Axiomatizations of Pareto Equilibria in Multicriteria Games
|
|
- Randall Baker
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 ames and Economc Behavor 28, Artcle ID game , avalable onlne at on Axomatzatons of Pareto Equlbra n Multcrtera ames Mark Voorneveld,* Dres Vermeulen, and Peter Borm Department of Econometrcs, Tlburg Unersty, P.O. Box 90153, 5000 LE Tlburg, The Netherlands Receved October 3, 1997 We focus on axomatzatons of the Pareto equlbrum concept n noncooperatve multcrtera games based on consstency. Some axomatzatons of the Nash equlbrum concept have mmedate generalzatons. For strategc games t was shown that there exst no consstent refnements of the Nash equlbrum concept that satsfy ndvdual ratonalty and nonemptness on a reasonably large class of games. We show that such refnements of the Pareto equlbrum concept on multcrtera games do exst. Journal of Economc Lterature Classfcaton Number: C Academc Press 1. INTRODUCTION In a recent manfesto, Bouyssou et al observe that wthn multcrtera decson makng. a systematc axomatc analyss of decson procedures and algorthms s yet to be carred out. In ths paper, several axomatzatons of the Pareto equlbrum concept for multcrtera games are provded. In multcrtera games, a player can have more than one crteron functon. Shapley ntroduced Pareto. equlbrum ponts for the type of games that are a straghtforward generalzaton of the Nash equlbrum concept for uncrteron games. Axomatc propertes of the Nash equlbrum concept based on the noton of consstency have been studed n several artcles, ncludng Peleg and Tjs 1996., Peleg, Potters, and Tjs 1996., and Norde et al Informally, consstency requres that f a strategy combnaton x s a soluton of a game wth player set N, and players outsde a coalton S of players commt to playng accordng to x N S,.e., the strategy combnaton restrcted to the players n N S, then x s a soluton of the reduced S *Correspondng author. E-mal: M.Voorneveld@kub.nl $30.00 Copyrght 1999 by Academc Press All rghts of reproducton n any form reserved. 146
2 AXIOMATIZATIONS OF PARETO EQUILIBRIA 147 game. Several of these axomatzatons carry over to multcrtera games. The strong result of Norde et al , characterzng the Nash equlbrum concept on the set of mxed extensons of fnte strategc form games by nonemptness, the selecton of utlty maxmzng strateges n one person games, and consstency, does not have such an analogon n multcrtera games: We show that nonemptness, consstency and an mmedate extenson of utlty maxmzaton are not suffcent to axomatze the Pareto equlbrum concept. An addtonal property s provded to establsh an axomatzaton. 2. PRELIMINARIES A fnte multcrtera game s a tuple ² N, X., u. : N N, where N s a fnte set of players, X s the fnte set of pure strateges of player N, and for each player N, the functon u : Ł j N Xj r. maps each strategy combnaton to a pont n r. -dmensonal Eucldean space. The nterpretaton of ths last functon s that player N consders not just one, but r. dfferent crtera. For notatonal convenence, the set of fnte multcrtera games s denoted fnte. The payoff functons are extended to mxed strateges n the obvous way. The set of mxed extensons of fnte multcrtera games s denoted by. Ths set contans the set strategc of mxed extensons of fnte games n strategc form, snce these are smply multcrtera games n whch each player has only one crteron. For notatonal convenence, let X. denote the set of probablty m m measures on a fnte set X, and for m, Ý 14 m 1 s the unt smplex n m. Let ² N, X., u. : N N be a multcrtera game, let. N x X be a strategy profle n, and let S 2, N 4 N be a proper subcoalton of the player set N. The reduced game S, x of wth respect to S and x s the multcrtera game n whch the player set s S; each player S has the same set X of pure strateges as n ; the payoff functons u. are defned by u y. u y, x. S S S N S for all y X.. S S Notce that ths s the game that arses f the players n N S commt to playng accordng to x N S, the strategy combnaton restrcted to the players n N S. Defntons for reduced games on fnte and strategc are completely analogous.
3 148 VOORNEVELD ET AL. A soluton concept on s a functon whch assgns to each element a subset. X. N of strategy combnatons. Analo- gously one defnes a soluton concept on strategc or fnte. For strategc form games, we recall the followng axoms. A soluton concept on satsfes: strategc Nonemptness ( NEM ),f. for all strategc; Utlty Maxmzaton ( UM ), f for each one player game ² 4, X, u : we have that. x X. u x. u y. strategc y X.4 ; Consstency ( CONS ), f for each game strategc, each proper N subcoalton S 2, N 4, and each element x., we have S, that x x.. S. Norde et al prove: PROPOSITION 2.1. A soluton concept on strategc satsfes NEM, UM, and CONS f and only f NE, the Nash equlbrum concept. Equlbrum ponts for multcrtera games are ntroduced by Shapley Let ² N, X., u. : N N be a multcrtera game. A Pareto equlbrum s a strategy combnaton x X. N such that for each N, there does not exst an x X. such that: u x, x. u x, x., where for two vectors a, b m, we wrte a b f aj bj for all j 1,..., m. The soluton concept on assgnng to each the set of Pareto equlbra s denoted by PE. The Pareto equlbrum concept PE on fnte s, of course, defned n a smlar way by restrctng attenton to pure, rather than mxed, strateges. Consder a multcrtera game n whch player has r. crtera. For each N, let r. be a vector of weghts for the crtera,. N. The -weghted game s the strategc form game wth player set N, mxed strategy spaces X.. N, and payoff. functons defned for all N and x X. by x. N N ².: r., u x Ý u x. k1 k k. If each player assgns equal weght to all 1. r. hs crtera,.e., r. 1,..., 1 for all N, the weghted game s denoted by. Shapley e proves that all Pareto equlbra can be found by a sutable weghng of the crtera of the players: LEMMA 2.2. For each : x PE. f and only f there exsts for each N a ector of weghts such that x NE.. r. As a corollary, Pareto equlbra always exst n mxed extensons of fnte multcrtera games, snce for any vector of weghts the game has Nash equlbra n mxed strateges.
4 AXIOMATIZATIONS OF PARETO EQUILIBRIA FINITE MULTICRITERIA AMES Peleg and Tjs and Peleg, Potters, and Tjs provde several axomatzatons of the Nash equlbrum concept for fnte strategc form games. In ths secton two of these axomatzatons are extended to fnte multcrtera games. We use the followng axoms. A soluton concept on satsfes: Restrcted Nonemptness ( r-nem ), f for every fnte wth PE. we have. ; One Person Effcency ( OPE ), f for each one player game ² 4, X, u : we have that. x X y X : u y. fnte u x.4 ; Consstency ( CONS ), f for each fnte, each proper subcoal- N ton S 2, N 4, and each element x., we have that S, x x. S ; Converse Consstency ( COCONS ), f for each fnte wth at least two players, we have that.., where fnte ½ 5 N S, x. x Ł X S 2, N 4: x S.. N Accordng to restrcted nonemptness, the soluton concept provdes a nonempty set of strateges whenever Pareto equlbra exst. One person effcency clams that n games wth only one player, the soluton concept pcks out all strateges whch yeld a maxmal payoff wth respect to the order. Consstency means that a soluton x of a game s also a soluton of each reduced game n whch the players that leave the game play accordng to the strateges n x. Converse consstency prescrbes that a strategy combnaton whch gves rse to a soluton n every reduced game s also a soluton of the orgnal game. Our frst result ndcates that the axomatzaton of the Nash equlbrum concept on fnte strategc games of Peleg, Potters, and Tjs 1996, Theorem 3. n terms of restrcted nonemptness, one person ratonalty and consstency can be generalzed to multcrtera games. THEOREM 3.1. A soluton concept on fnte satsfes r-nem, OPE, and CONS f and only f PE. Proof. It s clear that PE satsfes the axoms. Let be a soluton ² concept on fnte satsfyng r-nem, OPE, and CONS. Let N, X., u. :. We frst show that. PE. N N fnte. Let x..if N 1, then x PE. by OPE. If N 1, then CONS
5 150 VOORNEVELD ET AL. 4, mples that for each N : x x.,so x y X z X : u z, x. u y, x.4 by OPE. Hence, x s a Pareto equlbrum: x PE.. Snce fnte was chosen arbtrarly, conclude that PE. ² To prove the converse ncluson,.e., that PE, agan let N, X., u. : and let x PE. N N fnte ˆ. Construct a fnte multcrtera game H as follows: let m N ; the player set s N m 4; players N have the same strategy set X as n ; player m has strategy set 0, 14; payoff functons to players N are defned, for all x, x. m 0, 14 X, by: N u x. f xm 1 e r. x m, x. f x m 0, x ˆx e r. f x 0, x xˆ m where e r. r. s the vector wth each component equal to one. the payoff functon to player m s defned, for all x, x. m m 0, 14 X,by N 0 f xm 0 x, x m m. 1 f x m 1, x xˆ 1 f x m 1, x xˆ Smple verfcaton ndcates that 1, ˆx. s the unque Pareto equlbrum of H. Snce H. PE H. by the prevous part of the proof, we conclude.. N, 1, xˆ. by r-nem that 1, ˆx H. Then by CONS, ˆx H.., N, 1, xˆ. snce by defnton H. Hence ˆx., fnshng our proof. Our second result shows that the axomatzaton of the Nash equlbrum concept on fnte strategc games of Peleg and Tjs 1996, Theorem n terms of one person ratonalty, consstency and converse consstency can also be generalzed to multcrtera games. THEOREM 3.2. A soluton concept on fnte satsfes OPE, CONS, and COCONS f and only f PE. Proof. PE satsfes the axoms. Let be a soluton concept on fnte that also satsfes them. As n the proof of Theorem 3.1, we have that. PE. for each by OPE and CONS. To prove that fnte
6 AXIOMATIZATIONS OF PARETO EQUILIBRIA 151 PE.. for each fnte, we use nducton on the number of players. In one player games, the clam follows from OPE. Now assume the clam holds for all fnte multcrtera games wth at most n players and let be an n 1. -player game. By CONS of PE: PE. PE. fnte. By nducton: PE... By COCONS of :... Combnng these three nclusons: PE... These results seem to llustrate that the axomatzatons that exst n the lterature for the Nash equlbrum concept generalze to the Pareto equlbrum concept for multcrtera games. Ths analogy, however, breaks down when we consder mxed extensons of fnte multcrtera games, as s done n the next secton. 4. MIXED EXTENSIONS OF FINITE MULTICRITERIA AMES Norde et al characterze the Nash equlbrum concept on mxed extensons of fnte strategc form games by nonemptness, utlty maxmzaton, and consstency cf. Proposton In ths secton t s shown that analogons of these propertes are not suffcent to characterze the Pareto equlbrum concept n mxed extensons of fnte multcrtera games. Frst, we lst some of the axoms used n ths secton. A soluton concept on satsfes: Nonemptness ( NEM ),f. for each ; Weak One Person Effcency ( WOPE ), f for each one player game ² 4, X, u : we have that. x X. y X. : u y. u x.4 ; Consstency ( CONS ), f for each, each proper subcoalton N S 2, N 4, and each element x., we have that x S S, x.; Converse Consstency ( COCONS ), f for each wth at least two players, we have that.., where ½ 5 N S, x. x Ł X. S 2, N 4: xs.. N. It s easy to see that PE on satsfes NEM See Lemma 2.2, WOPE, and CONS. LEMMA 4.1. If a soluton concept on satsfes WOPE and CONS, then PE. Hence, PE s the unque maxmal-under-ncluson soluton concept that satsfes WOPE and CONS.
7 152 VOORNEVELD ET AL. Proof. Let be a soluton concept on, satsfyng WOPE and CONS. Let and x..if N 1, then x PE. by WOPE. If 4, N 1, then for each player N : x x. by CONS, so x y X. z X.: u z, x. u y, x.4 by WOPE. Hence, x s a Pareto equlbrum: x PE.. Obvously, PE s the largest soluton concept on satsfyng NEM, WOPE, and CONS, but not the only one, as our next result shows. THEOREM 4.2. There exsts a soluton concept on whch satsfes NEM, WOPE, and CONS, such that PE. Proof. Defne as follows. Let ² N, X., u. :. N N If N 1, take x X y X : u y u x PE.. Ths guarantees that satsfes WOPE. If N 1, take ½. x Ł X. N : y X. such that N u y, x. u x, x. 5, where for a, b m we wrte a b f aj bj for all j 1,..., m and a b. Shapley calls ths the set of strong equlbrum ponts and provdes an exstence theorem smlar to Lemma 2.2, thereby establshng NEM. It s easy to see that s also consstent. To show that PE, consder the game n Fg. 1, where both players have two pure strateges and two crtera. Obvously B, L. PE., but B, L.., snce u T, L. 1 u B, L.. 1 In order to arrve at an axomatzaton of PE, we requre an addtonal axom. A soluton concept on satsfes: WEIHT f for every game and each vector. N Ł of weghts:... N r. FIURE 1
8 AXIOMATIZATIONS OF PARETO EQUILIBRIA 153 The soluton concept satsfes WEIHT f for every weght vector, the solutons of the assocated weghted strategc form game are solutons of the underlyng multcrtera game. Our man result, usng the strong theorems of Norde et al and Shapley 1959., shows that the Pareto equlbrum concept s the unque soluton concept on satsfyng NEM, WOPE, CONS, and WEIHT. THEOREM 4.3. A soluton concept on satsfes NEM, WOPE, CONS, and WEIHT f and only f PE. Proof. Straghtforward verfcaton and applcaton of Lemma 2.2 ndcates that PE ndeed satsfes the four axoms. Now let be a soluton concept on satsfyng NEM, WOPE, CONS, and WEIHT. By Lemma 4.1, PE. Now let, and x PE.. Remans to show that x.. By Lemma 2.2, there exsts a vector. Ł N N r. of weghts such that x NE.. Notce that restrcted to strategc, the set of mxed extensons of strategc form games, satsfes NEM, UM, and CONS, and hence by Proposton 2.1, H. NE H. for all H strategc. Consequently,. NE. x. So by WEIHT: x.. Fnally, wthout proof, we menton that the analogon of Theorem 3.2 also holds when we consder mxed extensons: THEOREM 4.4. A soluton concept on satsfes OPE, CONS, and COCONS f and only f PE. It s an easy exercse to show that the axoms used n our theorems are logcally ndependent. Remark 4.5. In the proof of Theorem 4.2 we mentoned the strong Pareto equlbrum concept. By slght modfcatons n the axoms n partcular, to weak. one person strong effcency and a weght axom concernng strctly postve, rather than nonnegatve, weghts., all axomatzatons n Secs. 3 and 4 have analogons for the strong Pareto equlbrum concept. Also, a result analogous to Theorem 4.2 holds. To see ths, defne a soluton concept on as follows. Let ² N, X., u. : N N If N 1, take x X y X : u y u x. Ths guarantees that satsfes weak. one person strong effcency. If N 1, take. NE. e, the set of Nash equlbra of the scalarzed game n whch the players assgn equal weght to ther crtera. By the exstence of Nash equlbra n mxed extensons, satsfes NEM. It s easy to see that s also consstent. To show that s not equal to the strong Pareto equlbrum concept, refer agan to the game n Fg. 1.
9 154 VOORNEVELD ET AL. T, L. s a strong Pareto equlbrum of, but the weghted payoff to player 2 ncreases from 2 to 2 f he devates to R, ndcatng that T, L.. NE.. e REFERENCES Bouyssou, D., Perny, P., Prlot, M., Tsoukas, A., and Vncke, P A Manfesto for the New MCDA Era, J Mult-Crt. Decson Anal. 2, Norde, H., Potters, J., Rejnerse, H., and Vermeulen, D Equlbrum Selecton and Consstency, ames Econ. Behaor 12, Peleg, B., Potters, J., and Tjs, S Mnmalty of Consstent Solutons for Strategc ames, n Partcular for Potental ames, Econ. Theory 7, Peleg, B. and Tjs, S The Consstency Prncple for ames n Strategc Form, Int. J. ame Theory 25, Shapley, L. S Equlbrum Ponts n ames wth Vector Payoffs, Naal Res. Log. Quarterly 6, 5761.
Games of Threats. Elon Kohlberg Abraham Neyman. Working Paper
Games of Threats Elon Kohlberg Abraham Neyman Workng Paper 18-023 Games of Threats Elon Kohlberg Harvard Busness School Abraham Neyman The Hebrew Unversty of Jerusalem Workng Paper 18-023 Copyrght 2017
More informationInfinitely Split Nash Equilibrium Problems in Repeated Games
Infntely Splt ash Equlbrum Problems n Repeated Games Jnlu L Department of Mathematcs Shawnee State Unversty Portsmouth, Oho 4566 USA Abstract In ths paper, we ntroduce the concept of nfntely splt ash equlbrum
More informationCOS 521: Advanced Algorithms Game Theory and Linear Programming
COS 521: Advanced Algorthms Game Theory and Lnear Programmng Moses Charkar February 27, 2013 In these notes, we ntroduce some basc concepts n game theory and lnear programmng (LP). We show a connecton
More informationPerfect Competition and the Nash Bargaining Solution
Perfect Competton and the Nash Barganng Soluton Renhard John Department of Economcs Unversty of Bonn Adenauerallee 24-42 53113 Bonn, Germany emal: rohn@un-bonn.de May 2005 Abstract For a lnear exchange
More informationLinear, affine, and convex sets and hulls In the sequel, unless otherwise specified, X will denote a real vector space.
Lnear, affne, and convex sets and hulls In the sequel, unless otherwse specfed, X wll denote a real vector space. Lnes and segments. Gven two ponts x, y X, we defne xy = {x + t(y x) : t R} = {(1 t)x +
More informationExercise Solutions to Real Analysis
xercse Solutons to Real Analyss Note: References refer to H. L. Royden, Real Analyss xersze 1. Gven any set A any ɛ > 0, there s an open set O such that A O m O m A + ɛ. Soluton 1. If m A =, then there
More informationThe Second Anti-Mathima on Game Theory
The Second Ant-Mathma on Game Theory Ath. Kehagas December 1 2006 1 Introducton In ths note we wll examne the noton of game equlbrum for three types of games 1. 2-player 2-acton zero-sum games 2. 2-player
More information8.4 COMPLEX VECTOR SPACES AND INNER PRODUCTS
SECTION 8.4 COMPLEX VECTOR SPACES AND INNER PRODUCTS 493 8.4 COMPLEX VECTOR SPACES AND INNER PRODUCTS All the vector spaces you have studed thus far n the text are real vector spaces because the scalars
More informationAffine transformations and convexity
Affne transformatons and convexty The purpose of ths document s to prove some basc propertes of affne transformatons nvolvng convex sets. Here are a few onlne references for background nformaton: http://math.ucr.edu/
More informationA SURVEY OF PROPERTIES OF FINITE HORIZON DIFFERENTIAL GAMES UNDER ISAACS CONDITION. Contents
A SURVEY OF PROPERTIES OF FINITE HORIZON DIFFERENTIAL GAMES UNDER ISAACS CONDITION BOTAO WU Abstract. In ths paper, we attempt to answer the followng questons about dfferental games: 1) when does a two-player,
More informationAPPENDIX A Some Linear Algebra
APPENDIX A Some Lnear Algebra The collecton of m, n matrces A.1 Matrces a 1,1,..., a 1,n A = a m,1,..., a m,n wth real elements a,j s denoted by R m,n. If n = 1 then A s called a column vector. Smlarly,
More informationA note on the one-deviation property in extensive form games
Games and Economc Behavor 40 (2002) 322 338 www.academcpress.com Note A note on the one-devaton property n extensve form games Andrés Perea Departamento de Economía, Unversdad Carlos III de Madrd, Calle
More informationEconomics 101. Lecture 4 - Equilibrium and Efficiency
Economcs 0 Lecture 4 - Equlbrum and Effcency Intro As dscussed n the prevous lecture, we wll now move from an envronment where we looed at consumers mang decsons n solaton to analyzng economes full of
More informationSubjective Uncertainty Over Behavior Strategies: A Correction
Subjectve Uncertanty Over Behavor Strateges: A Correcton The Harvard communty has made ths artcle openly avalable. Please share how ths access benefts you. Your story matters. Ctaton Publshed Verson Accessed
More informationThe Order Relation and Trace Inequalities for. Hermitian Operators
Internatonal Mathematcal Forum, Vol 3, 08, no, 507-57 HIKARI Ltd, wwwm-hkarcom https://doorg/0988/mf088055 The Order Relaton and Trace Inequaltes for Hermtan Operators Y Huang School of Informaton Scence
More informationCOWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS YALE UNIVERSITY
Best Response Equvalence by Stephen Morrs and Takash U July 2002 COWLES FOUNDATION DISCUSSION PAPER NO. 1377 COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS YALE UNIVERSITY Box 208281 New Haven, Connectcut
More informationEdge Isoperimetric Inequalities
November 7, 2005 Ross M. Rchardson Edge Isopermetrc Inequaltes 1 Four Questons Recall that n the last lecture we looked at the problem of sopermetrc nequaltes n the hypercube, Q n. Our noton of boundary
More informationFACTORIZATION IN KRULL MONOIDS WITH INFINITE CLASS GROUP
C O L L O Q U I U M M A T H E M A T I C U M VOL. 80 1999 NO. 1 FACTORIZATION IN KRULL MONOIDS WITH INFINITE CLASS GROUP BY FLORIAN K A I N R A T H (GRAZ) Abstract. Let H be a Krull monod wth nfnte class
More informationIntroductory Cardinality Theory Alan Kaylor Cline
Introductory Cardnalty Theory lan Kaylor Clne lthough by name the theory of set cardnalty may seem to be an offshoot of combnatorcs, the central nterest s actually nfnte sets. Combnatorcs deals wth fnte
More informationGame Theory. Lecture Notes By Y. Narahari. Department of Computer Science and Automation Indian Institute of Science Bangalore, India February 2008
Game Theory Lecture Notes By Y. Narahar Department of Computer Scence and Automaton Indan Insttute of Scence Bangalore, Inda February 2008 Chapter 10: Two Person Zero Sum Games Note: Ths s a only a draft
More informationprinceton univ. F 17 cos 521: Advanced Algorithm Design Lecture 7: LP Duality Lecturer: Matt Weinberg
prnceton unv. F 17 cos 521: Advanced Algorthm Desgn Lecture 7: LP Dualty Lecturer: Matt Wenberg Scrbe: LP Dualty s an extremely useful tool for analyzng structural propertes of lnear programs. Whle there
More informationand problem sheet 2
-8 and 5-5 problem sheet Solutons to the followng seven exercses and optonal bonus problem are to be submtted through gradescope by :0PM on Wednesday th September 08. There are also some practce problems,
More informationSome basic inequalities. Definition. Let V be a vector space over the complex numbers. An inner product is given by a function, V V C
Some basc nequaltes Defnton. Let V be a vector space over the complex numbers. An nner product s gven by a functon, V V C (x, y) x, y satsfyng the followng propertes (for all x V, y V and c C) (1) x +
More informationAppendix B. Criterion of Riemann-Stieltjes Integrability
Appendx B. Crteron of Remann-Steltes Integrablty Ths note s complementary to [R, Ch. 6] and [T, Sec. 3.5]. The man result of ths note s Theorem B.3, whch provdes the necessary and suffcent condtons for
More informationA note on almost sure behavior of randomly weighted sums of φ-mixing random variables with φ-mixing weights
ACTA ET COMMENTATIONES UNIVERSITATIS TARTUENSIS DE MATHEMATICA Volume 7, Number 2, December 203 Avalable onlne at http://acutm.math.ut.ee A note on almost sure behavor of randomly weghted sums of φ-mxng
More informationMore metrics on cartesian products
More metrcs on cartesan products If (X, d ) are metrc spaces for 1 n, then n Secton II4 of the lecture notes we defned three metrcs on X whose underlyng topologes are the product topology The purpose of
More informationOn the Operation A in Analysis Situs. by Kazimierz Kuratowski
v1.3 10/17 On the Operaton A n Analyss Stus by Kazmerz Kuratowsk Author s note. Ths paper s the frst part slghtly modfed of my thess presented May 12, 1920 at the Unversty of Warsaw for the degree of Doctor
More informationEcon107 Applied Econometrics Topic 3: Classical Model (Studenmund, Chapter 4)
I. Classcal Assumptons Econ7 Appled Econometrcs Topc 3: Classcal Model (Studenmund, Chapter 4) We have defned OLS and studed some algebrac propertes of OLS. In ths topc we wll study statstcal propertes
More informationSupplement to Clustering with Statistical Error Control
Supplement to Clusterng wth Statstcal Error Control Mchael Vogt Unversty of Bonn Matthas Schmd Unversty of Bonn In ths supplement, we provde the proofs that are omtted n the paper. In partcular, we derve
More informationModeling values for TU-games using generalized versions of consistency, standardness and the null player property
ath eth Oper Res (2016) 83:179 205 DOI 10.1007/s00186-015-0525-x ORIGINAL ARTICLE odelng values for TU-games usng generalzed versons of consstency, standardness and the null player property Tadeusz Radzk
More informationOn the set of natural numbers
On the set of natural numbers by Jalton C. Ferrera Copyrght 2001 Jalton da Costa Ferrera Introducton The natural numbers have been understood as fnte numbers, ths wor tres to show that the natural numbers
More informationON THE EQUIVALENCE OF ORDINAL BAYESIAN INCENTIVE COMPATIBILITY AND DOMINANT STRATEGY INCENTIVE COMPATIBILITY FOR RANDOM RULES
ON THE EQUIVALENCE OF ORDINAL BAYESIAN INCENTIVE COMPATIBILITY AND DOMINANT STRATEGY INCENTIVE COMPATIBILITY FOR RANDOM RULES Madhuparna Karmokar 1 and Souvk Roy 1 1 Economc Research Unt, Indan Statstcal
More informationLinear Algebra and its Applications
Lnear Algebra and ts Applcatons 4 (00) 5 56 Contents lsts avalable at ScenceDrect Lnear Algebra and ts Applcatons journal homepage: wwwelsevercom/locate/laa Notes on Hlbert and Cauchy matrces Mroslav Fedler
More informationOnline Appendix. t=1 (p t w)q t. Then the first order condition shows that
Artcle forthcomng to ; manuscrpt no (Please, provde the manuscrpt number!) 1 Onlne Appendx Appendx E: Proofs Proof of Proposton 1 Frst we derve the equlbrum when the manufacturer does not vertcally ntegrate
More informationCanonical transformations
Canoncal transformatons November 23, 2014 Recall that we have defned a symplectc transformaton to be any lnear transformaton M A B leavng the symplectc form nvarant, Ω AB M A CM B DΩ CD Coordnate transformatons,
More information12 MATH 101A: ALGEBRA I, PART C: MULTILINEAR ALGEBRA. 4. Tensor product
12 MATH 101A: ALGEBRA I, PART C: MULTILINEAR ALGEBRA Here s an outlne of what I dd: (1) categorcal defnton (2) constructon (3) lst of basc propertes (4) dstrbutve property (5) rght exactness (6) localzaton
More informationA CHARACTERIZATION OF ADDITIVE DERIVATIONS ON VON NEUMANN ALGEBRAS
Journal of Mathematcal Scences: Advances and Applcatons Volume 25, 2014, Pages 1-12 A CHARACTERIZATION OF ADDITIVE DERIVATIONS ON VON NEUMANN ALGEBRAS JIA JI, WEN ZHANG and XIAOFEI QI Department of Mathematcs
More informationCS286r Assign One. Answer Key
CS286r Assgn One Answer Key 1 Game theory 1.1 1.1.1 Let off-equlbrum strateges also be that people contnue to play n Nash equlbrum. Devatng from any Nash equlbrum s a weakly domnated strategy. That s,
More informationRandom Walks on Digraphs
Random Walks on Dgraphs J. J. P. Veerman October 23, 27 Introducton Let V = {, n} be a vertex set and S a non-negatve row-stochastc matrx (.e. rows sum to ). V and S defne a dgraph G = G(V, S) and a drected
More informationBallot Paths Avoiding Depth Zero Patterns
Ballot Paths Avodng Depth Zero Patterns Henrch Nederhausen and Shaun Sullvan Florda Atlantc Unversty, Boca Raton, Florda nederha@fauedu, ssull21@fauedu 1 Introducton In a paper by Sapounaks, Tasoulas,
More informationStructure and Drive Paul A. Jensen Copyright July 20, 2003
Structure and Drve Paul A. Jensen Copyrght July 20, 2003 A system s made up of several operatons wth flow passng between them. The structure of the system descrbes the flow paths from nputs to outputs.
More informationThe First Steps with Alexia, the Average Lexicographic Value Tijs, S.H.
Tlburg Unversty The Frst Steps wth Alexa, the Average Lexcographc Value Tjs, S.H. Publcaton date: 2005 Lnk to publcaton Ctaton for publshed verson (APA): Tjs, S. H. (2005). The Frst Steps wth Alexa, the
More informationTHERE ARE INFINITELY MANY FIBONACCI COMPOSITES WITH PRIME SUBSCRIPTS
Research and Communcatons n Mathematcs and Mathematcal Scences Vol 10, Issue 2, 2018, Pages 123-140 ISSN 2319-6939 Publshed Onlne on November 19, 2018 2018 Jyot Academc Press http://jyotacademcpressorg
More informationConvexity preserving interpolation by splines of arbitrary degree
Computer Scence Journal of Moldova, vol.18, no.1(52), 2010 Convexty preservng nterpolaton by splnes of arbtrary degree Igor Verlan Abstract In the present paper an algorthm of C 2 nterpolaton of dscrete
More informationVoting Games with Positive Weights and. Dummy Players: Facts and Theory
Appled Mathematcal Scences, Vol 10, 2016, no 53, 2637-2646 HIKARI Ltd, wwwm-hkarcom http://dxdoorg/1012988/ams201667209 Votng Games wth Postve Weghts and Dummy Players: Facts and Theory Zdravko Dmtrov
More information2.3 Nilpotent endomorphisms
s a block dagonal matrx, wth A Mat dm U (C) In fact, we can assume that B = B 1 B k, wth B an ordered bass of U, and that A = [f U ] B, where f U : U U s the restrcton of f to U 40 23 Nlpotent endomorphsms
More informationMAT 578 Functional Analysis
MAT 578 Functonal Analyss John Qugg Fall 2008 Locally convex spaces revsed September 6, 2008 Ths secton establshes the fundamental propertes of locally convex spaces. Acknowledgment: although I wrote these
More informationWeek 2. This week, we covered operations on sets and cardinality.
Week 2 Ths week, we covered operatons on sets and cardnalty. Defnton 0.1 (Correspondence). A correspondence between two sets A and B s a set S contaned n A B = {(a, b) a A, b B}. A correspondence from
More informationTit-For-Tat Equilibria in Discounted Repeated Games with. Private Monitoring
1 Tt-For-Tat Equlbra n Dscounted Repeated Games wth Prvate Montorng Htosh Matsushma 1 Department of Economcs, Unversty of Tokyo 2 Aprl 24, 2007 Abstract We nvestgate nfntely repeated games wth mperfect
More informationA combinatorial problem associated with nonograms
A combnatoral problem assocated wth nonograms Jessca Benton Ron Snow Nolan Wallach March 21, 2005 1 Introducton. Ths work was motvated by a queston posed by the second named author to the frst named author
More informationFoundations of Arithmetic
Foundatons of Arthmetc Notaton We shall denote the sum and product of numbers n the usual notaton as a 2 + a 2 + a 3 + + a = a, a 1 a 2 a 3 a = a The notaton a b means a dvdes b,.e. ac = b where c s an
More informationThe Myerson value in terms of the link agent form: a technical note
The Myerson value n terms of the lnk agent form: a techncal note André Casajus (September 2008, ths verson: October 1, 2008, 18:16) Abstract We represent the Myerson (1977) value n terms of the value ntroduced
More informationn α j x j = 0 j=1 has a nontrivial solution. Here A is the n k matrix whose jth column is the vector for all t j=0
MODULE 2 Topcs: Lnear ndependence, bass and dmenson We have seen that f n a set of vectors one vector s a lnear combnaton of the remanng vectors n the set then the span of the set s unchanged f that vector
More informationInner Product. Euclidean Space. Orthonormal Basis. Orthogonal
Inner Product Defnton 1 () A Eucldean space s a fnte-dmensonal vector space over the reals R, wth an nner product,. Defnton 2 (Inner Product) An nner product, on a real vector space X s a symmetrc, blnear,
More informationComplete subgraphs in multipartite graphs
Complete subgraphs n multpartte graphs FLORIAN PFENDER Unverstät Rostock, Insttut für Mathematk D-18057 Rostock, Germany Floran.Pfender@un-rostock.de Abstract Turán s Theorem states that every graph G
More informationConstant Best-Response Functions: Interpreting Cournot
Internatonal Journal of Busness and Economcs, 009, Vol. 8, No., -6 Constant Best-Response Functons: Interpretng Cournot Zvan Forshner Department of Economcs, Unversty of Hafa, Israel Oz Shy * Research
More informationMaximizing the number of nonnegative subsets
Maxmzng the number of nonnegatve subsets Noga Alon Hao Huang December 1, 213 Abstract Gven a set of n real numbers, f the sum of elements of every subset of sze larger than k s negatve, what s the maxmum
More information42. Mon, Dec. 8 Last time, we were discussing CW complexes, and we considered two di erent CW structures on S n. We continue with more examples.
42. Mon, Dec. 8 Last tme, we were dscussng CW complexes, and we consdered two d erent CW structures on S n. We contnue wth more examples. (2) RP n. Let s start wth RP 2. Recall that one model for ths space
More informationGenericity of Critical Types
Genercty of Crtcal Types Y-Chun Chen Alfredo D Tllo Eduardo Fangold Syang Xong September 2008 Abstract Ely and Pesk 2008 offers an nsghtful characterzaton of crtcal types: a type s crtcal f and only f
More informationCHAPTER III Neural Networks as Associative Memory
CHAPTER III Neural Networs as Assocatve Memory Introducton One of the prmary functons of the bran s assocatve memory. We assocate the faces wth names, letters wth sounds, or we can recognze the people
More informationCompetition and Efficiency in Congested Markets
Competton and Effcency n Congested Markets Daron Acemoglu Department of Economcs Massachusetts Insttute of Technology Asuman E. Ozdaglar Department of Electrcal Engneerng and Computer Scence Massachusetts
More informationFINITELY-GENERATED MODULES OVER A PRINCIPAL IDEAL DOMAIN
FINITELY-GENERTED MODULES OVER PRINCIPL IDEL DOMIN EMMNUEL KOWLSKI Throughout ths note, s a prncpal deal doman. We recall the classfcaton theorem: Theorem 1. Let M be a fntely-generated -module. (1) There
More informationAbstract Single Crossing and the Value Dimension
Abstract Sngle Crossng and the Value Dmenson Davd Rahman September 24, 2007 Abstract When auctonng an ndvsble good wthout consumpton externaltes, abstract sngle crossng s necessary and suffcent to mplement
More informationa b a In case b 0, a being divisible by b is the same as to say that
Secton 6.2 Dvsblty among the ntegers An nteger a ε s dvsble by b ε f there s an nteger c ε such that a = bc. Note that s dvsble by any nteger b, snce = b. On the other hand, a s dvsble by only f a = :
More informationGeneral viscosity iterative method for a sequence of quasi-nonexpansive mappings
Avalable onlne at www.tjnsa.com J. Nonlnear Sc. Appl. 9 (2016), 5672 5682 Research Artcle General vscosty teratve method for a sequence of quas-nonexpansve mappngs Cuje Zhang, Ynan Wang College of Scence,
More informationREAL ANALYSIS I HOMEWORK 1
REAL ANALYSIS I HOMEWORK CİHAN BAHRAN The questons are from Tao s text. Exercse 0.0.. If (x α ) α A s a collecton of numbers x α [0, + ] such that x α
More informationDIFFERENTIAL FORMS BRIAN OSSERMAN
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS BRIAN OSSERMAN Dfferentals are an mportant topc n algebrac geometry, allowng the use of some classcal geometrc arguments n the context of varetes over any feld. We wll use them to defne
More informationAssortment Optimization under MNL
Assortment Optmzaton under MNL Haotan Song Aprl 30, 2017 1 Introducton The assortment optmzaton problem ams to fnd the revenue-maxmzng assortment of products to offer when the prces of products are fxed.
More informationAli Omer Alattass Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science, Hadramout University of science and Technology, P. O. Box 50663, Mukalla, Yemen
Journal of athematcs and Statstcs 7 (): 4448, 0 ISSN 5493644 00 Scence Publcatons odules n σ[] wth Chan Condtons on Small Submodules Al Omer Alattass Department of athematcs, Faculty of Scence, Hadramout
More information3.1 Expectation of Functions of Several Random Variables. )' be a k-dimensional discrete or continuous random vector, with joint PMF p (, E X E X1 E X
Statstcs 1: Probablty Theory II 37 3 EPECTATION OF SEVERAL RANDOM VARIABLES As n Probablty Theory I, the nterest n most stuatons les not on the actual dstrbuton of a random vector, but rather on a number
More informationAn (almost) unbiased estimator for the S-Gini index
An (almost unbased estmator for the S-Gn ndex Thomas Demuynck February 25, 2009 Abstract Ths note provdes an unbased estmator for the absolute S-Gn and an almost unbased estmator for the relatve S-Gn for
More information(1 ) (1 ) 0 (1 ) (1 ) 0
Appendx A Appendx A contans proofs for resubmsson "Contractng Informaton Securty n the Presence of Double oral Hazard" Proof of Lemma 1: Assume that, to the contrary, BS efforts are achevable under a blateral
More informationNotes on Frequency Estimation in Data Streams
Notes on Frequency Estmaton n Data Streams In (one of) the data streamng model(s), the data s a sequence of arrvals a 1, a 2,..., a m of the form a j = (, v) where s the dentty of the tem and belongs to
More information20. Mon, Oct. 13 What we have done so far corresponds roughly to Chapters 2 & 3 of Lee. Now we turn to Chapter 4. The first idea is connectedness.
20. Mon, Oct. 13 What we have done so far corresponds roughly to Chapters 2 & 3 of Lee. Now we turn to Chapter 4. The frst dea s connectedness. Essentally, we want to say that a space cannot be decomposed
More informationCommon Belief Foundations of Global Games
Common Belef Foundatons of Global Games Stephen Morrs Prnceton Unversty Hyun Song Shn Bank for Internatonal Settlements November 2015 Muhamet Yldz M.I.T. Abstract We study coordnaton games under general
More informationAccepted Manuscript. Games of threats. Elon Kohlberg, Abraham Neyman S (17) Reference: YGAME Received date: 30 August 2017
Accepted Manuscrpt Games of threats Elon Kohlberg, Abraham Neyman PII: S0899-8256(7)3090-2 DOI: https://do.org/0.06/j.geb.207.0.08 eference: YGAME 277 To appear n: Games and Economc Behavor eceved date:
More informationPricing and Resource Allocation Game Theoretic Models
Prcng and Resource Allocaton Game Theoretc Models Zhy Huang Changbn Lu Q Zhang Computer and Informaton Scence December 8, 2009 Z. Huang, C. Lu, and Q. Zhang (CIS) Game Theoretc Models December 8, 2009
More informationWelfare Properties of General Equilibrium. What can be said about optimality properties of resource allocation implied by general equilibrium?
APPLIED WELFARE ECONOMICS AND POLICY ANALYSIS Welfare Propertes of General Equlbrum What can be sad about optmalty propertes of resource allocaton mpled by general equlbrum? Any crteron used to compare
More informationCONJUGACY IN THOMPSON S GROUP F. 1. Introduction
CONJUGACY IN THOMPSON S GROUP F NICK GILL AND IAN SHORT Abstract. We complete the program begun by Brn and Squer of charactersng conjugacy n Thompson s group F usng the standard acton of F as a group of
More informationBOUNDEDNESS OF THE RIESZ TRANSFORM WITH MATRIX A 2 WEIGHTS
BOUNDEDNESS OF THE IESZ TANSFOM WITH MATIX A WEIGHTS Introducton Let L = L ( n, be the functon space wth norm (ˆ f L = f(x C dx d < For a d d matrx valued functon W : wth W (x postve sem-defnte for all
More informationOpen Systems: Chemical Potential and Partial Molar Quantities Chemical Potential
Open Systems: Chemcal Potental and Partal Molar Quanttes Chemcal Potental For closed systems, we have derved the followng relatonshps: du = TdS pdv dh = TdS + Vdp da = SdT pdv dg = VdP SdT For open systems,
More informationJournal of Mathematical Economics
Journal of Mathematcal Economcs 46 (2010) 393 399 Contents lsts avalable at ScenceDrect Journal of Mathematcal Economcs journal homepage: www.elsever.com/locate/jmateco A note on the evaluaton of nformaton
More informationAnti-van der Waerden numbers of 3-term arithmetic progressions.
Ant-van der Waerden numbers of 3-term arthmetc progressons. Zhanar Berkkyzy, Alex Schulte, and Mchael Young Aprl 24, 2016 Abstract The ant-van der Waerden number, denoted by aw([n], k), s the smallest
More informationTHE CHINESE REMAINDER THEOREM. We should thank the Chinese for their wonderful remainder theorem. Glenn Stevens
THE CHINESE REMAINDER THEOREM KEITH CONRAD We should thank the Chnese for ther wonderful remander theorem. Glenn Stevens 1. Introducton The Chnese remander theorem says we can unquely solve any par of
More informationAnother converse of Jensen s inequality
Another converse of Jensen s nequalty Slavko Smc Abstract. We gve the best possble global bounds for a form of dscrete Jensen s nequalty. By some examples ts frutfulness s shown. 1. Introducton Throughout
More informationLectures - Week 4 Matrix norms, Conditioning, Vector Spaces, Linear Independence, Spanning sets and Basis, Null space and Range of a Matrix
Lectures - Week 4 Matrx norms, Condtonng, Vector Spaces, Lnear Independence, Spannng sets and Bass, Null space and Range of a Matrx Matrx Norms Now we turn to assocatng a number to each matrx. We could
More informationCOMPUTING THE NORM OF A MATRIX
COMPUTING THE NORM OF A MATRIX KEITH CONRAD 1. Introducton In R n there s a standard noton of length: the sze of a vector v = (a 1,..., a n ) s v = a 2 1 + + a2 n. We wll dscuss n Secton 2 the general
More informationCHAPTER 4. Vector Spaces
man 2007/2/16 page 234 CHAPTER 4 Vector Spaces To crtcze mathematcs for ts abstracton s to mss the pont entrel. Abstracton s what makes mathematcs work. Ian Stewart The man am of ths tet s to stud lnear
More informationCounterexamples to the Connectivity Conjecture of the Mixed Cells
Dscrete Comput Geom 2:55 52 998 Dscrete & Computatonal Geometry 998 Sprnger-Verlag New York Inc. Counterexamples to the Connectvty Conjecture of the Mxed Cells T. Y. L and X. Wang 2 Department of Mathematcs
More informationSmooth Games, Price of Anarchy and Composability of Auctions - a Quick Tutorial
Smooth Games, Prce of Anarchy and Composablty of Auctons - a Quck Tutoral Abhshek Snha Laboratory for Informaton and Decson Systems, Massachusetts Insttute of Technology, Cambrdge, MA 02139 Emal: snhaa@mt.edu
More informationMarket structure and Innovation
Market structure and Innovaton Ths presentaton s based on the paper Market structure and Innovaton authored by Glenn C. Loury, publshed n The Quarterly Journal of Economcs, Vol. 93, No.3 ( Aug 1979) I.
More informationFinite State Equilibria in Dynamic Games
Fnte State Equlbra n Dynamc Games Mchhro Kandor Faculty of Economcs Unversty of Tokyo Ichro Obara Department of Economcs UCLA June 21, 2007 Abstract An equlbrum n an nfnte horzon game s called a fnte state
More informationU.C. Berkeley CS294: Beyond Worst-Case Analysis Luca Trevisan September 5, 2017
U.C. Berkeley CS94: Beyond Worst-Case Analyss Handout 4s Luca Trevsan September 5, 07 Summary of Lecture 4 In whch we ntroduce semdefnte programmng and apply t to Max Cut. Semdefnte Programmng Recall that
More informationRepresentation theory and quantum mechanics tutorial Representation theory and quantum conservation laws
Representaton theory and quantum mechancs tutoral Representaton theory and quantum conservaton laws Justn Campbell August 1, 2017 1 Generaltes on representaton theory 1.1 Let G GL m (R) be a real algebrac
More informationMechanisms with Evidence: Commitment and Robustness 1
Mechansms wth Evdence: Commtment and Robustness 1 Elchanan Ben-Porath 2 Edde Dekel 3 Barton L. Lpman 4 Frst Draft January 2017 1 We thank the Natonal Scence Foundaton, grant SES 0820333 (Dekel), and the
More informationComputing Correlated Equilibria in Multi-Player Games
Computng Correlated Equlbra n Mult-Player Games Chrstos H. Papadmtrou Presented by Zhanxang Huang December 7th, 2005 1 The Author Dr. Chrstos H. Papadmtrou CS professor at UC Berkley (taught at Harvard,
More informationExample: (13320, 22140) =? Solution #1: The divisors of are 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 9, 10, 12, 15, 18, 20, 27, 30, 36, 41,
The greatest common dvsor of two ntegers a and b (not both zero) s the largest nteger whch s a common factor of both a and b. We denote ths number by gcd(a, b), or smply (a, b) when there s no confuson
More informationTemperature. Chapter Heat Engine
Chapter 3 Temperature In prevous chapters of these notes we ntroduced the Prncple of Maxmum ntropy as a technque for estmatng probablty dstrbutons consstent wth constrants. In Chapter 9 we dscussed the
More informationOn the existence of essential and trembling-hand perfect equilibria in discontinuous games
Econ Theory Bull (2014) 2:1 12 DOI 10.1007/s40505-013-0021-5 RESEARCH ARTICLE On the exstence of essental and tremblng-hand perfect equlbra n dscontnuous games Vncenzo Scalzo Receved: 31 August 2013 /
More informationVolume 18 Figure 1. Notation 1. Notation 2. Observation 1. Remark 1. Remark 2. Remark 3. Remark 4. Remark 5. Remark 6. Theorem A [2]. Theorem B [2].
Bulletn of Mathematcal Scences and Applcatons Submtted: 016-04-07 ISSN: 78-9634, Vol. 18, pp 1-10 Revsed: 016-09-08 do:10.1805/www.scpress.com/bmsa.18.1 Accepted: 016-10-13 017 ScPress Ltd., Swtzerland
More information