The spectrum of a square matrix A, denoted σ(a), is the multiset of the eigenvalues

Transcription

1 CONSTRUCTIONS OF POTENTIALLY EVENTUALLY POSITIVE SIGN PATTERNS WITH REDUCIBLE POSITIVE PART MARIE ARCHER, MINERVA CATRAL, CRAIG ERICKSON, RANA HABER, LESLIE HOGBEN, XAVIER MARTINEZ-RIVERA, AND ANTONIO OCHOA Abstract Potentially eventually positive (PEP) sign patterns were introduced in Sign patterns that allow eventual positivity, Electronic Journal of Linear Algebra, 9 (200): 08 20, where it was noted that A is PEP if its positive part is primitive, and an example was given of a 3 3 PEP sign pattern with reducible positive part We extend these results by constructing n n PEP sign patterns with reducible positive part, for every n 3 6 Key words potentially eventually positive, PEP, sign pattern, matrix, digraph 7 AMS subject classifications (200) 5B35, 5B48, 05C50, 5A Introduction A sign pattern matrix (or sign pattern) is a matrix having entries in {+,, 0} For a real matrix A, sgn(a) is the sign pattern having entries that correspond to the signs of the entries in A If A is an n n sign pattern, the qualitative class of A, denoted Q(A), is the set of all A R n n such that sgn(a) = A, where sgn(a) = [sgn(a ij )]; such a matrix A is called a realization of A Qualitative matrix problems were introduced more than sixty years ago by Samuelson in the mathematical modeling of problems from economics [7] Sign pattern matrices have useful applications in economics, population biology, chemistry and sociology If P is a property of a real matrix, then a sign pattern A is potentially P (or allows P ) if there is some A Q(A) that has property P The spectrum of a square matrix A, denoted σ(a), is the multiset of the eigenvalues of A, and the spectral radius of A is defined as ρ(a) = max{ λ : λ σ(a)} Department of Mathematics, Columbia College, Columbia, SC 29203, USA (mharcher@iastateedu) Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, Xavier University, Cincinnati, OH 45207, USA (catralm@xavieredu) Department of Mathematics, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 500, USA (craig@iastateedu) Department of Mathematics, California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, CA 9768, USA (ranahaber@hotmailcom) Department of Mathematics, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 500, USA (lhogben@iastateedu) & American Institute of Mathematics, 360 Portage Ave, Palo Alto, CA (hogben@aimathorg) Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of Puerto Rico, Mayagüez, PR 0068, USA (xaviermartinez@upredu) Department of Mathematics, California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, CA 9768, USA (aochoa@csupomonaedu)

2 Matrix A has the strong Perron-Frobenius property if ρ(a) > 0 is a simple strictly dominant eigenvalue of A that has a positive eigenvector A matrix A R n n is eventually positive if there exists a k 0 Z + such that for all k k 0, A k > 0, where the inequality is entrywise Handelman developed the following test for eventual positivity in [2]: a matrix A is eventually positive if and only if both A and A T satisfy the strong Perron-Frobenius property If there exists a k such that A k > 0 and A k+ > 0, then A is eventually positive [4] A sign pattern A is potentially eventually positive (PEP) if there exists an eventually positive realization A Q(A) For a sign pattern A = [α ij ], define the positive part of A to be A + = [ α ij] + 28 and the negative part of A to be A = [ αij] 29, where 30 α + ij = { + if αij = +, 0 if α ij = 0 or α ij =, and α ij = { if αij =, 0 if α ij = 0 or α ij = Clearly A = A + + A For a matrix A R n n, the positive part A + of A and negative part A of A are defined analogously, and A = A + + A A digraph Γ = (V, E) consists of a finite, nonempty set V of vertices, together with a set E V V of arcs Note that a digraph allows loops (arcs of the form (v, v)) and may have both arcs (v, w) and (w, v) but not multiple copies of the same arc Let A = [a ij ] R n n The digraph of A, denoted Γ(A), has vertex set {,, n} and arc set {(i, j) : a ij 0} If A is a sign pattern, then Γ(A) = Γ(A) where A Q(A) A digraph Γ is strongly connected if for any two distinct vertices v and w of Γ, there is a path in Γ from v to w A square matrix A is reducible if there exists a permutation matrix P such that [ ] P AP T A 0 = A 2 A 22 where A and A 22 are nonempty square matrices and 0 is a (possibly rectangular) block consisting entirely of zero entries, or A is the zero matrix If A is not reducible, then A is called irreducible It is well known that for n 2, A is irreducible if and only if Γ(A) is strongly connected For a strongly connected digraph Γ, the index of imprimitivity is the greatest common divisor of the lengths of the cycles in Γ A strongly connected digraph is primitive if its index of imprimitivity is one; otherwise it is imprimitive The index of imprimitivity of a nonnegative sign pattern A is the index of imprimitivity of Γ(A) and A 0 is primitive if Γ(A) is primitive, or equivalently, if the index of imprimitivity of A is one The study of PEP sign patterns was introduced in [], where it was shown that if A + is primitive, then A is PEP The first example of a PEP sign pattern with 2

3 reducible positive part was also given in []; this is the 3 3 pattern + 0 B = In Section 2 we extend the results of [] by generalizing the 3 3 pattern B from [] to a family of PEP sign patterns having reducible positive part for every order n 3 In section 3 we examine the effect of the Kronecker product on PEP sign patterns and obtain another method of constructing PEP sign patterns with reducible positive part 2 A family of sign patterns generalizing B The sign pattern B from [] was the first PEP sign pattern with a reducible positive part This sign pattern may be generalized by defining the n n sign pattern B n = The following result, which is a special case of the Schur-Cohn Criterion (see, eg, [5]), will be used in the proof that B n is PEP Lemma 2 If the polynomial f(x) = x 2 βx + α satisfies the inequalities β < + α < 2, then all zeros of f(x) lie strictly inside the unit circle It is well known that if the characteristic polynomial of A is p(x) = x n + a n x n + + a x + a 0 then a n k = ( ) k E k (A), where E k (A) is the sum of the k k principal minors of A (see, eg, [3]) Theorem 22 For n 3 the n n sign pattern B n is PEP Proof For t > 0, let B n (t) be the n n matrix + (n 2)t t t 0 + t 0 0 t B n (t) = + t 0 0 t (n 2)t 2 t2 t t + 2 t2 Then B n (t) Q(B n ), and is an eigenvalue of B n (t) with positive right eigenvector (the all ones vector) and positive left eigenvector w = [(2n 5)/t,,,, (2n 4)/t] T 3

4 We show that for some choice of t > 0, is a simple strictly dominant eigenvalue of B n (t) and hence B n (t) is eventually positive Since σ(b n (t)) and rank B n (t) 3, the characteristic polynomial p Bn(t)(x) of B n (t) is of the form p Bn(t)(x) = x n 3 (x )(x 2 βx + α) = x n ( + β)x n + (α + β)x n 2 αx n 3 80 Computing α and β using the sums of principal minors to evaluate the characteristic 8 polynomial gives β = 2 t2 + (n 2)t + and α = (n 2)t( + 2t + 2 t2 ) For n > 3, setting t = 2(n 2) gives β < + α < 2 which, using Lemma 2, guarantees that the 83 two non-zero eigenvalues of B n other than have modulus strictly less than (recall 84 that a 3 3 eventually positive matrix B 3 Q(B 3 ) was given in [] so we have not 85 been concerned with this case in choosing t) We illustrate this theorem with an example Example 23 Let n = 5 Following the proof of Theorem 22, we choose t = 6 and define 9 0 B 5 = B 5 (/6) = Moreover, σ(b 5 ) = { ( ) ( ) }, i 2087, i 2087, 0, 0 {, i, i, 0, 0} and [ ] T [ and ] T are 9 right and left eigenvectors corresponding to ρ(b 5 ) = respectively Therefore B 92 5 and B5 T 93 have the strong Perron-Frobenius property, so B 5 is eventually positive by 94 Handelman s criterion In [] it was shown that if the sign pattern A is PEP, then any sign pattern achieved by changing one or more zero entries of A to be non-zero is also PEP Applying this to B n yields a variety of additional PEP sign patterns having reducible positive part 3 Kronecker products The Kronecker product (sometimes called the tensor product) is a useful tool for generating larger eventually positive matrices and thus PEP sign patterns The Kronecker product of A = [a ij ] and B = [b ij ] is defined as a B a n B A B = a n B a nn B 4

5 It is clear that if A > 0 and B > 0, then A B > 0 The following facts can be found in many linear algebra books, (see, eg, [6]) For A R n n and B R m m, (A B) k = A k B k For A, C, B, and D of appropriate dimensions, (A B)(C D) = (AC) (BD) There exists a permutation matrix P such that B A = P (A B)P T Proposition 3 If A and B are eventually positive matrices, then A B is eventually positive Proof Assume A and B are eventually positive matrices Since A and B are eventually positive, there exists some s 0, t 0 Z, with s 0, t 0 > 0, such that for all s s 0 and t t 0, A s > 0 and B t > 0 Set k 0 = max{s 0, t 0 } Then for all k k 0, (A B) k = A k B k > 0 Corollary 32 If A and B are PEP sign patterns, then A B is PEP If either A or B is a reducible matrix, then A B is reducible since, without loss of generality, if [ ] P AP T A 0 = A 2 A then [ ] (P I)(A B)(P I) T A B 0 = A 2 B A 22 B Thus Corollary 32 provides another way to construct PEP sign patterns having reducible positive part Example 33 Let B = In [] it was shown that B is eventually positive, and in fact B k > 0 for k 0 [ ] 2 3 Let A = Then A k > 0 for k 2, hence A is eventually positive 0 Then B A =

6 Moreover (B A) 0 > 0 and (B A) > 0, so B A is eventually positive and sgn(b A) is a PEP sign pattern with reducible positive part Any 0 in sgn(b A) from Example 33 may be changed to to get yet another PEP sign pattern with reducible positive part 3 REFERENCES [] A Berman, M Catral, LM DeAlba, A Elhashash, F Hall, L Hogben, I-J Kim, DD Olesky, P Tarazaga, MJ Tsatsomeros, P van den Driessche, Sign patterns that allow eventual positivity Electronic Journal of Linear Algebra, 9 (200): [2] D Handelman, Positive matrices and dimension groups affiliated to C -algebras and topological Markov chains Journal of Operator Theory 6 (98): [3] RA Horn and JR Johnson Matrix Analysis Cambridge University Press, New York, 985 [4] C R Johnson and P Tarazaga, On matrices with Perron-Frobenius Properties and some negative entries Positivity, 8 (2004): [5] M Marden, Geometry of Polynomials Mathematical Surveys Number III, American Mathematical Society, New York, 949 [6] R Reams, Partitioned matrices In Handbook of Linear Algebra, L Hogben, Editor, Chapman & Hall/CRC Press, Boca Raton, 2007 [7] P A Samuelson Foundations of Economic Analysis Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 947 6