Prediction of National Airport Pavement Test Facility Pavement Layer Moduli from Heavy Weight Deflectometer Test Data Using Artificial Neural Networks
|
|
- Edmund Mathews
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Prediction of ational Airport Pavement Test Facility Pavement Layer Moduli from Heavy Weight Deflectometer Test Data Using Artificial eural etworks Kasthurirangan Gopalakrishnan Department of Civil, Construction and Environmental Engineering Iowa State University 192 Town Engineering Building Ames, IA 511 ABSTRACT The ational Airport Pavement Test Facility (APTF) was constructed to generate full-scale testing data to investigate the performance of airport pavements subjected to complex gear loading configurations of new generation aircraft. During the first test program, the APTF test sections were simultaneously subjected to Boeing 777 trafficking in one lane and Boeing 747 trafficking in another lane using the ational Airport Pavement Test Machine. To monitor the effect of time and traffic on pavement structural responses, heavy weight deflectometer (HWD) tests were conducted on the trafficked lanes and the untrafficked centerline of flexible test sections as trafficking progressed. The primary objective of this study was to develop a tool for backcalculating APTF non-linear flexible pavement layer moduli from HWD data using artificial neural networks (A). A multi-layer, feedforward network that uses an error-backpropagation algorithm was trained to approximate the HWD backcalculation function. The synthetic database generated using the non-linear pavement finite element program, ILLI-PAVE, was used to train the A. Using the A, the asphalt concrete moduli and subgrade moduli were successfully predicted. Further research is required to develop A models for predicting the granular layer moduli. These results could be used to compare the relative effect of Boeing 777 and Boeing 747 trafficking on the elastic moduli and characterize the seasonal variation in moduli values. The same concept could also be used for backcalculating non-linear pavement moduli of highway pavements for input into mechanistic-empirical analysis and design. Key words: artificial neural networks ILLI-PAVE ational Airport Pavement Test Facility pavement moduli Proceedings of the 25 Mid-Continent Transportation Research Symposium, Ames, Iowa, August by Iowa State University. The contents of this paper reflect the views of the author(s), who are responsible for the facts and accuracy of the information presented herein.
2 ITRODUCTIO The Federal Aviation Administration s (FAA) ational Airport Pavement Test Facility (APTF) is located at the Atlantic City International Airport, ew Jersey. It was constructed to generate full-scale test data needed to develop pavement design procedures for the new generation of large civil transport aircraft, including the Boeing 777 and Boeing 747. During the first series of tests, two gear configurations, a six-wheel tridem landing gear (Boeing 777) in one lane and a four-wheel dual-tandem landing gear (Boeing 747) in the other lane, were tested simultaneously. Heavy weight deflectometer (HWD) tests were conducted at regular time intervals as trafficking continued. The primary objective of this study was to develop a tool for backcalculating APTF non-linear pavement layer moduli from HWD test data using artificial neural networks (A). The elastic layer moduli backcalculated from non-destructive test results are good indicators of pavement layer condition (Xu, Ranjinathan, and Kim 21) as well as required inputs for the a priori mechanistic design of a flexible pavement. The backcalculation approach is particularly appealing for characterizing subgrade soils that display large variability in subgrade modulus (as large as 35% 5% over few miles of a pavement) (Thompson, Tutumluer, and Bejarano 1998). Conventional elastic layer program (ELP)-based backcalculation software assumes that pavement materials are linear-elastic, homogenous, and isotropic. The non-linearity or stress-dependency of resilient modulus for unbound granular materials and cohesive fine-grained subgrade soils is well documented in the literature (Hicks 197; Thompson and Robnett 1979). Previous studies have observed the nonlinearity of underlying layers at the APTF. Gomez-Ramirez and Thompson (Garg and Marsey 22) reported the presence of material non-linearity at APTF by separately analyzing the individual layer compression from multi-depth deflectometer (MDD) readings. Garg and Marsey (22) have similarly observed the stress-dependent nature of the granular and subgrade layers in APTF flexible test sections. Therefore, it is more realistic to use non-linear layer moduli for conducting APTF pavement structural analysis and for studying the variation in moduli with trafficking. ILLI-PAVE is a two-dimensional axi-symmetric pavement finite-element software developed at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC) (Raad and Figueroa 198). It incorporates stresssensitive material models and provides a more realistic representation of the pavement structure and its response to loading (CHRP 199). Based on extensive repeated laboratory testing data at UIUC, Thompson and Robnett (1979) indicated that the breakpoint resilient modulus (E Ri ), typically associated with a repeated deviator stress of about six psi, is a good indicator of the subgrade soil s resilient modulus. The Asphalt Institute s Thickness Design Manual MS-1 (Asphalt Institute 1982) recommends E Ri (subgrade modulus at a deviator stress of six psi) as the subgrade modulus input for ELP analysis. The E Ri is also one of the subgrade material property inputs to ILLI-PAVE. However, there is no commercial ILLI-PAVE-based backcalculation program currently available. Previous research at UIUC showed that the asphalt concrete moduli and non-linear subgrade moduli (E Ri ) could be successfully predicted using an A trained with the ILLI-PAVE database (Gopalakrishnan and Thompson 24). Ceylan et al. (24) demonstrated the use of As trained with ILLI-PAVE results as pavement structural analysis tools for the rapid and accurate prediction of critical responses and deflection profiles of flexible pavements subjected to typical highway loadings. Ongoing research at Iowa State University on backcalculting pavement moduli using A is being performed under Dr. Halil Ceylan s supervision. However, the current research specifically focuses on developing a tool for backcalculating APTF pavement nonlinear moduli using A trained with ILLI-PAVE results. Gopalakrishnan 2
3 ATIOAL AIRPORT PAVEMET TEST FACILITY The APTF test pavement area is 9 feet (274.3 meters) long and 6 feet (18.3 meters) wide. The first test series installation included a total of nine test sections (six flexible and three rigid) built on three different subgrade materials: low-strength (target CBR of 4), medium-strength (target CBR of 8), and high-strength (target CBR of 2). Two different base sections are used in flexible test sections: conventional (granular) and stabilized (asphalt concrete). The low-strength and the medium-strength flexible test sections alone are considered in this study. The naturally occurring sandy soil material at the APTF site underlies each subgrade layer. Pavement Sections Each APTF test section is identified using a three-character code, where the first character indicates the subgrade strength (L for low, M for medium, and H for high), the second character indicates the test pavement type (F for flexible and R for rigid), and the third character signifies whether the base material is conventional-aggregate (C) or asphalt-stabilized (S). Thus, test section refers to a conventionalbase flexible pavement built over a medium strength subgrade, whereas test section refers to a stabilized-base flexible pavement built over a medium-strength subgrade. Cross-sectional views of the asbuilt APTF flexible test items considered in this study are shown in Figure 1. ote that P-41 asphalt concrete was used in the surface layer and in the stabilized base layer as well. AC Surface (P-41) 5 in. AC Surface (P-41) 5 in. AC Surface (P-41) 5.1 in. AC Surface (P-41) 5 in. Granular Base (P-29) 7. in. Asphalt Stab. Base (P-41) 4.9 in. Granular Base (P-29) 7.9 in. Asphalt Stab. Base (P-41) 4.9 in. Granular Subbase (P-4) 36.4 in. Granular Subbase (P-29) 29.6 in. Granular Subbase (P-4).1 in. Granular Subbase (P-29) 8.5 in. LOW Strength Subgrade LOW Strength Subgrade MEDIUM Strength Subgrade MEDIUM Strength Subgrade Subgrade=94.7 in. Subgrade=.5 in. Subgrade=94.8 in. Subgrade=11.6 in. Traffic Testing Figure 1. Cross-sectional views of as-built APTF flexible test sections A six-wheel dual-tridem gear configuration (Boeing 777) with 54-inch (1,372-mm) dual spacing and 57- inch (1,448-mm) tandem spacing was loaded on the north wheel track, while the south side was loaded with a four-wheel dual-tandem gear configuration (Boeing 747) having 44-inch (1,118-mm) dual spacing and 58-inch (1,473-mm) tandem spacing. The wheel loads were set to, lbs (2.4 tons) each and the tire pressure (cold) was 188 psi (1,295 Kpa). In the (a conventional aggregate-base pavement built over low-strength subgrade) and (an asphalt-stabilized base pavement built over low-strength subgrade) test sections, the wheel loads were increased from, lbs (2.4 tons) to, lbs (29.4 tons) after 2, initial load repetitions. Throughout the traffic test program, the traffic speed was 5 mph (8 kmh). Gopalakrishnan 3
4 APTF Flexible Pavement Failure Criterion The APTF failure criterion is based on the criterion utilized by the U.S. COE MWHGL Tests (Ahlvin et al. 1971). It is defined as 1-inch (25.4-mm) surface upheaval adjacent to the traffic lane. This is considered to reflect a structural or shearing failure in the subgrade. Data Availability All test data referenced in this paper are available for download on the FAA Airport Pavement Technology website: HEAVY WEIGHT DEFLECTOMETER TESTS For HWD testing, the FAA HWD KUAB Model 24, configured with a -inch loading plate and a 27 3 msec pulse width, was used. The deflections were measured with seven seismometers at offsets of - inch (D ), -inch (35-mm) (D ), 24-inch (61-mm) (D 24 ), 36-inch (9-mm) (D 36 ), 48-inches (1,219- mm) (D 48 ), and 6-inch (1,524-mm) (D 6 ) intervals from the center of the load. The HWD tests were performed at nominal force amplitudes of, lbs or kip (53.4 k), 24, lbs or 24 kip (.8 k), and 36, lbs or 36 kip (.2 k). These tests were performed on the centerline, Boeing 777 traffic lane (Lane 2) and Boeing 747 traffic lane (Lane 5). The HWD test sequences were repeated at 1-foot (3.1-meter) intervals along the test lanes. The location and orientation of HWD test lanes are illustrated in Figure ft. - ft. B777 LAE 2 ft. C/L ft. B747 LAE 5 3 ft. Figure 2. APTF HWD test lanes Pavement Temperature The temperature of the asphalt concrete layer at the time of FWD testing has a significant influence on the surface deflections. During the APTF construction, static temperature sensors were installed at different depths along the test sections to record the pavement temperatures at different times of the day. The HWD Gopalakrishnan 4
5 tests were all conducted between January 11, 2 and June 6, 21. The asphalt concrete temperature varied between 4 F to F during the entire duration of traffic testing. DATABASE GEERATIO USIG ILLI-PAVE To generate the synthetic database for training the A, each APTF flexible test section was modeled in ILLI-PAVE. The as-constructed layer thicknesses (see Figure 1) were used for each test section. The individual pavement layers were characterized as follows. The asphalt concrete layer and the sand layer were treated as linear elastic material. Stress-dependent elastic models along with Mohr-Coulomb failure criteria were applied for the base, subbase, and subgrade layers. The stress-hardening K-θ model was used for the base and subbase layers: M R σ = ε = D n Kθ (1) R Where M R is resilient modulus (psi), θ is bulk stress (psi), and K and n are statistical parameters. The following relationship exists between K and n (R 2 =.68, SEE =.22) (Rada and Witczak 1981): Log 1 (K) = n (2) The stress-softening bilinear model was used for the subgrade layer: M M R R = M = M Ri Ri + K.( σ σ ) + K.( σ σ ) 1 d di d di (3) 2 d di for σ for σ d < σ > σ di Where M R is resilient modulus (psi), σ d is applied deviator stress (psi), and K 1 and K 2 are statistically determined coefficients from laboratory tests. A total of 5, input cases were generated for each test section by randomly varying the asphalt concrete and subgrade layer moduli and the K b - n b and K s - n s values (note that K and n are related) for the base and subbase layers, respectively. The effect of 36-kip HWD loading was simulated in ILLI-PAVE and the pavement surface deflections were computed. Initially, it was decided to use separate A models for each section. Of the total number of data sets for each test section, 3, data vectors were used in training the A and the remaining 1,25 data vectors were used to test the network after the training was completed. The range of layer properties used in training the A is summarized in Table 1. ARTIFICIAL EURAL ETWORK ARCHITECTURE A generalized n-layer feedforward A that uses an error-backpropogation algorithm (Haykin 1994) was implemented in the Visual Basic (VB 6.) programming language. The program can allow for a general number of inputs, hidden layers, hidden layer elements, and output layer elements. Two hidden layers were found to be sufficient for solving a problem of this size, and therefore the architecture was reduced to a four-layer feedforward network. A four-layer feedforward network consists of a set of sensory units (source nodes) that constitute the input layer, two hidden layers of computation nodes, and an output layer of computation nodes. The following notation is generally used to refer to a particular type of architecture that has two hidden layers: (# inputs)-(# hidden neurons)-(# hidden neurons)-(# outputs). For example, the notation refers to an A architecture that takes in 1 inputs (features), has 2 hidden layers consisting of 4 neurons each, and produces 3 outputs. Gopalakrishnan 5
6 Table 1. Range of pavement layer properties used in generating the A training database Pavement layer Thickness (inches) Elastic layer modulus (ksi) Poisson s ratio Asphalt concrete Base Subbase Subgrade Sand 5 - & 1 - & 8 - & & - & - Medium 4 - Low 1 2,5.35 K b : n b : K s : n s : An A-based backcalculation procedure was developed to approximate the HWD backcalculation function. Using the ILLI-PAVE synthetic database, the A was trained to learn the relationship between the synthetic deflection basins (inputs) and the pavement layer moduli (outputs). Initialization of Weights The first step in back-propogation learning is to initialize the network. It is recommended that the initialization of the synaptic weights of the network be uniformly distributed inside a small range. A range of -.2 to +.2 was used for random initialization of all synaptic weight vectors in the network. onlinear Activation Function The model of each neuron in the hidden layer(s) and output layer of the network includes a nonlinearity at the output end. The presence of a nonlinear activation function, ϕ(.), is important because otherwise the input-output relation of the network could be reduced to that of a single-layer perceptron. The computation of the local gradient for each neuron of the multilayer perceptron requires that the function ϕ(.) be continuous. In other words, differentiability is the only requirement that an activation function would need to satisfy. For this problem, an asymmetric hyperbolic tangent function (tanh) was chosen for which the output amplitude lies inside the range -1 y j +1. Since we require the final outputs to be real values instead of binary outputs, a linear combiner model was used for neurons in the output layer, thus omitting the nonlinear activation function. Performance Measure (RMSE) In order to track the performance of the network, the root mean squared error (RMSE) at the end of each epoch was calculated. An epoch is defined as one full presentation of all the training vectors to the network. The RMSE at the end of each epoch is defined as the following: RMSE = [ d j Y ( X j )] j= 1 2 Gopalakrishnan 6
7 Where d j is the desired response for the input training vector X j, and is the total number of input vectors presented to the network for training. For the network to learn the problem smoothly, a monotonic decrease in the RMSE is expected with an increase in the number of epochs. A smooth learning curve was achieved with a learning-rate parameter (η) of.1. A IPUTS AD OUTPUTS Deflection basin parameters (DBPs) derived from falling weight deflectometer (FWD) and/or HWD deflection measurements are shown to be good indicators of selected pavement properties and conditions (Hossain and Zanniewski 1991). Recently, Xu et al. (21) used DBPs in developing new relationships between selected pavement layer condition indicators and FWD deflections by applying regression and A techniques. Apart from the six independent deflection measurements (D to D 6 ), some of the commonly used DBPs were included as inputs for training the A. The DBPs considered in this study are shown in Table 2. Each DBP supposedly represents the condition of specific pavement layers. For example, AUPP is sensitive to the asphalt concrete layer properties, whereas BCI and AI4 are expected to reflect the condition of subgrade. The desired outputs from the A are asphalt concrete modulus (E AC ), subgrade modulus (E Ri ), base modulus parameter (K b or n b ), and subbase modulus parameter (K s or n s ). ote that by predicting either K or n, the other parameter can be determined using the relation proposed by Rada and Witzcak (1981). Table 2. DBPs considered in this study Deflection basin parameter (DBP) Formula AREA AREA = 6(D + 2D + 2D 24 + D 36 )/D Area under pavement profile AUPP = (5D 2D 2D 24 D 36 )/2 (AUPP) Area index AI 4 = (D 36 + D 48 )/2D Base curvature index (BCI) BCI = D 24 D 36 BCI2 = D 6 D 48 Base damage index (BDI) BDI = D D 24 Deflection ratio DR = D /D Shape factors F 1 = (D D 24 )/D F 2 = (D D 36 )/D 24 SELECTIO OF BEST-PERFORMACE ETWORKS Separate A models were used for each desired output rather than using the same architecture to determine all the outputs together. The most effective set of input features for each A model were determined based on both engineering judgment and the experience gained through past research studies conducted at UIUC. Parametric analyses were performed by systematically varying the choice and number of inputs and number of hidden neurons to identify the best-performance networks. As it was found that the prediction accuracy of the network remained the same for hidden layers greater than or equal to two, the number of hidden layers was fixed at two for all runs. The learning curve (RMSE vs number of epochs) and the testing RMSE were studied in order to arrive at the best networks. A previous Gopalakrishnan 7
8 study that focused on the section alone showed that the base and subbase moduli parameters were the hardest to predict (Gopalakrishnan and Thompson 24). During the course of this study, the same conclusion was reached for other test sections. It was concluded that further research is needed to develop robust A models for predicting the base and subbase moduli parameters. RESEARCH RESULTS A summary of the sensitivity analyses performed to select the best-performance networks for predicting asphalt concrete modulus (E AC ) and subgrade modulus (E Ri ) in APTF test sections are shown in Table 3. ote that the A inputs are similar for all four test sections. In Figure 3, the A-predicted moduli values and the target values are compared using the 1,25 test data vectors for each APTF section. Excellent agreement is found between the predicted and target values for both E AC and subgrade modulus E Ri in all four test sections, except for E Ri in section, where an R 2 value of.81 was obtained. Table 3. Summary of best-performance A pavement moduli prediction models APTF etwork Training Testing Output Inputs section architecture RMSE RMSE E AC D ~ D ksi 69 ksi E Ri D ~ D 6, BCI, AI ksi.82 ksi E AC D ~ D ksi 97 ksi E Ri D ~ D 6, BCI, AI ksi 1.18 ksi E AC D ~ D ksi 67 ksi E Ri D ~ D 6, BCI, AI ksi.78 ksi E AC D ~ D ksi 9 ksi E Ri D ~ D 6, BCI, AI ksi 2. ksi One of the major reasons for developing this A-based backcalculation procedure is to evaluate the structural integrity of the APTF pavement test sections reliably as they were subjected to traffic loading. The APTF test sections were subjected to trafficking until they exhibited failure. The test section was the first one to fail at,952 load repetitions exhibiting 3 to 3.5 inches of rutting and severe cracking. In the section, localized failure occurred in the Boeing 777 traffic lane toward the west end. At 19,9 passes, 3.5 inches of rut depth was observed on the Boeing 777 traffic lane, with upheaval outside the traffic path. Trafficking was terminated on the Boeing 777 traffic lane, but it continued on the Boeing 747 traffic lane. The Boeing 747 lane failed at 3, passes. HWD tests were not conducted on the section beyond 19,9 passes. The low-strength test sections ( and ) showed few signs of genuine distress, even after 2, passes, and therefore the wheel loading was increased from, lbs to, lbs. The trafficking was terminated in the low-strength test sections after 28, passes of, lbs. While the and sections failed at the subgrade level, the and sections failed in the surface layers, signifying tire pressure or other upper layer failure effects, but not subgrade level failure (Gervais, Hayhoe, and Garg 23). Gopalakrishnan 8
9 A Predicted AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) R 2 = A Predicted Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) R 2 = Target AC Modulus, E AC (Ksi) Target Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) A Predicted AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) R 2 = Target AC Modulus, E AC (Ksi) A Predicted Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) R 2 = Target Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) A Predicted AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) R 2 = A Predicted Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) R 2 = Target AC Modulus, E AC (Ksi) Target Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) A Predicted AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) R 2 = A Predicted Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) R 2 = Target AC Modulus, E AC (Ksi) Target Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) Figure 3. A prediction of APTF asphalt concrete moduli (left) and subgrade moduli (right) Gopalakrishnan 9
10 A vs FAABACKCAL Using the 36-kip HWD test data acquired at the APTF, the asphalt concrete moduli and subgrade moduli were backcalculated with the best-performance As for all four sections. The results were then compared with those obtained using FAABACKCAL, an ELP-based backcalculation program. FAABACKCAL was developed under the sponsorship of the FAA Airport Technology Branch and is based on the LEAF layered elastic computation program. In this program, the pavement layer moduli and subgrade moduli are adjusted to minimize the root mean square (rms) of the differences between FWD/HWD sensor measurements and the LEAF-computed deflection basin for a specified pavement structure. A standard multidimensional simplex optimization routine is then used to adjust the moduli values (McQueen, Marsey, and Arze 21). A stiff layer with a modulus of 1,, psi and a Poisson s ratio of.5 was used in backcalculation. Based on the as-constructed conditions, the stiff layer was set at 1 feet for the medium-strength test sections and at feet for the low-strength sections. The most recent version of the FAA backcalculation software is called BAKFAA. The detailed backcalculation results for APTF sections using FAABACKCAL are reported elsewhere (Gopalakrishnan and Thompson 24). The plots comparing the results of A-based backcalculation with those obtained using FAABACKCAL are shown in Figure 4 for asphalt concrete moduli and in Figure 5 for subgrade moduli. The gray arrow in the plots for the and sections indicate where (after 2, load repetitions) the wheel load was increased from, lbs to, lbs. In Figure 4, the variation in asphalt concrete temperature as a function of the number of load repetitions () in each test section is also included and is indicated by a gray line. In these plots, the changes in layer moduli in the Boeing 777 traffic lane and the Boeing 747 traffic lane are due to both traffic loading as well as variation in temperature and climate. The changes in pavement material properties in the untrafficked pavement centerline are only due to environmental effects. The trends for asphalt concrete moduli are very similar using both approaches. The asphalt concrete moduli values are significantly influenced by asphalt concrete temperature. In the and sections, the A approach seem to be more sensitive to trafficking and temperature, indicated by a sharp decrease in the moduli values towards the end of trafficking. In the and sections, the structural degradation resulting from increasing the wheel load from, lbs to, lbs after 2, repetitions is clearly reflected in the moduli values. Compared to the centerline moduli values, the traffic lane moduli values decrease further after 2, repetitions. In Figure 5, the Y-axis is magnified in the individual plots as the subgrade moduli values varied over a narrow range compared to the asphalt concrete moduli. ote that the subgrade modulus predicted by A is the stress-dependent breakpoint subgrade modulus (at a deviator stress of about 6 psi) and is indicated as E Ri. The subgrade modulus backcalculated by FAABACKCAL is indicated as E. The initial magnitudes of subgrade modulus obtained using both the approaches are similar for the and sections. For the and sections, the initial subgrade moduli obtained using the A are about 5 psi higher than the those obtained using FAABACKCAL. The sharp decrease in the subgrade modulus in the Boeing 777 traffic lane of the section towards the end of the trafficking, as captured by the A results, could be due to the localized failure, as mentioned earlier. The APTF rutting study results showed that the eest end of the Boeing 777 traffic lane in the section exhibited a rapid increase in surface rutting after, load repetitions (Gopalakrishnan and Thompson 23). Gopalakrishnan 1
11 AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) A B777-A B747-A C/L-A ACTemperature ( F) AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) B777-FAABACKCAL B747-FAABACKCAL C/L-FAABACKCAL FAABACKCAL AC Temperature ( F) AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) AC Temperature ( F) AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) AC Temperature ( F) AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) AC Temperature ( F) AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) AC Temperature ( F) AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) AC Temperature ( F) AC Modulus, E AC (ksi) AC Temperature ( F) Figure 4. Comparison of A-predicted asphalt concrete moduli (left) with FAABACKCAL asphalt concrete moduli (right) for APTF test sections Gopalakrishnan 11
12 Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) A B777-A B747-A C/L-A Subgrade Modulus, E (ksi) FAABACKCAL B777-FAABACKCAL B747-FAABACKCAL C/L-FAABACKCAL Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) Subgrade Modulus, E (ksi) Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) Subgrade Modulus, E Ri (ksi) Subgrade Modulus, E (ksi) Subgrade Modulus, E (ksi) Figure 5. Comparison of A-predicted subgrade moduli (left) with FAABACKCAL subgrade moduli (right) for APTF test sections Gopalakrishnan
13 SUMMARY AD COCLUSIOS The primary objective of this study was to develop a tool for backcalculating APTF non-linear pavement layer moduli from HWD data using A. The APTF sections were modeled in ILLI-PAVE and a synthetic database was generated for a range of moduli values. A multi-layer feedforward network that uses an error-backpropagation algorithm was successfully trained to approximate the HWD backcalculation function using the ILLI-PAVE database. A models were successfully developed for predicting asphalt concrete and non-linear subgrade moduli. However, the base/subbase moduli could not be predicted using A. The best-performance A models were used to predict asphalt concrete and subgrade moduli from APTF HWD deflection basins collected at regular intervals during trafficking. The results were compared with results obtained using FAABACKCAL, a conventional ELP-based backcalculation software. The results definitely indicate that the non-linear pavement layer moduli could be successfully backcalculated from FWD/HWD deflection basins using an A trained with ILLI-PAVE results. The backcalculated results could be used to establish realistic a priori moduli inputs to mechanistic pavement structural analysis. Although regression models could also be developed for predicting layer moduli using ILLI-PAVE results, a significant advantage of using the A-based approach over the regression approach is that the functional forms of the relationships are not needed a priori. Also, the robustness of the A can be improved by including the field data sets in the training process, as they implicitly incorporate noise and errors typically seen in field measurements. Further research is needed to develop robust A models for predicting base/subbase moduli parameters. It is proposed that by including the A-predicted E AC and E Ri values as inputs to the A and by training the A with the ILLI-PAVE results for the -kip and 24-kip HWD loads, the chances of accurately predicting base/subbase moduli will increase. It is also noted that the A moduli backcalculation concept developed in this study could be used to backcalculate highway pavement non-linear moduli successfully. Gopalakrishnan 13
14 ACKOWLEDGMETS This paper was prepared from a study conducted in the Center of Excellence for Airport Technology. Funding for the Center is provided in part by the Federal Aviation Administration under research grant 95-C-1. The Center is maintained at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, which works in partnership with orthwestern University and the Federal Aviation Administration. The author gratefully acknowledges the financial assistance and support by Professor Marshall R. Thompson for conducting this research. The author is also grateful to Dr. Franco Gomez-Ramirez for his valuable help and suggestions in developing the training database. REFERECES Ahlvin, R. G., H. H. Ulery, R. L. Hutchinson, and J. L. Rice Multiple-Wheel Heavy Gear Load Pavement Tests, Vol. 1: Basic Report. Technical Report o. AFWL-TR Vicksburg, MS: U.S. Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station. Asphalt Institute Research and Development of The Asphalt Institute s Thickness Design Manual (MS-1) inth Edition. Research Report o College Park, MD: The Asphalt Institute. Ceylan, H., Tutumluer, E., Thompson, M. R., and F. Gomez-Ramirez. 24. eural etwork-based Structural Models for Rapid Analysis of Flexible Pavements with Unbound Aggregate Layers. Proceedings of the Sixth International Symposium on Pavements Unbound, ottingham, England, UK. Garg,. and W. H. Marsey. 22. Comparison Between Falling Weight Deflectometer and Static Deflection Measurements on Flexible Pavement at the ational Airport Pavement Facility (APTF). Paper presented at the 22 Federal Aviation Administration Airport Technology Conference, Chicago, IL. Gervais, E. L., G. F. Hayhoe, and. Garg. 23. Towards a Permanent Solution for 6-Wheel Landing Gear Aircraft. Proceedings of the 23 ASCE Airfield Specialty Conference, Las Vegas, V. Gopalakrishnan, K. and M. R. Thompson. 23. Rutting Study of APTF Flexible Pavement Test Sections. In Proceedings of the 23 ASCE Airfield Specialty Conference, Las Vegas, V. Gopalakrishnan, K. and M. R. Thompson. 24. Backcalculation of Airport Flexible Pavement on- Linear Moduli Using Artificial eural etworks. Proceedings of the 17 th International Florida Artificial Intelligence Research Symposium Conference, FLAIRS-24, Miami Beach, FL. Gopalakrishnan, K. and M. R. Thompson. 24. Comparative Effect of B777 and B747 Trafficking on Elastic Layer Moduli of APTF Flexible Pavements. In Proceedings of the 24 FAA Worldwide Airport Technology Transfer Conference, Atlantic City, J. Gomez-Ramirez, F. M., and M. R. Thompson. 22. Characterizing Aircraft Multiple Wheel Load Interaction for Airport Flexible Pavement Design. Civil Engineering Studies, COE Report. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Haykin, S eural etworks: A Comprehensive Foundation. ew York: Macmillan College Publishing Company, Inc. Hossain, S. M. and J. P. Zaniewski Characterization of Falling Weight Deflectometer Deflection Basin. Transportation Research Record 93. Washington, D.C.: TRB, ational Research Council, pp Hicks, R. G Factors Influencing the Resilient Properties of Granular Materials. Ph.D. dissertation, University of California, Berkeley. McQueen, R. D., W. Marsey, and J. M. Arze. 21. Analysis of ondestructive Data on Flexible Pavement Acquired at the ational Airport Pavement Test Facility. In Proceedings of the 21 ASCE Airfield Pavement Specialty Conference, Chicago, IL. Gopalakrishnan
15 CHRP Calibrated Mechanistic Structural Analysis Procedures for Pavements. Final Report. ational Cooperative Highway Research Program Project Washington, D.C.: TRB, ational Research Council. Raad, L. and J. L. Figueroa Load Response of Transportation Support Systems. Transportation Engineering Journal (TE1). Rada, G. and M. W. Witczak Comprehensive Evaluation of Laboratory Resilient Moduli Results for Granular Material. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, o.81. Washington, D.C.: TRB, ational Research Council. Thompson, M. R. and Q. L. Robnett Resilient Properties of Subgrade Soils. Transportation Engineering Journal.1. Thompson, M. R., E. Tutumluer, and M. Bejarano Granular Material and Soil Moduli Review of the Literature. Final Report. Center of Excellence for Airport Pavement Research COE Report o. 1. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. U.S. COE. 21. O & M: PAVER, Asphalt Surfaced Airfields Pavement Condition Index (PCI). Unified Facilities Criteria U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (preparing activity), aval Facilities Engineering Command, Air Force Civil Engineering Support Agency. Xu, B., S. R. Ranjithan and Y. R. Kim. 21. Development of Relationships between FWD Deflections and Asphalt Pavement Layer Condition Indicators. Paper presented at the 81 st Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C. Gopalakrishnan
Stress Rotations Due to Moving Wheel Loads and Their Effects on Pavement Materials Characterization
Stress Rotations Due to Moving Wheel Loads and Their Effects on Pavement Materials Characterization Erol Tutumluer June 9, 2005 OMP Brown Bag Seminar Presentation FAA Center of Excellence for Airport Technology
More informationBackcalculation of Airport Flexible Pavement Non-Linear Moduli Using Artificial Neural Networks
Backcalculation of Airport Flexible Pavement Non-Linear Mouli Using Artificial Neural Networks Kasthurirangan Gopalakrishnan an Marshall R. Thompson Grauate Research Assistant an Professor Emeritus Department
More informationNeural Networks Analysis of Airfield Pavement Heavy Weight Deflectometer Data
The Open Civil Engineering Journal, 28, 2, 15-23 15 Neural Networks Analysis of Airfiel Pavement Heavy Weight Deflectometer Data Kasthurirangan Gopalakrishnan* Department of Civil, Construction an Environmental
More informationALACPA-ICAO Seminar on PMS. Lima Peru, November 2003
ALACPA-ICAO Seminar on PMS Lima Peru, 19-22 November 2003 Airport Pavements FWD/HWD Testing and Evaluation By: Frank B. Holt Vice President Dynatest International A/S Dynamic Testing The method of FWD/HWD
More informationSUITABILITY OF USING CALIFORNIA BEARING RATIO TEST TO PREDICT RESILIENT MODULUS
SUITABILITY OF USING CALIFORNIA BEARING RATIO TEST TO PREDICT RESILIENT MODULUS By: Beena Sukumaran, Associate Professor, Civil & Environmental Engineering Rowan University 201 Mullica Hill Road, Glassboro,
More informationGeoShanghai 2010 International Conference Paving Materials and Pavement Analysis
Particle Shape, Type and Amount of Fines, and Moisture Affecting Resilient Modulus Behavior of Unbound Aggregates Debakanta Mishra 1, Erol Tutumluer 2, M. ASCE, Yuanjie Xiao 3 1 Graduate Research Assistant,
More informationILLI-PAVE-Based Response Algorithms for Design of Conventional Flexible Pavements
5 Transportation Research Record 143 ILLI-PAVE-Based Response Algorithms for Design of Conventional Flexible Pavements MARSHALL R. THOMPSON and ROBERT P. ELLIOTT ABSTRACT In a mechanistic design procedure
More informationABSTRACT. PARK, HEE MUN. Use of Falling Weight Deflectometer Multi-Load Level Data for
ABSTRACT PARK, HEE MUN. Use of Falling Weight Deflectometer Multi-Load Level Data for Pavement Strength Estimation. (Under the direction of Y. Richard, Kim). The objective of this study is to describe
More informationLecture 3: Stresses in Rigid Pavements
Lecture 3: Stresses in Rigid Pavements Nature of Responses under Flexible and Rigid Plates Flexible plate: Uniform Contact Pressure Variable Deflection Profile Flexible Plate Rigid Plate plate: Non-Uniform
More informationMn/DOT Flexible Pavement Design Mechanistic-Empirical Method
Mn/DOT Flexible Pavement Design Mechanistic-Empirical Method Pavement Design Systems and Pavement Performance Models March 22-23, 2007 - Reykjavik, Iceland Bruce Chadbourn Assistant Pavement Design Engineer
More informationMechanistic Pavement Design
Seminar on Pavement Design System and Pavement Performance Models Reykjavik, 22. 23. March, 2007 Mechanistic Pavement Design A Road to Enhanced Understanding of Pavement Performance Sigurdur Erlingsson
More informationNEW GENERATION AIRCRAFT FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT DESIGN CHALLENGES. M. Thompson U of Urbana-Champaign
NEW GENERATION AIRCRAFT FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT DESIGN CHALLENGES M. Thompson U of IL @ Urbana-Champaign NEW GENERATION AIRCRAFT BOEING-777 (1995) -Gross Load 632,000 lbs A380-800 800 (2006) -Gross Load 1.23
More information2002 Pavement Design
2002 Pavement Design Federal Highway Administration June 2001 Thomas P. Harman Asphalt Team Leader Predicting Pavement Performance Pavements are designed to fail But how do they perform? Defining Performance
More informationLecture 2: Stresses in Pavements
Lecture 2: Stresses in Pavements Stresses in Layered Systems At any point, 9 stresses exist. They are 3 normal stresses (s z, s r, s t ) and 6 shearing stresses ( t rz = t zr, t rt = t tr, and t tz = t
More informationDevelopment of a Quick Reliability Method for Mechanistic-Empirical Asphalt Pavement Design
Tanquist 1 Development of a Quick Reliability Method for Mechanistic-Empirical Asphalt Pavement Design Submission date: August 1, 2001 Word Count: 4654 Bruce A. Tanquist Research Project Engineer Minnesota
More informationCharacterization of Anisotropic Aggregate Behavior Under Variable Confinement Conditions
Characteriation of Anisotropic Aggregate Behavior Under Variable Confinement Conditions Erol Tutumluer 1, Member, Umit Seyhan 2, Student Member, And Navneet Garg 3, Member Abstract Compared to the standard
More informationINTRODUCTION TO PAVEMENT STRUCTURES
INTRODUCTION TO PAVEMENT STRUCTURES A pavement is a structure composed of structural elements, whose function is to protect the natural subgrade and to carry the traffic safety and economically. As a wheel
More informationImpact of Water on the Structural Performance of Pavements
Impact of Water on the Structural Performance of Pavements S. Erlingsson Highway Engineering, VTI The Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute, Linköping, Sweden & Faculty of Civil and Environmental
More informationDevelopment and Validation of Mechanistic-Empirical Design Method for Permeable Interlocking Concrete Pavement
Development and Validation of Mechanistic-Empirical Design Method for Permeable Interlocking Concrete Pavement Hui Li, David Jones, Rongzong Wu, and John Harvey University of California Pavement Research
More informationDetermination of Resilient Modulus Model for Road-Base Material
JOURNAL OF APPLIED SCIENCES RESEARCH ISSN: 1819-544X Published BY AENSI Publication EISSN: 1816-157X http://www.aensiweb.com/jasr 2017 January; 13(1): pages 10-16 Open Access Journal Determination of Resilient
More informationACKNOWLEDGMENT OF SPONSORSHIP
ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF SPONSORSHIP This work was sponsored by the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, in cooperation with the Federal Highway Administration, and was conducted
More informationAnalysis of in-service PCC pavement responses from Denver International Airport
Analysis of in-service PCC pavement responses from Denver International Airport Dulce Rufino ERES Consultants, A Division of ARA, Inc. Presented at ISU Spring Transportation Seminar February 2, 24 Overview
More informationMECHANISTIC-EMPIRICAL LOAD EQUIVALENCIES USING WEIGH IN MOTION
MECHANISTIC-EMPIRICAL LOAD EQUIVALENCIES USING WEIGH IN MOTION Prepared By: Curtis Berthelot Ph.D., P.Eng. Dept. of Civil Engineering University of Saskatchewan Tanya Loewen Dept. of Civil Engineering
More informationVerification of the dissipated energy based fatigue model using field data
Rowan University Rowan Digital Works Theses and Dissertations 3-2-2015 Verification of the dissipated energy based fatigue model using field data Thomas Redles Follow this and additional works at: http://rdw.rowan.edu/etd
More informationFATIGUE LIFE PREDICTIONS FOR ASPHALT CONCRETE SUBJECTED TO MULTIPLE AXLE LOADINGS
FATIGUE LIFE PREDICTIOS FOR ASPHALT COCRETE SUBJECTED TO MULTIPLE AXLE LOADIGS Karim Chatti, Hyungsuk Lee and Chadi El Mohtar Assistant Professor, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Michigan
More informationRevised Test Plan for Seasonal Monitoring Program using HWD Testing
April 2005 Revised Test Plan for Seasonal Monitoring Program using HWD Testing Partnered Pavement Research Prepared for: California Department of Transportation Prepared by: University of California Berkeley
More informationADVANCED COMPUTING TECHNIQUES IN STRUCTURAL EVALUATION OF FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS USING THE FALLING WEIGHT DEFLECTOMETER. Fabricio Leiva-Villacorta
ADVANCED COMPUTING TECHNIQUES IN STRUCTURAL EVALUATION OF FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS USING THE FALLING WEIGHT DEFLECTOMETER by Fabricio Leiva-Villacorta A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Auburn
More informationAccelerated Loading Evaluation of Base & Sub-base Layers
Accelerated Loading Evaluation of Base & Sub-base Layers Zhong Wu, Ph.D., P.E. Louisiana Transportation Research Center (LTRC) April 2006 What is Accelerated Loading? Accelerated loading refers to Accelerated
More informationMETHODS FOR EVALUATING RESILIENT MODULI OF PAVING MATERIALS
Project Number ST 2019-7 Summary Report METHODS FOR EVALUATING RESILIENT MODULI OF PAVING MATERIALS sponsored by The State of Alabama Highway Department Montgomery, Alabama Frazier Parker, Jr. David J.
More informationField Rutting Performance of Various Base/Subbase Materials under Two Types of Loading
Field Rutting Performance of Various Base/Subbase Materials under Two Types of Loading Qiming Chen, Ph.D., P.E. (presenter) Murad Abu-Farsakh, Ph.D., P.E. Louisiana Transportation Research Center Apr.
More informationEvaluating Structural Performance of Base/Subbase Materials at the Louisiana Accelerated Pavement Research Facility
Evaluating Structural Performance of Base/Subbase Materials at the Louisiana Accelerated Pavement Research Facility Zhong Wu, Ph.D., P.E. Zhongjie Zhang, Bill King Louay Mohammad Outline Background Objectives
More informationFlexible Pavement Analysis Considering Temperature Profile and Anisotropy Behavior in Hot Mix Ashalt Layer
Open Journal of Civil ngineering, 2011, 1, 7-12 doi:10.4236/ojce.2011.12002 Published Online December 2011 (http://www.scirp.org/journal/ojce) Flexible Pavement Analysis Considering Temperature Profile
More informationLRRB INV 828 Local Road Material Properties and Calibration for MnPAVE
LRRB INV 828 Local Road Material Properties and Calibration for MnPAVE Task 4 Report Calibration Bruce Tanquist, Assistant Pavement Design Engineer Minnesota Department of Transportation May 23, 2008 Introduction
More informationNJDOT RESEARCH PROJECT MANAGER: Mr. Anthony Chmiel
Project Title: RFP NUMBER: CAIT NJDOT Bureau of Research QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT Evaluation of Poisson s Ratio NJDOT RESEARCH PROJECT MANAGER: Mr. Anthony Chmiel TASK ORDER NUMBER/Study Number: Task
More informationFalling Weight Deflectometer vs Laboratory Determined Resilient Modulus (Slab Curling Study)
FWD-RU6701 Falling Weight Deflectometer vs Laboratory Determined Resilient Modulus (Slab Curling Study) FINAL REPORT December 2005 Submitted by Dr. Sameh Zaghloul, P.E., P.Eng.* Managing Senior Principal
More informationAdvanced Numerical Study of the Effects of Road Foundations on Pavement Performance
Advanced Numerical Study of the Effects of Road Foundations on Pavement Performance X. Liu Section of Structural Mechanics, Faculty of Civil Engineering and Geosciences, Delft University of Technology,
More informationEvaluation of FWD software and deflection basin for airport pavements
University of New Mexico UNM Digital Repository Civil Engineering ETDs Engineering ETDs 9-3-21 Evaluation of FWD software and deflection basin for airport pavements Mesbah Uddin Ahmed Follow this and additional
More informationEvaluation of Rutting Depth in Flexible Pavements by Using Finite Element Analysis and Local Empirical Model
American Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 2012, 5 (2), 163-169 ISSN: 1941-7020 2014 Abed and Al-Azzawi, This open access article is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY)
More informationSENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF THE VESYS PROGRAM TO PREDICT CRITICAL PAVEMENT RESPONSES FOR RUTTING AND FATIGUE PERFORMANCES OF PAVEMENT INFRASTRUCTURES
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF THE VESYS PROGRAM TO PREDICT CRITICAL PAVEMENT RESPONSES FOR RUTTING AND FATIGUE PERFORMANCES OF PAVEMENT INFRASTRUCTURES Ghazi G. Al-Khateeb 1, Raghu Satyanarayana 2, and Katherine
More informationFULL-DEPTH HMA PAVEMENT DESIGN
FULL-DEPTH HMA PAVEMENT DESIGN Marshall R. Thompson Department of Civil Engineering University of Illinois @ U-C FULL-DEPTH HMA FULL QUALITY HMA IDOT & FULL-DEPTH HMA PAVEMENT (FD-HMA) BEFORE 1989 *AASHTO
More informationEvaluating Structural Performance of Base/Subbase Materials at the Louisiana Accelerated Pavement Research Facility
Evaluating Structural Performance of Base/Subbase Materials at the Louisiana Accelerated Pavement Research Facility Zhong Wu, Ph.D., P.E. Louisiana Transportation Research Center 2007 Transportation Engineering
More informationMechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design Guide: A User s Perspective. Brian D. Prowell, Ph.D., P.E.
Mechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design Guide: A User s Perspective Brian D. Prowell, Ph.D., P.E. Empirical Approach Based on results of experiments or experience Scientific basis not established AASHTO
More informationAdvanced approaches to hot-mix asphalt dynamic modulus prediction
Civil, Construction and Environmental Engineering Civil, Construction and Environmental Engineering Publications 2008 Advanced approaches to hot-mix asphalt dynamic modulus prediction Halil Ceylan Iowa
More informationCharacterizing Horizontal Response Pulse at the Bottom of Asphalt Layer Based on Viscoelastic Analysis
Technical Paper ISSN 1996-6814 Int. J. Pavement Res. Technol. 6(4):379-385 Copyright @ Chinese Society of Pavement Engineering Characterizing Horizontal Response Pulse at the Bottom of Asphalt Layer Based
More informationStresses and Strains in flexible Pavements
Stresses and Strains in flexible Pavements Multi Layered Elastic System Assumptions in Multi Layered Elastic Systems The material properties of each layer are homogeneous property at point A i is the same
More informationImpact of Existing Pavement on Jointed Plain Concrete Overlay Design and Performance
Impact of Existing Pavement on Jointed Plain Concrete Overlay Design and Performance Michael I. Darter, Jag Mallela, and Leslie Titus-Glover 1 ABSTRACT Concrete overlays are increasingly being constructed
More informationFlexible Pavement Design
Flexible Pavement Design The Mechanistic-Empirical Way Presented by: Keith D. Herbold, P.E. 1 Presentation Outline What s new in flexible design Example of new design Differences Capabilities Tests and
More informationResilient modulus and segregation potential estimation from simplified laboratory procedure
Resilient modulus and segregation potential estimation from simplified laboratory procedure Jean-Pascal Bilodeau, ing., Ph.D. Research engineer, department of civil engineering, Laval University Guy Doré,
More informationPavement Discontinuities and Dynamic Load Response
1 TRANSPORTATON RESEARCH RECORD 1448 Finite Element Simulation of Pavement Discontinuities and Dynamic Load Response W AHEED UDDN, DNGMNG ZHANG, AND FRANCSCO FERNANDEZ Assumption of a linear elastic system
More informationEstimation of Standard Deviation of Predicted Performance of Flexible Pavements Using AASHTO Model
46 TRANSPORT~TION RESEARCH RECORD 1449 Estimation of Standard Deviation of Predicted Performance of Flexible Pavements Using AASHTO Model A. SAMY NOURELDIN, ESSAM SHARAF, ABDULRAHIM ARAFAH, AND FAISAL
More informationEvaluation of In-Situ Resilient Modulus Testing Techniques
Evaluation of In-Situ Resilient Modulus Testing Techniques Dar-Hao Chen, 1 Wei Wu, 1 Rong He, 2 John Bilyeu 2 and Mike Arrelano 2 Abstract A series of field experiments has been conducted to evaluate various
More informationNevels, et al 1 KAY COUNTY SHALE SUBGRADE STABILIZATION REVISITED
Nevels, et al 1 Title: KAY COUNTY SHALE SUBGRADE STABILIZATION REVISITED Submitted: 15 November 2012 (revised) Word Count: 3581 + 7 figures = 5331 Name: Affiliation: Email: Joakim G. Laguros, Ph.D., P.E.
More informationEXTENSION OF THE YONAPAVE METHOD FOR DETERMINING FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS OVERLAY THICKNESS FROM FALLING- WEIGHT DEFLECTOMETER DEFLECTIONS
EXTENSION OF THE YONAPAVE METHOD FOR DETERMINING FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS OVERLAY THICKNESS FROM FALLING- WEIGHT DEFLECTOMETER DEFLECTIONS MARIO S. HOFFMAN, PHD. Technical director, YONA, Engineering Consulting
More informationApplication of an Artificial Neural Network Based Tool for Prediction of Pavement Performance
0 0 0 0 Application of an Artificial Neural Network Based Tool for Prediction of Pavement Performance Adelino Ferreira, Rodrigo Cavalcante Pavement Mechanics Laboratory, Research Center for Territory,
More informationMECHANISTIC CHARACTERIZATION OF RESILIENT MODULI FOR UNBOUND PAVEMENT LAYER MATERIALS
MECHANISTIC CHARACTERIZATION OF RESILIENT MODULI FOR UNBOUND PAVEMENT LAYER MATERIALS Except where reference is made to the work of others, the work described in this thesis is my own or was done in collaboration
More information2002 Design Guide Preparing for Implementation
2002 Preparing for Implementation By Monte Symons 2003 NCUAPG Annual Meeting Excerpts from the 2002 Guide Implementation Package 2002 Presentation Overview Need for NCHRP 1-37A - Status Guide Basics Asphalt
More informationFlexible Pavement Stress Analysis
Flexible Pavement Stress Analysis Dr. Antonis Michael Frederick University Notes Courtesy of Dr. Christos Drakos, University of Florida Need to predict & understand stress/strain distribution within the
More informationNon-linear Inverse Analysis of Transportation Structures Using Neuro-adaptive Networks with Hybrid Learning Algorithm
Civil, Construction and Environmental Engineering Civil, Construction and Environmental Engineering Conference Presentations and Proceedings 2009 Non-linear Inverse Analysis of Transportation Structures
More information2007 Joseph K. Anochie-Boateng
2007 Joseph K. Anochie-Boateng ADVANCED TESTING AND CHARACTERIZATION OF TRANSPORTATION SOILS AND BITUMINOUS SANDS BY JOSEPH K. ANOCHIE-BOATENG B.S., University of Science & Technology, 1994 M.S., North
More informationACET 406 Mid-Term Exam B
ACET 406 Mid-Term Exam B SUBJECT: ACET 406, INSTRUCTOR: Dr Antonis Michael, DATE: 24/11/09 INSTRUCTIONS You are required to answer all of the following questions within the specified time (90 minutes).you
More informationGEOSYNTHETICS ENGINEERING: IN THEORY AND PRACTICE
GEOSYNTHETICS ENGINEERING: IN THEORY AND PRACTICE Prof. J. N. Mandal Department of civil engineering, IIT Bombay, Powai, Mumbai 400076, India. Tel.022-25767328 email: cejnm@civil.iitb.ac.in Module-5 LECTURE-
More informationEXAMINATION OF MECHANICAL PROPERTIES IN UNBOUND ROAD BASES
PERIODICA POLYTECHNICA SER. CIV. ENG. VOL. 46, NO. 1, PP. 53 69 (2002) EXAMINATION OF MECHANICAL PROPERTIES IN UNBOUND ROAD BASES Kornél ALMÁSSY Department of Highway and Railway Engineering Budapest University
More informationComparison of Backcalculated Moduli from Falling Weight Deflectometer and Truck Loading
88 TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH RECORD 1377 Comparin of Backcalculated Moduli from Falling Weight Deflectometer and Truck Loading PETER E. SEBAALY, NADER TABATABAEE, AND TOM SCULLION Historically, the in situ
More informationDetermination of AASHTO Layer Coefficients for Granular Materials by Use of Resilient Modulus
Missouri University of Science and Technology Scholars' Mine Civil, Architectural and Environmental Engineering Faculty Research & Creative Works Civil, Architectural and Environmental Engineering 1-1-1994
More informationresearch report Characterization of Unbound Pavement Materials From New Mechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design Procedure
Final Report VTRC 11-R6 Virginia Transportation Research Council research report Characterization of Unbound Pavement Materials From Virginia Sources for Use in the New Mechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design
More information2008 SEAUPG CONFERENCE-BIRMINGHAM, ALABAMA
Introduction Overview M E E Design Inputs MEPDG Where are we now MEPDG Inputs, Outputs, and Sensitivity Southeast Asphalt User Producer Group Bill Vavrik 19 November 2008 2 Implementation Timeframe DARWin
More informationSTRUCTURAL ADEQUACY OF RUBBLIZED PCC PAVEMENT
STRUCTURAL ADEQUACY OF RUBBLIZED PCC PAVEMENT By Khaled A. Galal 1, MSCE Materials Research Engineer Indiana Department of Transportation - Division of Research 1205 Montgomery Street, P. O. Box 2279 West
More informationStudy on How to Determine Repair Thickness of Damaged Layers for Porous Asphalt
Study on How to Determine Repair Thickness of Damaged Layers for Porous Asphalt K. Kamiya & T. Kazato Nippon Expressway Research Institute Company Limited, Tokyo, Japan ABSTRACT: Porous asphalt has been
More informationCOMPARISON BETWEEN LABORATORY AND FIELD MEASURED RESILIENT MODULUS FOR FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET) Volume 9, Issue 10, October 2018, pp. 558 568, Article ID: IJCIET_09_10_057 Available online at http://www.iaeme.com/ijciet/issues.asp?jtype=ijciet&vtype=9&itype=10
More informationUnbound material characterisation with Nottingham asphalt tester
Civil, Construction and Environmental Engineering Civil, Construction and Environmental Engineering Publications 2012 Sunghwan Kim Iowa State University, sunghwan@iastate.edu Kasthurirangan Gopalakrishnan
More informationSURFACE MODULI DETERMINED WITH THE FALLING WEIGHT DEFLECTOMETER USED AS BENCHMARKING TOOL
SURFACE MODULI DETERMINED WITH THE FALLING WEIGHT DEFLECTOMETER USED AS BENCHMARKING TOOL E Horak* Professor and Head of Department of Civil and Biosystems Engineering, University of Pretoria, e-mail:
More informationMechanistic Investigation of Granular Base and Subbase Materials A Saskatchewan Case Study
Mechanistic Investigation of Granular Base and Subbase Materials A Saskatchewan Case Study Curtis Berthelot, P. Eng. Department of Civil and Geological Engineering University of Saskatchewan 57 Campus
More informationEffect of tire type on strains occurring in asphalt concrete layers
Effect of tire type on strains occurring in asphalt concrete layers Grellet D., Doré G., & Bilodeau J.-P. Department of Civil Engineering, Laval University, Québec, Canada ABSTRACT: The three main causes
More informationComputation of Equivalent Single-Wheel Loads Using Layered Theory
Computation of Equivalent Single-Wheel Loads Using Layered Theory Y. H. HUANG, Assistant Professor of Civil Engineering, University of Kentucky A method based on elastic layered theory and programmed for
More informationArtificial Neural Network Models For Assessing Remaining Life of Flexible Pavements
Artificial Neural Network Models For Assessing Remaining Life of Flexible Pavements by Imad Abdallah, MSCE Octavio Melchor-Lucero, MSCE Carlos Ferregut, Ph.D. and Soheil Nazarian, Ph.D., P.E. Research
More informationSubject Index. STP1026-EB/Nov. 1989
STP1026-EB/Nov. 1989 Subject Index A AASHTO and Unified Soil Classification System, 686, 687 (table) 1986 AASHTO Guide for Design of Pavement Structures, 64, 683-690 AASHTO Test Method T 274-82,640-643,
More informationAnalysis of Non-Linear Dynamic Behaviours in Asphalt Concrete Pavements Under Temperature Variations
ENOC 2017, June 25 30, 2017, Budapest, Hungary Analysis of Non-Linear Dynamic Behaviours in Asphalt Concrete Pavements Under Temperature Variations Amal Abdelaziz *, Chun-Hsing Ho *, and Junyi Shan * *
More informationArtificial Neural Network-Based Methodologies for Rational Assessment of Remaining Life of Existing Pavements. Research Project
Artificial Neural Network-Based Methodologies for Rational Assessment of Remaining Life of Existing Pavements by Carlos Ferregut, Ph.D. Imad Abdallah, MSCE Octavio Melchor-Lucero, MSCE and Soheil Nazarian,
More informationAssessment of Computer Programs for Analysis of Flexible Pavement Structure
TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH RECORD 1482 123 Assessment of Computer Programs for Analysis of Flexible Pavement Structure DAR-HAO CHEN, MUSHARRAF ZAMAN, JOAKIM LAGUROS, AND ALAN SOLTANI Five computer programs
More informationPavement Design Where are We? By Dr. Mofreh F. Saleh
Pavement Design Where are We? By Dr. Mofreh F. Saleh Pavement Design Where are We?? State-of-Practice State-of-the-Art Empirical Mechanistic- Empirical Mechanistic Actual Current Practice?? Inputs Structure
More informationUnbound Pavement Applications of Excess Foundry System Sands: Subbase/Base Material
Unbound Pavement Applications of Excess Foundry System Sands: Subbase/Base Material Tuncer B. Edil University of Wisconsin-Madison Recycled Materials Resource Center RMRC Participant Job Description Which
More informationStructural Design of Pavements
CAIRO UNIVERSITY FACULTY OF ENGINEERING PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT 4 th Year Civil Engineering Highway Engineering Course 2008-2009 Structural Design of Pavements Lecturer Dr. Eng. Omar Osman Asst. Professor
More informationBase Design Considerations for Jointed Concrete. Dan G. Zollinger, Ph.D., P.E. Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, USA
Base Design Considerations for Jointed Concrete Dan G. Zollinger, Ph.D., P.E. Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, USA Discussion What is Erosion Effects on Performance Erosion Testing Use of Erosion
More informationMidwest Transportation Consortium Fall Student Conference, November 15, 2006 Ames, Iowa
Midwest Transportation Consortium Fall Student Conference, November 15, 6 Ames, Iowa Backcalculation of Layer Moduli for Jointed Plain Concrete Pavement Systems Using Artificial Neural Networks By: Mustafa
More informationMonitoring the structural behaviour variation of a flexible pavement. structure during freeze and thaw
Monitoring the structural behaviour variation of a flexible pavement structure during freeze and thaw Junyan Yi, Ph.D. Post-doc researcher, Department of civil engineering, Laval University Guy Doré, ing.
More informationComparison of Rigid Pavement Thickness Design Systems
Transportation Kentucky Transportation Center Research Report University of Kentucky Year 1988 Comparison of Rigid Pavement Thickness Design Systems Herbert F. Southgate University of Kentucky This paper
More informationFigure 2-1: Stresses under axisymmetric circular loading
. Stresses in Pavements.1. Stresses in Fleible Pavements.1.1. Stresses in Homogeneous Mass Boussinesq formulated models for the stresses inside an elastic half-space due to a concentrated load applied
More informationBOUSDEF: A Backcalculation Program for Determining Moduli of a Pavement Structure
166 TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH RECORD 1260 BOUSDEF: A Backcalculation Program for Determining Moduli of a Pavement Structure HAIPING ZHOU, R. G. HICKS, AND c. A. BELL Highway and transportation agencies have
More informationImprovement of Cracking Resistance for the Semi-Rigid Base Layer Reinforced by Geogrid
Improvement of Cracking Resistance for the Semi-Rigid Base Layer Reinforced by Geogrid Zhu Yun Sheng * Chimi Tegachouang Nathan School of Transportation, Wuhan University of Technology, # 25 Luoshi Road,
More informationresearch report Virginia Transportation Research Council Final Report VTRC 09-R4 M. SHABBIR HOSSAIN, Ph.D., P.E. Research Scientist
Final Report VTRC 09-R4 Virginia Transportation Research Council research report Characterization of Subgrade Resilient Modulus for Virginia Soils and Its Correlation with the Results of Other Soil Tests
More informationModulus of Rubblized Concrete from Surface Wave Testing
from Surface Wave Testing Nenad Gucunski Center for Advanced Infrastructure and Transportation (CAIT) Infrastructure Condition Monitoring Program (ICMP) 84 th Annual NESMEA Conference October 8, 2008 Route
More informationCHARACTERIZATION OF UNBOUND GRANULAR LAYERS IN FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS
CHARACTERIZATION OF UNBOUND GRANULAR LAYERS IN FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS RESEARCH REPORT ICAR - 502-3 Sponsored by the Aggregates Foundation for Technology, Research and Education Technical Report Documentation
More informationAdvanced Backcalculation of FWD Data on Asphalt Pavements
0 0 0 0 Advanced Backcalculation of FWD Data on Asphalt Pavements Carl Lenngren ( Sweco Civil,Vasagatan Västerås, Sweden, Carlsbox@telia.com) ABSTRACT Backcalculation of pavement layer moduli is a way
More informationSensitivity Analysis Of Aashto's 2002 Flexible And Rigid Pavement Design Methods
University of Central Florida Electronic Theses and Dissertations Masters Thesis (Open Access) Sensitivity Analysis Of Aashto's 2002 Flexible And Rigid Pavement Design Methods 2006 Sanjay Shahji University
More informationField Performance Monitoring and Modeling of Instrumented Pavement on I-35 in McClain County ANNUAL REPORT FOR FY 2010 ODOT SPR ITEM NUMBER 2200
Field Performance Monitoring and Modeling of Instrumented Pavement on I-35 in McClain County ANNUAL REPORT FOR FY 2010 ODOT SPR ITEM NUMBER 2200 Submitted to: Ginger McGovern, P.E. Planning and Research
More informationCalibration of Mechanistic-Empirical Fatigue Models Using the PaveLab Heavy Vehicle Simulator
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 Calibration of Mechanistic-Empirical Fatigue Models Using the PaveLab Heavy Vehicle Simulator Eliecer Arias-Barrantes 1, José Pablo Aguiar-Moya, Luis Guillermo Loría-Salazar,
More informationDEVELOPMENT OF METHODOLOGY TO INCLUDE THE STRENGTH CONTRIBUTION OF SELECT SUGRADE MATERIALS IN PAVEMENT STRUCTURE
WISCONSIN HIGHWAY RESEARCH PROGRAM #0092-03-12 DEVELOPMENT OF METHODOLOGY TO INCLUDE THE STRENGTH CONTRIBUTION OF SELECT SUGRADE MATERIALS IN PAVEMENT STRUCTURE A FINAL REPORT on the WHRP Project Strength
More informationNOTTINGHAM DESIGN METHOD
NOTTINGHAM DESIGN METHOD Dr Andrew Collop Reader in Civil Engineering University of Nottingham CONTENTS Introduction Traffic Design temperatures Material properties Allowable strains Asphalt thickness
More informationSTUDY ON EFFECTS OF NONLINIAR DISTRIBUTION AND SLAB THICKNESS ON THERMAL STRESS OF AIRPORT CONCRETE PAVEMENT
STUDY ON EFFECTS OF NONLINIAR DISTRIBUTION AND SLAB THICKNESS ON THERMAL STRESS OF AIRPORT CONCRETE PAVEMENT TSUBOKAWA, Yukitomo Airport Department, National Institute for Land and Infrastructure Management,
More informationTHE BEHAVIOUR OF FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT BY NONLINEAR FINITE ELEMENT METHOD
International Journal of Latest Research in Science and Technology Volume 3, Issue 1: Page No.537,January-February 214 http://www.mnkjournals.com/ijlrst.htm ISSN (Online):2278299 THE BEHAVIOUR OF FLEXIBLE
More information