1 NUKLEONIKA 2015;60(2): doi: /nuka ORIGINAL PAPER Important problems of future thermonuclear reactors* Marek J. Sadowski Abstract. This paper concerns important and difficult problems connected with a design and construction of thermonuclear reactors, which have to use nuclear fusion reactions of heavy isotopes of hydrogen, i.e., deuterium (D) and tritium (T). There are described conditions in which such reactions can occur, and different methods of a high-temperature plasma generation, i.e., high-current electrical discharges, intense microwave pulses, and injection of energetic neutral atoms (NBI). There are also presented experimental facilities which can contain hot plasma for an appropriate period, and particularly so-called tokamaks. The second part presents the technical problems which must be solved in order to build a thermonuclear reactor, that might be used for energetic purposes. There are considered problems connected with a choice of constructional materials for a vacuum chamber, its internal parts, external windings generating a magnetic field, and necessary shields. The next part considers the handling of radioactive tritium; the using of alpha particles ( 4 He) for additional heating of plasma; recuperation of hydrogen isotopes absorbed in the tokamak internal parts, and a removal of a helium excess. There is presented a scheme of a future thermonuclear power plant and critical comments on a road map which should enable the construction of an industrial thermonuclear reactor (DEMO). Key words: fusion reactions plasma tokamak power plant thermonuclear reactor Introduction M. J. Sadowski Plasma Studies Division (TJ5), National Centre for Nuclear Research (NCBJ), 7 Andrzeja Soltana Str., Otwock/Swierk, Poland and Division of Magnetised Plasma, Institute of Plasma Physics and Laser Microfusion (IPPLM), 23 Hery Str., Warsaw, Poland, Tel.: , Fax: , Received: 3 August 2014 Accepted: 1 December 2014 During the recent 400 years, the world population has grown more than ten-fold to the 6.5 billion people that today inhabit the Earth. Over the next 50 years the world s population is expected to grow from the present value to a level in the range 8 12 billion, and energy needs are expected to double or even triple during that period. Therefore, it is a major challenge to provide these people with clean and safe energy sources. At present, almost 80% of the energy production comes from fossil fuels and their burning generates huge amounts of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) which pollutes the environment, induces the greenhouse effects and extreme climate changes . Energy from the so-called renewable sources is very dilute and its power per unit of surface used is low, e.g., from solar energy (5 50) W/m 2, from hydro- -energy about 11 W/m 2, from on-shore and off-shore wind (2 3) W/m 2, and from biomass 0.5 W/m 2 only . For a substantial contribution renewable power production plants depend on the size and localization of a country. Appropriate installations are very large and costly, e.g., to produce about 70 GW from photo-voltaic and on-shore wind installations * This review paper is based on an invited lecture given at the Polish Energy Mix-2014 Conference held at Ustroń Śląski, Poland, on October 2014.
2 332 M. J. Sadowski Fig. 1. Modelling of electric power production from different energy sources (COA coal, OIL petrol, GAS gas, FIS nuclear fission, FUS nuclear fusion, HYD hydro-energy, BIO bio-sources, GEO geothermal, WIN wind installations, SOL solar installations, CHP combined heat and power technologies), according to the English CCFE . Germany spent about 24 billion Euro. Therefore, it is unrealistic to assume that energy in the future might be produced from a renewable sources only. Nuclear energy from conventional nuclear reactors, which are based on the fission processes, is also not an option because such reactors produce huge amounts of radioactive wastes and are not completely safe during their exploitation. Hence, it seems that the only option for the future might be energy produced by thermonuclear reactors which might use nuclear fusion of heavy hydrogen isotopes, i.e. deuterium (D) and tritium (T). This opinion is shared by the Culham Centre for Fusion Energy (CCFE) experts , as shown in Fig. 1. It should be noted that thermonuclear reactors will not produce any long-living radioactive wastes and they will not threaten any explosion, but there are many difficult technological issues to be solved before the first energetic fusion reactor is put into operation. This paper describes the most important problems of future thermonuclear reactors. The first part presents physical principles of controlled nuclear fusion reactions, various methods of high-temperature plasma production, different devices used for plasma containment, and particularly tokamaks. The second part considers the most important problems connected with a design and construction of the tokamak-type thermonuclear reactor. The last part presents problems of fuel control and processing, the scheme of a future fusion energy plant and critical comments on a road map leading to the first industrial thermonuclear reactor. Generation and containment of high-temperature plasma As mentioned above, nuclear energy can be released not only by the fission of heavy nuclei, but also by the fusion of light nuclei into the heavier ones [3, 4]. An example of the fusion reaction is joining 4 protons into a helium nucleus. Probability of this process is very small, but it is realized through several intermediate reactions (the so-called p-p cycle) inside the Sun and many other stars. Although such fusion reactions run very slowly, due to gigantic dimensions of the Sun they deliver enough energy to keep very high temperature (about K) and to emit enormous amounts of radiation energy. It should be noted that inside very hot stars (>10 8 K) there occur other fusion reactions, e.g. 13 C + 4 He 16 O + n. The produced neutrons can then be absorbed by heavy nuclei and produce still heavier elements. Since such fusion reactions occur at very high temperatures usually in a thermodynamic equilibrium state, they are called the thermonuclear reactions. In order to master nuclear fusion, physicists have searched reactions possible in a laboratory [3 5], and it has been found that one can relatively easily realize the fusion of deuterium (D) and tritium (T) through several reactions, as shown in Fig. 2. The D-D and D-T nuclear fusion reactions can be realized by appropriate acceleration of deuterons or tritons and the irradiation of targets containing deuterium or tritium, but such processes occur without thermodynamic equilibrium. Such reactions are not thermonuclear ones, and they do not ensure a positive energy balance. From the physical point of view, the fusion reactions are possible if the interacting nuclei have energy high enough to overcome the repulsion force of their positive charges (the Coulomb barrier). This can be achieved at very high temperatures, but in such conditions the matter is in the plasma state, i.e., constitutes a mixture of free electrons and positive ions or atomic nuclei. High-temperature plasma loses energy by an intense electromagnetic emission. Weakly ionized plasma emits different spectral lines, but at higher temperatures fully-ionized plasma emits a continuous spectrum, due to the ion electron recombination and electron Bremsstrahlung. In such a state the energy distribution of electrons is often different from that of ions, but in spite of the lack of full equilibrium there are used such parameters as electron temperature (T e ) and ion temperature (T i ), usually expressed in electron-volts [ev], where 1 ev corresponds to about K. With an increase in temperature, the efficiency of nuclear fusion increases faster, and the ignition temperature is achieved when the energy released from fusion reactions is higher than the radiation losses. For pure deuterium plasma, it amounts to about 35 kev (ca K), while for a deuterium tritium mixture it is equal to about 4.5 kev (ca K). To master new energy sources, in the early 1950s, physicists in the USA performed tests of the Fig. 2. Scheme of the D-T fusion reaction (left) and other important fusion reactions (middle and right).
3 Important problems of future thermonuclear reactors so-called enriched atomic bomb, which contained 235 U and some amounts of deuterium and tritium . The first fully thermonuclear explosion, which was equivalent to 10 megaton TNT, was realized in About 10 months later, the Soviet Union performed the first thermonuclear explosion using the lithium reactions (see Fig. 2 right). For a comparison the fission of 1 kg of uranium produces energy equivalent to 20 kiloton TNT, while the fusion of 1 kg of 6 LiD can release energy of 68 kiloton TNT, and 1 kg of a D-T mixture of 80 kiloton TNT [4, 6], but such powerful explosions could not be used for industrial purposes. Therefore, simultaneously with military tests, physicists have also tried to realize controlled nuclear fusion and to construct a thermonuclear reactor. These efforts were motivated by the fact that deuterium resources in water upon the Earth are about kg, equivalent to energy of about kwh, while the present power consumption amounts to about kw. In order to achieve positive energy balance in a thermonuclear reactor based on controlled fusion reactions, high-temperature plasma must have appropriate concentration and life-time, i.e. at a lower density (n) the confinement time ( ) must be longer . This condition is determined by the so-called Lawson criterion: for the D-D fusion one must obtain n > s/cm 3, and for D-T fusion this product should be > s/cm 3. Considering the dependence on plasma temperature (T), it is more reasonable to use the so-called triple product T n E, where E is the energy confinement time depending on the losses by electromagnetic- and corpuscular-rad iation, particle diffusion, etc. To produce and heat up plasma one can use different methods. The most simple is a powerful electrical discharge between electrodes placed inside a vacuum chamber and supplied form a high-voltage condenser bank. This technique has been used in the so-called Z-pinch facilities, where plasma confinement is realized by magnetic field produced by a very intense current flowing through this plasma . The same techniques is applied in the so-called Plasma-Focus (PF) discharges which are performed between two coaxial electrodes. Although large Z-pinch devices (e.g. Z-machine in the USA) and large PF facilities (e.g. PF-1000 machine in Poland) 333 produce relatively high yields of fusion-produced neutrons (up to about per discharge) , it is not possible now to build an efficient thermonuclear reactor based on this principle. Another important method is based on the production of very dense and hot plasma from a small target (containing D-T mixture) irradiated by a very powerful laser or particle beams. Plasma produced in such a way can have a very high density (>10 23 cm 3 ) and temperature (>5 kev), and be confined by its inertial effects long enough to produce a large number of fusion reactions. Such an inertial confinement has been used in many laser plasma experiments, e.g., in the very large laser system NIF (National Ignition Facility) use was made of 192 laser beams of the total energy equal to 1.9 MJ converted into X-rays (inside a gold Hohlraum cylinder) and concentrated upon a miniature fusion target (a 2.3-mm-diam. sphere containing a D-T mixture). During about 20-ns laser pulse, this target could absorb kj from laser radiation and produce kj energy from D-T fusion reactions , but the efficiency of the whole system was very low. Therefore, in spite of very fast development of laser technology and construction of new powerful laser systems (e.g. an LMJ in France), it is impossible in the near future to build an industrial thermonuclear reactor based on the inertial confinement. The most effective method to realize controlled fusion reactions seems now to be a magnetic containment of plasma of thermonuclear parameters within the so-called tokamak , shown in Fig. 3. In such magnetic traps plasma is induced inside a quasi-toroidal vacuum chamber (like in the secondary winding of a powerful transformer) and heated up by intense (up to several tens MW) electromagnetic pulses of different frequencies (ranging from MHz to GHz) and/or intense high-energy ( kev) neutral atomic beams (NBI). Since the 50s of the previous century, many tokamaks have been constructed and investigated in different countries. The best results have been achieved with a large JET (Joint European Tokamak) facility operated in Culham, England . In 1997, using a D-T mixture in JET there was produced about 16 MW during about 2 s (i.e., there was obtained about fusion neutrons) . In the described experiments for plasma heating Fig. 3. Construction of a tokamak (left) and dimensions of different tokamaks (right).
4 334 M. J. Sadowski there were applied microwaves of 3 MW power and neutral deuterium beams of 22 MW power. This means that the positive energy balance has not been achieved, but the obtained results have became the basis for acceleration of efforts to build a new large ITER (International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor) facility . Technological requirements for thermonuclear reactors The size of a thermonuclear reactor must be relatively large and its construction very complex, as shown in Fig. 4. Fig. 4. Scheme of ITER with the main structural components marked by arrows . Fig. 5. Design of divertor modules for ITER . All the main structural components, i.e., a vacuum vessel, plasma facing parts, the so-called divertor construction, blanket modules, tritium breeding modules, toroidal- and poloidal-field coils, cryostat for superconducting windings, plasma-heating and plasma-diagnostics systems, constructional supports, external shielding and appropriate power supplies, must be designed very carefully . The main technical problems connected with the design of a vacuum vessel and plasma facing components are very high thermal and corpuscular loads. It is estimated that the plasma facing components must withstand thermal loads of the order of 1 3 MJ/m 2 during the so-called ELMs (Egde Localized Modes) instabilities lasting ms, and MJ/m 2 when a disruption of plasma discharge appears (during 1 10 ms). As regards corpuscular loads, the most important are fast fusion-produced neutrons which can induce serious degradation of the constructional materials. The first tokamaks were equipped with stainless-steel walls and had no neutron shield (blanket). The JET facility had pure carbon (graphite) internal walls, and recently it has been equipped with beryllium (Be) ITER-like walls. The ITER will have Be walls and a blanket, which will convert power of the 14-MeV neutrons into heat and tritium breeding. Another technical problem is the construction of a divertor (a bottom part of the vacuum vessel), as shown in Fig. 5. The divertor (composed of 54 assemblies, ca. 8.7 tonnes each), due to the local inversion of magnetic field lines, is designed to collect heavy impurity ions from a near-wall plasma region, and to ensure efficient vacuum pumping through special slits and external cryopumps. Because of large thermal loads (up to 20 MW/m 2 over 10 s, and 5 10 MW/m 2 over longer periods) the inner and outer divertor targets as well as its central part (dome) will be made from tungsten. Although some portion of power carried out by alpha particles (about 20% of fusion power) will be used for plasma heating, the rest power must also be extracted by the first wall. It is estimated that in ITER there will be produced 500 MW from D-T fusion, and at 40 MW delivered for auxiliary plasma heating, only about 140 MW will be consumed in Fig. 6. Scheme of an ITER port with a TMB module .
5 Important problems of future thermonuclear reactors plasma, while 400 MW (carried out by the fast neutrons) should be absorbed in a blanket. Therefore, in ITER each blanket module will be composed of a separable plasma-facing panel (covered with Be tiles) and a semi-permanent massive shielding block (total mass ca t). A difficult problem is the design of tritium breeding modules (TBM), which might use the neutron lithium reactions: 6 Li + n 4 He + 3 T MeV and 7 Li + n 4 He + T + n 2.5 MeV. For neutron multiplication, one can also use neutron beryllium reactions. Hence, different chemical compounds, e.g. PbLi, Li 2 O, Li 2 ZrO 3, Li 8 ZrO 6, Li 2 TiO 3, LiAlO 2, Li 2 SiO 3, Li 4 SiO 4, 2LiF-BeF 2 ( Flibe ), might be applied. To investigate these materials all ITER parties are now involved in the construction of TBM and three ports of ITER will be used for their testing, as shown in Fig. 6. A very difficult aim is the design and construction of large superconducting coils which should produce toroidal and poloidal components of the magnetic field as well as auxiliary control fields. An example of a large toroidal field coil is shown in Fig. 7. The whole magnetic system of ITER will be composed of 18 toroidal field coils (total weight 6540 t), 6 central solenoid modules (total weight 974 t), 6 poloidal field coils (total weight 2163 t), 9 pairs of so-called correction coils (total weight 85 t), and 31 superconducting feeders . The total length of superconducting cables (made of Nb 3 Sn or NbTi) will amount to about 190 km. In order to produce these superconducting coils large industrial facilities are under construction. It should be added that to stabilize plasma within the ITER vessel use will be made of additional in-vessel coils made of mineral-insulated cables placed inside special stainless-steel jackets. Another technical problem constitutes the construction of a large cryostat for all superconducting coils, which should have about 29 m in diameter and m in height. It must also be equipped with many ports needed for plasma heating and diagnostics. Different technical problems are also connected with the design and construction of plasma heating systems, and, in particular, with powerful microwave sources for the ion cyclotron resonance heating (ICRH, MHz, 20 MW) and electron cyclotron resonance heating (ECRH, gyrotrons 170 GHz, 20 MW). In the near future it will be necessary to solve also technical problems connected with the construction of 1-MeV neutral-beam injection (NBI, 33 MW) units, lower-hybrid heating (LH, 5 GHz, 40 MW) sources, and appropriate power supplies. Difficult technical problems are connected with the design and construction of 40 various plasma diagnostic systems, and particularly those needed for the measurements of plasma density and temperature profiles as well as emission characteristics of fusion-produced neutrons. One should also mention technical problems connected with the construction of remote handling systems needed for in-vessel operation, as shown in Fig. 8. The construction of an anti-seismic basement, designed for a tonn ITER complex, is a very difficult task, but it has already been undertaken, as shown in Fig. 9. Other technical problems are connected with the design and construction of an external Tritium Reprocessing Plant (7 floors building, L = 80 m, W = 25 m, H = 35 m), which might use existing technologies, but on a much larger scale (factor about 10). Some problems connected with large water-cooling and cryogenic plants, as well as large power-supply stations, must also be solved. In spite of many technical problems described above, as well as necessary political and financial decisions, the ITER International Fusion Energy Organisation (IIFEO) agreement was reached in December Since the inception of the FP7 (Frame Programme) and the start of the building of ITER, the EU fusion budget has risen to 1947 M of which about 900 M have been consumed by the Euratom Associations and JET. In 2014, a new Fusion Programme has been initiated, which constitutes a Fig. 7. Construction of the toroidal field coil of about 16 m in height and 9 m in width (total mass 360 t) . Fig. 8. Construction of a multi-purpose manipulator (deployer) for the remote handling in ITER .
6 336 M. J. Sadowski Fig. 9. Construction of the large basement (containing m 3 of concrete) for ITER . co-fund action for the implementation of the Roadmap on Fusion Energy Research under Horizon According to present estimates, the construction of ITER during next 30 years will consume above M. Fusion fuel supplies Fig. 11. Scheme of the large (80 m in length, 35 m in height) tritium reprocessing plant (TRP) for ITER . In order to operate a thermonuclear reactor one must deliver appropriate amounts of deuterium and tritium, e.g., a large fusion power station generating 1500 MW of electricity will consume about 400 g of deuterium and about 600 g of tritium. Power deposited by fast fusion-produced neutrons in the neutron blanket can be extracted by means of an appropriate heat exchange circuit and delivered to conventional electrical generators. Hence, one can easily image a scheme of a future thermonuclear power station, as shown in Fig. 10. It should be noted that no serious problems connected with fusion fuel supplies are expected. Pure deuterium can be obtained from electrolysis of heavy water (D 2 O), which can relatively easily be separated from ordinary water, or from isotopic exchange in a hydrogen-sulphate gas. The separation of hydrogen isotopes can also be done by means of gas chromatography or cryogenic distillation. Since deuterium constitutes approximately 0.015% of hydrogen content in water, there is enough deuterium to produce energy for consumption for billion of years. In contrary, tritium (due to its radioactive decay, with a half lifetime equal to 12.3 years) cannot be stored in big amounts and for a long time, but it can be obtained from tritium breeding modules described above. It is estimated that for 400 s operation of ITER one will need an input of 54 g of tritium, and if 1 g of that is burnt the rest should be extracted through tritium breeding modules (TBM) and the external tritium reprocessing plant (TRP) described above. It should here be noted that a safety limit for in-vessel retention of tritium in ITER will amount to about 700 g only. Therefore, special techniques for deuterium and tritium removal from ITER internal components are now under development, e.g., laser cleaning of plasma-facing materials. It should here be noted that taking into account the present costs, it is estimated that the fusion fuel will contribute much less than 1% of the cost of electricity. Other elements, which are needed for the fusion fuel cycle, can be found in various minerals. In particular, lithium necessary for the tritium breeding can be extracted from several minerals and from clays. Its natural deposits are particularly found in South America. The Earth s crust contains enough lithium for thousands of years, and the world seas also contain a huge supply of lithium. The main problem is only the construction of efficient TBM and a safe TRP, but they might be built on the basis of the existing technology, although on a much larger scale, as shown in Fig. 11. Next generation of thermonuclear reactors Fig. 10. Scheme of a future electric power plant based on the toroidal magnetic trap of the tokamak type . The main aim of ITER, now under construction in Cadarache, France, is to produce a significant fusion power (about 500 MW), at the amplification factor Q = 10, during long (15 30 min) pulse operation. The second aim will be obtaining a steady state operation with Q = 5, and to test the possibility to achieve controlled fusion with higher Q values (e.g. >30). The whole ITER complex will be not a thermonuclear power station, but a large experiment aiming to test technical components needed for a future
7 Important problems of future thermonuclear reactors fusion power plant (e.g. different tritium breeding modules) and to demonstrate the integrated operation of technologies for an industrial thermonuclear reactor. Acco rding to the present plans and funding, the ITER construction should be completed within a few years and after different operational tests (e.g. low-duty D-T operation, high-duty D-T operation etc.) the main operation phase should be initiated about A very important issue is the behaviour of first- -wall materials, which should have a high thermal conductivity, high resistance to thermal shocks, high stability under neutron irradiation, low chemical erosion, oxygen remnants gettering (if possible), low affinity to deuterium and tritium towards formation of volatile products, and a low sorption of hydrogen isotopes. Therefore, particular attention must be paid to the investigation of different constructional materials. For this purpose, simultaneously with the ITER construction there are planned special facilities for material engineering studies, e.g. the International Fusion Material Irradiation Facility (IFMIF), which (using powerful deuteron accelerators and stripping reactions in a thick lithium target) might produce a very intense neutron flux (of the order of n/s m 2 ) . The construction of IFMIF should be started simultaneously with the ITER construction, but because of a lack of funds this programme is delayed. Nevertheless, extensive material studies are carried out within different fusion laboratories. In order to demonstrate the first commercial thermonuclear fusion reactor, extensive conceptual studies have already been undertaken. The main 337 aim is to design and construct the so-called DEMO reactor with an output of electrical power of 1 GW . Since the engineering design of DEMO has already been started, if the R&D research is finished until 2030 and appropriate political and financial decisions are undertaken in proper time, then the DEMO might be constructed before The next step (in about 40 years) might be the design and construction of a commercial fusion reactor of the 2nd generation (Fusion Reactor type 2) . Hence, the development of thermonuclear reactors can be presented in a diagram shown in Fig. 12. Summary and conclusions This paper can be summarized as follows: 1. The world population is growing, fossil fuels are running out and the rise of CO 2 concentration in the atmosphere threatens our climate. Hence, alternative CO 2 -free energy sources must be exploited, but taking into account limitations of green energy sources (hydro-energy, wind and solar installations, etc.) as well as disadvantages of conventional nuclear reactors based on fission reactions, the only way is to develop thermonuclear reactors based nuclear fusion reactions of hydrogen isotopes; 2. The most prospective seems now to be the construction of a thermonuclear reactor on the basis of a tokamak- -type magnetic trap; 3. The construction of the large ITER complex has already been started and this large physical and technological experiment is expected to produce 10 times more energy than needed for Fig. 12. History and plans for thermonuclear reactors in the coming years .
8 338 M. J. Sadowski plasma heating during operation pulses lasting minutes; 4. After exploitation of ITER, the next steps should be the construction of the first commercial thermonuclear reactor DEMO, and subsequently the building of fusion-based reactors of the second generation (in the next years). Acknowledgments. The elaboration of this paper was partly supported by the National Centre for Research and Development (NCBR) under contract no. SP/J/2/ The views and opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of the ITER Organization. References 1. Ongena, J. (2014). How to shape our future energy supply. In Proceedings of 12th Kudowa Summer School Towards Fusion Energy, 9 13 June 2014, Kudowa Zdroj, Poland (p. IL-1). Warsaw: IPPLM. CD Issue. 2. Culham Centre for Fusion Energy, ac.uk. 3. Conn, R. W., Chuyanov, V. A., Inoue, N., & Sweetman, D. R. (1992). The International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor. Sci. Am., 266(4), DOI: /scientificamerican Sadowski, M. J. (2005). Nuclear fusion energy for future. Nukleonika, 50(Suppl. 3), S41 S Vandenplas, P. E. (1980). Reflections on the past and future of fusion and plasma physics research. Plasma Phys. Contr. Fusion, 40, Rhodes, R. (1995). Dark Sun; The making of the hydrogen bomb. New York: Simon & Schuster. 7. Sadowski, M. J., & Scholz, M. (2012). Important issues of high-current plasma experiments of the Z-pinch type. Nukleonika, 57(1), Hurricane, O. A., Callahan, D. A., Casey, D. T., Celliers, P. M., Cerjan, C., Dewald, E. L., Dittrich, T. R., Döppner, T., Hinkel, D. E., Berzak Hopkins, L. F., Kline, J. L., Le Pape, S., Ma, T., MacPhee, A. G., Milovich, J. L., Pak, A., Park, H. -S., Patel, P. K., Remington, B. A., Salmonson, J. D., Springer, P. T., & Tomassini, R. (2014). Fuel gain exceeding unity in an inertially confined fusion implosion. Nature, 506, DOI: /nature Todd, T. N. (2012). The engineering design of ITER. In Proceedings of 11th Kudowa Summer School Towards Fusion Energy, June 2012, Kudowa Zdroj, Poland. (p. IL-6), Warsaw: IPPLM. CD Issue. 12. Pinches, S. D. (2014). Physics challenges and status of ITER. In Proceedings of 12th Kudowa Summer School Towards Fusion Energy, 9 13 June 2014, Kudowa Zdroj, Poland. (p. IL-6). Warsaw: IPPLM. CD Issue. 13. Garin, P., & Sugimoto, M. (2011). IFMIF s new design; Status after 2 years of the EVEDA project. J. Nucl. Mater., 417(1/3), DOI: /j. jnucmat Todd, T. N. (2014). The technical challenges of DEMO. In Proceedings of 12th Kudowa Summer School Towards Fusion Energy, 9 13 June 2014, Kudowa Zdroj, Poland. (p. IL-15). Warsaw: IPPLM. CD Issue.
The Path to Fusion Energy creating a star on earth S. Prager Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory The need for fusion energy is strong and enduring Carbon production (Gton) And the need is time urgent Goal
Chalmers energy conference 2012 Magnetic Confinement Fusion-Status and Challenges F. Wagner Max-Planck-Institute for Plasma Physics, Greifswald Germany, EURATOM Association RLPAT St. Petersburg Polytechnic
JET and Fusion Energy for the Next Millennia JET Joint Undertaking Abingdon, Oxfordshire OX14 3EA JG99.294/1 Talk Outline What is Nuclear Fusion? How can Fusion help our Energy needs? Progress with Magnetic
Role and Challenges of Fusion Nuclear Science and Technology (FNST) toward DEMO Mohamed Abdou Distinguished Professor of Engineering and Applied Science (UCLA) Director, Center for Energy Science & Technology
Host: Fusion specialist: Jacob s Ladder Controlling Lightning PART 1 Jacob s ladder demonstration Video Teacher resources Phil Dooley European Fusion Development Agreement Peter de Vries European Fusion
Perspective on Fusion Energy Mohamed Abdou Distinguished Professor of Engineering and Applied Science (UCLA) Director, Center for Energy Science & Technology (UCLA) President, Council of Energy Research
The Sun Magnetic Confinement Fusion and Tokamaks Chijin Xiao Department of Physics and Engineering Physics University of Saskatchewan 2017 CNS Conference Niagara Falls, June 4-7, 2017 Tokamak Outline Fusion
Nuclear Fusion and ITER C. Alejaldre ITER Deputy Director-General Cursos de Verano UPM Julio 2, 2007 1 ITER the way to fusion power ITER ( the way in Latin) is the essential next step in the development
EFDA LEAD ING DEVICE FOR FUSION STUDIES HOLDER OF THE WORLD RECORD OF FUSION POWER PRODUCTION EXPERIMENTS STRONGLY FOCUSSED ON THE PREPARATION FOR ITER EXPERIMENTAL DEVICE USED UNDER THE EUROPEAN FUSION
Neutronic Activation Analysis for ITER Fusion Reactor Barbara Caiffi 100 Congresso Nazionale SIF 1 Outlook Nuclear Fusion International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) Neutronics Computational
Introduction to Fusion Physics Hartmut Zohm Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik 85748 Garching DPG Advanced Physics School The Physics of ITER Bad Honnef, 22.09.2014 Energy from nuclear fusion Reduction
An introduction to Nuclear Physics Jorge Pereira firstname.lastname@example.org National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory Joint Institute for Nuclear Astrophysics The Origin of Everything Layout The Nucleus.
Lecture 14, 8/9/2017 Nuclear Reactions and the Transmutation of Elements Nuclear Fission; Nuclear Reactors Nuclear Fusion Nuclear Reactions and the Transmutation of Elements A nuclear reaction takes place
Tokamak Divertor System Concept and the Design for ITER Chris Stoafer April 14, 2011 Presentation Overview Divertor concept and purpose Divertor physics General design considerations Overview of ITER divertor
Nuclear Energy in the Future The ITER Project Brad Nelson Chief Engineer, US ITER Presentation for NE-50 Symposium on the Future of Nuclear Energy November 1, 2012 Fusion research is ready for the next
Innovative fabrication method of superconducting magnets using high T c superconductors with joints (for huge and/or complicated coils) Nagato YANAGI LHD & FFHR Group National Institute for Fusion Science,
Control of the fission chain reaction Introduction to Nuclear Science Simon Fraser University Spring 2011 NUCS 342 April 8, 2011 NUCS 342 (Lecture 30) April 8, 2011 1 / 29 Outline 1 Fission chain reaction
β and γ decays, Radiation Therapies and Diagnostic, Fusion and Fission Last Lecture: Radioactivity, Nuclear decay Radiation damage This lecture: nuclear physics in medicine and fusion and fission Final
1 Nuclear Energy Learning Outcomes Describe the principles underlying fission and fusion. Interpret nuclear reactions. Discuss nuclear weapons. Describe the structure and operation of a nuclear reactor.
by fastfission public domain by fastfission public domain 1 Nuclear Energy Learning Outcomes Describe the principles underlying fission and fusion. Interpret nuclear reactions. Discuss nuclear weapons.
Aspects of Advanced Fuel FRC Fusion Reactors John F Santarius and Gerald L Kulcinski Fusion Technology Institute Engineering Physics Department CT2016 Irvine, California August 22-24, 2016 email@example.com;
A SUPERCONDUCTING TOKAMAK FUSION TRANSMUTATION OF WASTE REACTOR A.N. Mauer, W.M. Stacey, J. Mandrekas and E.A. Hoffman Fusion Research Center Georgia Institute of Technology Atlanta, GA 30332 1. INTRODUCTION
Fusion Principles Jef ONGENA Plasma Physics Laboratory Royal Military Academy Brussels 4 th SIF-EPS International School on Energy Villa Monastero Varenna, Lago di Como 25 July 2017 Outline Fusion reactions
THE HENRYK NIEWODNICZAŃSKI INSTITUTE OF NUCLEAR PHYSICS POLISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES PLASMA-FOCUS AND CONTROLLED NUCLEAR FUSION Marek Scholz PLASMA-FOCUS and controlled nuclear fusion Marek Scholz Translation
Recent Development of LHD Experiment O.Motojima for the LHD team National Institute for Fusion Science 4521 1 Primary goal of LHD project 1. Transport studies in sufficiently high n E T regime relevant
Laser in Fusion Department of Electronics of TEI of Crete Dr Petridis Kostantinos Lecturer Optoelectronics, Laser and Plasma Technologies Group Nuclear Fusion Since we have tried any energy source in our
Fusion: The Ultimate Energy Source for the 21 st Century and Beyond Mohamed Abdou Distinguished Professor of Engineering and Applied Science (UCLA) Director, Center for Energy Science & Technology (UCLA)
The enryk Niewodniczański INSTITUTE F NULEAR PYSIS Polish Academy of Sciences ul. Radzikowskiego 152, 31-342 Kraków, Poland www.ifj.edu.pl/publ/reports/2016/ Kraków, April 2016 Report No. 2091/AP Monte
Lecture PowerPoints Chapter 31 Physics: Principles with Applications, 7th edition Giancoli This work is protected by United States copyright laws and is provided solely for the use of instructors in teaching
WELCOME TO PERIOD 18: CONSEQUENCES OF NUCLEAR ENERGY Homework #17 is due today. Midterm 2: Weds, Mar 27, 7:45 8:55 pm (Same room as your midterm 1 exam.) Covers periods 10 19 and videos 3 & 4 Review: Tues,
Nuclear Energy ECEG-4405 Today s Discussion Technical History and Developments Atom Nuclear Energy concepts and Terms Features Fission Critical Mass Uranium Fission Nuclear Fusion and Fission Fusion Fission
Tritium Safety of Russian Test Blanket Module V.K. Kapyshev, V.G. Kovalenko, Y.S. Strebkov N.A. Dollezhal Research and Development Institute of Power Engineering, PO Box 788, Moscow 101000, Russia Abstract
The Physics of Nuclear Reactors Heather King Physics 420 Nuclear Reactions A nuclear reaction is a reaction that involves atomic nuclei, or nuclear particles (protons, neutrons), producing products different
The Atomic Nucleus & Radioactive Decay ( Chapter 10) Student Learning Outcomes Analyze radioactive decay and its results Differentiate between nuclear fission and fusion Major Constituents of an Atom U=unified
L 38 Modern Physics  Nuclear physics what s s inside the nucleus and what holds it together what is radioactivity, halflife carbon dating Nuclear energy nuclear fission nuclear fusion nuclear reactors
Nuclear Chemistry Chapter 24 Radioactivity Radioisotopes are isotopes that have an unstable nucleus. They emit radiation to attain more stable atomic configurations in a process called radioactive decay.
The release of atomic energy has not created a new problem. It has merely made more urgent the necessity of solving an existing one. -Albert Einstein David J. Starling Penn State Hazleton PHYS 214 Ernest
Chapter 12 Magnetic Fusion Toroidal Machines: Principles, results, perspective S. Atzeni May 10, 2010; rev.: May 16, 2012 English version: May 17, 2017 1 Magnetic confinement fusion plasmas low density
L 38 Modern Physics  Nuclear physics what s inside the nucleus and what holds it together what is radioactivity, halflife carbon dating Nuclear energy nuclear fission nuclear fusion nuclear reactors
Which Superconducting Magnets for DEMO and Future Fusion Reactors? Reinhard Heller Inspired by Jean Luc Duchateau (CEA) INSTITUTE FOR TECHNICAL PHYSICS, FUSION MAGNETS KIT University of the State of Baden-Wuerttemberg
Radioactivity, Spontaneous Decay: Nuclear Reactions A Z 4 P D+ He + Q A 4 Z 2 Q > 0 Nuclear Reaction, Induced Process: x + X Y + y + Q Q = ( m + m m m ) c 2 x X Y y Q > 0 Q < 0 Exothermic Endothermic 2
Overview of Pilot Plant Studies and contributions to FNST Jon Menard, Rich Hawryluk, Hutch Neilson, Stewart Prager, Mike Zarnstorff Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory Fusion Nuclear Science and Technology
Q1. What is the diameter of a proton? m Q2. What is the extent of the visible universe? m Q3. What is the mass of an electron? kg Q4. What is the mass of the universe? kg Q5. How long does light take to
Japan-US Workshop on Fusion Power Plants and Related Advanced Technologies February 26-28, 2013 at Kyoto University in Uji, JAPAN Conceptual Design of CFETR Tokamak Machine Yuntao Song for CFETR Design
Matter, Models and Density What is a typical size of an atom? Choose from the following. 10 15 m 10 12 m 10 10 m Matter, Models and Density The size of an atom is of the order of 10 10 m. 1 1 Temperature
M13/4/PHYSI/HPM/ENG/TZ1/XX 22136507 Physics Higher level Paper 1 Monday 6 May 2013 (morning) 1 hour INSTRUCTIONS TO CANDIDATES Do not open this examination paper until instructed to do so. Answer all the
Radioactivity: the process by which atoms emit energy in the form of electromagnetic waves, charged particles, or uncharged particles. In 1896, Henri Bequerel discovered that uranium and other elements
Chemical Engineering 412 Introductory Nuclear Engineering Lecture 21 Other Nuclear Power Systems +Fusion Spiritual Thought 2 Thermoelectric Generators Low-efficiency (5-10%) and high cost conversion of
Alfred Nobel Symposium Energy in Cosmos, Molecules and Life Whatever became of Nuclear Fusion? Robert Aymar 18-22 June 2005 Stockholm Table of Contents Whatever became of Nuclear Fusion? Introduction Nuclear
Design window analysis of LHD-type Heliotron DEMO reactors Fusion System Research Division, Department of Helical Plasma Research, National Institute for Fusion Science Takuya GOTO, Junichi MIYAZAWA, Teruya
NUCLEAR ENERGY! DAY 1: (RADIATION, FISSION, FUSION) Nucleus Stability Stability of the nucleus depends on the nuclear forces that act between protons and neutrons Protons repel each other Protons attract
Tritium Transport Modelling: first achievements on ITER Test Blanket Systems simulation and perspectives for DEMO Breeding Blanket I. Ricapito 1), P. Calderoni 1), A. Ibarra 2), C. Moreno 2), Y. Poitevin
7.1 Atomic Theory and Radioactive Decay Natural background radiation exists all around us. Radioactivity is the release of high energy particles or waves When atoms lose high energy particles and waves,
12 Moderator And Moderator System 12.1 Introduction Nuclear fuel produces heat by fission. In the fission process, fissile atoms split after absorbing slow neutrons. This releases fast neutrons and generates
Inertial Confinement Fusion Experiments & Modeling Using X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy of Thin Tracer Layers to Diagnose the Time-Dependent Properties of ICF Ablator Materials David Cohen (Swarthmore College,
AP Physics 2 Questions 1. What particles make up the nucleus? What is the general term for them? What are those particles composed of? 2. What is the definition of the atomic number? What is its symbol?
L 36 Atomic and Nuclear Physics- Nuclear physics what s inside the nucleus and what holds it together what is radioactivity, half-life carbon dating Nuclear energy nuclear fission nuclear fusion nuclear
ITER - the decisive step towards Fusion Energy DPG Bonn March 15 th 2010 Guenter Janeschitz Senior Scientific Advisor for Technical Integration (SSATI) to the PDDG ITER Organization, Route de Vinon, CS
Modern Physics Study Questions for the Spring 2018 Departmental Exam December 3, 2017 1. An electron is initially at rest in a uniform electric field E in the negative y direction and a uniform magnetic
D- He HA tokamak device for experiments and power generations US-Japan Fusion Power Plant Studies Contents University of Tokyo, Japan January -, 5 O.Mitarai (Kyushu Tokai University).Motivation.Formalism,
Solar Fusion After Steele Hill, SOHO by Michael Gallagher for the BDAS Astronomy Course 28 th April 2006 Sources Books Michael Zeilic, Astronomy, the Evolving Universe, 5 th Edition, John Wiley, 1988 Simon
9:006 FINAL EXAM The final exam is on Monday MAY 7:30 AM - 9:30 AM in W90 CB The FE is not cumulative, and will cover lectures 3 through 36. (50 questions) The last regular lecture (Lec. 36) will be given
Chemistry: The Central Science Chapter 21: Nuclear Chemistry A nuclear reaction involves changes in the nucleus of an atom Nuclear chemistry the study of nuclear reactions, with an emphasis in their uses
Nuclear Chemistry Isotopes An isotope is an atoms of the same element (same number of protons) that vary in the number of neutrons. Most elements have several isotopes Some are unstable and emit radiation
(a) (i) 238 92 U + 0 n 239 92 U (ii) β particle(s) Electron antineutrinos (b) For: Natural uranium is 98% uranium-238 which would be otherwise unused. Plutonium-239 would not need to be stored long-term
Adaptation of Pb-Bi Cooled, Metal Fuel Subcritical Reactor for Use with a Tokamak Fusion Neutron Source E. Hoffman, W. Stacey, G. Kessler, D. Ulevich, J. Mandrekas, A. Mauer, C. Kirby, D. Stopp, J. Noble
Nuclear Chemistry Table of Contents Section 1 What Is Radioactivity? Section 2 Nuclear Fission and Fusion Section 3 Nuclear Radiation Today Section 1 What Is Radioactivity? Bellringer Before studying about
PERSPECTIVE Nuclear fusion as a massive, clean, and inexhaustible energy source for the second half of the century: brief history, status, and perspective Joaquin Sanchez Laboratorio Nacional de Fusion,
Nuclear fission and nuclear fusion 1. Four different processes are described in List A. The names of these processes are given in List B. Draw a line to link each description in List A to its correct name
Radiation Shielding for Fusion Reactors R. T. Santoro Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oak Ridge, TN 37831-6363 USA Radiation shielding requirements for fusion reactors present different problems than those
CLASS 3. NUCLEAR BINDING ENERGY 3.. INTRODUCTION Scientists found that hitting atoms with alpha particles could induce transformations in light elements. (Recall that the capture of an alpha particle by
Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology ISSN: 0022-3131 (Print) 1881-1248 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tnst20 Evolution of the ITER program and prospect for the next-step
Radioactivity In 1896 Henri Becquerel on developing some photographic plates he found that the uranium emitted radiation. Becquerel had discovered radioactivity. Models of the Atom Ernest Rutherford, A
: Nuclear Radiation Today Preview Key Ideas Bellringer Where is Radiation? Beneficial Uses of Nuclear Radiation Risks of Nuclear Radiation Nuclear Power Key Ideas Where are we exposed to radiation? What
Accelerator-Based Neutron Generator to Drive Sub-Critical Isotope Production Systems Ross Radel, PhD President, Phoenix Nuclear Labs PNL Introduction Development stage company in Madison, WI with ~35 employees
1. An electron has a mass of 9.11 x 10-31 kg and its charge is -1.6 x 10-19 C. The electron is released from rest in a vacuum between two flat, parallel metal plates that are 10 cm apart. The potential
Neutron Transport Calculations Using Monte-Carlo Methods Sean Lourette Fairport High School Advisor: Christian Stoeckl Laboratory for Laser Energetics University of Rochester Summer High School Research
Neutron and gamma ray measurements for fusion experiments and spallation sources Carlo Cazzaniga prof.ssa Claudia Riccardi 1 External supervisor: dr. Marco Tardocchi Supervisor: 1) Istituto di Fisica del
Ch. 10 - Radioactivity Henry Becquerel, using U-238, discovered the radioactive nature of elements in 1896. Radioactivity the process in which an unstable atomic nucleus emits charged particles and energy
Atoms and Nuclei. State two limitations of JJ Thomson s model of atom. 2. Write the SI unit for activity of a radioactive substance. 3. What observations led JJ Thomson to conclusion that all atoms have
Exam #2 Review Sheet Part #1 Clicker Questions 1) The energy of a photon emitted by thermonuclear processes in the core of the Sun takes thousands or even millions of years to emerge from the surface because
Astronomy 182: Origin and Evolution of the Universe Prof. Josh Frieman Lecture 11 Nov. 13, 2015 Today Cosmic Microwave Background Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Assignments This week: read Hawley and Holcomb,
1 Inner Transition Metals Inner Transition Metals Inner Transition Metals The inner transition metals are found in the f-block, usually put at the bottom of the Periodic Table. These elements were sometimes