Are There Links Between Earthquakes and Oil & Gas Activity in Oklahoma?
|
|
- Emory Strickland
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Are There Links Between Earthquakes and Oil & Gas Activity in Oklahoma? Randy Keller, Director Austin Holland, Research Seismologist Oklahoma Geological Survey Collaborators: Kyle Murray, Ken Luza, and many students
2 Increased Earthquake Activity in Oklahoma What we know and what we don't know Randy Keller, Director Austin Holland, Research Seismologist Oklahoma Geological Survey Collaborators: Kyle Murray, Ken Luza, and many students
3 Are There Links Between Earthquakes and Oil & Gas Activity in Oklahoma? In Some Cases Collaborators: Kyle Murray, Ken Luza, and many students
4 Earthquake Triggering Natural Causes Dynamically by the passage of seismic waves Remote Triggering Statically by local stress changes from previous earthquakes Small amounts of stress change have been shown to trigger earthquakes as little as 2-7 psi Natural fluid movement May be the cause of many aftershocks Hydrologic loads-some correlations with rainfall Anthropogenic Reservoir Impoundment Mining and Oil Production (Mass Removal) Fluid Injection Geothermal Production & Thermal Contraction
5 Earthquake Triggering How? Increase in shear stress Mass changes Permeability barriers Thermal changes Increase in pore pressure Fluid injected under pressure Fluid injected under little or no pressure can generate a hydraulic head (100 m head ~1 MPa or 145 psi) General Observations Most of the Earth s crust is near failure so the stress released is natural Magnitudes may correlate with total injected volume over time Earthquakes may start close to a well and migrate outward Earthquakes may show a temporal correlation to injection
6 Oklahoma Earthquakes Oklahoma has long been known to be Earthquake Country
7 Seismicity of the US,
8 Meers Fault NW S E
9 An aerial view of the scarp
10 Mapped Faults in Oklahoma
11 A perspective view
12 Perspective View of Oklahoma s Subsurface Structure
13 ~1500ft
14 What about hydrologic fracturing?
15
16 Seismographs Used to Locate OK Events OGS Network is 35 stations
17 Earthquakes years of seismicity 86 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >=4.0
18 Earthquakes years of seismicity 86 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >=4.0 Last 4 years of seismicity 278 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >=4.0
19 Most Oklahoma Faults Appear to be Near Critical Stress Levels Oklahoma Earthquakes 2009 through 2014 Greatest increase in earthquakes is occurring over about 15,000 sq. miles
20 Dramatic Increase in Oklahoma Earthquakes
21 years of seismicity 86 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >= years of seismicity 278 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >= days of seismicity 309 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >=4.0 Updated 08/19/2014 UTC 13:36:45
22 Oklahoma s Increase in Earthquakes Earthquake rates per year Magnitude 4 or Greater Earthquakes Magnitude 3 or Greater Earthquakes Years Years Year Years Year 2009 Year 2010 Year 2011 Year Year 2013 Updated Oct. 20, 2014 Year 2014
23 An increase like this has not been observed in modern seismology in an intra-plate setting. The Gutenberg-Richter Law: log 10 N(x) = a bx It states that, for every 10 magnitude 3.0 earthquakes within a region, we can expect 1 magnitude 4.0 earthquake.
24 Simple Probabilities for Earthquakes From the Gutenberg-Richter Scaling Law
25 An example of the result of high Q
26 Earthquakes Present Mississippi Lime Play years of seismicity 86 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >= Present Jones Swarm Woodford Shale Play M5.6 Prague & Hunton Dewatering
27 Seismicity Rates Mississippi Lime Play Large amounts of produced water ~10% oil cut Best correlation to change in injection volumes and seismicity rates Increase in 2009 Southern extent Increase in Heart of the play, northern Oklahoma Cumulative Number of Earthquakes
28 Disposal wells in Oklahoma It is very hard to find an earthquake that is not near an injection well. Is the well active? What is the injected volume? What is the pressure?
29 Which zones are used for EOR and SWD injection? KS UIC data from KGS (2013) Well Database OK UIC data from Lord (2012) UIC Database Murray and Irwinsky, 2013-in review
30
31 Well Completions /2012 ~5000 wells completed Compilation from the OCC ~50 wells bad spatial referencing
32 Earthquakes years of seismicity 86 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >=4.0 Last 4 years of seismicity 278 earthquakes magnitude >= earthquakes magnitude >=4.0
33 ~1500ft
34 Earthquakes triggered by hydraulic fracturing Several earthquakes felt by one local resident Largest earthquake M earthquakes >= M 2.0 Holland, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Amer. (2013)
35 Identification is easy when you have more information; took ~6 months to get injection data Holland, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Amer. (2013)
36
37 What are pressures versus depth in the Arbuckle Group? KS & OK Arbuckle pressure data from IHS database (Murray et al., 2014, in preparation)
38 Pressure distribution in the Arbuckle Group? OK Arbuckle pressure data from IHS database
39 Interagency Cooperation OCC UIC Program Data OGS Optimally Oriented Faults New Permit & Existing Permits Fault Maps Earthquake Information Fault Database Project Earthquake Monitoring and Reporting Injection and Operational Data Additional Studies
40 Industry Contributing to Enhanced Fault Database
41 3D geologic and geophysical model development 100,000 s of Wells in central Oklahoma Geological and geophysical logs combined to build 3D models Incorporated into 3D seismic velocity models Geospatially referenced surfaces Hunton (orange) and basement (brown). Geologic units are assigned physical properties such as from well logs with spatially varying properties such as permeability, density, porosity, and velocity.
42 Current Mitigation Steps Oklahoma Corporation Commission is the regulator of UIC Class II wells, and have implemented different mitigation strategies New rules regarding reporting of injection volumes and pressures in the Arbuckle Permit modifications; i.e. Traffic Light System Enhanced reporting requirements in OCC areas of interest, currently 10 km around ML 4+ earthquakes New permits are checked against fault maps and background seismicity
43 Industry Contributing to Enhanced Fault Database
44 General Comments No dramatic increase in injected volumes in significant areas are associated with corresponding earthquakes Except for the Mississippi Lime Play & perhaps the Woodford Shale Play Injected volumes have been decreasing in the Hunton Dewatering Play Given the rate of known cases of induced seismicity it is unlikely that the entire earthquake rate increase in Oklahoma is due to fluid injection from oil and gas More than 10,000 UIC Class II wells in Oklahoma More than 80% of Oklahoma is within 15 km of a UIC Class II well (It would be hard not to have spatial correlations) Either there is a natural contribution to some of the rate increase, or there is a large-scale tipping point that has been reached Developing a set of best practices
45 Summary of Induced Seismicity Issues If not addressed properly, Induced Seismicity could unduly delay and cancel important energy applications (already has) Oil and Gas, CCS, Geothermal Has come to the attention of Congress (NAS Study) Induced seismicity issues are not new (over 100 yrs). Generally, causes are known and have been (or can be) mitigated Induced Seismicity risk cannot be calculated in the same manner as natural seismicity Must calculate risk as an adaptive process Must have a mitigation plan Risk will change as net volume increases Best practices must be developed for all stakeholders needs Geothermal best practices in use and being followed by the industry Modified from points raised by: Ernie Majer LBL
46 Conclusions & Further Work We do see some induced, or triggered, earthquakes in Oklahoma Like the rest of the country, induced earthquakes are probably rare We may be seeing a combination of natural earthquake rate changes and induced seismicity Adding more staff and seismic stations to do more science and better understand our earthquakes RPSEA (DoE) Grant has recently been funded and work is well underway
47
48
49 Some Considerations Concerning the Formulation of Best Practices It is for regulators or operators to decide what level of risk is acceptable? Within an established risk level, non-specific terms such as frequent and near can be more precisely defined. The recommendations would be general and based on current understanding of the causes of induced seismicity.
50 Sources for some ideas about best practices Minimizing and managing potential impacts of induced-seismicity from class II disposal wells: practical approaches, EPA Draft released through FOIA Committee on Induced Potential in Energy Technologies, Induced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies, National Academy of Sciences. Nicholson, C. & Wesson, R.L., Earthquake Hazard Associated With Deep Well Injection -- A Report the the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, U.S. Geological Survey Bulletin, 1951, 74. Zoback, M.D., Managing the Seismic Risk Posed by Wastewater Disposal, Earth Magazine, April Shemeta, J.E., Eide, E.A., Hitzman, M.W., Clarke, D.D., Detournay, E., Dietrich, J.H., Dillon, D.K., Green, S.J., Habiger, R.M., McGuire, R.K., Mitchell, J.K., Smith, J.L. & Gibbs, C.R., The potential for induced seismicity in energy technologies, The Leading Edge, December, Talwani, P., Chen, L. & Ghalaut, K., Seismogenic permeability, k s, J. Geophys. Res., 112, Davis, S.D. & Frohlich, C., Did (or Will) Fluid Injection Cause Earthquakes? Criteria for a Rational Assessment, Seismol. Res. Lett., 64, Majer, E.L., Baria, R., Stark, M., Oates, S., Bommer, J., Smith, B. & Asanuma, H., Induced siemicity associated with Enhanced Geothermal Systems, Geothermics, 36, Shapiro, S.A., Dinske, C. & Kummerow, J., Probability of a given-magnitude earthquake induced by a fluid injection, Geophys. Res. Lett., 34, 1-5. Suckale, J., Induced Seismicity in Hydrocarbon Fields, Advances in Geophysics, 51, Case examples from: Paradox Valley, CO; Rocky Mountain Arsenal, CO; Rangely, CO; Carthage Cotton Valley Gas Field, TX; Fenton Hill, NM; KTB Deep Drilling Site; Basel; Cooper Basin; Soultz-sous-Foreˆts Hot Dry Rock facility, and many others
51 Our Workshop Brought Out Several Tricky Questions About Faults Where are the faults located? What does near really mean? What does large mean, and how do we measure it? What is the depth extent of faults? Is anyone willing to share their information that would help us address these questions?
52 Identified risk factors for triggered seismicity Proximity to known faults, large faults poses a greater risk for consequences Faults oriented favorably within the regional stress field Historical background seismicity indicates that there are faults at or near critical stress and favorably oriented within the regional stress field These are environments which would be considered higher risk environments for fluid injection Earthquake triggering occurs naturally in areas without fluid injection (van der Elst & Brodsky 2010) Earthquakes can be dynamically triggered by the passage of surface waves from distant large earthquakes or remotely triggered Indicates that small stress or pore pressure changes have an impact on fault rupture (van der Elst et al., 2013, Science)
53 Proximity to faults 1. Fluid injection near known faults should be avoided Faults and asperities (fault roughness) within faults act as stress concentrators, fault branches also act as stress concentrators Faults can act as both permeability barriers as well as high permeability zones (highly dependent on fault properties) Highly permeable zones can channel the diffusion of pore pressure significantly large distances Fluid pressure may build near an injection well (does not require injection under pressure, hydraulic head) 2. Fluid injection wells should be sited further from faults that are favorably oriented within either the regional or local stress field Zoback (April 2012) Earth magazine, and many others
54 Optimal Fault Orientations for Oklahoma Approximate Regional Stress Field
55 Monitoring of injection and formation pressure 3. Injection pressure and volume should be monitored and recorded frequently during the operation of the well. Monthly injection information will likely not accurately represent the injection history of the well Inadequate for detailed reservoir modeling 4. Formation pressure should be as often as practical. However, at a minimum, regular shut in, pressure fall-off tests should be conducted to measure formation pressure. This monitoring may help identify when and how fluid injection is altering properties within the formation Has the potential to improve performance of an injection well May help to identify or discount potential induced seismicity
56 Injection into or near basement 5. Injection into crystalline basement should be avoided. Permeability in crystalline basement is generally low Fluid and pore pressure may concentrate in networks of existing natural fractures and faults where permeability is the greatest Permeability barriers or spatial inhomogeneity can lead to increased stress
57 Permeability Barriers Can Increase Stress Roeloffs and Denlinger (SSA Mtg 2013) Permeability Barrier in the injected formation
58 Balance of fluid volumes 6. In operations that involve both production and injection of fluids in nearby wells, volumes should ideally be balanced to avoid any major increase in net fluid volume. Recommended by the NAS Induced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies If net fluid volume injected is related to magnitude then this is one method of mitigation Does not address majority of disposal wells This may not be true in geothermal fields Recent work at the Salton Sea, Brodsky and Lajoie (2013) Science
59 Additional Monitoring in Higher Risk Environments 7. The siting of new injection wells in higher risk environments should be approached with caution. More frequent monitoring of injected volume, injection pressure, and formation pressure is recommended, as well as additional earthquake monitoring. 8. In cases where fluid injection is occurring in higher risk environments, additional geotechnical information may help to provide further constraints on injection limits. Mini-fracs and image logs can provide the orientation and magnitude of stresses as well as the orientation of natural fractures and can help to address the potential for triggered seismicity.
60 Response to Potential Induced Seismicity 9. The operator should have a plan in place to recognize and respond in a timely manner to unexpected seismicity or changes in injection pressure or volume. Modifications to injection parameters Additional seismic monitoring Prior to operations, identify what levels of seismicity will generate actions within a response plan Zoback (April 2012) Earth magazine
61 LOVE COUNTY 2013 STATUS UPDATE Austin Holland, Research Seismologist Oklahoma Geological Survey ( )
62 The Love Co. example where the operator is on a yellow light status Earthquake swarms have occurred in the past Poorly recorded because they were shallow so the regional network did not do well detecting and locating them Portable deployments were attempted but unsuccessful due to shallow depths Earthquakes /29/2013 Personal Comm. Ken Luza (OGS)
63 Some Additional Questions Are there additional risk factors not identified here? What should be considered near a fault? Is there additional geotechnical information that may be useful in high risk environments? Extent of seismic monitoring? Is the database available to the public adequate? Capability to detect small earthquakes? Establish baseline prior to start of injection? Impact of local geology? What about companies that only do waste water disposal?
64 In spite of recent controversial high profile publications and statements by some earthquake seismologists, there is a lot agreement. The earthquake seismic community broadly agrees that earthquake triggering by injection wells is a rare occurrence. However, there are a few well-documented examples. This community also agrees that the probability of a damaging earthquake being triggered by hydraulic fracturing is extremely low. What can we, should we do? Ignore the issue Wait until something really bad happens Take some measured steps such as considering some best practices concerning fluid injection
65 Summary of Induced Seismicity Issues If not addressed properly, Induced Seismicity could unduly delay and cancel important energy applications (already has) Oil and Gas, CCS, Geothermal Has come to the attention of Congress (NAS Study) Induced seismicity issues are not new (over 100 yrs). Generally, causes are known and have been (or can be) mitigated Induced Seismicity risk cannot be calculated in the same manner as natural seismicity Must calculate risk as an adaptive process Must have a mitigation plan Risk will change as net volume increases Best practices must be developed for all stakeholders needs Geothermal best practices in use and being followed by the industry Modified from points raised by: Ernie Majer LBL
66 Conclusions & Further Work We do see some induced, or triggered, earthquakes in Oklahoma Like the rest of the country, induced earthquakes are probably rare We may be seeing a combination of natural earthquake rate changes and induced seismicity Adding more staff and seismic stations to do more science and better understand our earthquakes RPSEA (DoE) Grant has just been funded and work is underway
67 Induced Seismicity from Fluid Injection Increased pore pressure from fluid injection effectively reduces friction on fault Or in Mohr-Coulomb space moves the circle towards failure Increase deviatoric stress o σ 1 -σ 3 σ n Failure σ i Add Pore Pressure - p
68 Pressure Diffuses Within the Earth Pressure increase is not due to actual fluid flow Can be much more rapid Because water is fairly incompressible it is similar to an elastic response although slower Diffusivity constant is T = transmissivity S = storativity Proportional to permeability Pressure Talwani increases et al. (2007) over J. Geophys time Res.
69 Maximum Seismic Moment (related to magnitude) vs. Injected Volume RAT=Raton Basin RMA=Rocky Mtn Arsenal. YOH=Youngstown OH PBN=Paradox Valley CO GAK=Guy AK BAS=Basel Switzerland GAR=Garvin County OK BUK=Bowland Shale UK KTB=Eastern Bavaria Germany Injection Duration Courtesy of Art McGarr (USGS)
70 Earthquakes may start close to the well and migrate away Pressure diffusion is often modeled using this observation Most of the earthquakes still tend to occur very near the injection interval Paradox Valley, Ake et al. (2005)
71 Stress Changes from mass or volume changes Fluid extraction can change the stress field and style of faulting Stress changes and style of faulting modeled for extraction from a reservoir Stress changes can also occur due mass loading reservoir loading Segall (1989)
72 Are all faults created equal? Large faults may lead to large earthquakes Energy and magnitude are proportional to fault size Faults of all sizes show great complexity at all subsequent scales This makes identifying all optimally oriented faults problematic Scholz (1990)
73 Optimal Fault Orientations Sibson (1990) Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am. Red lines indicate the range of possible orientations aligned within the regional stress field. Fault slip outside of this region is unlikely but possible with very dramatic increases in pore pressure.
74 Active Fault Orientations in Oklahoma Holland (2013) Seismol. Res. Let.
75 Stress Orientations from Focal Mechanisms Oklahoma is generally experiencing eastwest compression in a strike-slip regime Most notable exception are parts of the Jones swarm which show NE-SW compressive strikeslip regime, with faults oriented N-S
76 UIC Wells It is very hard to find an earthquake that is not near an injection well. Is the well active? What is the injected volume? What is the pressure? KS Well Locations from: KGS (2013) Well Database OK Well Locations from: Lord (2012) UIC Database
77
Recent Earthquakes in Oklahoma. and Potential for Induced Seismicity Austin Holland Oklahoma State Seismologist
Recent Earthquakes in Oklahoma and the Mid-Continent: Significance and Potential for Induced Seismicity Austin Holland Oklahoma State Seismologist Outline Seismicity Rates in Mid-continent and Oklahoma
More informationConcerns About the Poten/al for Induced Seismicity Associated with the Mississippian Play: Perceived or Real?
Concerns About the Poten/al for Induced Seismicity Associated with the Mississippian Play: Perceived or Real? Aus/n Holland and Dr. G. Randy Keller Oklahoma Geological Survey University of Oklahoma 10/31/12
More informationJulie Shemeta, MEQ Geo Inc., WCEE Webinar 1/13/2016 1/14/2016
1/14/16 1 Julie Shemeta, MEQ Geo Inc., WCEE Webinar 1/13/2016 1/14/2016 WSJ, Nov 16, 2015 Women s Council on Energy and the Environment (WCEE) January 13, 2016 http://www.cpr.org 1/7/2016 http://stateimpact.npr.org/texas/tag/earthquake/
More informationFAQs - Earthquakes Induced by Fluid Injection
of 1 http://earthquake.usgs.gov/learn/faq/?categoryid=46&faqid=357 4/23/2012 9:26 PM Q: Does the production of natural gas from shales cause earthquakes? If so, how are the earthquakes related to these
More informationInduced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies
Induced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies Conducted by the National Research Council s Committee on Induced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies Sponsor Department of Energy Overseen by
More informationUnraveling the Mysteries of Seismicity in Oklahoma. A Story Map
Unraveling the Mysteries of Seismicity in Oklahoma A Story Map Background Why create a story map? Visualization of various types of data (graphics, text, symbols, etc.) within a geographical context to
More informationAddressing the risks of induced seismicity in sub-surface energy operations
Addressing the risks of induced seismicity in sub-surface energy operations Richard Porter a, Alberto Striolo a, Haroun Mahgerefteh a, Joanna Faure Walker b a Department of Chemical Engineering, University
More informationPotential Injection-Induced Seismicity Associated With Oil & Gas Development
Potential Injection-Induced Seismicity Associated With Oil & Gas Development A primer on technical & regulatory considerations informing risk management & mitigation Second Edition September, 2017 www.statesfirstinitiative.org
More informationTectonic Seismogenic Index of Geothermal Reservoirs
Tectonic Seismogenic Index of Geothermal Reservoirs C. Dinske 1, F. Wenzel 2 and S.A. Shapiro 1 1 Freie Universität Berlin 2 KIT Karlsruhe November 27, 2012 Introduction M max reservoir location -2.0 Barnett
More informationAn Investigation on the Effects of Different Stress Regimes on the Magnitude Distribution of Induced Seismic Events
An Investigation on the Effects of Different Stress Regimes on the Magnitude Distribution of Induced Seismic Events Afshin Amini, Erik Eberhardt Geological Engineering, University of British Columbia,
More informationWhat We Know (and don t know)
What We Know (and don t know) about the M5.1 La Habra Earthquake Dr. Robert Graves U.S. Geological Survey In collaboration with: Dr. Egill Hauksson and Dr. Thomas Göbel Caltech Dr. Elizabeth Cochran U.S.
More informationSeismicity and the SWD-C4A well: An ongoing UIC case study in the Denver Basin, Colorado
Seismicity and the SWD-C4A well: An ongoing UIC case study in the Denver Basin, Colorado Ground Water Protection Council Annual Forum October 6, 2014 Chris Eisinger Stuart Ellsworth Bob Koehler I. Colorado
More informationInduced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies
Induced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies Robin K. McGuire Lettis Consultants International, Inc. Boulder, Colorado Committee on Induced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies, National
More informationInterpretation of Microseismic Events of Large Magnitudes Collected at Cooper Basin, Australia and at Basel, Switzerland
Proceedings World Geothermal Congress 2010 Bali, Indonesia, 25-29 April 2010 Interpretation of Microseismic Events of Large Magnitudes Collected at Cooper Basin, Australia and at Basel, Switzerland Yusuke
More informationOklahoma Earthquakes: Trends and Underlying Causes. Jeremy Boak, Oklahoma Geological Survey October 21, 2016
Oklahoma Earthquakes: Trends and Underlying Causes Jeremy Boak, Oklahoma Geological Survey jboak@ou.edu October 21, 2016 1 The Oklahoma Geological Survey is a state agency for research and public service
More informationAnalysis of Seismicity Coincident with Hydraulic Fracturing of a Well in South Central Oklahoma Amberlee Darold, Research Seismologist Austin
Analysis of Seismicity Coincident with Hydraulic Fracturing of a Well in South Central Oklahoma Amberlee Darold, Research Seismologist Austin Holland, State Seismologist Oklahoma Geological Survey adarold@ou.edu
More informationColorado s Underground Injection Control Program: Prevention and Mitigation of Induced Seismicity
Colorado s Underground Injection Control Program: Prevention and Mitigation of Induced Seismicity Energy & Environment Symposium April 2015 Robert P. Koehler, PhD. UIC Lead OVERVIEW What is a UIC well?
More informationModeling pressure response into a fractured zone of Precambrian basement to understand deep induced-earthquake hypocenters from shallow injection
Modeling pressure response into a fractured zone of Precambrian basement to understand deep induced-earthquake hypocenters from shallow injection S. Raziperchikolaee 1 and J. F. Miller 1 Abstract Analysis
More informationRegulatory Considerations for Evaluating the Potential for Induced Seismicity of a Class I Non-Hazardous Disposal Well
Regulatory Considerations for Evaluating the Potential for Induced Seismicity of a Class I Non-Hazardous Disposal Well Chad Milligan, P.G.-SCS Engineers Craig Pangburn, P.G.-T&C Consulting Many Options
More informationDaniel O Connell and Robert Creed. Fugro Consultants, Inc Cole Blvd., Suite 230, Lakewood CO
PROCEEDINGS, Thirty-Eighth Workshop on Geothermal Reservoir Engineering Stanford University, Stanford, California, February 11-13, 2013 SGP-TR-198 DETERMINING INJECTION-INDUCED EARTHQUAKE MAGNITUDE AND
More information3D Finite Element Modeling of fault-slip triggering caused by porepressure
3D Finite Element Modeling of fault-slip triggering caused by porepressure changes Arsalan Sattari and David W. Eaton Department of Geoscience, University of Calgary Suary We present a 3D model using a
More informationHow will induced seismicity in Oklahoma respond to decreased saltwater injection rates?
SEISMOLOGY How will induced seismicity in Oklahoma respond to decreased saltwater injection rates? Cornelius Langenbruch* and Mark D. Zoback In response to the marked number of injection-induced earthquakes
More informationInduced Seismicity: Can it Happen in Kentucky Too?
Induced Seismicity: Can it Happen in Kentucky Too? Seth Carpenter Seismologist Geologic Hazards Section 2015 KGS Annual Seminar Outline - What s the problem? - Earthquake magnitude - Types of induced seismic
More informationUSGS: USGS: NEIC NEIC
Triggered Earthquakes in North-Central Arkansas and their Relationship to Class II UIC Wells Scott M. Ausbrooks, The Arkansas Geological Survey Steve Horton, Ph.D., CERI at University i of Memphis Contributors:
More informationGeomechanical Analysis of Hydraulic Fracturing Induced Seismicity at Duvernay Field in Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin
Geomechanical Analysis of Hydraulic Fracturing Induced Seismicity at Duvernay Field in Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin Suvrat P Lele 1, Timothy Tyrrell 2, Ganeswara R Dasari 1, William A Symington 1
More informationRisk Evaluation. Todd Shipman PhD, Alberta Geological Survey/Alberta Energy Regulator November 17 th,2017 Induced Seismicity Workshop, Yellowknife NWT
Risk Evaluation Todd Shipman PhD, Alberta Geological Survey/Alberta Energy Regulator November 17 th,2017 Induced Seismicity Workshop, Yellowknife NWT Risk Management Approach to Induced Seismicity Establishing
More informationCOGCC Underground Injection Program & Induced Seismicity
COGCC Underground Injection Program & Induced Seismicity February 2017 Stuart Ellsworth, Engineering Manager Bob Koehler, UIC Lead, Geologic Advisor Agenda: Colorado UIC Permit Process UIC Well Construction
More informationTexNet and CISR: An Update on Monitoring and Understanding Seismicity in Texas
TexNet and CISR: An Update on Monitoring and Understanding Seismicity in Texas Michael H. Young a, Alexandros Savvaidis a, Peter Hennings a, Ellen Rathje b a Bureau of Economic Geology, Jackson School
More information1 of 5 12/10/2018, 2:38 PM
1 of 5 12/10/2018, 2:38 PM The depth of the rock layer that serves as the disposal site for wastewater produced during unconventional oil extraction plays a significant role in whether that disposal triggers
More informationChapter 6. Conclusions. 6.1 Conclusions and perspectives
Chapter 6 Conclusions 6.1 Conclusions and perspectives In this thesis an approach is presented for the in-situ characterization of rocks in terms of the distribution of hydraulic parameters (called SBRC
More informationPassive seismic monitoring in unconventional oil and gas
Passive seismic monitoring in unconventional oil and gas Michael Kendall, James Verdon, Alan Baird, Anna Stork and Philip Usher Bristol University Microseismicity Projects (BUMPS) Microseismicity and
More informationFinite element modelling of fault stress triggering due to hydraulic fracturing
Finite element modelling of fault stress triggering due to hydraulic fracturing Arsalan, Sattari and David, Eaton University of Calgary, Geoscience Department Summary In this study we aim to model fault
More informationRall Walsh and Mark Zoback
Update to Oklahoma s Recent Earthquakes and Saltwater Disposal with 2014 Injection Data 1 Rall Walsh and Mark Zoback Fig. 1. Earthquakes and injection wells in Oklahoma. The map shows the locations of
More informationExtending the magnitude range of seismic reservoir monitoring by Utilizing Hybrid Surface Downhole Seismic Networks
Extending the magnitude range of seismic reservoir monitoring by Utilizing Hybrid Surface Downhole Seismic Networks Gisela Viegas*, ESG, Kingston, Ontario, Canada Gisela.Fernandes@esgsolutions.com and
More informationMEASUREMENT OF HYDRAULICALLY ACTIVATED SUBSURFACE FRACTURE SYSTEM IN GEOTHERMAL RESERVOIR BY USING ACOUSTIC EMISSION MULTIPLET-CLUSTERING ANALYSIS
MEASUREMENT OF HYDRAULICALLY ACTIVATED SUBSURFACE FRACTURE SYSTEM IN GEOTHERMAL RESERVOIR BY USING ACOUSTIC EMISSION MULTIPLET-CLUSTERING ANALYSIS HIROKAZU MORIYA 1, HIROAKI NIITSUMA 1 and ROY BARIA 2
More informationBRIEFING MEMO ON RESERVOIR TRIGGERED SEISMICITY (RTS)
BRIEFING MEMO ON RESERVOIR TRIGGERED SEISMICITY (RTS) 1. General. The issue of reservoir-triggered seismicity (RTS) has been controversial, and hotly debated, for many decades. There has been general recognition
More informationPreliminary Analysis of the 2013 Love County Earthquake Swarm. Austin A. Holland
OF1-2013 V. 2013.9.30 1 Preliminary Analysis of the 2013 Love County Earthquake Swarm Austin A. Holland Oswalt E2060 35 Marietta Legend Report Locality Earthquake MMI: 0 0.5 1 2 Miles III IV V VI VII Created
More informationCoulomb stress changes due to Queensland earthquakes and the implications for seismic risk assessment
Coulomb stress changes due to Queensland earthquakes and the implications for seismic risk assessment Abstract D. Weatherley University of Queensland Coulomb stress change analysis has been applied in
More informationCOULOMB STRESS CHANGES DUE TO RECENT ACEH EARTHQUAKES
COULOMB STRESS CHANGES DUE TO RECENT ACEH EARTHQUAKES Madlazim Physics Department, Faculty Mathematics and Sciences of Surabaya State University (UNESA) Jl. Ketintang, Surabaya 60231, Indonesia. e-mail:
More informationWhite Paper II Summarizing a Special Session on Induced Seismicity
White Paper II Summarizing a Special Session on Induced Seismicity November 2013 White Paper II on Induced Seismicity Page 1 White Paper II Summarizing a Special Session on Induced Seismicity 1 Chapter
More informationDallas-Fort Worth and Cleburne, TX
The 2008-20092009 Earthquakes Near Dallas-Fort Worth and Cleburne, TX See also paper in Leading Edge March 2010 Cliff Frohlich Institute for Geophysics University of Texas Eric Potter Bureau of Economic
More informationSeismicity in Texas in Relation to Active Class I Underground Injection Control Wells: Preliminary Observations
Seismicity in Texas in Relation to Active Class I Underground Injection Control Wells: Preliminary Observations David Murry Groundwater Protection Council UIC Conference Austin, Texas February 22, 2017
More informationFrom an earthquake perspective, 2011 was. Managing the Seismic Risk Posed by Wastewater Disposal. 38 EARTH April
Liquid carbon dioxide has been injected into the Sleipner gas- and oilfield in the North Sea for 15 years without triggering any seismicity. It serves as a good example of how fluid injection can be done
More informationYusuke Mukuhira. Integration of Induced Seismicity and Geomechanics For Better Understanding of Reservoir Physics
Integration of Induced Seismicity and Geomechanics For Better Understanding of Reservoir Physics Yusuke Mukuhira Postdoctoral Fellow (JSPS research fellow) Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary
More informationRisk Treatment. Todd Shipman PhD, Alberta Geological Survey/Alberta Energy Regulator November 17 th,2017 Induced Seismicity Workshop, Yellowknife NWT
Risk Treatment Todd Shipman PhD, Alberta Geological Survey/Alberta Energy Regulator November 17 th,2017 Induced Seismicity Workshop, Yellowknife NWT Risk Management Approach to Induced Seismicity Establishing
More informationCharacterizing and Responding to Seismic Risk Associated with Earthquakes Potentially Triggered by Saltwater Disposal and Hydraulic Fracturing
Characterizing and Responding to Seismic Risk Associated with Earthquakes Potentially Triggered by Saltwater Disposal and Hydraulic Fracturing R. J. Walters 1, M. D. Zoback 1, J. W. Baker 2 and G. C. Beroza
More informationAre earthquakes triggered by hydraulic fracturing more common than previously recognized? Aus$n Holland and Amberlee Darold GSA South- Central Sec$on
Are earthquakes triggered by hydraulic fracturing more common than previously recognized? Aus$n Holland and Amberlee Darold GSA South- Central Sec$on 2015 Earthquakes Triggered by Hydraulic Fracturing
More informationSPATIAL AND TEMPORAL DISTRBUTION OF LARGER SEISMIC EVENTS AT EUROPEAN AND AUSTRALIAN HDR SITES
PROCEEDINGS, Thirty-First Workshop on Geothermal Reservoir Engineering Stanford University, Stanford, California, January 30-February 1, 2006 SGP-TR-179 SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL DISTRBUTION OF LARGER SEISMIC
More informationMaking the Earth Shake:
M A R C E L L U S S H A L E I S S U E N U M B E R 3 M A Y 2 0 1 1 Making the Earth Shake: Understanding Induced Seismicity A discussion of the possibility of induced seismicity resulting from natural gas
More informationEarthquakes. Earthquake Magnitudes 10/1/2013. Environmental Geology Chapter 8 Earthquakes and Related Phenomena
Environmental Geology Chapter 8 Earthquakes and Related Phenomena Fall 2013 Northridge 1994 Kobe 1995 Mexico City 1985 China 2008 Earthquakes Earthquake Magnitudes Earthquake Magnitudes Richter Magnitude
More informationEstimating energy balance for hydraulic fracture stimulations: Lessons Learned from Basel
Estimating energy balance for hydraulic fracture stimulations: Lessons Learned from Basel David W. Eaton*, Department of Geoscience, University of Calgary, Calgary, Canada eatond@ucalgary.ca and Neda Boroumand,
More informationKansas Underground Injection Control Program & Induced Seismicity. By: Benjamin Busboom Stinson Leonard Street
Kansas Underground Injection Control Program & Induced Seismicity By: Benjamin Busboom Stinson Leonard Street What is underground injection? Unground injection is used to place fluid underground into porous
More informationEnhanced remote earthquake triggering at fluid injection sites in the Midwestern US
Enhanced remote earthquake triggering at fluid injection sites in the Midwestern US Nicholas van der Elst 1 Heather Savage 1 Katie Keranen 2 Geoff Abers 1 1 Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory 2 Cornell University
More informationLocation uncertainty for a microearhquake cluster
Analysis of location uncertainty for a microearhquake cluster: A case study Gabriela Melo, Alison Malcolm, Oleg Poliannikov, and Michael Fehler Earth Resources Laboratory - Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary
More informationKEY CONTROLLING FACTORS OF SHALEGAS INDUCED SEISMICITY
KEY CONTROLLING FACTORS OF SHALEGAS INDUCED SEISMICITY Brecht Wassing, Jan ter Heege, Ellen van der Veer, Loes Buijze Acknowledgements This work is part of a project that received funding by the European
More informationINDUCED SEISMICITY AND THE O&G INDUSTRY
INDUCED SEISMICITY AND THE O&G INDUSTRY This presentation represents the collective thoughts of subject matter experts drawn from AXPC member companies and other Oil and Gas Industry companies. The subject
More informationRisk Management of Induced Seismicity: Technical Elements & Research Opportunities
October 30, 2014 Risk Management of Induced Seismicity: Technical Elements & Research Opportunities K. J. (Kris) Nygaard, ExxonMobil Upstream Research Company U.S. Department of Energy Informational Briefing
More informationMinimizing and Managing Potential Impacts of Injection-Induced Seismicity from Class II Disposal Wells: Practical Approaches
Minimizing and Managing Potential Impacts of Injection-Induced Seismicity from Class II Disposal Wells: Practical Approaches Philip Dellinger, Chief Ground Water/UIC Section EPA Region 6 Acknowledgments
More informationFrom observations of microseismic source parameters to reservoir geomechanics
From observations of microseismic source parameters to reservoir geomechanics B. Goertz-Allmann 1, V. Gischig, C. Bachmann, and S. Wiemer AGIS workshop, 27 th November 2012 1 now at Presentation outline
More informationMINIMIZING AND MANAGING POTENTIAL IMPACTS OF INJECTION INDUCED SEISMICITY FROM CLASS II DISPOSAL WELLS: PRACTICAL APPROACHES
MINIMIZING AND MANAGING POTENTIAL IMPACTS OF INJECTION INDUCED SEISMICITY FROM CLASS II DISPOSAL WELLS: PRACTICAL APPROACHES Underground Injection Control National Technical Workgroup US Environmental
More informationPREDICTIVE MODELING OF INDUCED SEISMICITY: NUMERICAL APPROACHES, APPLICATIONS, AND CHALLENGES
PREDICTIVE MODELING OF INDUCED SEISMICITY: NUMERICAL APPROACHES, APPLICATIONS, AND CHALLENGES Mark McClure Assistant Professor Petroleum and Geosystems Engineering The University of Texas at Austin Overview
More informationInvestigation of Injection-Triggered Slip on Basement Faults: Role of Fluid Leakoff on Post Shut-In Seismicity
Proceedings World Geothermal Congress 2015 Melbourne, Australia, 19-25 April 2015 Investigation of Injection-Triggered Slip on Basement Faults: Role of Fluid Leakoff on Post Shut-In Seismicity Jack Norbeck
More informationSynthetic Seismicity Models of Multiple Interacting Faults
Synthetic Seismicity Models of Multiple Interacting Faults Russell Robinson and Rafael Benites Institute of Geological & Nuclear Sciences, Box 30368, Lower Hutt, New Zealand (email: r.robinson@gns.cri.nz).
More informationA comparison of seismicity rates and fluid injection operations in Oklahoma and California: Implications for crustal stresses
A comparison of seismicity rates and fluid injection operations in Oklahoma and California: Implications for crustal stresses Thomas Goebel California Institute of Technology Seismological Laboratory,
More informationLeveraging Cross-Disciplinary Science for Induced Seismicity Risk Management
Transatlantic Knowledge Sharing Conference on Unconventional Hydrocarbons: Resources, Risks, Impact and Research Needs Session 1 Induced Seismicity Amsterdam June 20, 2017 Leveraging Cross-Disciplinary
More informationDEP Office of Oil and Gas Management
DEP Office of Oil and Gas Management Bureau of Oil and Gas Planning and Program Management Well Plugging and Subsurface Activities Division Production Waste Trends and Management May 19, 2017 2017 Shale
More informationThe Stability Of Fault Systems In The South Shore Of The. St. Lawrence Lowlands Of Québec Implications For Shale Gas Development
The Stability Of Fault Systems In The South Shore Of The St. Lawrence Lowlands Of Québec Implications For Shale Gas Development John Brodylo, Jean-Yves Chatellier,Guillaume Matton & Michel Rheault Copyright
More informationKinematic inversion of pre-existing faults by wastewater injection-related induced seismicity: the Val d Agri oil field case study (Italy)
Kinematic inversion of pre-existing faults by wastewater injection-related induced seismicity: the Val d Agri oil field case study (Italy) Buttinelli M., Improta L., Bagh S., Chiarabba C. 1/10 The Val
More informationHuman-Induced Earthquakes from Deep-Well Injection: A Brief Overview
Human-Induced Earthquakes from Deep-Well Injection: A Brief Overview Peter Folger Specialist in Energy and Natural Resources Policy Mary Tiemann Specialist in Environmental Policy December 22, 2014 Congressional
More informationThe Frictional Regime
The Frictional Regime Processes in Structural Geology & Tectonics Ben van der Pluijm WW Norton+Authors, unless noted otherwise 1/25/2016 10:08 AM We Discuss The Frictional Regime Processes of Brittle Deformation
More informationThe Deep Fault Drilling Project, Alpine Fault Getting Inside the Earthquake Machine
The Deep Fault Drilling Project, Alpine Fault Getting Inside the Earthquake Machine John Townend Director, EQC Programme in Seismology and Fault Mechanics Head, School of Geography, Environment and Earth
More informationSupplement A. Effective Coulomb Stress Analysis We assessed changes in Coulomb stress beneath reservoirs by the general theory of decoupled linear poroelasticity [Biot, 1956; Roeloffs, 1988; Wang 2000;
More informationPotential Injection-Induced Seismicity Associated with Oil & Gas Development:
2015 Potential Injection-Induced Seismicity Associated with Oil & Gas Development: A Primer on Technical and Regulatory Considerations Informing Risk Management and Mitigation Potential Injection-Induced
More informationWhat s Shaking in the Barnett Shale? STEP Dallas, August 11, 2015
What s Shaking in the Barnett Shale? STEP Dallas, August 11, 2015 BSEEC.org @BSEEC Barnett Shale Facts The Barnett Shale was the first energy shale to be developed and therefore is the birthplace of the
More informationSeismogenic properties of the crust inferred from recent studies of reservoir-induced seismicity Application to Koyna
Seismogenic properties of the crust inferred from recent studies of reservoir-induced seismicity Application to Koyna Pradeep Talwani Department of Geological Sciences, University of South Carolina, Columbia,
More informationPreliminary Analysis of Seismicity Near Eagleton 1-29, Carter County, July Amberlee Darold, Austin A. Holland, Chen Chen, Amie Youngblood
Preliminary Analysis of Seismicity Near Eagleton 1-29, Carter County, July 2014 Amberlee Darold, Austin A. Holland, Chen Chen, Amie Youngblood Oklahoma Geological Survey Open- File Report OF2-2014 September
More informationModeling Injection-Induced Seismicity with the Physics-Based Earthquake Simulator RSQSim
Modeling Injection-Induced Seismicity with the Physics-Based Earthquake Simulator RSQSim by James H. Dieterich, Keith B. Richards-Dinger, and Kayla A. Kroll INTRODUCTION Although the phenomenon of earthquakes
More informationRISK ANALYSIS AND RISK MANAGEMENT TOOLS FOR INDUCED SEISMICITY
Eleventh U.S. National Conference on Earthquake Engineering Integrating Science, Engineering & Policy June 25-29, 2018 Los Angeles, California RISK ANALYSIS AND RISK MANAGEMENT TOOLS FOR INDUCED SEISMICITY
More informationChallenges and Strategies for Monitoring Induced Seismic Activity
Challenges and Strategies for Monitoring Induced Seismic Activity Designing and operating induced seismic monitoring networks to meet regulations Dario Baturan Geophysical Society of Tulsa 2015 Introduction
More informationDATA MINING THE KNOWN UNKNOWNS OF OKLAHOMA S CLASS II UIC DATA TO IMPROVE INJECTION INDUCED SEISMICITY STUDIES
Groundwater Protection Council (GWPC) Underground Injection Control Conference Tulsa, OK Feb 13, 2018 DATA MINING THE KNOWN UNKNOWNS OF OKLAHOMA S CLASS II UIC DATA TO IMPROVE INJECTION INDUCED SEISMICITY
More informationA century of oil-field operations and earthquakes in the greater Los Angeles Basin, southern California
A century of oil-field operations and earthquakes in the greater Los Angeles Basin, southern California Egill Hauksson 1, Thomas Göbel 1, Jean-Paul Ampuero 1, and Elizabeth Cochran 2 Downloaded 06/03/15
More informationIntegrating Lab and Numerical Experiments to Investigate Fractured Rock
Integrating Lab and Numerical Experiments to Investigate Fractured Rock Bradford H. Hager Director, Earth Resources Laboratory and Cecil and Ida Green Professor Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary
More informationHijiori HDR Reservoir Evaluation by Micro-Earthquake Observation
GRC Transactions, Vol. 38, 2014 Hijiori HDR Reservoir Evaluation by Micro-Earthquake Observation Hideshi Kaieda Central Research Institute of Electric Power Industry, Abiko, Chiba, Japan Keywords HDR,
More informationGeomechanics for reservoir and beyond Examples of faults impact on fluid migration. Laurent Langhi Team Leader August 2014
Geomechanics for reservoir and beyond Examples of faults impact on fluid migration Laurent Langhi Team Leader August 2014 Reservoir Geomechanics It is critical to understand the mechanical behaviour of
More informationPotential risks of fault reactivation associated with the production of shale gas by hydraulic fracturing. Haijun Zhao, Fengshan Ma, Jie Guo
Potential risks of fault reactivation associated with the production of shale gas by hydraulic fracturing Haijun Zhao, Fengshan Ma, Jie Guo Key Laboratory of Shale Gas and Geoengineering, Institute of
More informationCoupling between deformation and fluid flow: impacts on ore genesis in fracture-controlled hydrothermal systems
Coupling between deformation and fluid flow: impacts on ore genesis in fracture-controlled hydrothermal systems Stephen F Cox Research School of Earth Sciences The Australian National University INTRODUCTION
More informationWhat is an Earthquake?
Earthquakes What is an Earthquake? Earthquake - sometimes violent shaking of ground caused by movement of Earth s tectonic plates; creates seismic waves Often followed by smaller earthquakes (aftershocks);
More informationWe are IntechOpen, the world s leading publisher of Open Access books Built by scientists, for scientists. International authors and editors
We are IntechOpen, the world s leading publisher of Open Access books Built by scientists, for scientists 3,500 108,000 1.7 M Open access books available International authors and editors Downloads Our
More informationDangerous tsunami threat off U.S. West Coast
Earthquakes Ch. 12 Dangerous tsunami threat off U.S. West Coast Earthquakes What is an Earthquake? It s the shaking and trembling of the Earth s crust due to plate movement. The plates move, rocks along
More informationResearch in Induced Seismicity
Research in Induced Seismicity Grant Bromhal, NETL GWPC Annual UIC Meeting January 22-24. 2013 1 NAS Study on Induced Seismicity Three major findings emerged from the study: hydraulic fracturing does not
More informationWhite Paper on Induced Seismicity Related to Oil and Gas Development
White Paper on Induced Seismicity Related to Oil and Gas Development Environmentally Friendly Drilling Systems (EFD) Program Houston Advanced Research Center (HARC) 4800 Research Forest Drive The Woodlands,
More informationGeothermal Induced Seismicity : Summary of International Experience IEA-GIA Environmental Mitigation Workshop Taupo, June 2012
Geothermal Induced Seismicity : Summary of International Experience IEA-GIA Environmental Mitigation Workshop Taupo, 15-16 June 2012 1 Chris Bromley, Wairakei Research Centre, Taupo, New Zealand 1.0 Background
More informationRELOCATION OF THE MACHAZE AND LACERDA EARTHQUAKES IN MOZAMBIQUE AND THE RUPTURE PROCESS OF THE 2006 Mw7.0 MACHAZE EARTHQUAKE
RELOCATION OF THE MACHAZE AND LACERDA EARTHQUAKES IN MOZAMBIQUE AND THE RUPTURE PROCESS OF THE 2006 Mw7.0 MACHAZE EARTHQUAKE Paulino C. FEITIO* Supervisors: Nobuo HURUKAWA** MEE07165 Toshiaki YOKOI** ABSTRACT
More informationTable One: Induced seismicity since 2011 in five previously aseismic Ohio counties. Locality County Year Induced Recorded Reference
Merry Christmas Brookfield Here s Five Salt Water Injection Wells Dr. Raymond Beiersdorfer, Distinguished Professor of Geology Department of Geological and Environmental Sciences Youngstown State University,
More informationAbstracts ESG Solutions
Abstracts ESG Solutions 2015-2016 For more information, please contact Melissa Hoy, Technical Marketing Coordinator at melissa.hoy@esgsolutions.com Visit us online at www.esgsolutions.com Abstract #1 Fracture
More informationOn 31 October 2008 and the following day, numerous
Dallas-Fort Worth earthquakes coincident with activity associated with natural gas production Cliff Frohlich and Eric Potter, University of Texas at Austin Chris Hayward and Brian Stump, Southern Methodist
More informationSupplemental Information for. Geospatial analysis of Oklahoma earthquakes ( ): Quantifying the limits of regional-scale earthquake mitigation
GSA Data Repository 8 Supplemental Information for Geospatial analysis of Oklahoma earthquakes ( - 6): Quantifying the limits of regional-scale earthquake mitigation measures Ryan M. Pollyea, Neda Mohammadi,
More informationMaterial is perfectly elastic until it undergoes brittle fracture when applied stress reaches σ f
Material is perfectly elastic until it undergoes brittle fracture when applied stress reaches σ f Material undergoes plastic deformation when stress exceeds yield stress σ 0 Permanent strain results from
More informationAnalysis of Microseismic Events from a Stimulation at Basel, Switzerland
GRC Transactions, Vol. 31, 2007 Analysis of Microseismic Events from a Stimulation at Basel, Switzerland Hiroshi Asanuma 1, Yusuke Kumano 1, Akito Hotta 1, Ulrich Schanz 2, Hiroaki Niitsuma 1, and Markus
More information