arxiv: v1 [astro-ph.sr] 15 Nov 2015

Transcription

1 Research in Astronomy and Astrophysics manuscript no. (L A TEX: fa.te; printed on July 7, 8; :) arxiv:.v [astro-ph.sr] Nov Mode coupling in solar spicule oscillations Z. Fael Astrophysics Department, Physics Faculty, University of Tabri, Tabri, Iran; fael@tabriu.ac.ir Abstract In a real medium which has oscillations, the perturbations can cause the energy transfer between different modes. The perturbation interpreted as an interaction between the modes is inferred as mode coupling. Mode coupling process in an inhomogeneous medium such as solar spicules may lead to the coupling of kink waves to local Alfvén waves. This coupling occurs practically in any conditions when there is smooth variation in density in the radial direction. This process is seen as the decay of transverse kink waves in the medium. To study the damping of kink waves due to mode coupling, a.-dimensional numerical simulation of the initial wave is considered in spicules. The initial perturbation is assumed to be in a plane perpendicular to the spicule ais. The considered kink wave is a standing wave which shows an eponential damping in the inhomogeneous layer after occurrence of the mode coupling. Key words: Solar spicules mode coupling MHD waves INTRODUCTION Spicules are one of the important phenomena in the solar chromosphere which are observed at the limb (Zaqarashvili & Erdélyi (9)). In order to study the oscillations in spicules, many works have been done observationally and theoretically (De Pontieu et al. (), Kukhianide et al. (6), Kuride et al. (), Verth et al. ()). The generation and propagation of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves in the interval of the spicule lifetime (about min.) can be detected by spicule observations. Helioseismology can determine the properties of the solar phenomena from the observed oscillations which was originally suggested by Zaqarashvili et al. (7) for the chromospheric spicules (Verth et al. ()). By estimating the period of oscillations, two types of MHD waves are observed in spicules: kink waves (Nikolski & Platova (97), De Pontieu et al. (7), He et al. (9a), Ebadi et al. ()) and Alfvén waves reported by Jess et al. (9). Since spicules are denser than surrounding coronal plasma (Beckers (968)), they can be modeled as cool magnetic tubes embedded in hot coronal plasma. Damping of MHD waves (kink or Alfvén waves) can be considered as mechanisms of the solar coronal heating. When MHD waves interact with plasma inhomogeneities, a number of physical phenomena is

2 Z. Fael The conversion of energy from the incompressible kink mode to an Alfvén wave describe mode coupling process in an inhomogeneous medium. This process can take place in each oscillating phenomena. For eample in sunspots, it takes place between the p-mode seismic wave field of the solar interior and the oscillations in the overlying atmosphere (conversion of fast to slow modes) (Cally et al. (99)). Pascoe et al. () have studied the damping of kink waves due to mode coupling in solar coronal loops. They have demonstrated that the observed loop displacements are the coupled kink-alfvén waves, i.e. transverse footpoint motions travel along the loop and through the inhomogeneity at the loop boundary couple to Alfvén waves. At the presence of an inhomogeneous layer, the Alfvén speed varies continuously and resonant absorption occurs where the phase speed of the kink wave matches the local Alfvén wave speed (C k = V A (r)) (Allan & Wright (), Hood et al. ()). Terradas et al. () demonstrated that the damping of the transverse motions through mode coupling is frequency dependent. Using the CoMP data (Tomcyk & McIntosh (9)), Verth et al. () found evidence for this frequency that strengthen the interpretation of the observed propagating Doppler shift oscillations as the coupled kink- Alfvén waves. Here, we study the damping of the observed transverse oscillations of the solar spicule ais. This study is referring to the results obtained by analying of the time series of Ca II H-line obtained from Hinode/SOT on the solar limb Tsuneta et al. (8). These observed transverse oscillations were interpreted as standing kink waves (Ebadi et al. ()). This paper is organied as follows. The basic equations and theoretical model are presented in section. In section, numerical results are presented and discussed, and section contains the conclusion. BASIC EQUATIONS OF MODEL The damping of standing kink waves is studied in a spicule environment through the mode coupling mechanism. We perform a.-dimensional simulation of MHD equations in a stratified medium. Non-ideal MHD equations in the plasma dynamics are as follows: ρ + (ρv) =, t () ρ V t +ρ(v )V = p+ρg+ ( B) B+ρν V, µ () B = (V B), B =, t () p + (pv) = ( γ)p V. t () where p = ρrt/µ is the pressure for the perfect gas; ρ is the plasma density, µ is the mean molecular weight,µ is the vacuum permeability,ν is constant viscosity coefficient,γ = / is the adiabatic inde,g is the gravitational acceleration. And we apply ρν =. 7 T / kg m s for a fully ionied H plasma (Priest (98)).. The equilibrium state VectorsV andbin Eqs. - are the velocity and magnetic field which are defined as follows: V = v + v,

3 Mode coupling where v = v ˆk and B are the equilibrium velocity and magnetic field. In order to have the kink waves coupled with Alfvén waves, the equilibrium magnetic field is considered as B = B (αĵ +ˆk) whereα is a constant value (α < ). In this case, the y-component of the magnetic field is smaller than its -component by the factor α. Since the equilibrium magnetic field is force-free, the pressure gradient is balanced by the gravity force via this equation p (,) + ρ (,)g =, where g=(,, g), and the pressure in an equilibrium state is: p (,) = p () ep( /H). (6) Since coupling between kink and Alfvén waves occurs practically in any conditions when there is smooth density variations in the radial direction (here, -direction) (Ruderman & Roberts (), Soler et al. ()), the density profile is written in the following form: ρ (,) = ρ () ep( /H), (7) where H = RT µg is the pressure scale height and the atmosphere is considered isothermal. And ρ () is considered as (De Moortel et al. (999), Ruderman & Roberts (), Karami & Ebrahimi (9)): ρ () = ρ [+d ρ ( d ρ )tanh(( )/d)]. (8) here, d ρ = ρe ρ =. where ρ is the plasma density in the spicule and ρ e is the eternal density, and d is the width of inhomogeneous layer.. Perturbation Equations In order to make the continuous displacements of the tube ais of a spicule, the perturbation in the velocity and magnetic field is considered at the lower boundary of the tube. Vectorsv andbin Eq. are the perturbed velocity and magnetic field which are defined as v = (v,v y,v ) and b = (b,b y,b ), respectively. The initial perturbed velocity is considered as two dimensional dipole form as introduced by Pascoe et al. (): v (,,t = ) = ( + ), v y (,,t = ) = ( + ), v (,,t = ) = A v sin(π)sin(π). (9) and (b,b y,b )(,,t = ) = A b sin(π)sin(π), p(,,t = ) = A p sin(π)sin(π). () where A v, A b and A p are the small amplitudes of the perturbed velocity, magnetic field and pressure (by choosing these small amplitudes, the components tend almost to ero. These choices are made to avoid of some unwanted effects in our simulation code).

4 Z. Fael equations with considered assumptions are as follows: v t +v v = ρ (,) ( b α b y b )+ν v, v y t +v v y = ρ (,) v t +v v = β P g + α ρ (,) b y +ν v y b y +ν v, () b t = v v b, b y t = v y v b y, b t = v v b. () where β() = p() is the ratio of gas pressure to magnetic pressure. The boundary conditions for a B /µ standing formalism are considered v = and b = at =, L. Hence by considering these conditions in Eq., we havep = at =,L (Ruderman & Roberts ()). DISCUSSION In order to solve the coupled Eqs., and numerically, the finite difference and the Fourth-Order Runge- Kutta methods are used to take the space and time derivatives, respectively. The implemented numerical scheme is using by the forward finite difference method to take the first spatial derivatives with the truncation error of ( ), which is the spatial resolution in the direction. The order of approimation for the second spatial derivative in the finite difference method is O(( ) ). On the other hand, the Fourth-order Runge-Kutta method takes the time derivatives in the questions. The computational output data are given in 7 decimal digits of accuracy (Fael & Ebadi ()). We set the number of mesh-grid points as6 6. The time step is chosen as., and the system length in the and dimensions (simulation bo sies) are set to be (,) and (,). In considered spicule condition, the value of the all presented parameters are (Murawski & Zaqarashvili (), Ebadi et al. (), Fael & Ebadi ()):L = 6 km (spicule length),a = km (spicule radius),d =.a = km (inhomogeneous layer width),n e =. 6 m,v A = km/s, v = km/s, B =. Tesla, T = K, p =.7 N m, ρ =.9 kg m, g = 7 m s, R = 8 m s k (universal gas constant), H = 7 km, µ =.6, µ = π 7 Tesla m A, τ = a/c k = s (the period of oscillations), A v = A b = A p = 8 (dimensionless amplitudes of perturbed velocity, magnetic field and pressure). Considering Eqs., and, the y-component of the velocity and the magnetic field define the y- independent Alfvén waves. By rewriting the y-component of these equations and by combining them, we can obtain ρ [ v y t +(v ) v y t ] = µ [(B ) v y (v )b y ]+ρ ν v y t () This equation describes the damped Alfvén waves that have velocity and magnetic field perturbations in the y-direction and propagate along the equilibrium magnetic field. If for a moment we forget about ν and adopt

5 Mode coupling... v (,,t=) v y (,,t=) Fig. The initial wave packet (v andv y ) is showed at t = s. parallel wave number andv A is the local Alfvén velocity. The second row of Eqs., and describes the damped Alfvén waves which are coupled with the first and third rows of Eqs., and. The equations tell us that a transfer of energy from motions described by the variables (v,v,b,b ) to motions described by the variables (v y,b y ) can occur in the considered MHD waves. The variables (v,v,b,b ) are damped due to the coupling to Alfvén waves. These results are demonstrated in the following figures for the perturbed velocity and magnetic field variations. At t =, the initial perturbation is applied at lower boundary. This perturbation propagates upward uniformly and then it stops at upper boundary (the standing case). Figure is the plot the initial wave packet given by Eq. 9. In the case of an inhomogeneous layer (ρ /ρ e > ), since the initial perturbation acts over all density regions (inside the spicule, in the inhomogeneous layer and outside of spicule), the Alfvén speed varies in these regions (V A (,)). The Alfvén speed varies continuously in the inhomogeneous layer and resonant absorption occurs where the condition v A = v phase is satisfied. Here, v phase = ω/k, where ω is the angular frequency of kink oscillation and k is the local longitudinal wave number. In our simulation, the spicule is considered as a thin flu tube (a = km radius) with a thin inhomogeneous layer (d =.a = km width). In this approach, the above condition is satisfied in the considered inhomogeneous layer, so

6 6 Z. Fael 6 v v Fig. The perturbed velocity variations are showed with respect to at two time steps:t = τ s (top panel) and t = τ s (bottom panel). Figure shows the perturbed velocity variations,v with respect to (height or propagation direction) at t = τ s (upper panel) and t = τ s (lower panel), respectively. The perturbed velocity is normalied to V A. At t = τ s, the perturbed v already shows the damping due to phase miing occurring in the inhomogeneous layer. By the later stage att = τ s, we see that the initial perturbation (the kink wave) has undergone the complete attenuation and only the phase-mied Alfvén wave with bigger amplitude remains in the layer. The lower panel shows an eponential damping of v with. This is in good agreement with results obtained by Pascoe et al. (). They have demonstrated that for standing kink modes with thin flu tube and thin boundary layer approimation, an eponential damping envelope is obtained. In both panels at the first heights, total amplitude of velocity oscillations has values near to the initial ones. As height increases, the perturbed velocity amplitude decreases to smaller values which demonstrates damping process due to mode coupling. The coupling of the kink wave to a local Alfvén mode causes a decrease in wave energy in the spicule, and so appears to damp the spicule oscillation. Figure is the D plots of the perturbed velocity in space at two time steps (as mentioned in Figure ). Figure demonstrates variations of the perturbed magnetic field component, b, with respect to at two locations: spicule ais (according to our simulation bo, the spicule ais is placed at dimensionless = corresponding to = km) (upper panel), and inhomogeneous layer ( =.8 corresponding to

7 Mode coupling 7. v (,,t=) v (,,t=) Fig. The perturbed velocity in space is showed. Top panel corresponds tot = τ s and the bottom to t = τ s. amplitude) along the spicule ais which undergoes damping due to mode coupling as height increases. The lower panel shows the Alfvén mode (with bigger amplitude) in the inhomogeneous layer. The component b grows in as energy is transferred to the Alfvén mode from the kink mode. Figure demonstrates variations of the perturbed magnetic field component, b, with respect to at the same locations as in Figure. The component b has small fluctuations which indicates an almost incompressible kink mode in the inhomogeneous layer (with an amplitude about 9 ). TheD plots of the perturbed magnetic field components with respect to, are presented in Figures 6 and 7 at t = τ s and t = τ s, respectively. In these figures, also the spatial damping of the oscillations is seen along the tube ais. In Figure 8, the total energy normalied to the initial total energy is presented. The wave energy is defined ase tot = /(ρ(v +v y +v )+/µ(b +b y +b )). The coupling of kink mode to the local Alfvén mode leads to a decrease in the kink wave energy in spicule which shows the damping of the tube oscillations. The amplitude of total energy decreases eponentially with time. The period of the kink waves (P k = L/C k =. s) are in good agreement with spicule lifetimes ( min) (Zaqarashvili

8 8 Z. Fael b b Fig. The perturbed magnetic field (b ) variations are showed with respect to. Upper panel shows the kink mode along the spicule ais at = km. Lower panel shows the Alfvén mode in the inhomogeneous layer at = 7 km. The perturbed magnetic fields are normalied tob. CONCLUSION In this paper, it is attempted to investigate the behavior of magnetohydrodynamics waves observed in solar spicules. The purpose is the study of their damping process by mode coupling mechanism. To do this, a typical spicule is considered as a thin flu tube in the plane, and an initial perturbation is assumed as a transverse kink wave in the lower -boundary of the tube. The initial perturbation is applied on the velocity and the magnetic field of the spicule, which it leads to transverse displacement of the spicule ais. These transversal waves undergo a damping due to plasma inhomogeneity as height increases in which an energy transferring takes place from the kink mode to the local Alfvén mode. The amplitude of the Alfvén wave grows along the tube ais, and then eperiences a spatial damping in the spicule. We observed that total energy of the coupled kink to Alfvén waves decreases with time eponentially. In the approach of a thin tube with a thin inhomogeneous layer for a modeled spicule, the dissipation takes place in this layer aroundv A = C k wherec k = ( +ρ e/ρ )V A (Kukhianide et al. (6)). The eponentially damping of the spicule oscillations, gives a damping time which it depends on the period of oscillation

9 Mode coupling 9.. b b Fig. The perturbed magnetic field (b ) variations are showed with respect to. Upper panel shows the kink mode along the spicule ais. Lower panel shows the Alfvén mode in the inhomogeneous layer. The perturbed magnetic fields are normalied tob. the spicule life time. This simulation is based on observational results reported by Ebadi et al. (). They have studied these oscillations observationally and theoretically. They analyed the time series of Ca II H- line obtained from Hinode/SOT on the solar limb. The time distance analysis shows that the ais of spicule undergos quasi-periodic transverse displacement at different heights from the photosphere. The theoretical analysis also showed that the observed oscillations may correspond to the fundamental harmonic of standing kink waves. In this case, our initial perturbation corresponds to some general photospheric motion and our kink waves corresponds to the transverse oscillations in spicule ais observed from Hinode/SOT by Tsuneta et al. (8). References Allan, W., Wright, A.N.,, J. Geophys. Res.,, 7 Beckers, J.M., 968, Sol. Phys., 67 Cally, P.S., Bogdan, T.J., Zweibel, E.G., 99, ApJ 7, De Pontieu, B., Erdélyi, R., James, S.P.,, Nature,, 6D De Pontieu, B., McIntosh, S.W., Carlsson, M., et al., 7, Science, 8, 7

10 Z. Fael.. b (,,t=) b (,,t=).... Fig. 6 The perturbed magnetic field is shown in space at t = τ s. Ebadi, H., Zaqarashvili, T.V., Zhelyakov, I.,, Ap&SS 7, Fael, Z., Ebadi, H.,, Ap&SS 6, 9 Fael, Z., Ebadi, H.,, Ap&SS, 7 He, J., Marsch, E., Tu, C., Tian, H., 9, ApJ 7, L7 Hood, A.W., Ruderman, M., Pascoe, D.J., De Moortel, I., Terradas, J., Wright, A.N.,, A&A, 9 Jess, D.B., Mathioudakis, M., Erdélyi, R., Crockett, P.J., Keenan, F.P., Christian, D.J., 9, Science,, 8 Karami, K., Ebrahimi, Z., 9, Publ. Astron. Soc. Aust., 6, 8 Kukhianide, V., Zaqarashvili, T. V., Khutsishvili, E., 6, A&A 9, Kuride, D., Verth, G., Mathioudakis, M., Erdélyi, R., Jess, D.B., Morton, R.J., Christian, D.J., Keenan, F.P.,, ApJ 779, 8 Murawski, K., Zaqarashvili, T.V.,, A&A 9, A8 Nikolski, G.M., Platova, A.G., 97, Sol. Phys. 8, Pascoe, D.J., Wright, A.N., De Moortel, I.,, ApJ 7, 99 Pascoe, D.J., Hood, A.W., De Moortel, I., Wright, A.N.,, A&A 9, 7 Priest, E.R., Solar magnetohydrodynamics. Reidel, Dordrecht (98)

11 Mode coupling b (,,t=) b (,,t=).. 6 Fig. 7 The perturbed magnetic field is shown in space at t = τ s. 6 E tot (t)/e tot () 8 6 t(*τ) sec Fig. 8 Time variations of the total energy are presented. Soler, R., Terrades, J., Verth, G., Goossens, M.,, ApJ 76:, Sterling, A.C.,, Sol. Phys. 96, 79 Terradas, J., Goossens, M., Verth, G.,, A&A, A Tsuneta, S., Ichimoto, K., Katsukawa, Y., et al., 8, Sol. Phys. 9, 67

12 Z. Fael Verth, G., Terradas, J., Goossens, M.,, ApJ 78, L Verth, G., Goossens, M., He, J.-S.,, Astrophys. J. Lett., 7, D Zaqarashvili, T.V., Erdélyi, R., 9, Space Sci. Rev. 9, Zaqarashvili, T. V., Khutsishvili, E., Kukhianide, V., Ramishvili, G., 7, A&A 7, 67