arxiv: v1 [hep-ph] 16 Jan 2019

Transcription

1 Summary of recent progress in searces for additional Higgs bosons arxiv:9.569v [ep-p] 6 Jan 9 Institute of Hig Energy Pysics, Austrian Academy of Sciences martin.flecl@cern.c Tere as been a tremendous increase of sensitivity in searces for carged Higgs bosons and additional neutral Higgs bosons since te last CHARGED worksop in 6. We will review recent experimental and teory developments as presented at CHARGED8, and conclude wit future prospects for te field. Prospects for Carged Higgs Discovery at Colliders - CHARGED8 5-8 September 8 Uppsala, Sweden Speaker. c Copyrigt owned by te autor(s) under te terms of te Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4. International License (CC BY-NC-ND 4.). ttps://pos.sissa.it/

2 . Introduction Additional Higgs bosons H ± appear in many extensions of te standard model (SM), in particular wen adding additional doublets or triplets to its scalar sector. Typically, te focus is on -Higgs-doublet models (HDMs) including te special case of te Higgs sector of te minimal supersymmetric extension of te standard model (MSSM). In te MSSM, te dominant production mode for a carged Higgs boson is in top quark decays if kinematically allowed, or in association wit a top quark oterwise. Neutral Higgs bosons are dominantly produced via gluon fusion (for low values of, te ratio of te vacuum expectation values of te two Higgs doublets) and in association wit bottom quarks (intermediate and ig tan β). However, non-standard production and decay modes may become dominant in oter HDMs or for specific relations between te Higgs boson masses, allowing e.g. Higgs-to-Higgs decays. Oter beyond-te-standard-model (BSM) Higgs sectors offer an even larger variety: for example, te next-to-mssm (NMSSM) predicts two neutral Higgs bosons in addition to te MSSM wic could be relatively ligt witout violating existing bounds; and models wit Higgs triplets predict among oters doubly-carged Higgs bosons.. Carged Higgs bosons 5 result s= TeV, 6. fb modm scenario τν 95% CL limits exclusion exclusion ± σ ± σ H 8 tan β Preliminary ± H τν mod MSSM 5.9 fb ( TeV) 95% CL upper limits Excluded Median expected MSSM 5± GeV 4 ± (GeV) tbh, H tb modm s = TeV 6. fb 95% obs. excl. (CL ) s 95% exp. excl. (CL ) s ± σ ± σ Figure : 95% CL limits for te MSSM interpretation of te searc for H ± τν by [7] (left) and [8] (middle), and of H ± tb by [9] (rigt). Carged Higgs boson (H ± ) searces are primarily motivated by te MSSM but te results are also given in a largely model-independent way, i.e. in terms of cross section limits. Tere is also an increasing number of non-mssm searces, e.g. for carged Higgs boson production in vector boson fusion []. For masses below te top quark mass, a carged Higgs boson would be dominantly produced in top quark decays. Terefore, te production cross section is proportional to te top quark pair production times te brancing ratio t H b. Te dominant mode of H ± production for ± > m t in a HDM is via te process pp th ± X [,, 4, 5, 6]. Recent progress on teory side as led to te first consistent NLO calculations also for te so-called intermediatemass region [], i.e. te region were te contributions wit and witout intermediate on-sell top quarks are of similar size. Tis region is of particular interest because MSSM models were

3 ± ± Summary of recent progress in searces for additional Higgs bosons te eavy neutral scalar as a mass of 5 GeV and te ligt Higgs boson can act as mediator to dark matter typically ave a carged Higgs boson mass in tis region. In te MSSM, te most sensitive H ± decay mode is to a τ lepton and a neutrino [7, 8], except for very low values of tan β. If kinematically allowed, decays to tb are typically similarly abundant, owever, reconstructing suc events is experimentally even more callenging [9]. An MSSM interpretation of te obtained limits is given in Fig.. Previous limits ave been extended from several undreds of GeV to one TeV (for te same value of ) in te last two years, marking tremendous progress since te last worksop. Tese results also mark te first results for te intermediate-mass region. Several oter ways to searc for carged Higgs bosons ave been proposed to te experimental collaborations at tis worksop. Examples are carged Higgs boson decays to Wγ [], H ± production in cs fusion in a HDM [], or carged Higgs boson decays to neutralinos and carginos [].. Doubly-carged Higgs bosons Doubly-carged Higgs bosons H are for example predicted by models wit Higgs triplets suc as left-rigt symmetric models or te Georgi-Macacek model, and te Zee-Babu model wic only adds two singlets to te SM. Variants of tese models can serve to explain te tiny observed neutrino masses or to restore parity symmetry in weak interactions at ig energy. Models wit triplets do not automatically lead to te observed value of ρ M W close to unity, cos θ W MZ as models wit only additional singlets and doublets do, and are tus more or less severely constrained. For several models, te main H production mecanism at te LHC is via qq Z/γ H H or qq W H H. Searces at te LHC focus at H decays to leptons [4, 5] or W bosons [6]. Te H coupling to leptons is typically not proportional to te lepton mass and te focus is tus on ligt leptons wic can be andled more easily experimentally. Te result of some of te LHC searces are illustrated in Fig.. Depending on models and assumed brancing ratios, typically H below GeV to 9 GeV are excluded. Preliminary.9 fb ( TeV) % Φ e ± e ± % Φ e ± µ ± % Φ µ ± µ ± % Φ e ± τ ± W ) [fb] ± ± W W W H H σ x (pp B 8 s= TeV 6. fb observed 95% CL upper limit expected 95% CL upper limit expected limit (±σ) expected limit (±σ) teory (NLO QCD) 7 H µ ± µ ± ) [%] L B(H 846 s= TeV, 6. fb ± ± B(H l l )=% L B(H e ± e ± ) [%] L ) limit L observed 95% CL m(h % Φ % Φ µ ± τ ± τ ± τ ± Bencmark Bencmark Bencmark Bencmark Φ Mass (GeV) exclusion 95% CL exclusion 95% CL Associated Production Pair Production Combined Figure : Limits from searces for doubly carged Higgs bosons in pair production and decays to leptons by [4] (left) and [5] (middle), as well as in decays to W bosons by [6] (rigt).

4 4. Additional neutral Higgs bosons Additional neutral Higgs bosons are te ingredient of virtually every model wit an extended Higgs sector. Te main motivation for searces for tese particles is traditionally te MSSM; owever, te portfolio as been significantly extended since te LHC start. In addition, te MSSM searces can be reinterpreted in te context of oter models. Te main LHC production mode for neutral MSSM Higgs bosons are associated production wit b quarks (intermediate and ig ) as well as gluon fusion (low ). For all but very low values, decays to τ leptons are te most sensitive experimental probe [7, 8] wit decays to bottom quarks adding additional sensitivity [9], as sown in Fig.. Since te last worksop, te excluded region as been significantly extended, reacing up to.6 TeV at ig. At tis worksop, adding te investigation of neutral Higgs boson decays to neutralinos or carginos to te portfolio [] and investigating te impact of CP-violating effects [] as been proposed. s = TeV, 6. fb mod- MSSM scenario, M SUSY H/A ττ 95% CL limits = 6.5 GeV = GeV = GeV = 6. GeV = GeV = TeV ± σ ± σ =.5 GeV = 6. GeV = 6 GeV = 5 GeV = 4 GeV m A mod scenario 5.9 fb ( TeV) 95% CL excluded: MSSM 5 ± GeV m A (GeV) 78 TeV exp. mod scenario µ = GeV 5.7 fb ( TeV),H 5 ± GeV 8 m A Figure : MSSM interpretation of te limits from searces for additional neutral Higgs bosons in ττ decays by [7] (left) and [8] (middle), as well as in bb decays by [9] (rigt). In models wit additional Higgs bosons wit masses below about 6.5 GeV, te 5-GeV Higgs boson can decay to tese Higgs bosons, aa. Searces for tese ligt Higgs bosons are often motivated by te NMSSM but te results can be interpreted in a generic way. Tese bosons ten dominantly decay to te eaviest particles kinematically allowed, leading to a variety of searc modes [, ]. Te results of two suc searces are sown in Fig. 4. Generically, ligt Higgs bosons are searced for in γγ decays in te mass range 65 GeV GeV. Here, a sligt excess of events is observed for m γγ 95 by [] wic is not confirmed by [4], see Fig. 5. Similarly, generic Higgs boson searces are extended to ig masses up to 4 TeV in te WW [5] and ZZ [6] decay modes. At te igest masses, a cross section as low as fb is excluded, see Fig Resonant decays to Higgs bosons Te SM predicts te production of events wit two Higgs bosons of a mass of 5 GeV wit a relatively low pp cross section at s = TeV of about fb, including diagrams bot wit and witout vertices wit tree Higgs bosons. Tis as not been observed yet at te LHC and te current

5 B( aa bτ) (%) σ() σ SM 95% CL limit on 5 Median expected 5 5 Combined 5.9 fb ( TeV) m a (GeV) σ B( aa µτ) SM σ 95% CL limit on Combined 5.9 fb ( TeV) Median expected m a (GeV) Figure 4: 95% CL cross section limits on te cross section times brancing ratio of aa in te bτ [] and µτ [] final states. SM B(H γγ) / σ H 95%CL B(H γγ) σ H.6 H γγ fb (8 TeV) 5.9 fb ( TeV) ± σ ± σ (GeV) B [fb] fid 95% CL Upper Limit on σ 8 8 Preliminary s = TeV, 8 fb X γγ ± σ ± σ m X Figure 5: 95% CL cross section limits on ligt Higgs bosons in γγ decays by [] (left) and AT- LAS [4] (rigt). 95% CL limits, in multiples of te expected SM cross section, are 6.7 observed (.4 expected) for [7] and. observed (.8 expected) for [8]. An increased rate of HH production could be due to a eavy resonance X decaying to two Higgs bosons, i.e. pp X HH. Bot and ave searced for suc resonant decays but found good agreement wit te SM expectation. Limits on a scalar resonance decaying to HH, combining several final states, are sown in Fig. 7, and reac from about pb at m X = GeV down to a few fb at m X = GeV. 6. BSM searc summary For given bencmark scenarios, limits using different final states can be compared wic is particularly useful if tey ave teir main sensitivity in different regions of te parameter space. Examples for te MSSM scenarios MSSM () [9] and m mod () [] are given in Fig. 8. Te most stringent limits are obtained for te MSSM were an additional neutral Higgs boson wit < GeV is excluded (e.g. by using, for eac point in parameter space, te observed limit corresponding to te most sensitive analysis tere). Wile analyses of te ττ final state cover te excluded parameter space at intermediate and ig tan β, decays involving bosons or up-type fermions are needed to close te gap at low. 4

6 5.9 fb ( TeV) B(H WW) [pb] σ H s = TeV, 6. fb H WW eνµν (ggf, 5% LWA) 95% CL 95% CL ± σ ± σ σ(pp X ZZ) [pb] Γ= = GeV ± σ ± σ 4l lq lν 7 m X Figure 6: 95% CL cross section limits on eavy Higgs bosons in VV decays by [5] (left) and [6] (rigt). SM 95% CL upper limit on σ(pp S HH) [pb] bbbb (exp.) bbbb (obs.) - bbτ τ (exp.) - bbτ τ (obs.) bbγγ (exp.) bbγγ (obs.) Preliminary s = TeV, fb Combined (exp.) Combined (obs.) ±σ (Combined) ±σ (Combined) MSSM ( = ) spin m S 95% CL limit on σ(pp X HH) [fb] 5.9 fb Spin Median expected ( TeV) 7 m X (GeV) Figure 7: 95% CL cross section limits on a scalar resonance decaying to two Higgs bosons wit = 5 GeV for [7] (left) and [8] (rigt). 7. Prospects at future colliders Sensitivity projections for neutral MSSM Higgs bosons are sown in Fig. 9 for te LHC and a future pp-collider. Wile te LHC will be able to probe a region up to TeV at intermediate and ig using ττ decays of te Higgs boson, a future collider will be able to probe te region up to about 5 TeV for all, combining te information from different final states. 8. Summary Wile so far none of te searces for additional Higgs bosons revealed a significant deviation from te SM expectation, te remaining parameter space as been strongly limited in te last two years wit an increased amount of analyzed LHC data at s = TeV, and te increasing number of models and final states investigated. Te LHC and future colliders will furter pus tese boundaries in te coming decades, aving te sensitivity to discover additional Higgs bosons. 5

7 tan β October 8 H/A ττ s = TeV, 6. fb JHEP (8) 55 H τν s = TeV, 6. fb JHEP 9 (8) 9 H tb s = TeV, 6. fb arxiv: [ep-ex] H ZZ 4l/llνν s = TeV, 6. fb Preliminary 5. fb (7 TeV) 9.7 fb mod MSSM m (8 TeV) =6 GeV 4 Preliminary MSSM, 95% CL limits m A Eur. Pys. J. C (8) 78: 9 gg A Z s = TeV, 6. fb JHEP (8) 74 H WW lνlν s = TeV, 6. fb Eur. Pys. J. C 78 (8) 4 H 4b, bb γγ/ττ, WWγγ s = 8 TeV,. fb Pys. Rev. D9, 94 (5) H bb γγ s = TeV,. fb -CONF-6-4 couplings [κ V, κ u, κ d ] s = TeV, fb -CONF =5 GeV =4 GeV = GeV = GeV exclusion 95% CL exclusion 95% CL τν (arxiv:8.7774) H WW/ZZ (arxiv:4.96) m A ± H A/H bb (arxiv:6.89) A/H/ µµ A/H/ ττ (arxiv:8.47) (HIG4-9) Figure 8: Summary plots of BSM Higgs boson searces for te MSSM scenario by [9] and for te m mod scenario by []. tan β Projection 95% CL expected exclusion: JHEP 9(8)7 ± σ YR8 syst. uncert. ±σ fb fb fb mod m MSSM 5 ± GeV tan β m A (GeV) m A [TeV ] Figure 9: Exclusion sensitivity for neutral eavy Higgs bosons. Left: Hig-Luminosity LHC [] reac for A ττ. Rigt: Te low region (red) is covered by tth, H tt. Te intermediate region (orange) is covered by b-associated production wit H tt decays. Te large region (blue) is covered by b-associated production wit ττ decays. Te smaller bound (lines) corresponds to. and ab, te larger bound (filled regions) to and ab at te LHC and a future pp-collider, respectively []. References [] Collaboration, Measurement of electroweak WZ production and searc for new pysics in pp collisions at s = TeV, -PAS-SMP8-. [] M. Flecl, R. Klees, M. Krämer, M. Spira, M. Ubiali, Improved cross-section predictions for eavy carged Higgs boson production at te LHC, PRD 9 (5) 75. 6

8 [] E.L. Berger, T. Han, J. Jiang, T. Plen, Associated Production of a Top Quark and a Carged Higgs Boson, PRD 7 (5). [4] S. Dittmaier, M. Krämer, M. Spira, M. Walser, Carged-Higgs-boson production at te LHC: NLO supersymmetric QCD corrections, PRD 8 () 55 [5] C. Weydert, S. Frixione, M. Herquet, M. Klasen, E. Laenen, T. Plen, G. Stavenga, C. D. Wite, Carged Higgs boson production in association wit a top quark in MC@NLO, EPJ C67 () 67. [6] LHC Higgs Cross Section Working Group, Handbook of LHC Higgs cross sections: 4. Decipering te nature of te Higgs sector, CERN Yellow Reports: Monograps Volume /7. [7] Collaboration, Searc for carged Higgs bosons decaying via H τν τ in te τjets and τlepton final states wit 6 fb of pp collision data recorded at s = TeV wit te experiment, JHEP 9 (8) 9. [8] Collaboration, Searc for carged Higgs bosons wit te H ± τ ± ν τ decay cannel in proton-proton collisions at s = TeV, -PAS-HIG8-4. [9] Collaboration, Searc for carged Higgs bosons decaying into top and bottom quarks at s = TeV wit te detector, JHEP (8) 85. [] C. Degrande, R. Frederix, V. Hirsci, M. Ubiali, M. Wiesemann, M. Zaro, Accurate predictions for carged Higgs production: closing te ± m t window, arxiv:7.59. [] H. E. Logan, Y. Wu, Searcing for te W γ decay of a carged Higgs boson, JHEP (8). [] R. Pasecnik, Heavy carged scalars from c s fusion: A generic searc strategy applied to a HDM wit U() U() family symmetry, JHEP (8) 4 [] H. Bal et. al., MSSM Higgs Boson Searces at te LHC: Bencmark Scenarios for Run and Beyond, arxiv: [4] Collaboration, Searc for doubly carged Higgs boson production in multi-lepton final states wit te detector using proton proton collisions at s = TeV, EPJ C78 (8) 99. [5] Collaboration, A searc for doubly-carged Higgs boson production in tree and four lepton final states at s = TeV, -PAS-HIG6-6. [6] Collaboration, Searc for doubly carged scalar bosons decaying into same-sign W boson pairs wit te detector s = TeV, arxiv:88.899, submitted to EPJ C. [7] Collaboration, Searc for additional eavy neutral Higgs and gauge bosons in te ditau final state produced in 6 fb of pp collisions at s = TeV wit te detector, JHEP (8) 55. [8] Collaboration, Searc for additional neutral MSSM Higgs bosons in te ττ final state in proton-proton collisions at s = TeV, JHEP 9 (8)7. [9] Collaboration, Searc for beyond te standard model Higgs bosons decaying into a b b pair in pp collisions at s = TeV, JHEP 8 (8). [] S. Patel, E. Fucs, S. Liebler, G. Weiglein, CP-violating Effects on MSSM Higgs Searces, Acta Pys. Polon. Supp. (8) [] Collaboration, Searc for an exotic decay of te Higgs boson to a pair of ligt pseudoscalars in te final state wit two b quarks and two τ leptons in proton-proton collisions at s = TeV, PLB 785 (8) 46. 7

9 [] Collaboration, Searc for an exotic decay of te Higgs boson to a pair of ligt pseudoscalars in te final state of two muons and two τ leptons in proton-proton collisions at s = TeV, JHEP (8) 8. [] Collaboration, Searc for a standard model-like Higgs boson in te mass range between 7 and GeV in te dipoton final state in proton-proton collisions at s = 8 and TeV, arxiv:8.8459, submitted to PLB. [4] Collaboration, Searc for resonances in te 65 to GeV dipoton invariant mass range using 8 fbâĺš of pp collisions collected at s = TeV wit te detector, -CONF-8-5. [5] Collaboration, Searc for eavy resonances decaying into WW in te eνµν final state in pp collisions at s = TeV wit te detector, EPJ C78 (8) 4. [6] Collaboration, Searc for a new scalar resonance decaying to a pair of Z bosons in proton-proton collisions at s = TeV, JHEP 6 (8) 7. [7] Collaboration, Combination of searces for Higgs boson pairs in pp collisions at TeV wit te experiment, -CONF-8-4. [8] Collaboration, Combination of searces for Higgs boson pair production in proton-proton collisions at s = TeV, arxiv:8.9689, submitted to PRL. [9] Collaboration, Summary plots from te Higgs pysics group, ttps://atlas. web.cern.c/atlas/groups/physics/combinedsummaryplots/higgs/. [] Collaboration, Summary results of ig mass BSM Higgs searces using run-i data, -PAS-HIG6-7. [] Collaboration, Projection of te Run MSSM ττ limits for te Hig-Luminosity LHC, -PAS-FTR8-7. [] N. Craig, J. Hajer, Y. Li, T. Liu, H. Zang, Heavy Higgs bosons at low : from te LHC to TeV, JHEP (7) 8 8