Review of Robert A. Paul Mixed Messages: Cultural and Genetic Inheritance in the Constitution of Human Society. Herbert Gintis

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Review of Robert A. Paul Mixed Messages: Cultural and Genetic Inheritance in the Constitution of Human Society. Herbert Gintis"

Transcription

1 Review of Robert A. Paul Mixed Messages: Cultural and Genetic Inheritance in the Constitution of Human Society Herbert Gintis December 12, 2016 Robert A. Paul s recent book is an extremely broad-ranging and informative investigation of cultural dynamics in small-scale societies. Paul is a cultural anthropologist with a broad range of sociological knowledge concerning such societies. His theoretical framework is that of dual inheritance theory, which he applies it to a vast number of issues in different societies. His analysis is very successful scientifically and yet remains enjoyable throughout. He is an excellent writer and the book fits together well. Dual inheritance theory, as I explain below, arose as a theory of the interaction between genes and culture in the evolution of our species the only known species to which the notion of long-term cultural evolution applies. Paul s interpretation of this theory is, however, purely cultural. This interpretation is idiosyncratic, but defensible because he is dealing with societies in time periods too short for extensive genetic evolution to have taken place. Paul s version of dual inheritance theory posits that there are two competing/conflicting systems of human sociality. The first is kinship/family, which we share with innumerable other species. The second is tribal, which does not suppress family, but promotes cooperation, amity, and regard independent of kinship genealogy. He suggests that human cultural symbolic systems induce individuals to stress their cooperation and friendship with non-family, which accounts for our success as a species. Paul has thought deeply about these matters, and his treatment is well worth thinking about. The reason this interpretation of dual inheritance theory is plausible is that humans share with innumerable sexually-reproducing species the tendency to favor family members over genealogically distant individuals. It follows that kin/family preference is genetic in a way that tribal preferences 1

2 are not (applying, as they do, only to our species). Paul stresses repeatedly that kinship/family and tribal cultural systems develop almost independently, and are often in conflict. The fitness-reducing nature of some cultural institutions was stressed by Robert B. Edgerton decades ago in his in his Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony (New York, Press, 1992), and curiously Paul does not reference this great book at all. I suspect that Paul prefers the term dual inheritance to gene-culture coevolution because the latter suggests harmony, not conflict, between the two systems. Paul s treatment of human evolutionary theory is, however, not completely balanced. First, he refers to the masters of inclusive fitness theory only in the historical section of the book, and he misstates repeated the notion that individuals can spread their genes only by personal biological reproduction. This is not a big problem, but it is incorrect and very annoying. Moreover, it conflicts with one of Paul s major building blocks, the kinship/family nexus. As was shown long ago by William see, for instance, his collection of articles Narrow Roads of Gene Land, Oxford University Press, 1998 individuals can enhance their fitness both by raising more offspring or by helping relatives to raise their offspring, precisely because relatives share more genes that randomly selected groups of individuals. Indeed, the main reason humans differentially help relatives is not that we share genes for kin-helping with other species, but because Hamilton s notion of inclusive fitness applies just as much to humans as to other species. Genes that promote cooperation independent of kinship, the key to our success as a species, can also spread, according to standard population biology see, for instance my recent book with Samuel Bowles, A Cooperative Species: Human Reciprocity and its Evolution (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2011). But the mechanisms are rather subtle and apply only to highly social species, as has been stressed by Bert Holldobler and Edward O. Wilson see their inspiring work The Superorganism: The Beauty, Elegance, and Strangeness of Insect Societies (New York: Norton, 2008). A second imbalance in his treatment is that he makes no case whatever for the gene-side of dual inheritance theory, or what I prefer to call gene-culture coevolution, a process which is of fundamentally important interest in making humans what they are, independent from the clash of kinship/family versus tribal values. Gene-culture coevolution explores the evolutionary dynamic that applies to any species for which epigenetic information takes the form of culture that accumulates reliably and long-term across generations. That applies strongly only to Homo sapiens. The main point is that culture includes techniques and social norms that determine which genes will be evolutionarily rewarded in a given society. Therefore human genes are the product of human culture as much as the reverse. This theory was developed by Lumsden and Wilson (1981), Cavalli-Sforza and Feldman (1981), and Boyd and Richerson (1985), and has become a major branch of 2

3 evolutionary theory. Indeed, it is supplies the basic framework of my recent book Individuality and Entanglement: The Moral and Material Bases of Human Social Life, Princeton University Press, I give, as an extended example of the intimate links between genes and culture in humans, the evolution of the physiology of communication. This example is important because it involves the development of key human genetic capacities that are the product of social structure as opposed to simple individual adaptation. The physiology of communication in humans is an emergent property of human social evolution (Gintis 2011). The example is especially relevant to this journal, which explores the evolutionary roots of the humanities. How are genes and human culture similar? Both genes and human culture consist of information passed across generations and subject to mutation and selection. How have humans managed to evolve their extraordinary capacity for verbal commumnication? Persuasive and informative speakers in the hunter-gatherer period of our existence were rewarded with higher quality mates and increased reproductive opportunities. Their offspring inherited their cognitive and physiological communicative powers. This is gene-culture coevolution of human communication, operating over tens and hundreds of thousands of years. The evolution of the physiology of speech and facial communication presents a theoretical challenge. It is easy to explain, if everyone else is gabbing away and you can only grunt and pant, why you might be handicapped in finding a spouse and teaching your children. But how could the use of complex phonics begin? When everyone is grunting and panting, what is the fitness benefit of being able to make more complex varieties of sounds? What is the fitness benefit of being able to interpret complex sounds? The answers are far from obvious and go far beyond simple individual fitness, or even inclusive fitness, maximization. For this reason, the evolution of the physiology of speech is a dramatically complex example of gene-culture coevolution. A most common error in the literature is to consider language as a purely mental phenomenon that can be explained simply as a byproduct of brain size and intelligence. In fact, the ability to communicate through facial sign and speech has required major changes in human physiology. These could only have come about because individuals with superior communication capacities were rewarded with more and healthier children. Why might this have occurred? The increased social importance of communication in human society rewarded genetic changes that facilitate speech. Regions in the motor cortex expanded in early humans to facilitate speech production. Concurrently, nerves and muscles to the mouth, larynx, and tongue became more numerous to handle the complexities of speech (Jurmain, Nelson, Kilgore and Travathan 1997). Parts of the cerebral cortex, Broca s and Wernicke s areas, which do not exist or are relatively small 3

4 in other primates, are large in humans and permit grammatical speech and comprehension (Binder, Frost, Hammeke, Cox, Rao and Prieto 1997, Belin, Zatorre, Lafaille, Ahad and Pike 2000). Adult modern humans have a larynx low in the throat, a position that allows the throat to serve as a resonating chamber capable of a great number of sounds (Relethford 2007). The first hominids that have skeletal structures supporting this laryngeal placement are the Homo heidelbergensis, who lived from 800,000 to 100,000 years ago. In addition, the production of consonants requires a short oral cavity, whereas our nearest primate relatives have much too long an oral cavity for this purpose. The position of the hyoid bone, which is a point of attachment for a tongue muscle, developed in Homo sapiens in a manner permitting highly precise and flexible tongue movements. Another indication that the tongue has evolved hominids to facilitate speech is the size of the hypoglossal canal, an aperture that permits the hypoglossal nerve to reach the tongue muscles. This aperture is much larger in Neanderthals and humans than in early hominids and nonhuman primates (Dunbar 2005). Human facial nerves and musculature have also evolved to facilitate communication. This musculature is present in all vertebrates, but except in mammals it serves feeding and respiratory functions alone (Burrows 2008). In mammals, this mimetic musculature attaches to the skin of the face, thus permitting the facial communication of such emotions as fear, surprise, disgust, and anger. In most mammals, however, a few wide sheetlike muscles are involved, rendering fine information differentiation impossible, whereas in primates, this musculature divides into many independent muscles with distinct points of attachment to the epidermis, thus permitting higher bandwidth facial communication. Humans have the most highly developed facial musculature by far of any primate species, with a degree of involvement of lips and eyes that is not present in any other species. In short, humans have evolved a highly specialized and very costly complex of physiological characteristics that both presuppose and facilitate sophisticated aural and visual communication, whereas communication in other primates, lacking as they are in cumulative culture, goes little beyond simple calling and gesturing capacities. This example is quite a dramatic and concrete illustration of the intimate interaction of genes and culture in the evolution of our species. REFERENCES Belin, P., R. J. Zatorre, P. Lafaille, P. Ahad, and B. Pike, Voice-selective Areas in Human Auditory Cortex, Nature 403 (2000): Binder, J. R., J. A. Frost, T. A. Hammeke, R. W. Cox, S. M. Rao, and T. Prieto, 4

5 Human Brain Language Areas Identified by Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Journal of Neuroscience 17 (1997): Boyd, Robert and Peter J. Richerson, Culture and the Evolutionary Process (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1985). Burrows, Anne M., The Facial Expression Musculature in Primates and Its Evolutionary Significance, BioEssays 30,3 (2008): Cavalli-Sforza, Luigi Luca and Marcus W. Feldman, Cultural Transmission and Evolution (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1981). Dunbar, Robin M., The Human Story (New York: Faber & Faber, 2005). Gintis, Herbert, Gene-culture Coevolution and the Nature of Human Sociality, Proceedings of the Royal Society B 366 (2011): Jurmain, Robert, Harry Nelson, Lynn Kilgore, and Wenda Travathan, Introduction to Physical Anthropology (Cincinnati: Wadsworth Publishing Company, 1997). Lumsden, Charles J. and Edward O. Wilson, Genes, Mind, and Culture: The Coevolutionary Process (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1981). Relethford, John H., The Human Species: An Introduction to Biological Anthropology (New York: McGraw-Hill, 2007). cnpapersnhuman EvolutionnHyperCognition.tex December 12,

1 Gene-Culture Coevolution

1 Gene-Culture Coevolution 1 Gene-Culture Coevolution The eye and the animal to which it belongs... are only so many out of the possible varieties and combinations of being, which the lapse of infinite ages has brought into existence...

More information

Sociobiological Approaches. What We Will Cover in This Section. Overview. Overview Evolutionary Theory Sociobiology Summary

Sociobiological Approaches. What We Will Cover in This Section. Overview. Overview Evolutionary Theory Sociobiology Summary Sociobiological Approaches What We Will Cover in This Section Overview Evolutionary Theory Sociobiology Summary 7/22/2007 Sociobiological Approaches.ppt 2 Overview Total focus on internal aspects of personality

More information

Two critical areas of change as we diverged from our evolutionary relatives: 1. Changes to peripheral mechanisms

Two critical areas of change as we diverged from our evolutionary relatives: 1. Changes to peripheral mechanisms Two critical areas of change as we diverged from our evolutionary relatives: 1. Changes to peripheral mechanisms 2. Changes to central neural mechanisms Chimpanzee vs. Adult Human vocal tracts 1 Human

More information

The Evolution of Mind and Morality: 19th-21st Centuries. Winter, 2007

The Evolution of Mind and Morality: 19th-21st Centuries. Winter, 2007 The Evolution of Mind and Morality: 19th-21st Centuries Winter, 2007 Instructor: Robert J. Richards Hist 35501, HiPSS 25901, Phil 24300/34300 Psyc 28200/38200, CHSS 35900 Course Assistants: P.-J. Benson

More information

Chapter 1: Introduction

Chapter 1: Introduction Chapter 1: Introduction Animism Dualism Monism Using our own brain to explain the brain? Can we explain consciousness? Blindsight Split brains--is right hemisphere also thinking? Unilateral neglect Raised

More information

Primate Diversity & Human Evolution (Outline)

Primate Diversity & Human Evolution (Outline) Primate Diversity & Human Evolution (Outline) 1. Source of evidence for evolutionary relatedness of organisms 2. Primates features and function 3. Classification of primates and representative species

More information

1 low Humans Evolved

1 low Humans Evolved 1 low Humans Evolved Robert Howl IOIIIB Silk UNIVERS1. i 1 \..UK I..1 I \ Nv I Technische Unive-^itdt Darmstadt FACHDCRLICH 10 BIOLOGIE B i!. I i o t h p k -_ ScLninspilinstiafiG 10 D-6 4287 Darmstadt

More information

Human Adaptation - ad aptos: good fit between trait and environment

Human Adaptation - ad aptos: good fit between trait and environment Human Adaptation - ad aptos: good fit between trait and environment -produced by natural selection -better than alternatives in immediate circumstances How are health and disease related to human adaptations?

More information

Evolution & Natural Selection

Evolution & Natural Selection Evolution & Natural Selection Human Origins & Adaptations Charles Darwin Darwin did not discover evolution Darwin explain how natural selection decided which genes would be selected and passed on to the

More information

[in press, July, 2006: In W. A. Darity (Ed.), International Encyclopedia of Social Sciences (2 nd ed.). New. Genetic Determinism

[in press, July, 2006: In W. A. Darity (Ed.), International Encyclopedia of Social Sciences (2 nd ed.). New. Genetic Determinism p. 1 [in press, July, 2006: In W. A. Darity (Ed.), International Encyclopedia of Social Sciences (2 nd ed.). New York: Thomson Gale.] Genetic Determinism Lucas D. Schipper and Todd K. Shackelford Florida

More information

3/30/2012. Two Contrasting but Complementary Evolutionary Perspectives on Human Behavior:

3/30/2012. Two Contrasting but Complementary Evolutionary Perspectives on Human Behavior: Two Contrasting but Complementary Perspectives on Human Behavior: Psychology (EP) derived from a synthesis of biology and psychology Human Behavioral Ecology (HEB) derived from a synthesis of biology and

More information

ABSTRACT: Dissolving the evolutionary puzzle of human cooperation.

ABSTRACT: Dissolving the evolutionary puzzle of human cooperation. ABSTRACT: Dissolving the evolutionary puzzle of human cooperation. Researchers of human behaviour often approach cooperation as an evolutionary puzzle, viewing it as analogous or even equivalent to the

More information

Standards A complete list of the standards covered by this lesson is included in the Appendix at the end of the lesson.

Standards A complete list of the standards covered by this lesson is included in the Appendix at the end of the lesson. Lesson 8: The History of Life on Earth Time: approximately 45-60 minutes, depending on length of discussion. Can be broken into 2 shorter lessons Materials: Double timeline (see below) Meter stick (to

More information

The Evolution of Speech

The Evolution of Speech The Evolution of Speech Q: How did speech arise in humans? A: We don t know. 1 How did speech arise in humans? scholars: interminable, acrimonious debates limited scientific data 1860: Paris Linguistic

More information

Neanderthal vs Cro-Magnon 1of10 found at

Neanderthal vs Cro-Magnon 1of10 found at We will watch the excellent documentary Clash of the Cavemen to learn about Neanderthals and the early humans who lived in Europe. Do a search of Clash of the Cavemen at www.youtube.com. (In 2012, when

More information

FLASH CARDS. Kalat s Book Chapter 1 Alphabetical

FLASH CARDS.   Kalat s Book Chapter 1 Alphabetical FLASH CARDS www.biologicalpsych.com Kalat s Book Chapter 1 Alphabetical altruistic behavior altruistic behavior Sacrificing personal welfare being to help another. Seen in many species, particularly in

More information

Anthro 101: Human Biological Evolution. Lecture 11: Cooperation, Intelligence, Communication, Culture, & Human Behavior. Prof.

Anthro 101: Human Biological Evolution. Lecture 11: Cooperation, Intelligence, Communication, Culture, & Human Behavior. Prof. Anthro 101: Human Biological Evolution Lecture 11: Cooperation, Intelligence, Communication, Culture, & Human Behavior Prof. Kenneth Feldmeier Reminders Fossil lecture for homework Quiz about material

More information

Lesson Topic Learning Goals

Lesson Topic Learning Goals Unit 2: Evolution Part B Lesson Topic Learning Goals 1 Lab Mechanisms of Evolution Cumulative Selection - Be able to describe evolutionary mechanisms such as genetic variations and key factors that lead

More information

:: Slide 1 :: :: Slide 2 :: :: Slide 3 :: :: Slide 3 continued :: :: Slide 4 :: :: Slide 5 ::

:: Slide 1 :: :: Slide 2 :: :: Slide 3 :: :: Slide 3 continued :: :: Slide 4 :: :: Slide 5 :: :: Slide 1 :: :: Slide 2 :: Why Do We Say Nature and Nurture Are Intertwined? What Are the Building Blocks of Behavior? What Is the Field of Behavioral Genetics? How Does Evolution Occur? How Does Evolution

More information

Bio 1M: The evolution of apes. 1 Example. 2 Patterns of evolution. Similarities and differences. History

Bio 1M: The evolution of apes. 1 Example. 2 Patterns of evolution. Similarities and differences. History Bio 1M: The evolution of apes 1 Example Humans are an example of a biological species that has evolved Possibly of interest, since many of your friends are probably humans Humans seem unique: How do they

More information

At Penn Museum Conference: Summary of Richerson

At Penn Museum Conference: Summary of Richerson At Penn Museum Conference: Summary of Richerson Steven O. Kimbrough kimbrough@wharton.upenn.edu 215-898-5133 29 September 2007 File: PennMuseum-foils-sok.tex/pdf. Two papers Conference paper: Rethinking

More information

APES C4L2 HOW DOES THE EARTH S LIFE CHANGE OVER TIME? Textbook pages 85 88

APES C4L2 HOW DOES THE EARTH S LIFE CHANGE OVER TIME? Textbook pages 85 88 APES C4L2 HOW DOES THE EARTH S LIFE CHANGE OVER TIME? Textbook pages 85 88 Big Ideas Concept 4-2A The scientific theory of evolution explains how life on Earth changes over time through changes in the

More information

'University of Michigan

'University of Michigan Mi chu DeptE CenREST W #93-01 Center for Research on Economic and Social Theory and Department of Economics Working Paper Series I,. How Altruism Can Prevail in an Evolutionary Environment Theodore C.

More information

Evolution by Natural Selection. Though it is considered a theory, there are few facts more widely accepted in all of science!

Evolution by Natural Selection. Though it is considered a theory, there are few facts more widely accepted in all of science! Evolution by Natural Selection Though it is considered a theory, there are few facts more widely accepted in all of science! Charles Darwin & Alfred Russel Wallace Charles Darwin is often called the father

More information

Evolution Problem Drill 10: Human Evolution

Evolution Problem Drill 10: Human Evolution Evolution Problem Drill 10: Human Evolution Question No. 1 of 10 Question 1. Which of the following statements is true regarding the human phylogenetic relationship with the African great apes? Question

More information

NGSS Example Bundles. 1 of 15

NGSS Example Bundles. 1 of 15 Middle School Topics Model Course III Bundle 3 Mechanisms of Diversity This is the third bundle of the Middle School Topics Model Course III. Each bundle has connections to the other bundles in the course,

More information

MS-LS3-1 Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits

MS-LS3-1 Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits MS-LS3-1 Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits MS-LS3-1. Develop and use a model to describe why structural changes to genes (mutations) located on chromosomes may affect proteins and may result

More information

arxiv: v1 [q-bio.pe] 9 Sep 2016

arxiv: v1 [q-bio.pe] 9 Sep 2016 Puzzles in modern biology. II. Language, cancer and the recursive processes of evolutionary innovation Steven A. Frank 1 1 Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of California, Irvine,

More information

Cooperation Achieved by Migration and Evolution in a Multilevel Selection Context

Cooperation Achieved by Migration and Evolution in a Multilevel Selection Context Proceedings of the 27 IEEE Symposium on Artificial Life (CI-ALife 27) Cooperation Achieved by Migration and Evolution in a Multilevel Selection Context Genki Ichinose Graduate School of Information Science

More information

Level 3 Biology, 2014

Level 3 Biology, 2014 91606 916060 3SUPERVISOR S Level 3 Biology, 2014 91606 Demonstrate understanding of trends in human evolution 9.30 am Thursday 13 November 2014 Credits: Four Achievement Achievement with Merit Achievement

More information

Origin of an idea about origins

Origin of an idea about origins Origin of an idea about origins Biological evolution is the process of change during the course of time because of the alteration of the genotype and the transfer of these altered genes to the next generation.

More information

How related are organisms?

How related are organisms? The Evolution and Classification of Species Darwin argued for adaptive radiation in which demes spread out in a given environment and evolved How related are organisms? Taonomy the science of classifying

More information

Who Were Neanderthals and Did They Interbreed with Modern Humans?

Who Were Neanderthals and Did They Interbreed with Modern Humans? Anthropology 1020 Sharon Vidriales-Estrada Who Were Neanderthals and Did They Interbreed with Modern Humans? References 1. Wikipedia (Internet) www.wikipedia.org Neanderthals search 2. Scientific American

More information

ADAPTATIONS. Characteristics that give an organism a better chance of survival.

ADAPTATIONS. Characteristics that give an organism a better chance of survival. ADAPTATIONS Characteristics that give an organism a better chance of survival. Special traits that help living organisms survive in a particular environment. Ex: Polar bear s thick white fur keeps him

More information

Introduction. THE FORMATION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM - Theories Old and New Imperial College Press

Introduction. THE FORMATION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM - Theories Old and New Imperial College Press Most scientists think that the work they do is very important. Well, they would wouldn t they? It is a human trait, an aspect of vanity, to consider that what one does is more significant than it really

More information

Understanding Natural Selection

Understanding Natural Selection Understanding Natural Selection Charles Darwin (1809-1882) Sailed around the world 1831-1836 What did Darwin s Travels reveal The diversity of living species was far greater than anyone had previously

More information

MATCHING STRUCTURE AND THE EVOLUTION OF COOPERATION IN THE PRISONER S DILEMMA

MATCHING STRUCTURE AND THE EVOLUTION OF COOPERATION IN THE PRISONER S DILEMMA MATCHING STRUCTURE AN THE EVOLUTION OF COOPERATION IN THE PRISONER S ILEMMA Noureddine Bouhmala 1 and Jon Reiersen 2 1 epartment of Technology, Vestfold University College, Norway noureddine.bouhmala@hive.no

More information

On the Origin of Altruism. desire that compels humans to help is called altruism by psychologists. Through this feeling,

On the Origin of Altruism. desire that compels humans to help is called altruism by psychologists. Through this feeling, Ding 1 Chunyang Ding Mrs.Boness Gifted Freshmen English 12 February 2012 On the Origin of Altruism How do humans actually behave when faced with the decision to help others? The innate desire that compels

More information

Yes. 1 ENGL 191 * Writing Workshop II. 2 ENGL 191 * Writing Workshop II. Yes

Yes. 1 ENGL 191 * Writing Workshop II. 2 ENGL 191 * Writing Workshop II. Yes COURSE DISCIPLINE : COURSE NUMBER : COURSE TITLE (FULL) : COURSE TITLE (SHORT) : ANTHR 101 CATALOG DESCRIPTION ANTHR 101 introduces the concepts, methods of inquiry, and scientific explanations for biological

More information

6 HOW DID OUR ANCESTORS EVOLVE?

6 HOW DID OUR ANCESTORS EVOLVE? 6 HOW DID OUR ANCESTORS EVOLVE? David Christian introduces the science of taxonomy and explains some of the important methods used to identify and classify different species and several key human ancestors.

More information

Characteristics of Animals

Characteristics of Animals Animal Adaptations Notes Characteristics of Animals Animals are in Kingdom a. b. eukaryotic c. cells lack. do not have a backbone. Ex. do have a backbone. Ex. Animals survive by doing the following essential

More information

Chapter 16: Evolutionary Theory

Chapter 16: Evolutionary Theory Chapter 16: Evolutionary Theory Section 1: Developing a Theory Evolution: Artificial Selection: Evolution: I. A Theory to Explain Change Over Time B. Charles Darwin C. Theory: D. Modern evolutionary theory

More information

Mammalogy Lecture 15 - Social Behavior II: Evolution

Mammalogy Lecture 15 - Social Behavior II: Evolution Mammalogy Lecture 15 - Social Behavior II: Evolution I. Evolution of Social Behavior In order to understand the evolution & maintenance of social behavior, we need to examine costs & benefits of group

More information

Lesson 1 Syllabus Reference

Lesson 1 Syllabus Reference Lesson 1 Syllabus Reference Outcomes A student Explains how biological understanding has advanced through scientific discoveries, technological developments and the needs of society. Content The theory

More information

The Evolving Brain. Communication Intelligence Technologies Social Complexity Cultural Complexity

The Evolving Brain. Communication Intelligence Technologies Social Complexity Cultural Complexity LENScience Senior Biology Seminar Series 2011 The Evolving Brain: social interaction and complexity Peter Gluckman, Alan Beedle, Tatjana Buklijas and Jacquie Bay 2 June 2011 The Evolving Brain Communication

More information

Introduction to Biology

Introduction to Biology Introduction to Biology Biology The Study of Life Life arose more than 3.5 billion years ago First organisms (living things) were single celled Only life on Earth for millions of years Organisms changed

More information

Evolution of cooperation. Martin Nowak, Harvard University

Evolution of cooperation. Martin Nowak, Harvard University Evolution of cooperation Martin Nowak, Harvard University As the Fukushima power plant was melting down, a worker in his 20s was among those who volunteered to reenter. In an interview he said: There are

More information

Introduction to Biology

Introduction to Biology 1 Introduction to Biology 2 Biology The Study of Life Life arose more than 3.5 billion years ago First organisms (living things) were single celled Only life on Earth for millions of years Organisms changed

More information

15.3 Darwin Presents his Case. Biology Mr. Hines

15.3 Darwin Presents his Case. Biology Mr. Hines 15.3 Darwin Presents his Case Biology Mr. Hines Darwin returned to England with a wealth of new data. He brought many specimens from the Galapagos to further his studies and to present his data to others.

More information

UNIT 4: EVOLUTION Chapter 12: The History of Life. I. The Fossil Record (12.1) A. Fossils can form in several ways

UNIT 4: EVOLUTION Chapter 12: The History of Life. I. The Fossil Record (12.1) A. Fossils can form in several ways UNIT IV Chapter 12 The History Of Life UNIT 4: EVOLUTION Chapter 12: The History of Life I. The Fossil Record (12.1) A. Fossils can form in several ways 1. Permineralization- minerals carried by water

More information

Biological Anthropology

Biological Anthropology Biological Anthropology Human evolution, ecology and behaviour, past and present Courses available in BBS and from MVST Enquiries and questions to: Anna O Mahony, Undergraduate Administrator ao419@cam.ac.uk

More information

Cooperation. Main points for today. How can altruism evolve? Group living vs. cooperation. Sociality-nocooperation. and cooperationno-sociality

Cooperation. Main points for today. How can altruism evolve? Group living vs. cooperation. Sociality-nocooperation. and cooperationno-sociality Cooperation Why is it surprising and how does it evolve Cooperation Main points for today Sociality, cooperation, mutualism, altruism - definitions Kin selection Hamilton s rule, how to calculate r Group

More information

GRADE 6 SCIENCE REVISED 2014

GRADE 6 SCIENCE REVISED 2014 QUARTER 1 Developing and Using Models Develop and use a model to describe phenomena. (MS-LS1-2) Develop a model to describe unobservable mechanisms. (MS-LS1-7) Planning and Carrying Out Investigations

More information

Anthropology 562: Introduction to Evolutionary Anthropology

Anthropology 562: Introduction to Evolutionary Anthropology Anthropology 562: Introduction to Evolutionary Anthropology Instructor: Ed Hagen Office: VMMC 102E Phone: 360-546-9257 Email: edhagen@vancouver.wsu.edu Office hours: Anytime Course website: Lecture day

More information

Bones of Contention (Lubenow) PPT

Bones of Contention (Lubenow) PPT From the SelectedWorks of Jordan P Ballard 2013 Bones of Contention (Lubenow) PPT Jordan P Ballard Available at: https://works.bepress.com/jordan_ballard/8/ A Creationist Assessment of Human Fossils Marvin

More information

Biological Anthropology Sample Exam 2 MULTIPLE CHOICE

Biological Anthropology Sample Exam 2 MULTIPLE CHOICE Biological Anthropology Sample Exam 2 1 Name MULTIPLE CHOICE 1) Non-human primates are currently threatened by A) poaching for the live animal trade B) the bushmeat trade C) forest clearing D) all of these

More information

4. Identify one bird that would most likely compete for food with the large tree finch. Support your answer. [1]

4. Identify one bird that would most likely compete for food with the large tree finch. Support your answer. [1] Name: Topic 5B 1. A hawk has a genetic trait that gives it much better eyesight than other hawks of the same species in the same area. Explain how this could lead to evolutionary change within this species

More information

Theory a well supported testable explanation of phenomenon occurring in the natural world.

Theory a well supported testable explanation of phenomenon occurring in the natural world. Evolution Theory of Evolution Theory a well supported testable explanation of phenomenon occurring in the natural world. Evolution the process by which modern organisms changed over time from ancient common

More information

Computer Simulations on Evolution BiologyLabs On-line. Laboratory 1 for Section B. Laboratory 2 for Section A

Computer Simulations on Evolution BiologyLabs On-line. Laboratory 1 for Section B. Laboratory 2 for Section A Computer Simulations on Evolution BiologyLabs On-line Laboratory 1 for Section B Laboratory 2 for Section A The following was taken from http://www.biologylabsonline.com/protected/evolutionlab/ Introduction

More information

Biological Anthropology

Biological Anthropology Biological Anthropology Sample Exam 1 Multiple-Choice Questions For each of the following questions, circle the answer that is most correct. Each question is worth two (2) points. 1. Which of the following

More information

Selfishness and Cooperation: Challenge for Social Life

Selfishness and Cooperation: Challenge for Social Life Studia Humana Volume 6:3 (2017), pp. 15 23 DOI: 10.1515/sh-2017-0019 Konrad Szocik Selfishness and Cooperation: Challenge for Social Life University of Information Technology and Management in Rzeszow,

More information

The Theory of Evolution Chapter 6

The Theory of Evolution Chapter 6 The Theory of Evolution Chapter 6 Change over time. What is evolution? What Do You See? Two faces.. or one? A lady at her dressing table... or a skull? (try blinking.. or moving away from the screen) A

More information

Chapter 16: Reconstructing and Using Phylogenies

Chapter 16: Reconstructing and Using Phylogenies Chapter Review 1. Use the phylogenetic tree shown at the right to complete the following. a. Explain how many clades are indicated: Three: (1) chimpanzee/human, (2) chimpanzee/ human/gorilla, and (3)chimpanzee/human/

More information

The Origin of the Social Impulse: E.O. Wilson s Recent and Controversial Rejection of Kin Selection in Historical Context

The Origin of the Social Impulse: E.O. Wilson s Recent and Controversial Rejection of Kin Selection in Historical Context The Origin of the Social Impulse: E.O. Wilson s Recent and Controversial Rejection of Kin Selection in Historical Context Abraham H. Gibson Department of History Virginia Tech Outline 1. Wilson s intellectual

More information

The History of Life on Earth

The History of Life on Earth CHAPTER 9 VOCABULARY & NOTES WORKSHEET The History of Life on Earth By studying the Vocabulary and Notes listed for each section below, you can gain a better understanding of this chapter. SECTION 1 Vocabulary

More information

Studying Life. Lesson Overview. Lesson Overview. 1.3 Studying Life

Studying Life. Lesson Overview. Lesson Overview. 1.3 Studying Life Lesson Overview 1.3 Characteristics of Living Things What characteristics do all living things share? Living things are made up of basic units called cells, are based on a universal genetic code, obtain

More information

Evolution and Epigenetics. Seminar: Social, Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience Speaker: Wolf-R. Brockhaus

Evolution and Epigenetics. Seminar: Social, Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience Speaker: Wolf-R. Brockhaus Evolution and Epigenetics Seminar: Social, Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience Speaker: Wolf-R. Brockhaus 1. History of evolutionary theory The history of evolutionary theory ~ 1800: Lamarck 1859: Darwin's

More information

GENERAL INFORMATION. Number of One credit (1)

GENERAL INFORMATION. Number of One credit (1) GENERAL INFORMATION Course 2000410 Number: Course Path: Section: Basic and Adult Education» Grade Group: Secondary Grades 9-12» Subject: Science» SubSubject: Biological Sciences» Course Title: Zoology

More information

On the evolution of reciprocal cooperation

On the evolution of reciprocal cooperation On the evolution of reciprocal cooperation Jean-Baptiste André Ecologie & Evolution - CNRS - ENS, Paris, France Biodiversity and Environment: Viability and Dynamic Games Perspectives Montreal, November

More information

Extensive evidence indicates that life on Earth began more than 3 billion years ago.

Extensive evidence indicates that life on Earth began more than 3 billion years ago. V Extensive evidence indicates that life on Earth began more than 3 billion years ago. Fossils found in ancient rocks have given us many clues to the kind of life that existed long ago. The first living

More information

How Altruism Can Prevail Under Natural Selection

How Altruism Can Prevail Under Natural Selection How Altruism Can Prevail Under Natural Selection by Ted Bergstrom and Oded Stark University of Michigan and Harvard University Current version: March 22, 2002 How Altruism Can Prevail Under Natural Selection

More information

MS-LS4-1 Biological Evolution: Unity and Diversity

MS-LS4-1 Biological Evolution: Unity and Diversity MS-LS4-1 Biological Evolution: Unity and Diversity MS-LS4-1. Analyze and interpret data for patterns in the fossil record that document the existence, diversity, extinction, and change of life forms throughout

More information

EVOLUTION. - Selection, Survival, and Drift

EVOLUTION. - Selection, Survival, and Drift EVOLUTION - Selection, Survival, and Drift Evolution Darwin on the HMS Beagle Darwin s role on the ship was as a geologist and companion to the captain. His goal was to collect biological and geological

More information

Heredity and Evolution

Heredity and Evolution Heredity and Variation Heredity and Evolution Living organisms have certain recognisable heritable features such as height, complexion, colour of hair and eyes, shape of nose and chin etc. These are called

More information

The theory of evolution continues to be refined as scientists learn new information.

The theory of evolution continues to be refined as scientists learn new information. Section 3: The theory of evolution continues to be refined as scientists learn new information. K What I Know W What I Want to Find Out L What I Learned Essential Questions What are the conditions of the

More information

(Richard Dawkins) 20 Desmond Morris

(Richard Dawkins) 20 Desmond Morris 2005135694 703 Advances in Psychological Science 310028 90 B84-09 1 (Richard Dawkins) 20 Desmond Morris Konrad Lorenz Niko Tinbergen 80 20 50 (Evolutionary psychologyep) On Aggression Jerome (1966) Barkow

More information

The Human Animal. Molecular Evidence. Early Homo Evolution

The Human Animal. Molecular Evidence. Early Homo Evolution The Human Animal 1 Molecular Evidence Humans and Chimps/ Bonobos share 95% of our DNA in common The 5% is responsible for the important difference in body, brains and behaviours Gorilla Chimp. Bonobos

More information

The Human Animal. BIO 1300: The Human Animal

The Human Animal. BIO 1300: The Human Animal The Human Animal 1 Molecular Evidence Humans and Chimps/ Bonobos share 95% of our DNA in common The 5% is responsible for the important difference in body, brains and behaviours Gorilla Chimp. Bonobos

More information

B L U E V A L L E Y D I S T R I C T C U R R I C U L U M Science 7 th grade

B L U E V A L L E Y D I S T R I C T C U R R I C U L U M Science 7 th grade B L U E V A L L E Y D I S T R I C T C U R R I C U L U M Science 7 th grade ORGANIZING THEME/TOPIC UNIT 1: CELLS Structure and Function of Cells MS-LS1-1. Conduct an investigation to provide evidence that

More information

http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/341018. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at. http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp.

More information

Assessment Schedule 2016 Biology: Demonstrate understanding of trends in human evolution (91606)

Assessment Schedule 2016 Biology: Demonstrate understanding of trends in human evolution (91606) NCEA Level 3 Biology (91606) 2016 page 1 of 6 Assessment Schedule 2016 Biology: Demonstrate understanding of trends in human evolution (91606) Evidence Statement Q Evidence Achievement Merit Excellence

More information

Growth & Development. Characteristics of Living Things. What is development? Movement. What is a cell?

Growth & Development. Characteristics of Living Things. What is development? Movement. What is a cell? Characteristics of Living Things made of cells growth acquire and use energy reproduction movement adaptation respond to stimuli/homeostasis interdependence organization What is development? What are some

More information

Memes & Changing language

Memes & Changing language Memes & Changing language Richard K. Belew Evolution?! Computational models of evolution, learning Computational analyses of cultural artifacts What do you think? A B C Believing evolution? Gallup, 1997

More information

Evolution. Some quotes to begin:

Evolution. Some quotes to begin: Evolution Some quotes to begin: [BYU I] can t skip teaching sensitive issues. We re a Church school and we must give the same education as one would get at another [university]. What better place could

More information

Casey Leonard. Multiregional model vs. Out of Africa theory SLCC

Casey Leonard. Multiregional model vs. Out of Africa theory SLCC Casey Leonard Multiregional model vs. Out of Africa theory SLCC 2 It is debated where humans came from and how they spread across the world. Since people don't all look the same, or are categorized into

More information

Lesson 10 Study Guide

Lesson 10 Study Guide URI CMB 190 Issues in Biotechnology Lesson 10 Study Guide 15. By far most of the species that have ever existed are now extinct. Many of those extinct species were the precursors of the species that are

More information

Ray, Evolutionary Psychology Instructor Site: Test Bank Questions Ch. 2, p. 1. Chapter 2

Ray, Evolutionary Psychology Instructor Site: Test Bank Questions Ch. 2, p. 1. Chapter 2 Ray, Evolutionary Psychology Instructor Site: Test Bank Questions Ch. 2, p. 1 Multiple Choice Chapter 2 1. Which of the following statements about evolution is NOT correct? a. Evolution emerges from the

More information

Homework. Guided Reading Recent Hominids (#22-31) Need ear buds/headphones for Monday!!

Homework. Guided Reading Recent Hominids (#22-31) Need ear buds/headphones for Monday!! Homework Guided Reading Recent Hominids (#22-31) Need ear buds/headphones for Monday!! Learning Target I can explore various hominids from the skull lab and describe the evolution of hominids. What are

More information

Two Views of Adaptation

Two Views of Adaptation Mar 22: Adaptation--definitions Two Views of Adaptation Adaptation as a process The process by which an organism becomes better fitted to its environment, and stays that way Reflects role of natural selection

More information

Kingdom Animalia. Zoology the study of animals

Kingdom Animalia. Zoology the study of animals Kingdom Animalia Zoology the study of animals Summary Animals are multicellular and eukaryotic. consume and digest organic materials thereby being heterotrophs. Most are motile at some time in their lives.

More information

HOMO SAPIENS EXHIBITION

HOMO SAPIENS EXHIBITION HOMO SAPIENS EXHIBITION 1 HOMO SAPIENS The first exhibition in the world that tells the story of mankind through a large multidisciplinary fresco An international project involving over 14 countries 15

More information

Course Name: Biology Level: A Points: 5 Teacher Name: Claire E. Boudreau

Course Name: Biology Level: A Points: 5 Teacher Name: Claire E. Boudreau Course Name: Biology Level: A Points: 5 Teacher Name: Claire E. Boudreau Texts/Instructional Materials: Biology : Concepts and Connections 5 th edition Campbell, Reece, Taylor and Simon Pearson Syllabus:

More information

Life Science Curriculum Sixth Grade

Life Science Curriculum Sixth Grade Life Science Curriculum Sixth Grade The Sixth Grade life science curriculum emphasizes a more complex understanding of cycles, patterns and relationships in the living world. Students build on basic principles

More information

Environmental Influences on Adaptation

Environmental Influences on Adaptation Have you ever noticed how the way you feel sometimes mirrors the emotions of the people with whom you spend a lot of time? For example, when you re around happy people, do you tend to become happy? Since

More information

The Origin of New Species

The Origin of New Species The Origin of New Species Introduction If microevolution is small changes in gene frequencies What, then would macroevolution be? And how might that work???? The biological species concept emphasizes reproductive

More information

Group activities: Making animal model of human behaviors e.g. Wine preference model in mice

Group activities: Making animal model of human behaviors e.g. Wine preference model in mice Lecture schedule 3/30 Natural selection of genes and behaviors 4/01 Mouse genetic approaches to behavior 4/06 Gene-knockout and Transgenic technology 4/08 Experimental methods for measuring behaviors 4/13

More information

GRADE EIGHT Theme: Cause and Effect

GRADE EIGHT Theme: Cause and Effect GRADE EIGHT Theme: Cause and Effect Since causes of complex phenomena and systems are not always immediately or physically visible to students, the need to develop abstract thinking skills is a significant

More information

Evolution and Darwin

Evolution and Darwin Evolution and Darwin Evolution The processes that have transformed life on earth from it s earliest forms to the vast diversity that characterizes it today - Darwin Old Theories of Evolution Jean Baptiste

More information

NGSS UNIT OVERVIEW EVOLUTION

NGSS UNIT OVERVIEW EVOLUTION UNIT SPECIFIC RESOURCES TEACHER RESOURCES IV NGSS UNIT OVERVIEW EVOLUTION Performance Expectation MS-LS4-1: Analyze interpret data for patterns in the fossil record that document the existence, diversity,

More information

Evolution and Natural Selection (16-18)

Evolution and Natural Selection (16-18) Evolution and Natural Selection (16-18) 3 Key Observations of Life: 1) Shared Characteristics of Life (Unity) 2) Rich Diversity of Life 3) Organisms are Adapted to their Environment These observations

More information