Research Article MPPT Algorithm for Photovoltaic Panel Based on Augmented Takagi-Sugeno Fuzzy Model

Transcription

1 SRN Renewable Energy, Artile D , 1 pages Researh Artile MPPT Algorithm for Photovoltai Panel Based on Augmented Takagi-Sugeno Fuzzy Model Hafedh Abid, Ahmed Toumi, and Mohamed Chaabane Laboratory of Sienes and Tehniques of Automati Control & Computer Engineering (Lab-STA), National Shool of Engineering of Sfax, University of Sfax, P.O. Box 1173, 338 Sfax, Tunisia Correspondene should be addressed to Ahmed Toumi; toumi.a@gmail.om Reeived 3 Otober 213; Aepted 19 Deember 213; Published 17 February 214 Aademi Editors: T.-H. Meen and R. Miles Copyright 214 Hafedh Abid et al. This is an open aess artile distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution Liense, whih permits unrestrited use, distribution, and reprodution in any medium, provided the original work is properly ited. This paper deals with the Maximum Power Point Traking (MPPT) for photovoltai energy system. t inludes photovoltai array panel, DC/DC onverter, and load. The operating point for photovoltai energy system depends on limati parameters and load. For eah temperature and irradiation pair, there exists only one optimal operating point whih orresponds to the maximum power transmitted to the load. The photovoltai energy system is desribed by nonlinear equations. t is transformed into an augmented system whih is desribed with a Takagi-Sugeno (T-S) fuzzy model. The proposed MPPT algorithm whih permits transfering the maximum power from the panel to the load is based on Parallel Distributed Compensation method (PDC). The ontrol parameters have been omputed based on Linear Matrix nequalities tools (LM). The Lyapunov approah has been used to prove the stability of the system. Some reliable simulation results are provided to hek the effiieny of the proposed algorithm. 1. ntrodution n the most reent years, photovoltai (PV) energy has been the subjet of several researh projets. t is well known that the PV array power panel depends on limati variables suh as temperature and irradiation as shown in Figures 2 and 3. Atually, the operating point of the PV array panel depends on three parameters suh as temperature, irradiation, and the load. n fat, the operating point results from the intersetion of the -V harateristi and the load harateristi as shown in Figure 4.nmostases,thevalueofloadisonstantandthe limati parameters vary in the day, so the load harateristi remains fixed and the harateristi of the panel varies aording to limati variables. Consequently, the operating point is variable and the load annot extrat maximum power from the panel. To overome this disadvantage, a DC/DC onverter is inserted between the panel and the load. n this way,theloadvalueseenbythepvpanelanbehangedby varying the duty yle. n this ontext, several studies have been developed. Most of papers dealing with the MPPT ontrol algorithms are based on perturb and observe (P&O) [1 4], nremental Condutane [3, 5], Mamdani type fuzzy logi ontroller (FLC) [4, 6], and some different approahes as neural network ontroller (NNC) [7]. n this paper, the PV array panel has been modelled by fuzzy system approah. At every time, the desired state variables have been omputed based on the measurement of temperature and irradiation. Also, the MPP traker algorithm has been developed based on Parallel Distributed Compensation (PDC) method whih was designed for fuzzy system. Most of papers whih have used fuzzy system applied Mamdani method. Whereas in this work, the main ontribution whih deals with Maximum Power Point Traking for photovoltai panel, onsists on developing a new algorithm based on augmented T-S fuzzy system. t is well known that the Mamdani fuzzy system inludes three bloks whih are fuzzifiation, fuzzy inferene rules and defuzzifiation, whereas the T-S fuzzy system needs only two bloks suh as fuzzifiation and fuzzy inferene rules. The blok number has been redued. However, we deided to hoose the T-S type fuzzy system. n this paper, the T-S fuzzy system has been used in modelling stage of PV system and in the ontrol stage. The optimal duty yle, whih permits extrating the maximum power from thephotovoltaiarraypanel,isomputedbasedonpdc tehniques. This paper is organised as follows. n Setion 2,

2 2 SRN Renewable Energy PV DC-DC onverter R L PV urve G = 1 W/m 2 25 Figure 1: Photovoltai system. P (W) we desribe the problem statement and we show the influene of limati parameters suh as temperature and irradiation on the eletrial harateristi of the PV array panel. Then, we reall the model of photovoltai panel. At the end of the seond setion, we desribe the photovoltai energy system by a state model. The third setion is reserved to present the ontrol strategy. n the first part, we reall the T-S fuzzy system; then we desribe the photovoltai energy system by anaugmentedt-sfuzzymodel.ntheseondpartofthethird setion, we desribe the T-S fuzzy referene model and the MPPT algorithm whih is based on T-S fuzzy system. Setion four is devoted to the stability analysis of the losed loop system. The feedbak gains have been omputed by solving LMs expressions. The simulation results of photovoltai energy system showing performanes of the proposed MPPT algorithm traker are disussed in Setion 5. Conlusions are drawn in the final setion. 2. Problem Statement The photovoltai power depends on limati parameters suh as temperature and irradiation as shown in Figures 2 and 3. n fat, the photovoltai power, whih is transmitted to theload,isfuntionoftheimpedaneoftheloadandthe limati parameters as shown in Figure 4.However,to hange the impedane seen by the panel, it is neessary to insert a DC/DC onverter. The photovoltai system onsists of a photovoltai array panel onneted to a DC-DC onverter whih provides energy to the load, as shown in Figure 1. Figures 2 and 3 show the evolution of the generated power urves as a funtion of voltage, respetively, for a given onstant irradiation and different values of temperature and then for a given onstant temperature and different values of irradiation. n onlusion, we an say that the PV array panel is nonlinear and time-variant system. From Figures 2 and 3, it is lear that the temperature affets essentially the voltage and the irradiation affets fundamentally the intensity of the PV array panel. Also, we an onlude that the output power generated by the PV array panel depends on the limati parameters G and T. n fat, the power inreases with an inrease in solar radiation and dereases with an inrease in temperature. For eah given pair of parameters (G, T), there exists only one Maximum Power Point (MPP). The operating point is determined by the intersetion of the panel urrent-voltage harateristi and the load urrent-voltage harateristi. P (W) (A) V (V) Figure 2: PV power urves with different T. Power urve V (V) T=25 C Figure 3: PV power urves with different G. 1/R Panel harateristi 1/R op 75 G = 1 G = 7 G = 4 Load harateristi V pv (V) Figure 4: Operating point of the PV array panel. 1/R

3 SRN Renewable Energy 3 pv + V pv (G, T) ph o sh R sh R s V The overall photovoltai system energy an be represented by the sheme illustrated in Figure 6. The average dynami model of the photovoltai system given by Figure 6 an be expressed in ontinuous ondution by the following equations: dv pv = 1 ( dt C pv L ), 1 d L dt = 1 L [V pv V 2 (1 μ)], Figure 5: Equivalent iruit for PV ell. (5) However, a speifi algorithm traker should be used to searh the optimal operating point whih permits to extrat the maximum power from the PV array panel. n the next part of this setion, we reall the most popular model whih is developed by Singer et al. [8]; then we desribe the modeling of the overall photovoltai system energy. The eletrial equivalent iruit of the PV ell is given by Figure 5. t onsists of a urrent generator whih depends on irradiation (G) and temperature (T),in parallel with a diode, and onneted to an internal parallel and series resistor, namely, respetively, R sh and R s. The PV ell model is desribed by the following equations: sh = V+R s pv R sh, pv = ph o [exp ( V+R s ) 1] (V+R s), V t R sh V t = n skt q. The generated urrent by the photovoltai panel varies with temperature and irradiation; its expression is given by the following equation: (1) ph =( ph,n +K ΔT) G G n. (2) ph,n is the rated urrent generated by the PV panel under standard ondition of temperature and irradiation (T =25 C and G = 1 w/m 2 ): ( ph +K ΔT) o = exp ((V o +K V ΔT) /V t ) 1, (3) where o is a reverse saturation urrent: KT V o =n s q log ( s + o ), o V =n s KT q log ( s + o pv o ), where V o istheopeniruitvoltageand s is the short iruit urrent. (4) dv 2 dt = 1 C 2 [ L (1 μ) V 2 R L ]. n the ontinuous ondution, the average value of PV urrentisequaltotheaveragevalueof L urrent. t is very lear that the system an be desribed as the form of x (t) =A(x, t) x (t) +Bu(t), (6) where x(t) = [V pv L V 2 ] T is the state vetor, A(x, t) is the state matrix, B is the input vetor, and μ is the duty ratio. However, the state matrix is nonlinear. 3. Control Strategy The ontrol strategy that we propose is given by Figure 7. The ontrol strategy onsists of three bloks: referene model, ontroller, and plant, whih is defined by PV system (see Figure 1) T-S Fuzzy Model. Several studies have been proving that the Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy system an desribe the behavior of ontinuous nonlinear system. However, we use in this work the T-S fuzzy system to desribe the nonlinear energy onversion system. The fuzzy model is desribed by fuzzy rules where eah rule represents input-output relations of linear loal model. The ith rule of the fuzzy model has the following form: F z 1 is M i1 and z 2 is M i2 and,...,and z n is M in THEN { x (t) =A ix (t) +B i u (t), y (t) =C i x (t),,2,...,, where {M ij } are the fuzzy sets, x(t) is the state vetor, u(t) is the input vetor, A i is the state matrix, B i is the input matrix, z 1 (t),...,z n (t) are the premise variables, x(t) R n, A i R n n, B i R nxm, y(t) R m,and is the number of fuzzy rules. The global fuzzy model of the system has the following form: (7) x (t) = w i (z (t)) [A i x (t) +B i u (t)] w. (8) i (z (t))

4 4 SRN Renewable Energy G T + V PV pv C1 ndutor L Diode L T C2 C1 C 2 R L h V out PV array Boost onverter T G Fuzzy MPPT algorithm Load Figure 6: Photovoltai system. T G T-S fuzzy referene model x r (t) + e(t) T-S fuzzy ontroller (PDC) μ Photovoltai energy onversion system x(t) Figure 7: Control strategy. For eah rule R i attributed a weight w i (z(t)) whih depends on grade of membership funtion of premise variables z j (t) in fuzzy sets M ij : w i (z (t)) = n j=1 w i (z (t)) >, M ij (z j (t)), w i (z (t)), for i = 1,...,. M ij (z j (t)) is the grade of membership of z j (t) to the fuzzy set M ij : h j (z (t)) = w j (z (t)) w i (z (t)), h i (z (t)) 1, h i (z (t)) =1,,...,. Thepolytopiformofstateequationis x (t) = (9) (1) h i (z (t)) [A i x (t) +B i u (t)]. (11) 3.2. Augmented T-S Fuzzy Model of Photovoltai System. n the first stage of this subsetion, we transform the average dynami model of the photovoltai system desribed by (5) into an augmented model. However, a new state variable must beaddedtothestatevetor.notherwordsanintegratoris inluded previous to the real input μ and let μ=u. Therefore, μ beomesnewstatevariableandu is the new ontrol input of the augmented system. Then, the system an be desribed as a nonlinear system in the form of x (t) =A(x, t) x (t) +Bu(t), (12) where x(t) = [V pv L V 2 μ] T is the state vetor, A(x, t) is the state matrix, and B is the input matrix: α 1 C 1 C β A= L L L 1 1 γ, B = [ [ ]. (13) [ C 2 R L C 2 C 2 ] [ 1] [ ] with α= pv /V pv, β=v 2,andγ= L. t is lear that (12) is nonlinear. To obtain the T-S fuzzy model, we hoose the following three premises variables: PV, V PV,andV 2.However,eightloalmodelshavebeenobtained to desribe the T-S fuzzy model. The state matrix of eah loal model has the following struture: α i 1 C 1 C β i A i = L L L 1 1 γ, (14) i [ C 2 R L C 2 C 2 ] [ ] where eah of the variables α i = pvi /V pvi, β i = V 2i,and γ i = Li must be replaed, respetively, by the appropriate value aording to fuzzy rule base (α min or α max ), (β min or β max ),and(γ min or γ max ) Referene Model. t is well known that the maximum power produed by panel, also the orresponding optimal

5 SRN Renewable Energy 5 T G T-S fuzzy referene model x r (t) + e(t) h i (z)k i μ(t) Photovoltai energy onversion system MPPT algorithm based on T-S fuzzy ontroller x(t) Figure 8: Control strategy of MPPT. tension V MP and optimal urrent MP, depends on temperature T and irradiation G. However,these latest are used as premise variables, Z R1 = T and Z R2 = G,toomputethe referene model based on T-S fuzzy system. The ith rule of the fuzzy referene model has the following form: F z 1R is λ i1 and z 2R is λ i2 and,...,and z nr is λ in THEN { x R (t) =D i x R (t), y R (t) =C Ri x R (t),,2,...,r, (15) where {λ ij } are the fuzzy sets, x R (t) = [V pvr Lr V 2r μ r ] T isthestatereferenevariablevetor,d i R n n is the loal referene state matrix, and {z 1R (t),...,z nr (t)} are the premise variables. y(t) R m is the output vetor, r is the number of fuzzy rules. Then, the T-S fuzzy referene model is given by the following equation: x R (t) = r η i (z (t)) D i x R (t) (16) with r η i(z(t)) = 1 and D i is the loal referene state matrix: δ i 1 C 1 C σ i L L L D i = 1 1 ζ i C 2 R L C 2 C 2 [ 1 ] 1 [ 1 μ opi ] (17) with ζ i = MPPi, δ i =ζ i /V MPPi, μ opi =1 1/ R L δ i,andσ i = V MPP2i =V MPPi /(1 μ opi ) MPPT Algorithm Based on T-S Fuzzy Model. The ruial funtion of the MPPT algorithm is to searh the oordinates of the optimal operating point. n this work, the MPPT algorithm provided at eah time the appropriate duty ratio μ basedonthedesiredandmeasuredstatevariables.however, the MPPT algorithm whih represents a ontroller is based on Parallel Distributed Compensation (PDC) method. The T-S fuzzy ontroller is designed from the T-S fuzzy model of photovoltai energy onversion system. The T-S fuzzy ontroller is based on Parallel Distributed Compensation (PDC) tehnique, whih is proposed by Wang et al. [9]. The partiularityofthepdcontrolleristhatitsharesthesame fuzzy sets in the premise parts with the fuzzy model. Based on the T-S fuzzy models, the PDC fuzzy ontroller is designed as follows. ith ontroller rule: F z 1 is M i1 and z 2 is M i2 and,...,and z n is M in THEN u (t) = K i x (t),,2,...,. The global fuzzy ontroller is represented by u (t) = 4. Stability Analysis (18) h i (z) K i x (t). (19) n the previous setion, we disussed the main bloks of the ontrol strategy and we have developed an MPPT algorithm (Figure 8). However, the system of energy onversion transmits the maximum PV generated power to the load and it is ruial to ensure that the losed-loop system is stable. Theorem 1. Consider the referene model (16) whih is used to ompute the referene state variables, the nonlinear system (5) whih an be modeled by the T-S fuzzy model (11),andthe MPPT algorithm (19) based on the PDC tehniques. f there exist a ommon symmetri positive definite matrix Q and a feedbak gains K i whih satisfy the following LMs (2), then the losed loop system is asymptotially stable and the traking error onverges toward zero: [ QAT i +A i Q B i M i M T i BT i (A i D k )Q Q(A i D k ) T ρ 2 ]<, for,...,, k=1,...,r, [ QAT i +A i Q B i M j M T j BT i (A i D k )Q Q(A i D k ) T ρ 2 ]<, for,...,, j=1,...,, i=j, k=1,...,r with ρ>. Proof. The state traking error is given by (2) e (t) =x R (t) x(t). (21)

6 6 SRN Renewable Energy The following quadrati Lyapunov andidate funtion whih is positive definite, has been used to verify the system stability andomputethefeedbakgainsk i : V (e) =e T (t) Pe (t) + 1 t ρ 2 x T R (τ) x R (τ) dτ. (22) The system is asymptotially stable if we prove that V(e) < : e (t) = e (t) = V (e) = V (e) = V (e) = e T Pe + e T Pe+ 1 ρ 2 xt R x R, r h i (z) η k (z) k=1 r [A i e (t) +B i u (t) +(A i D k )x R (t)], h i (z) h j (z) η k (z) j=1 k=1 V (e) = j=1 r [A i e (t) B i (K j e) + (A i D k )x R (t)], r h i (z) h j (z) η k (z) j=1 k=1 [(A i B i K j )e(t) +(A i D k )x R (t) ] T Pe r +e T P h i (z) h j (z) η k (z) j=1 k=1 + 1 ρ 2 xt R x R, r k=1 h i (z) h j (z) η k (z) [(A i B i K j )e(t) +(A i D k )x R (t) ] (e T (A i B i K j ) T Pe + e T P(A i B i K j )e +x T R (A i D k ) T Pe + e T P(A i D k )x R ) + 1 ρ 2 xt R x R, h 2 i (z) η k (z) k=1 (e T (A i B i K i ) T Pe + e T P(A i B i K i )e +x T R (A i D i ) T Pe + e T P(A i D k )x R + 1 ρ 2 xt R x R) r + h i (z) h j (z) η k (z) j=1 k=1 i =j (e T (A i B i K j ) T Pe +e T P(A i B i K j )e+x T R (A i D k ) T Pe +e T P(A i D k )x R + 1 ρ 2 xt R x R). (23) We note in this analysis that the feedbak gains and stability onditions will be transformed to an LM problem. However, the inequality V(e) < is guaranteed when the following inequalities are satisfied: e T (A i B i K i ) T Pe + e T P (A i B i K i ) e+x T R (A i D k ) T Pe +e T P(A i D k )x R + 1 ρ 2 xt R x R <, e T (A i B i K j ) T Pe + e T P(A i B i K j )e+x T R (A i D k ) T Pe +e T P(A i D k )x R + 1 ρ 2 xt R x R <. (24) Using Shur omplement [1], the inequalities given in (24) an be written as A T i [ P+PA i PB i K i K T i BT i P P(A i D k ) (A i D k ) T ] P ρ 2 <, [ ] A T i [ P+PA i PB i K j K T j BT i P P(A i D k ) (A i D k ) T ] P ρ 2 <, [ ] for,...,, j=1,...,, i=j, k=1,...,r. (25) Sine oupled elements, suh as PB i K i,havebeenenlosed in these inequalities, then we have BiLMs inequalities. However, we must transform them to the LMs using a ongruene transformation by diag [P 1 ] to (29) and onsidering Q=P 1, M i =K i P 1,weobtainthefollowing matries in the LM form: [ QAT i +A i Q B i M i M T i BT i (A i D k )Q Q(A i D k ) T ρ 2 ]<, [ QAT i +A i Q B i M j M T j BT i (A i D k )Q Q(A i D k ) T ρ 2 ]<, for,...,, j=1,...,, i=j, k=1,...,r. (26)

7 SRN Renewable Energy 7 Table 1: Charateristis of the PV array panel. N p =1 N s =36 q = 1.6e 19 C A = 1.92 E g = 1.1 T r = K T r =25 C or = 9.579e 6 A V o = 27.4 V R s =.9 Ω R sh = 1 Ω R load =R L =3Ω P max =61W s = 4.8 A K =.171 A/ C F=1KHz C 2 =68μF K = J/K (Boltzmann s onstant) 5. Simulation Results This setion is reserved for presenting the main results. We use MATLAB to simulate the behavior of the energy onversion system. The main harateristis of the PV array panelaregivenbytable 1. The resolution of the LMs gives the following matries and feedbak gains, respetively, P, Q, K 1, K 2, K 3, K 4, K 5, K 6, K 7,andK 8. P = 1 [ [ ], [ ] Q= [ [ ], [ ] K 1 = 1.e + 4 [ ], K 2 = 1.e + 4 [ ], K 3 = 1.e + 4 [ ], K 4 = 1.e + 4 [ ], K 5 = 1.e + 4 [ ], K 6 = 1.e + 4 [ ], K 7 = 1.e + 4 [ ], K 8 = 1.e + 4 [ ]. (27) Temperature ( C) rradiation Times Figure 9: Evolution of temperature Times 1 4 Figure 1: Evolution of irradiation. TodemonstratetheperformaneoftheproposedMPPT ontrol approah, we apply a sudden variation of temperature or solar irradiation as shown in Figures 9 and 1. n Figure 9, we have applied a sudden hange of temperature,althoughitisimpossibletohaveareallydramati hange. n this test, we have hosen four pairs of irradiation and temperature. We know that for eah pair there exists only one optimal operating point whih an be determined from the power-voltage harateristis of the PV array panel whih is not always available for eah pair (G, T). tisimportant to mention that it is not possible to know the appropriate oordinates of the ideal optimal operating point (V MPP, MPP ) for all pairs (G, T) as there are infinitely of pairs (G, T). n Table 2, we give the ideal orresponding values (V MPPR, MPPR ) ofoperatingpointforeahpairoftemperature

8 8 SRN Renewable Energy Table 2: Coordinates for eah operating point. Temperature in C rradiation(wm 2 ) V MPPR (V) MPPR (A) V MPP (V) MPP (A) Evolution of operating panel voltage V s (V) V pv (V) Times 1 4 V 2 V 2r Times 1 4 V MP V MPR Figure 13: Evolution of the V MPP voltage. Error (V) Figure 11: Evolution of output voltage. Error Evolution of operating panel voltage error Times 1 4 Figure 14: Evolution of error V MPP voltage Times 1 4 Figure 12: Evolution of error output voltage. and irradiation and the omputed values (V MPP, MPP ) by our algorithm. Figures 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18,and19 show, respetively, the evolution of V MPP voltage,error of V MPP voltage, output voltage of onverter, error of output voltage of onverter, panel urrent, error of panel urrent, delivered power, error of delivered power, and the duty yle. n Figures 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17,and18, we observe momentary peaks; they are due to sudden and signifiant hange in temperature and irradiation. The hanges in temperature and irradiation are not made as that way given in Figures 9 and 1, but we have used it to show the performane of the proposed

9 SRN Renewable Energy Evolution of PV urrent (A) pv Times 1 4 pv pvr Figure 15: Evolution of the indutane urrent Times 1 4 P P r Figure 17: Evolution of the power Evolution of error urrent operating panel 3 2 Error (A) Times 1 4 Figure 16: Evolution of the error indutane urrent. Power error (W) Times 1 4 Figure 18: Evolution of the error power. algorithm. t is lear that at the steady state, the errors tend toward zero and the state variables reah the referene one. Also, it is visible that the omputed oordinates, of optimal operating point, based on the proposed algorithm, are almost the same as the ideal optimal operating point. This analysis allows demonstrating the performane of the proposed algorithm. 6. Conlusion n this paper, a new algorithm strategy based on the augmented Takagi-Sugeno type fuzzy system has been proposed for the MPPT of a PV energy system. All the PV system has been modeled by T-S fuzzy system. Based on the measurement of temperature and irradiation, we dedue the oordinates of the desired optimal operating point whih orresponds to the maximum power. The MPPT algorithm is based on an augmented T-S fuzzy model and PDC method. The ontroller parameters havebeenomputedbasedonthelmtools.thestabilityof system has been proved based on Lyapunov approah. The simulationresultsshowthattheproposedalgorithmtraks quikly the optimal operating point despite sudden variations of temperature and irradiation.

10 1 SRN Renewable Energy [8] S. Singer, B. Rozenshtein, and S. Surazi, Charaterization of PV array output using a small number of measured parameters, Solar Energy,vol.32,no.5,pp.63 67,1984. [9] H. O. Wang, K. Tanaka, and M. Griffin, Parallel distributed ompensation of nonlinear systems by Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy model, in Proeedings of the EEE nternational Conferene on Fuzzy Systems, pp , Marh [1] L. El Ghaoui and G. Sorletti, Control of rational systems using linear-frational representations and linear matrix inequalities, Automatia,vol.32,no.9,pp , Times 1 4 Figure 19: Evolution of the duty yle. Conflit of nterests The authors delare that there is no onflit of interests regarding the publiation of this paper. Referenes [1] A. Chermitti, O. Boukli-Haene, and B. Mohamed, mprovement of the perturb and observe MPPT algorithm in a photovoltai system under rapidly hanging limati onditions, nternational Computer Appliations, vol.56,no.12, pp. 5 1, 212. [2] J.J.Nedumgatt,K.B.Jayakrishnan,S.Umashankar,D.Vijayakumar,andD.P.Kothari, PerturbandobserveMPPTalgorithm for solar PV systems-modeling and simulation, in Proeedings of the Annual EEE ndia Conferene: Engineering Sustainable Solutions (NDCON 11), Hyderabad, ndia, Deember 211. [3]A.P.K.Yadav,S.Thirumaliah,andG.Haritha, Comparison of MPPTalgorithms for DC-DC onverters based PV systems, nternational Advaned Researh in Eletrial, Eletronis and nstrumentation Engineering,vol.1,no.1,pp.18 23, 212. [4] M. Azzouzi, Comparaison between MPPT P&O and MPPT fuzzy ontrols in optimizing the photovoltai generator, nternational Advaned Computer Siene and Appliations,vol.3,no.12,pp.57 62,212. [5] S. Gomathy, S. Saravanan, and S. Dr. Thangave, Design and implementation of maximum power point traking (MPPT) algorithm for a standalone PV system, nternational Sientifi & Engineering Researh, vol.3,no.3,pp , 212. [6] G. Balasubramanian and S. Singaravelu, Fuzzy logi ontroller for the maximum power point traking in photovoltai system, nternational Computer Appliations, vol.41,no.12, pp.22 28,212. [7] L. Jie and C. Ziran, Researh on the MPPT algorithms of photovoltai system based on PV neural network, in Proeedings of the Chinese Control and Deision Conferene (CCDC 11),pp , Mianyang, China, May 211.

11 Energy nternational Rotating Mahinery Wind Energy The Sientifi World Journal Strutures ndustrial Engineering Petroleum Engineering Solar Energy Submit your manusripts at Fuels Engineering Advanes in Power Eletronis nternational High Energy Physis Photoenergy nternational Advanes in Combustion Nulear Energy Renewable Energy nternational Advanes in Siene and Tehnology of Tribology Nulear nstallations Aerospae Engineering