PHYS First Midterm SOLUTIONS

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "PHYS First Midterm SOLUTIONS"

Kevin Osborne
6 years ago
Views:

1 PHYS First Midterm SOLUIONS 1. Comment on the following concepts (Just writing equations will not gain you any points): (3 points each, 21 points total) (a) Negative emperatures emperature is a measure of how entropy increases as the energy of the system increases. Hence negative temperature just means that the entropy of the system decreases as the energy of the system it increasing. his is possible only if the energy of the system is bounded from above. Negative temperature systems are hotter than positive temperature systems in the sense that if you bring into contact a system with negative temperature and another system with pisitive temperature, heat flows from negative temperatures to positive temperatures. (b) Micro canonical Distribution In micro canonical distribution it is assumed that the probability of the system to be in a state which satisfies the constraints imposed on the system such as the total energy, linear and angular momentum, is constant. hat is if you consider two states that have the same energy and momentum, the probability that the system will be in any one of these states is the same. his is called micro canonical distribution. (c) P- Diagram P- space is the plane which has P as one of the axis and as the other axis. If a system is in mechanical equilibrium, it has a definite pressure and volume at each instant. Hence any process which results in the change of P and/or or the system will correspond to a trajectory in the P- diagram. (d) hermodynamical Potential hermodynamical potentials such as the free energies, the heat function, energy, entropy, etc, are functions that contain all the information about the system. By differentiating the thermodynamical potentials it is possible to obtain the macroscopic properties of a given system and also starting from any one of the 1

2 thermodynamical potentials, it is possible to obtain all the others. (e) Reversible process A reversible process is a process in which the entropy of the whole system remains constant. By applying the operations in reverse order, one can trace back the process and come back to the initial state. (f) Ergodic Hypothesis Ergodic hypothesis is the assumption that the system will come close to any point in phase space that is consistant with the constraints imposed on the system infinitely many times. And the density of the trajectory will be uniform. (g) Entropy Mathematically, entropy is the logarith of the number of states that the system can be found it. It measures the disorder of a system and the lack of our knowledge about the state of the system. If one considers a closed system, the entropy of the closed system will always increase or at most remain constant. 2. Consider a gas of identical particles confined to move only on the surface of a rectangular area of side length L. he energy momentum relation for the particles is given as ɛ α(p 2 x + p2 y )wherep x and p y are the components of the momenta along two perpendicular directions on the surface and α is some constant. Calculate the entropy of this system if the system has energy E. (10 points). Calculate the temperature, (5 points), of the system and the surface tension σ(5 points) of the system. (Hint: For a two dimensional system, de ds σda where da is a differential change of the area of the system and σ is called the surface tension) (20 points) Just like the 3D case, we will first calculate Γ(E), the number of states that have the energy less then or equal to E. he energy of a state is 2

3 given by the 2N positive integers n i x,ni y as: E α h2 L 2 N (n i2 x + ni2 y ) (1) i1 Using the same reasoning as in the 3D case, Γ(E) is proportional to the volume of the 2N dimensional sphere with radius R EA where α h 2 A L 2 : Γ(E) 1 1 volume of sphere N! 22N 1 d 2N xθ(r r) N!2 2N 1 R drr 2N 1 dω N!2 2N 2N 0 1 2π N R 2N N!2 2N (N 1)! 2N 1 ( ) EπA N N! 2 4α h 2 (2) where in the first line, the factor 1/N! is to take into account the fact the that particles are identical, and the factor 1/2 2N is included to consider the volume of only part of the sphere where all the coordinates are positive (since n i x,ni y > 0) Once Γ(E) isknown, ΔΓ(E) can easily be obtained: ΔΓ(E) Γ(E) E ΔE ( ) 1 EπA N ΔE N!(N 1)! 4α h 2 E (3) he entropy is obtained by taking the logarithm os ΔΓ(E): S logδγ(e) N log EπA 4α h 2 2logN!+logΔE E ( ( )( ) ) π E A N log 4α h 2 e 2 N N (4) 3

4 where in order to obtain the last equality, Stirling s approximation is used and terms negligible compared to N are neglected. In order to obtain the temperature, we need to differentiate S w.r.t. E: 1 S E E (N log E + )N (5) E where are terms in entropy that do not depend on E and hence go to zero after differentiation. Hence: E N (6) Since de ds σda, ds 1 de + σ da. Hence ( ) S σ (7) A E Using the result for the entropy, we have: σ (N log A + )N (8) A A where in this expressions, stand for terms that do not depend on A. 3. Consider a Carnot cycle that uses the an Der Waals gas as the working gas. Show explicitly that the efficiency of this Carnot cycle is given by η 1 cold hot. In order to show this you need to go through several steps: (61 points) (a) First you need to calculate the adiabatic curve for the an der Waals gas. o calculate the adiabatic curve, consider the derivative ( ) S First change your variables to (,) from(s, ) and obtain the relation between the volume and temperature in an adiabatic process. hen substituting from the an der Waals equation of state, show that in an adiabatic process: ( Na) 5/3 ( P + a N ) const

5 (15 points) ( ) S (,S) (,S) (,S)/ (,) (,S)/ (,) ( S/) ( S/ ) (9) Using the Maxwell relation, ( ) S and the definition of C : C ( ) S (10) (11) one obtains: ( ) 1 S C ( P/) (12) Differentiation the given equation of state with respect to at constant volume, one obtains: ( Nb)N (13) or N Nb (14) Moreover, from the expression for the energy of the an der Walls gas, ( ) E C 3 2 N (15) 5

6 and hence ( ) 1 S 3 ( Nb) N 2 N 3( Nb) 2 (16) In terms of the differentials in an adiabatic process, we have d Nb 3 d 2 d ln( Nb)+ 3 2 d ln 0 d ln [ ( Nb) 3 2 ] 0 (17) Hence, in an adiabative process, for the an der Waals Gas, ( Nb) 3 2 const (18) Expression in terms of P and using the equation of state: ( Nb) 5 2 ( P + a N 2 2 ) 3 2 const (19) or taking the 2/3 rd power, we obtain: ( ( Nb) 5 3 P + a N 2 ) const (20) 2 which concludes our derivation of the adiabatic equation for the an der Waals gas. (b) Draw the P- diagram for the Carnot cycle. (5 points) he P- diagram for the Carnot cycle using the an der Waals gas is qualitatively similar to the carnot cycle that uses the ideal gas. (c) Calculate the work done on the gas, the heat absorbed by the gas, and the change in the internal energy of the gas for each of the 4 stages of the Carnot cycle. (You need to calculate results. 3 points each of the results (36 points) 6

7 i. he 1 2 process: his part of the cycle is an isothermal process and hence we can use the equation of state to calculate the work done during this process: W 12 ( ) 2 N1 Pd 1 1 Nb an2 d 2 ( N 1 ln( Nb)+a N N 1 ln ( 2 Nb 1 1 Nb an 2 1 ) 2 1 (21) 2 Since the internal energy of the an der Waals gas depend also on its volume, during the process, the internal energy of the an der Waals gas changes by: ΔE an 2 Δ 1 ( 1 an 2 1 ) (22) 2 1 he amount of heat absorbed by the system during this process is then Q 12 ΔE W 12 N 1 ln 2 Nb 1 Nb > 0 (23) Hence during this process, the system absorbes heat. ii. he 2 3 process his part of the cycle is adiabative, and hence there is no heat exchange: Q he work done during this process is: ( ) 3N W 23 ΔE Δ 2 an2 3N ( 1 2 ( 2 1 ) an 2 1 ) (24) 3 2 iii. he 3 4 process: he calculation of this process is the same as the 1 2 process, with the replacements: 1 3, 2 4, 1 2 7

8 since the starting point in this process is the point 3 and the final point is the point 4. Hence: W 34 N 2 ln ( 4 Nb 1 3 Nb an 2 1 ) 4 3 ΔE an 2 Δ 1 ( 1 an 2 1 ) 4 3 Q 34 ΔE W 34 N 2 ln 4 Nb 3 Nb < 0 (25) Hence, during this stage, the system releases heat to the cold reservoir. iv. he 4 1 process: hecalculationsofthisprocessisthesameasthe2 3 process with the replacement: 2 4, 3 1, 1 2, 2 1. Hence: Q 41 0 W 41 ΔE 3N ( 1 2 ( 1 2 ) an 2 1 ) 1 4 (26) (d) Calculate the efficiency (5 points) In order to calculate the efficiency, we need the total heat absorbed and the net work done by the system. he net work done can be obtained either by summing the works done in each stage of the process, i.e. W W 12 +W 23 +W 34 +W 41, or from the conservation of energy W Q absorbed Q released. where Q absorbed Q 12 N 1 ln 2 Nb and Q 1 Nb released Q 34 N 2 ln 3 Nb 4 where the Nb sign is due to the fact the Q 34 is negative. hen the efficiency is: W η 1 Q released Q absorbed Q absorbed 1 2 ln 3 Nb 4 Nb 1 ln 2 Nb 1 Nb (27) o simplify the ration of the logarithms, note that the points 2 and 3 lie on the same adiabatic curve and hence ( 2 Nb) ( 3 Nb) (28) 8

9 and similarly the points 1 and 2 lie on the same adiabatic curve and hence ( 1 Nb) ( 4 Nb) (29) Deviding both equations side by side, one obtains: 2 Nb 1 Nb 3 Nb (30) 4 Nb that is the arguments of the logarithms appearing in the efficiency are the same, and hence they cancel. hus as it should be. η (31) (Hint: he an der Walls equation of state is ( P + a N 2 ) ( Nb)N 2 and the energy of a an der Waals gas can be written as: ) E 3 N an Calculate the rate of change of the temperature of a an der Waals gas undergoing a Joule hompson process. (Hint: a Joule hompson process is a process that changes the pressure of the gas keeping the heat function constant). he relevant information about the an der Waals gas is given in the previous problem. he rate of change of the temperature is given by the derivative: ( ) (32) P W Using the Jacobian matrices, this can be written as: ( ) (,W) P (P, W) (,W)/ (, ) (33) (P, W)/ (, ) W 9

10 Let s study the numerator and the denominator seperately: he numerator can be written explicetly as: ( ) ( ) ( ) (,W) W S P (, ) + (34) wherewehaveuseddw ds + dp. Using the Maxwell relations, this can be rewritten as: (,W) (, ) + In the third problem we had already obtained in Eq. (14) that N Nb (35) (36) In order to evaluate the derivative ( ) P, we need to differentiate equation of state w.r.t volume at treating temperature as a constant to obtain or [ 2a N 2 ] ( ( Nb)+ P + a N 2 ) 0 (37) 3 2 Substituting in Eq. (35), we obtain: P + a N 2 2 Nb +2aN2 3 N ( Nb) 2 +2aN2 3 (38) (,W) (, ) N 2 b ( Nb) 2 +2aN2 (39) 2 he denominator of Eq. (32) can be written as: (P, W) (, ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) P W W P (40) 10

11 Substituting and ( W ) ( W ) C + Eq. (40) reduces to ( ) 2 (P, W) P (, ) + C (41) (42) (43) Substituting Eqs. (15), (14)and (38) into Eq. (43) we obtain: (P, W) (, ) 5 N 2 2 ( Nb) 2 3aN3 (44) 3 Hence the rate of change of the temperature of a an der Waals gas in a J process is: ( ) P W N 2 b +2a N 2 ( Nb) N 2 3a N 3 ( Nb) 2 3 2b 5 + 4a 5 + O(N ) (45) Note that, when a 0b, i.e. the gas is an ideal gas, the temperature does not change, a result that we had obtained in the class for the ideal gas. 11

CHAPTER - 12 THERMODYNAMICS

CHAPTER - 12 THERMODYNAMICS CHAPER - HERMODYNAMICS ONE MARK QUESIONS. What is hermodynamics?. Mention the Macroscopic variables to specify the thermodynamics. 3. How does thermodynamics differ from Mechanics? 4. What is thermodynamic