and Why should we care? Paul Beaudry, Dana Galizia & Franck Portier NBER macroannual April 2016 1 / 22 Introduction In most macro-models, BC fluctuation arises as the

More information

Learning and Global Dynamics

Learning and Global Dynamics Learning and Global Dynamics James Bullard 10 February 2007 Learning and global dynamics The paper for this lecture is Liquidity Traps, Learning and Stagnation, by George Evans, Eran Guse, and Seppo Honkapohja.

More information

Speculative behaviour and complex asset price dynamics: a global analysis

Speculative behaviour and complex asset price dynamics: a global analysis Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization Vol. 49 (2002) 173 197 Speculative behaviour and complex asset price dynamics: a global analysis Carl Chiarella a,, Roberto Dieci b, Laura Gardini c a School

More information

Indeterminacy and Sunspots in Macroeconomics

Indeterminacy and Sunspots in Macroeconomics Indeterminacy and Sunspots in Macroeconomics Friday September 8 th : Lecture 10 Gerzensee, September 2017 Roger E. A. Farmer Warwick University and NIESR Topics for Lecture 10 Tying together the pieces

More information

HERD BEHAVIOR AND NONFUNDAMENTAL ASSET PRICE FLUCTUATIONS IN FINANCIAL MARKETS

HERD BEHAVIOR AND NONFUNDAMENTAL ASSET PRICE FLUCTUATIONS IN FINANCIAL MARKETS Macroeconomic Dynamics, 10, 2006, 502 528. Printed in the United States of America. DOI: 10.1017.S136510050605036X HERD BEHAVIOR AND NONFUNDAMENTAL ASSET PRICE FLUCTUATIONS IN FINANCIAL MARKETS GIAN-ITALO

More information

Fundamental Disagreement

Fundamental Disagreement Fundamental Disagreement Philippe Andrade (Banque de France) Richard Crump (FRBNY) Stefano Eusepi (FRBNY) Emanuel Moench (Bundesbank) Price-setting and inflation Paris, Dec. 7 & 8, 5 The views expressed

More information

Stagnation Traps. Gianluca Benigno and Luca Fornaro

Stagnation Traps. Gianluca Benigno and Luca Fornaro Stagnation Traps Gianluca Benigno and Luca Fornaro May 2015 Research question and motivation Can insu cient aggregate demand lead to economic stagnation? This question goes back, at least, to the Great

More information

Advanced Macroeconomics

Advanced Macroeconomics Advanced Macroeconomics The Ramsey Model Marcin Kolasa Warsaw School of Economics Marcin Kolasa (WSE) Ad. Macro - Ramsey model 1 / 30 Introduction Authors: Frank Ramsey (1928), David Cass (1965) and Tjalling

More information

Rationally heterogeneous forecasters

Rationally heterogeneous forecasters Rationally heterogeneous forecasters R. Giacomini, V. Skreta, J. Turen UCL Ischia, 15/06/2015 Giacomini, Skreta, Turen (UCL) Rationally heterogeneous forecasters Ischia, 15/06/2015 1 / 37 Motivation Question:

More information

Probabilities & Statistics Revision

Probabilities & Statistics Revision Probabilities & Statistics Revision Christopher Ting Christopher Ting http://www.mysmu.edu/faculty/christophert/ : christopherting@smu.edu.sg : 6828 0364 : LKCSB 5036 January 6, 2017 Christopher Ting QF

More information

Macroeconomics Theory II

Macroeconomics Theory II Macroeconomics Theory II Francesco Franco Nova SBE February 2012 Francesco Franco Macroeconomics Theory II 1/31 Housekeeping Website TA: none No "Mas-Collel" in macro One midterm, one final, problem sets

More information

Comprehensive Exam. Macro Spring 2014 Retake. August 22, 2014

Comprehensive Exam. Macro Spring 2014 Retake. August 22, 2014 Comprehensive Exam Macro Spring 2014 Retake August 22, 2014 You have a total of 180 minutes to complete the exam. If a question seems ambiguous, state why, sharpen it up and answer the sharpened-up question.

More information

Intrinsic Heterogeneity in Expectation Formation

Intrinsic Heterogeneity in Expectation Formation Intrinsic Heterogeneity in Expectation Formation William A. Branch University of California, Irvine George W. Evans University of Oregon Revised June 01, 2004 Abstract We introduce the concept of Misspecification

More information

Graduate Macroeconomics - Econ 551

Graduate Macroeconomics - Econ 551 Graduate Macroeconomics - Econ 551 Tack Yun Indiana University Seoul National University Spring Semester January 2013 T. Yun (SNU) Macroeconomics 1/07/2013 1 / 32 Business Cycle Models for Emerging-Market

More information

STABILITY AND CYCLES IN A COBWEB MODEL WITH HETEROGENEOUS EXPECTATIONS

STABILITY AND CYCLES IN A COBWEB MODEL WITH HETEROGENEOUS EXPECTATIONS Macroeconomic Dynamics, 9, 2005, 630 650. Printed in the United States of America. DOI: 10.1017.S1365100505050017 STABILITY AND CYCLES IN A COBWEB MODEL WITH HETEROGENEOUS EXPECTATIONS LAURENCE LASSELLE

More information

Oblivious Equilibrium: A Mean Field Approximation for Large-Scale Dynamic Games

Oblivious Equilibrium: A Mean Field Approximation for Large-Scale Dynamic Games Oblivious Equilibrium: A Mean Field Approximation for Large-Scale Dynamic Games Gabriel Y. Weintraub, Lanier Benkard, and Benjamin Van Roy Stanford University {gweintra,lanierb,bvr}@stanford.edu Abstract

More information

Stochastic Processes

Stochastic Processes Stochastic Processes Stochastic Process Non Formal Definition: Non formal: A stochastic process (random process) is the opposite of a deterministic process such as one defined by a differential equation.

More information

The Lucas Imperfect Information Model

The Lucas Imperfect Information Model The Lucas Imperfect Information Model Based on the work of Lucas (972) and Phelps (970), the imperfect information model represents an important milestone in modern economics. The essential idea of the

More information

MA Advanced Macroeconomics: 6. Solving Models with Rational Expectations

MA Advanced Macroeconomics: 6. Solving Models with Rational Expectations MA Advanced Macroeconomics: 6. Solving Models with Rational Expectations Karl Whelan School of Economics, UCD Spring 2016 Karl Whelan (UCD) Models with Rational Expectations Spring 2016 1 / 36 Moving Beyond

More information